Notes:
I feel like most of the map is just moving left the whole way then right the whole way, mixing things up a little is what makes maps a bit more fun
At a lot of points, you use a 1/2 length slider where it should be a 1/3 slider followed by a 1/6 note -> ill just tag these as a "triplet" even though that's technically not correct XD. These note sounds should not be skipped!
At a lot of other points, you use a repeated 1/2 slider where it skips note sounds, I make a big fuss about this because there are many more points in the map where you include these 1/6 notes, and so for consistency you should not skip them. (Also, using repeating sliders adds a hit sound in the middle, so you need to make sure you're using these when they should be used.
Also, this is Salad not Cup! Try increase map spread, the catcher does not need to be standing still throughout & between some sliders. Mapping easy difficulties is actually hard to do well
. On the points I mark with "not enough map spread", I won't provide the new positions because I'm just a modder. You should just try position the hit objects so that the catcher is a little more dynamic.
00:06:141 (1,2,3) - Positioning of these sliders is inconsistent and starting a map near the edge doesn't feel comfortable. Try:
176,96,6141,6,0,L|56:96,1,100,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
160,192,6838,2,0,L|280:192,1,100,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
352,88,7536,2,0,L|472:88,1,100,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
00:08:224 (4) - Should be a triplet. Try:
256,192,8234,2,0,L|336:192,1,66.6666666666667
392,192,8583,1,0,0:0:0:0:
00:09:629 (2) - Not enough spread. Try: x:104 (00:10:211 (3,4) - would also have to be adjusted to compensate)
00:10:211 (3,4) - Missing note at 00:10:559 - maybe try individual notes at 00:10:210 - 00:10:327 - 00:10:559 - 00:10:676 - instead
00:11:024 (6) - Should not be a slider, it has emphasis at 00:11:373 - (should not be emphasised) & there is a missing note at 00:11:257 -
00:11:257 - add slider here to 00:11:722 -
^^^ if you follow all of these then try: (I'm just mixing up the movement a little to make it more fun, please try things like this in sections I mark as "Not enough spread")
272,296,8931,6,0,L|160:296,1,100,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
104,192,9629,2,0,L|-24:192,1,100,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
96,136,10211,1,8,0:0:0:0:
160,136,10327,1,0,0:0:0:0:
328,136,10559,1,0,0:0:0:0:
264,136,10676,1,0,0:0:0:0:
416,136,10908,1,8,0:0:0:0:
474,136,11024,1,0,0:0:0:0:
312,136,11257,2,0,L|160:136,1,133.333333333333
Just note the droplet which will be made at 00:11:606 -
00:24:280 (3) - at least make it a little bit diagonal :s
00:24:978 (4) - make triplet, missing note at 00:25:210 -
00:27:769 - make triplet, missing note at 00:28:001 -
00:32:652 (3) - should not be a slider, emphasis at 00:33:001 - when there are missing notes at 00:32:885 - and 00:33:234 - Try:
Add slider from 00:32:652 - to 00:32:885 -
Add note 00:33:001 -
Add note 00:33:234 -
Add note 00:33:350 -
00:34:048 (1,2) - add map spread
00:35:443 (3) - should not be a slider, if you listen carefully there is missing note at 00:35:676 - Try:
Add slider from 00:35:443 - to 00:35:676 -
Add slider from 00:35:792 - to 00:36:141 -
00:36:838 (1,2) - add map spread
00:38:234 (3) - should not be slider, missing notes at 00:38:466 - and 00:38:815 - Try:
Add note 00:38:234 -
Add note 00:38:466 -
Add slider 00:38:583 - to 00:38:931 -
00:39:280 (7) - I like the lead-in here, it adds emphasis, but its inconsistent with prior parts of the map which could've used the extra emphasis, eg. 00:33:699 - , so either replace with note or add slider from 00:33:699 - to 00:33:931 -
00:39:619 (1,2,3) - add map spread
00:43:001 - Again, I like the lead-in, so maybe try add note at 00:43:699 - to add more emphasis
00:44:513 - replace with slider to 00:44:862 -
00:45:094 - missing note, add note
00:46:606 - should not be slider, missing note at 00:46:838 - Try:
Add note 00:46:606 -
Add note 00:46:838 -
Add slider 00:46:955 - to 00:47:304 -
00:47:652 - If you changed any of the previous lead-in sliders then this must be changed as well for consistency
00:49:397 - should not be slider, missing note at 00:49:629 - Try:
Add note 00:49:397 -
Add note 00:49:629 -
Add slider 00:49:745 - to 00:50:094 -
00:50:782 (1,2) - add map spread
00:51:490 - should be a note for emphasis
00:51:838 - maybe slider to 00:52:187 -
00:54:978 (3) - should not be a slider, (optional missed note 00:55:094 - ) and missed note 00:55:210 - Try make into 3 or 4 notes
00:55:559 - should be a note
If you followed ^^ then
00:55:676 and 00:55:792 - missing notes, add slider
If you didn't follow then
00:55:792 - missing note
00:56:024 - Try adding a slider to 00:56:257 -
00:57:420 (4) - try full slider instead of repeated, 00:57:769 - should not be emphasized
00:58:699 - missing note, please read vv
00:59:048 - maybe add note here or try note at 00:58:699 - and slider from 00:58:815 - to 00:59:048 -
01:00:559 - should not be a slider, missing notes at 01:00:792 - and 01:01:141 -
01:04:397 - maybe add note (since its after a spinner this might be inconsistent with other difficulties, either change every difficulty missing this note or don't change it)
01:04:736 (1,2,3) - add map spread
01:06:141 - should not be a slider, missing notes at 01:06:373 - and 01:06:722 -
01:07:187 - Try slider to 01:07:420 - to match previous lead-in sliders you used
01:08:931 - should not be a slider, missing note at 01:09:164 -
01:13:117 (1) - should be either a note or a longer slider depending on whether you want hit sound at 01:13:466 -
^^ if note, add note 01:13:466 -
^^ if slider, extend to 01:13:815 -
01:13:815 - missing note
01:14:048 - missing note
01:14:164 - keep note here
01:14:513 - should be a note
01:14:745 - should be a note
01:15:210 - should be a note
01:15:443 - should be a note
^^ add emphasis before Kiai
01:15:559 - maybe add slider to 01:15:792 - for lead-in
01:17:536 (2) - should not be slider, missing note at 01:17:652 - Try:
Add note 01:17:536 -
Add note 01:17:652 -
Add slider from 01:18:001 - to 01:18:350 -
01:18:699 (1) - i feel like this slider should be broken down into two 1/2 sliders, (also missing note 01:19:978 - ) Try:
Add slider 01:18:699 - to 01:19:048 -
Add slider 01:19:397 - to 01:19:745 -
Add note 01:19:978 -
Add note 01:20:094 -
01:20:327 - Should not be a slider (missing note at 01:20:443 - ) also should not end at 01:20:676 - Try:
Add note 01:20:327 -
Add slider 01:20:443 - to 01:20:792 -
01:21:141 - Try slider to 01:21:373 - for lead-in
01:21:490 (1) - again, i feel like slider should be broken down into two 1/2 sliders (same timing as last combo) Try:
Add slider 01:21:490 - to 01:21:838 -
Add slider 01:22:187 - to 01:22:536 -
Add note 01:22:769 -
Add note 01:22:885 -
Add note 01:23:117 -
Add slider 01:23:117 - to 01:23:583 -
01:24:280 - ^^ same timing modifications - slider should be broken down into two 1/2 sliders
01:27:071 (1) - keep this slider as it is
01:28:699 - should not be slider, missing note at 01:28:815 -
01:29:862 (1) - slider should be broken down into two 1/2 sliders
01:31:490 (2) - should not be a slider, missing note at 01:31:606 -
01:32:304 - Try add slider to 01:32:536 - for lead-in
01:32:652 (1) - slider should be broken down into two 1/2 sliders
01:34:280 (2,3) - the note should be at 01:34:280 - and the slider from 01:34:397 - to 01:34:745 -
01:37:071 - maybe add note
01:37:536 - replace slider with notes (or 1/6 sliders) - this makes the hit sounds match the song better. Try:
Add note 01:37:536 -
Add note 01:37:652 -
Add note 01:37:885 -
Add note 01:38:117 -
Add note 01:38:234 -
01:45:210 (3) - should not be a slider, missing note at 01:45:210 (3) -
01:48:001 - same as ^^, 01:48:234 -
01:49:038 (4) - to 01:51:480 - add map spread
01:50:792 - same as ^^, 01:51:024 -
01:52:875 - to 01:57:061 - add map spread (note: map spread throughout rest of the song looks pretty good from here
)
01:53:583 - should be a note, slider should be from 01:53:815 - to 01:53:931 -
01:54:280 - should be a note, there shouldn't be hit sound at 01:54:513 -
01:56:373 (3) - should not be a slider, missing note at 01:56:373 (3) -
01:59:164 (3) - ^^, 01:59:397 -
02:01:606 (2) - make into note, should not be hit sound at 02:01:955 -
02:02:187 - add note
02:07:187 (2) - shorten slider to 02:07:769 - and add note at 02:07:885 -
02:10:210 (3) - remove note, no hit sound
02:10:327 - should not be slider, missing note at 02:10:559 -
02:11:373 - maybe add note? your choice as with/without note both sound good
02:13:117 (3) - should not be slider, missing note at 02:13:350 -
02:15:908 (3) - ^^, 02:16:141 -
02:16:955 (4) - replace with slider to 02:17:187 - for consistency
02:17:304 - maybe remove repeat, and add note at 02:18:350 - instead
02:18:931 - maybe add note
02:21:490 - maybe split into two notes and increase distance for emphasis (dash notes)
02:22:187 - ^^
02:24:513 (2,3) - swap slider and note timings
02:25:676 (1) - similar to last kiai mode, slider should be broken down into two 1/2 sliders
02:27:304 (2,3) - swap slider and note timings
02:28:466 (1) - slider should be broken down into two 1/2 sliders
02:30:094 (2,3) - swap slider and note timings
02:30:908 (4) - NC
02:31:257 (1) - shorten slider to 02:31:606 -
02:31:955 - add slider to 02:32:304 -
02:32:652 (3) - should not be slider, missing note at 02:32:885 -
02:33:583 - remove note
02:33:699 - add slider to 02:33:931 - for consistency
02:35:676 (2,3) - swap slider and note timings
02:36:838 (1) - slider should be broken down into two 1/2 sliders
02:38:466 (2,3) - swap slider and note timings
02:41:257 (2,3) - ^^
02:43:815 - and 02:45:210 - I didn't mention it on last spinner, but I find it awkward when spinner starts or ends are used as emphasised notes maybe this is something you get from playing standard lol because it actually has a hit at the end.
02:50:094 (1,2) - repeating sounds which happened in the previous spinner, maybe extend spinner to 02:50:443 - or 02:50:792 - depending on whether you will still use emphasised spinner ends
02:55:676 - awkward spinner finish, extend to 02:55:792 -
from 02:56:373 - to 03:06:838 - I think that skipping hit sounds is appropriate, so is kept the same, this is a section which should be mapped on a harder difficulty
03:15:210 - awkward spinner finish, extend to 03:15:559 -
03:16:955 - add note
03:18:350 - maybe add slider to 03:18:583 -
03:23:117 (4,5) - swap slider and note timings
03:24:280 (1) - make 1/2 slider
03:24:978 - add 1/2 slider
03:25:327 - remove note
03:25:908 (4,5) - swap slider and note timings
03:27:071 (1) - make 1/2 slider
03:27:769 - add 1/2 slider
03:28:466 - add note
03:28:699 (3,4) - swap slider and note timings
03:31:257 (3) - shorten to 03:31:490 -
03:31:606 - add note
03:31:955 - should be a note for emphasis
03:34:280 (4,5) - swap slider and note timings
03:35:443 (1) - make into 1/2 slider
03:36:141 - add 1/2 slider
03:37:071 (4,5) - swap slider and note timings
03:38:234 (1) - make into 1/2 slider
03:38:931 - add 1/2 slider
03:39:629 - should not be a slider, missing note at 03:39:862 -