Anxient wrote:

you begged. yes i did, for some reason

yoroshiku
00:10:829 (2,3) - maybe do this? http://puu.sh/omMUd/fab667dea4.jpg imo looks 300% better than it is :L k done
00:23:371 (1) - why NC? to specify the difference
00:30:998 (3) - flip this maybe? http://puu.sh/omMZX/a5b06ec42c.jpg nice
00:50:151 (2,1,2) - maybe make the distance seem the same lol i mean youve been doing that this whole time, why not do it here http://puu.sh/omN93/1c340fa10c.jpg a bit nazi, :I kinda fix the spacing anyway
00:52:693 (2,1) - maybe give this more distance? i mean theres a really thick sound in (1) http://puu.sh/omNc4/604abf7da1.jpg i feel that's enough :/
01:06:931 (3,4,5) - this spacing is weird imo. 01:06:931 (3,4) - has less emphasis but a buttload of spacing. 01:07:100 (4,5) - meanwhile, this has some sort of emphasis but has way less spacing. try http://puu.sh/omNhD/8b032a354d.jpg this. stack it here 01:05:913 (5) - Not really. I want to make an intentional slow down on (4) and (5) to drop a unique emphasizing on vocal. those differences are prepared for that.
01:27:609 (1,2,3) - what why oh wait fuck i forgot to change the hitsounds
01:49:304 (1,2) - ? yes
02:22:354 (1) - maybe give more spacing? http://puu.sh/omNyH/0ac7662f14.jpg tbh i think that's enough for this part
02:41:337 (1) - i seriously think ctrl g would work better not fond of stacking heads :p

Secretpipe wrote:

where's liiraye diff

1. You forgot to Disable widescreen support in Easy and It's my pleasure to meet you. diffs >w>

1. Decrease OD , 8.5 is really high for this~
2. 00:25:405 - it would be better if u do this : http://puu.sh/oEYcK/494a82a44e.jpg
3. 03:15:744 (3,1) - make blanket?

1. Maybe set AR to 8.7 or 8.8 ~ cuz 170 bpm
2. 01:31:676 (5,8) - maybe use 1/4 sliders instead

DeRandom Otaku wrote:

Kyubey's Insane :

1. Maybe set AR to 8.7 or 8.8 ~ cuz 170 bpm it feels readable with current AR
2. 01:31:676 (5,8) - maybe use 1/4 sliders instead i like how two triplets are played here

1. You have unused hitsounds: drum-hitclap3.wav, drum-hitfinish3.wav, drum-hitnormal3.wav, drum-hitwhistle3.wav, and drum-sliderslide3.wav

1. 02:23:710 (1,3) - Maybe swap combos? Like remove combo here and add one at 02:25:066 (1). Just a suggestion.

1. 00:06:761 (1) - Well, you do have an unsnapped green line here. Very minor tbh.

1. Good map, but maybe reduce the OD to 8.

DeRandom Otaku wrote:

Hi~ from my queue

Your request was accepted xD kool

General :

1. You forgot to Disable widescreen support in Easy and It's my pleasure to meet you. diffs >w>

ok
It's my pleasure to meet you. :

1. Decrease OD , 8.5 is really high for this~ alright
2. 00:25:405 - it would be better if u do this : http://puu.sh/oEYcK/494a82a44e.jpg gonna keep the long slider for the consistency
3. 03:15:744 (3,1) - make blanket? I'm not going to make a blanket there :/

BeatofIke wrote:

[General]

1. You have unused hitsounds: drum-hitclap3.wav, drum-hitfinish3.wav, drum-hitnormal3.wav, drum-hitwhistle3.wav, and drum-sliderslide3.wav

[Chu's Normal]

1. 02:23:710 (1,3) - Maybe swap combos? Like remove combo here and add one at 02:25:066 (1). Just a suggestion.

[Hard]

1. 00:06:761 (1) - Well, you do have an unsnapped green line here. Very minor tbh.

[It's my pleasure to meet you...]

1. Good map, but maybe reduce the OD to 8.

Not really much worth mentioning tbh. No need for kudosu if this doesn't help you lol

most of them are general things. all fixed.

Kisses wrote:

• Easy
  I think you're better off removing the slider tick rate as it's not really needed and even sounds awkward in some sliders such as 00:26:083 (1) but slidertick rate <1 is not rankable

1. 02:06:083 (1) - It's awfully quiet here and imo I dont think you can justify a spinner here the pitch slowly goes up so it works imo

• Hard

1. 02:06:083 (1) - i think this spiiner should start 02:10:151 . I mean this is where the sound starts ummm, that might be correct, but I want to extend the spinner so it won't be that hard to complete. But, this point did notice me about the problem on HP setting.
2. 02:56:931 (1) - Delete NC Personally I would like to keep it cuz they are two mirrored patterns, so I can simply specifying them with another NC

Kisses wrote:

• Normal

1. 00:36:253 (2) - I would move this down a bit so the between (1) and (3) is nice and smooth Tried something here
2. 01:12:354 - I really dont like how you skipped this beat, it feels really empty Fixed

N0thingSpecial wrote:

from your M4M, the diffs are good so I'll probably just be nazi-ing, so deny all of the mods if you will, cause it is all issues that can be ignored and it would still be rankable and fun to play

it's me pleasure to mod this

00:03:371 (3) - 00:06:083 (3) - 00:08:795 (3) - 00:11:507 (3) - 00:14:219 (3) - 00:16:931 (3) - 00:19:643 (3) - I feel like these are oversimplifying the melody that the song provides basically that's exactly what i want to do here tbh

00:23:032 (1,1) - it feels like this could be a slider instead for better playability but somehow a slider can't be better than circles for the momentum

00:24:219 (4) - OCD, the top part of the zig zag is not parallel to the bottom part. idk looks good to me

00:31:507 (1,2,3,4) - not a big fan of these symmetrical angled sliders, try this but their lengths are calculated so their angles can be all well-performed for the pattern

01:15:575 (3,4) - these could 1/4 sliders instead of 1/8, feels like it fits the no, they should be in 1/8

01:19:473 (5) - why not a 1/4 slider if the song did provided that 1/4 there, plus you have a clap there so the emphasis would be stronger there get into the background and you'll find out there's no bass and drum around this place, so a plain pattern is better for that cuz circles wont do echoing

01:38:626 (5,1) - not an overlap but it still felt cluttered when I played it and it caught my eye gonna say that's fine for me as always

02:39:473 (4) - I feel like it would fit the melody better if this was a 1/2 slider + triplet, I played it and it felt awkward as I need to hold for 1/1 when the was a prominent note in the melody All of the 1/4 triplets/streams are all intentionally removed (except the middle one cuz part finisher) so it can separate two kiais with their own different unique style. as you can see, the first kiai is much complicate.

03:02:580 (5) - this sounds like it should end at 1/4 not 1/6 NOT 1/4 but a different 1/6, changed

03:08:456 (1,2,1,2) - for more relaxing play (not necessarily better) I feel like these two should be 1/3 sliders with reveres arrow so the player would know the next set would also be 1/3 i'd rather stay like this with a different NC pattern

I know it's useless but have my star ༼ つ ◕_◕ ༽つ ☆

100bit wrote:

Hey from my queue, my name is Max 100bit, and this is my mod!
Well, opinion of modder is opinion of modder.
Do not judge strictly, I could be wrong.
And yep, I am just learning. My english is bad, so sorry for googletranslate.
P.S. I think, you need BN here... I'm afraid that I'll be useless.

Song and beatmaps

Add "8bit" or "chuptune" to Tags not going to do that cuz mashup, they both didn't go through the whole song

Easy

02:48:795 (4,1) - you can make blanket here (thereby you avoid this flow-overlap)
03:04:388 (3) - reverse red-sliderpoint (%image%)
both of them are intentionally made, and i don't know why people keep complaining about some sliderbody block

Hard

00:01:337 (1,2) - don't stack because you don't have stacks "slider-circle" in following patterns I'm gonna keep that for a calm intro starter
00:24:049 (3,4) - strange jump i think why do I have to change that? I guess I need a better reason to convince me for this move
01:19:219 - add note for triple (you have chiptune-sound here) triplets here are not for such a plain thing
01:40:659 (1) - remove nc this NC is placed for the pattern's sake

Good luck!
{end of mod}

100bit wrote:

Chu's Normal

00:17:609 (3) - normal lines is boring:D You're right omg fixed
00:54:219 (3,4,5,1) - i think this pattern is hard for novice (because it's hard for me xD) ok i will fix it for u ♥(wtf
01:12:524 (6) - make sliderpoints away from each other ok
01:31:676 (2,3) - i don't hear any sounds here and i think you should move 01:31:676 (2) - to 01:31:846 tried something here
01:35:575 (3,4) - strange flow fixed
02:27:100 (4,4) - stack? If I stack it ,the distance of 02:28:795 (4,1) will be sucky but I will keep your opinion
03:04:388 (1) - remove nc fixed

1. Would name this Normal already for these 1/1 circle patterns.

1. 00:34:219 (4,1) - NC switch and set one at 00:36:592 (5) - . Also switch NC at 00:42:015 (6,1) - and:
   00:47:439 (5,1) - 00:54:897 (5,1) - 00:55:236 (1,2) - 00:58:287 (7,1) -
2. 00:50:151 (4) - NC
3. Okay, seems like your NCing is somewhat strange, it'd have been better if you set them after every 2 stanzas. Please check your whole NCing again, it's inconsistent right now.
4. 01:25:066 (3,4) - Try to avoid polarity switches when possible, here it'd have been better if you set a circle at 01:25:744 - to avoid this.
5. 01:27:100 - Same as above.

1. 02:32:863 (1) - Shouldn't be necessary, delete NC.
2. 02:34:558 (5,1) - 03:12:524 (5,1) - Nc switch.

1. 01:06:422 (3) - NC for new song section
2. 01:18:456 (1,2,3,4) - Found that rhythm pattern unintuitive to play, mostly due to weird polarity changes. Works with the song, but considering you're not following that main 8-bit melody afterwards anymore it'd be better if you set circles on the white ticks after these doublets to have a more stable rhythm pattern.

1. Just naming it Another would be cool already imo
2. 01:15:236 (1,2,3,4) - Nice 1/8, but they don't follow what is played in the music. Idk if you want to leave this at that.
3. 01:17:948 (1) - I found this single 1/8 slider in the middle of nowhere confusing, a 1/4 slider would fit in better to the rhythm here.
4. 01:43:032 (1,2) -
5. 02:14:219 (4,1) - 02:19:643 (4,1) - NC switch here, you did the same at 00:47:439 (1) - 00:52:863 (1) -
6. 02:50:490 (2,2,2) - 328 | 16. Sets the accents on the 2-circles properly which are also the notes emphasized in the track.

Pho wrote:

Quality mod. LOL

[Easy]

1. Would name this Normal already for these 1/1 circle patterns. done. Also adjusted the song settings cuz that's too weird.

[Hard]

1. 02:32:863 (1) - Shouldn't be necessary, delete NC.
2. 02:34:558 (5,1) - 03:12:524 (5,1) - Nc switch. all done

[N/A]

1. Just naming it Another would be cool already imo i really want to keep this ;-;
2. 01:15:236 (1,2,3,4) - Nice 1/8, but they don't follow what is played in the music. Idk if you want to leave this at that. uhh i tend to keep them
3. 01:17:948 (1) - I found this single 1/8 slider in the middle of nowhere confusing, a 1/4 slider would fit in better to the rhythm here. I don't have problem playing this diff myself, but you're right. changed.
4. 01:43:032 (1,2) - not knowing what you're going to say...though I understand this sucks
5. 02:14:219 (4,1) - 02:19:643 (4,1) - NC switch here, you did the same at 00:47:439 (1) - 00:52:863 (1) - ok
6. 02:50:490 (2,2,2) - 328 | 16. Sets the accents on the 2-circles properly which are also the notes emphasized in the track. done. that's much better.

Can't say that much about this set, clean maps overall.
Can call me back when you think it's ready. Good luck! o/

1. remake the slider on 02:00:659 (1) - in Easy and Hard
2. change all of the 1/3 patterns into soft sample so hitnormal won't mess up with the song itself

Pho wrote:

[Kyubey's Insane]

1. 01:06:422 (3) - NC for new song section it's strange i skipped it
2. 01:18:456 (1,2,3,4) - Found that rhythm pattern unintuitive to play, mostly due to weird polarity changes. Works with the song, but considering you're not following that main 8-bit melody afterwards anymore it'd be better if you set circles on the white ticks after these doublets to have a more stable rhythm pattern. but i'm following the 8-bit tunes where it's possible, the only thing i mostly ignored is the tune in the end of track because it would be very unpleasant to play. chiptune doubles are way too significant here so i can't change them to triples, because it starts sounding weird for me

All updated.

MrSergio wrote:

Ok, nevermind, I'll be qualifying this tomorrow