Like in the title, i think it would render better to have the pitch of the song modified instead of the speed.
Let me know what do you think. /
Let me know what do you think. /
It is not possible to both maintain the original pitch and have smooth audio at the same time, you either pick one or the other. Pitch shift is miles better as it makes it a lot easier to determine pitch and incorrect snaps, I seriously don't know what valid argument could be brought up to keep it the way it is right now.abraker wrote:
No, but changing the pitch on any speed would be helpful. Also the editor needs to have smooth playback on slower speeds. Mapping to crackled audio is hard at times when there is a lot going on.
Read Halogen-'s post. Have you tried slowing down the pitch of a song? There's no difference in pitch. There are mappers with absolute (or relative) pitch who can prove this.baraatje123 wrote:
Back to my point for Taiko mappers
This should never happen
It makes distinguishing little different pitches near impossible
Note: I do not know how to call the pitch of a music, so I just use random numberRead Halogen-'s post. Slowed down or not the root note will be the same, and the differences in pitch between notes will be the same. The difference in pitch doesn't change because of the song is slowed down, it just lowers the octave of the music. Listening to it on a lower speed will make the music a lower octave and unarguably easier to catch pitch differences slowed down. Slowing down the track while keeping the pitch creates distortion and other unnecessary artifacts that create unnecessary clutter and difficulty.
Let's say, the pitch of a low tuned note is 80, a high tuned note is 100
Has a difference of 20, so good to distinguish
If you then play at 25%, the pitch will also be 25%
80 becomes 20, 100 becomes 25
Now there is only 5 difference, which is really low, and it's really hard to find out whether it's high or low
Since it goes too fast at 100%, even at 50%, most people use 25% to do this
Also, it would just sound terrible if you use it to check a map/modCompletely subjective and irrelevant to the topic. Please stop.
I strongly disagree with this, and I'll try to do as much to ever prevent this from happening
Then why not just have it as a toggled option? That way, everyone can be happy.baraatje123 wrote:
But still, it'll sound terrible, and it'll be annoying as heck for modders (and probably almost all mappers)
How did you do it?abraker wrote:
Jeez the one without the pitch shift is crap. What did you use?
This is how it is supposed to sound like and this is the action osu is missing (25% speed of original):
http://a.pomf.se/arjbxp.webm