1. Marathon (4,25 stars, 2782 notes)

1. 14:38:529 (2,4) - su su nazi stalka meglio questi due per essere perfettamente uno sotto l'altro
2. 14:44:648 (4,5) - io ti consiglierei di fare una cosa del genere dato che flowa molto meglio rispetto alla tua attuale pattern,ossia il cerchio che stava al centro puo rimanere ma cambia gli altri due in uno slider
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 14:50:766 (8) - io direi di metterci uno NC qui per accentuare il break che sta arrivando
4. 15:05:888 (7,8) - orribile D: ti consiglio di fare di questi uno slider e magari di posizionarlo in modo figo e difficile cosi ci sono due slider contemporaneamente \o3o\
5. 15:08:685 (7,8) - stessa cosa con questi due
6. 15:11:483 (7,8) - anche qui
7. 15:14:280 (7,8) - dinuovo
8. 15:18:038 (5) - all'inizio di questo slider diminuisci il volume è troppo forte imo e poi aumentalo piano piano andando alla fine dello slider affinche sia una cosa graduale
9. 15:24:069 (7,8) - stessa cosa di prima
10. 15:26:866 (7,8) - idem
11. 15:29:664 (7,8) - ancora o3o
12. 15:32:461 (7,8) - yap ^
13. 15:35:258 (7,8) - uguu ^
14. 15:38:142 (5,6) - che ne dici di finire cosi?
    
    SPOILER

    

1. 14:37:655 - Consider mapping to this spot to catch the second syllable of "needed"
2. 14:39:228 (4,5,1) - Since you already have a stack here, this isn't really needed as it really don't have much effect on the song, but if you want to stack these properly under the previous (2). move these to x256 y162 (y+2)
3. 14:43:074 (4) - Control+J and place at x40 y408 (so the tail ends in the same spot as before) to emphasize on the 1/1 gap more.
4. 15:18:038 (5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - how about 40-45% volume here? The current 65% is a bit loud and overpowers the music.
5. 15:19:437 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Maybe consider moving this stack to around x308 y172 (or diagonal from this) so it fits between both the 1/16 slider repeats when playing the song.
6. 15:32:723 (1) - Finish? This is really the only thing that didn't sound consistent throughout the rest of the difficulty as you Finish at both 15:21:534 (1) - and 15:27:129 (1) - before this.

1. 14:33:984 (1,2) - I personally feel that this jump is way too big compared to the other jumps in this section, even though they're spaced by a beat in the timeline. Make them smaller maybe, like this? It also creates a better flow.
2. 14:49:193 (4,1) - Move (4) to (214,273) and (1) to (256,362) for a better flow from 14:48:494 (2,3)?
3. 15:03:353 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Uh, don't you think you used this rhythm way too much? I know the music gets kinda repetitive, but I think you can use rhythm varieties too here... And maybe add whistles on spots like 15:03:353 (1), 15:03:790, and 15:04:402 so it won't feel too monotonous while playing.
4. 15:37:443 (3,4,5) - Make them spaced by around 1.2-1.3x? This is to make sure this part is more intuitive to play due to the off-beat rhythm (what with the 3/4 gaps and the positioning of the objects).

1. 14:28:914 (2) - why make jump this? I think not jump better this place.
   
   img

   
2. 14:33:984 (1,2) - Distance2.54 too large. Please same as distance 14:39:578 (1,2) - here?
   and same as suggestion 14:33:984 (1,2) - here. I think same melody 14:28:390 (1,2,3) - this.
   Try an arrange like this?
   
   img

   
3. 14:37:655 (4,5) - More better rhythm,follow with lyrics,like this.
   
   
   suggestion

   
4. 14:40:976 (4,5) - Why only this distance too large? please same as 14:46:571 (4,5) - this?

1. Try to move the preview point to 14:28:390 - since it's the most awesome part of the mix.Seriously, it's awesome and it is the MOST memorable part.
2. This mapset needs that nightcore skin. I really miss this awesome skin in this map, the ,osz file is already huge, adding extra 2mbs won't hurt too much.
3. You make Gero sad by keeping the Widescreen Support enabled. The SB is completely made for 4:3 displays!
4. It woulb be awesome to list all the songs and give links to them in case if anyone would like to play the full version. It may help some players.
5. List of the tags from th previous mod contains quite a lot of short (less than 3 characters words), which won't really work with the currnt search engime. So, I've fixed it a bit.
   
   tags (short words are removed)

   highland solo rollergirl superstar camilot amore you got dancing bimba hey now ursura and datura infinity molella love last forever stefy nrg it's its fable baracuda where is the alex feat yasmin angel of darkness astroline close eyes isabel will heart survive tune bounce cascada ready for again dangerous baby alice pina colada boy truly madly deeply kat deluna busta rhymes run the show getter jaani rockefeller street snyder ray together spyne pippo palmieri deep soul christmas melanie flash one in million fantasy project dam dadi doo jan wayne scarlet touch myself allstar featuring naz bermuda loverz girl belle lovers lawrence bad day digital sexy til until death yamboo feelings tronix be with remix
   Note: I've aded a few more tags like featuring instead of just feat and remix sice all these songs are remixed!
   
   It's awsome to see how you've organized it, it looks really amazing and brings so many memories. <3

1. Try Circle Size 4,5 since some of the maps were meant to be played with CS4 and some with CS5. Using something like 4,5 would help to make it look awesome.
2. 15:18:737 (6) - watch out! THe 1/8 transitions in the end of 15 minutes long map will surely be painful. Try to make each slider shorter by one repeat, so players will be able to pass it easier and it still will ft with the music.
3. 15:20:835 (1,2,3,4) - minor - I would unstack (4) since it may be a bit hard to switch from 1/4 to 1/2 like this. Please, keep in mind that this is a marathon map and players will be really tired after such a long map!
4. 15:20:835 (1,2,3,4) - sudden change to 1/1 rhythm here feels a bit unnatural. Try to map the bells on this downbeat, it will fit quite cool there, imo. Same applies to 15:37:618 - and 15:37:967 - you really should consider these two since polarity breaks here and it feels uncomfortable while playing.

1. While I do think Hp 7 is a fine idea, you might want to consider using 6,5. I think that'd be quite appropriate for the slower parts so the drain wouldn't be too harsh. Don't get me wrong here, 7 works nicely too, just something you might want to think!
2. Yeah I have to agree with -Bakari- here because even though Cs 4 looks really good on this mapset, I think Cs 4,5 would look more epic on it, give it a try.
3. 14:28:390 (1,2,3) - This pattern looks quite nice but I think this would look a bit better since it forms a better ''O'' if you get what I am saying here;
   
   Example

   
4. 14:50:067 (2,3) - Agreeing with Desperate-kun here, you really should put 2 more up in order to make this play better, consider it.
5. 15:20:136 - The whole empty space was dull, I mean it's cool to have a break like this somewhere but since it's the last song, I think there should be a movement or something you have to do. This is why I'm suggesting you to put a 1/4 repeat slider from 15:20:136 - till 15:20:660 - , I think that plays really nicely, your choice in the end, though!
6. 15:24:158 (9,2) - Wouldn't it make more sense if either 9 or 2 was on the same grid level? 9 is at x:96 while 2 is at x:92, place 2 at x:348 y:96 in order to fix this?
7. 15:35:870 (3,4,5,6,7) - This is alright, but what makes me angry is that the blanket got totally ignored and compared to rest of the sliders, these would need more curve in order to fit better so I've made an example how this gets fixed on the most part, use it if you like it;
   
   Example

   
8. 15:37:705 (4) - Yes, a NC here would be nice, same comment what Desperate-kun made, consider it o/

Lach wrote:

Do you people really think that this is okay? Literally every map is copy pasted from the originals. Disgusting.

Mao wrote:

But well, I guess we should accept it due to this being a Andrea-NC-Map compilation :<