-Kamikaze- wrote:

So, I'm kinda bored and I don't feel like modding atm

http://puu.sh/dh04u/d5bbd5a254.png

Spy wrote:

It's looks fine,but gaps between NM,HD and MX...
I feel not ok a bit,try to make gaps not such big,and call me back then.

hutunohito wrote:

Spy wrote:

It's looks fine,but gaps between NM,HD and MX...
I feel not ok a bit,try to make gaps not such big,and call me back then.

I think gap between hd and mx is ok
Because https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/260369 gets rank
This has 1.5 sd gap,same as mama

DE-CADE wrote:

This just my opinion how to deal with the gap, but still fun to play, feel free to ignore it

Gap amount :
6.77 - 5.15 = 1.62
5.15 - 4.84 = 0.31
4.84 - 3.59 = 1.25
3.59 - 1.82 = 1.77

[SHD]

SPOILER

by adding note at
00:24:918 - col 3
00:25:261 - col 3
02:13:604 - col 4
02:14:290 - col 1
02:14:975 - col 2
02:16:347 - col 1
02:17:032 - col 2
02:17:718 - col 3
^ i know it will be not symmetrical as before, the point is put double on every white line (clap sound) on that section so i think you will find a way to make your pattern symmetrical as before

this can make The Star into 5.4 and the diff gap is smoother than before
I also thought of that but I want the players to hit those patterns with comfortability.

6.77 - 5.40 = 1.37
5.40 - 4.84 = 0.51

[MX]

next will try to make it MX smoother with HD

SPOILER

I decided not to put chords on a snare/clap-like sounds and I want the players to feel the continuous rhythm in this pattern.
00:20:461 - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2368388
00:21:832 - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2368388
00:23:204 - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2368399
00:24:575 - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2368403


I rearranged the 02:10:175 part and made it half jumpstream, not jumptrills anymore. Thanks for this suggestion~!
02:10:175 - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2368413
02:11:547 - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2368415
02:12:918 - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2368411
02:15:661 - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2368409
^ sometimes you dont need to follow the instrument, this will make the chart easier, i think you wont like it but amount star of this diff will be around 4.66

so the gap on each diff will be

6.77 - 5.40 = 1.37
5.40 - 4.66 = 0.8
4.66 - 3.59 = 1.07
3.59 - 1.82 = 1.77

which is nearly to 1.0, very smooth unless NM to HD which is more than 1.5 but i think it's should be fine, this is 4K, it's easier to learn than 7K

My Opinion about difficulty

NM : good diff for newbie, advanced player can SS
HD : warmup diff, best place for 1/4 stream
MX : best diff to introduce 1/8 stream
SHD : best diff to use 1/8 st more also best way to introduce a 1/8 double
ExTra : best diff to kill yourself

i think that's all i can do,remember this is not nazi mod, you can always ignore all of it if you think it will ruin your Pattern/Beatmap
but you can rethink about that

I'm just wanna see this beatmap ranked
Good Luck ~ You're the Best arcwin

-Kamikaze- wrote:

Optionally you could nerf NM to around 1,5 star, change name to EZ and add NM with ~2,5 stars. This would assure a better spread.

Kuo Kyoka wrote:

High Speed Music Team Sharpnel - M.A.M.A. [Osu!Mania Modding]

===

From Kuo Kyoka's osu!mania Modding Queue

Mod Requested by arcwinolivirus

[Generals]
- BPM: Okay
- Offset: Okay
- AiMod: No Problem
- Tags: remove Sharpnel, already have on artist
- BG: Okay
- Kiai: Okay

Column
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |

“Here come of some suggest for your map, I always check fullmap, if I’m too tried I will come back soon, or only check that keys by the request! And remember to reply the mod when you’re accepcted it or not! And forget my kud if my suggest is useful ~ Thanks for requested me ~

[NM]

SPOILER

1. 00:25:947 (25947|0) - maybe add a note in here, cause it have the same strong with 00:28:690 - nope not the same strong sound as in this measure line there is no cymbals occured
2. 00:35:375 - you forgot a note on-purpose
3. 00:35:547 - remove one, the beat doesnt strong as 00:36:918 - removed note at column 1
4. 00:41:204 (41204|3) - remove this one, before only begin at 00:38:632 - when have the voice with bass following the bass also same as 00:46:690 (46690|3) -
5. 01:10:861 - forgot a note on-purpose, following the vocal to have variation
6. 01:11:718 - I think should remove this note, doesnt have this part when have the same sound (m a m a) like before vocal of woo-"hoo"
7. 01:16:347 - forgot a note same as the other one. on-purpose
8. 01:17:204 (77204|2) - remove if you following that sound only woo-hoo. same reason
9. 01:47:890 - and 01:48:232 - add one more note? great notice! also added some notes on other cymbalic sound parts~
   The after is okay with me :3
   Nice

[HD]

SPOILER

1. 01:04:261 - add a note in here? ooh great notice!
2. In 01:12:404 - you only used one note and in 01:15:147 - have the same strong with that and you used two notes, suggest move one its on purpose~ alternate 2-noter phase
   The rest seems fine with me
   This is my favorited's diff

[MX]

SPOILER

1. Ready for rank ~ Thank you ^o^

[SHD]

SPOILER

1. 00:04:004 - suggest to using the short long note like the after in here good idea!
2. 01:36:832 - you forgot a note, add one to like the other just realized, ok!
3. 01:31:347 - suggest add one more note in here cause it have the same strong with 01:32:718 - but only have a note been thinking of this but ok!
4. 01:42:318 - same here ok!
   I love the pattern while the last Thanks!

[ETxrA]

SPOILER

1. 00:00:318 (318|2) - the begin sound in on 00:00:404 -
2. 00:01:775 (1775|1) - the end voice is on 00:02:075 - (1/8)
3. 00:02:375 (2375|1) - the voice in on 00:02:332 - (1/8)
4. 00:02:547 - in here is only begin the sound but in 00:02:590 - is begin the voice, so 00:02:547 (2547|3) - move to 00:02:590 -
   All okay above, approved >w<)b
   
5. 00:04:004 - same with SHD done!
6. 00:25:947 - add a note in here?? cause doesnt have same strong with 00:25:775 - OK! fixed the Extra's version too!
   Nice diff with a lot of Challenges

[Comment]
I love the map with the map and your charts too :3 Mama :v lmao ~
Pls go rank this ~ pls pls, if yes, the ETxrA will be more harder than AiAe
Good luck ~

Also NM star rating from 1.82 to 2 stars!! Same with HD wich is 3.22 stars only! Now that's more reasonable


EDIT: On-hold for bubble request. Waiting for Kuo Kyoka for the SB

arcwinolivirus wrote:

EDIT: On-hold for bubble request. Waiting for Kuo Kyoka for the SB

Mike Ace wrote:

R.I.P M.A.M.A :v

rfandomization wrote:

This needs to come back :c