1. Easy (2,5 stars, 75 notes)
2. Hard (4,9 stars, 205 notes)
3. Impact (4,99 stars, 339 notes)
4. Normal (4,4 stars, 124 notes)

GoldenWolf wrote:

[Impact]
OD10 pls okay

You started a lot of triples/streams after a 1/2 slider, I hoped you'd start more of them directly :< Doesn't really matter though

01:19:894 (2) - felt a bit too far away from the slider, probably because of the low spacing just before, was a little awkward, not a big deal though it's the lowest spacing I used in the whole kiai parts o:

can't find anything, this is 2gud

[Hard]

AR+1, 7 feels a bit too low for this slider speed/kind of patterns not sure but okay

01:15:437 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - make it more neat pls goddamnit gw
01:16:637 - do you really want to skip that beat? feels weird yeah idk, I didn't want to overdo it with consecutive circles, I'll keep it in mind

[Normal]

01:37:380 (4,5,6) - looks like easy mess up for newbies, especially if you put at the very end :< evil
something like 01:15:437 (2,3) - would be better imo i'll wait for more opinions on this, keeping for now

[Easy]

HP-1 ? ok

Really can't find much more ;_; Nice hitsounds btw

彡☆

1. Why OD10, OD9 is already questionable for an insane, 10 is just too much
2. 00:48:523 (4,5,6) - Spacing this out just a little bit more would make it a ton better to read
3. 01:01:894 (2,3,4) - Would like to see a direction change here, flows kind of odd imo, try this? http://puu.sh/8s7Iz.jpg
4. 01:23:666 (1,2,3) - Would put this like this: http://puu.sh/8s7LQ.jpg just for the looks, gameplay doesn't really change

1. 01:12:694 (5) - ctrl+g this to create a simple jump, since there's a little gap between the hard and the insane it wouldn't hurt to do so
2. 01:30:523 (1) - Might as well do the same here
   Got nothing to complain here, great diff

1. 00:48:352 (3) - The whistle on the end of this slider feels off, there's not really something in the song that indicates there should be a whistle here, I think it would be better without it
2. 00:50:752 (2) - ^
3. 00:53:494 (2) - ^ kshro the hitsound modder
4. 00:55:723 - I think it'd play a lot better if you added a note here, would be consistent with the rest too

1. 00:42:523 (2) - Would be cool if you increased the slider's length by 1/2, you can stack it with 00:40:809 (5) - to fix the spacing if you do
2. 00:52:123 (1) - Same here actually, if you decrease this slider by 1/2 and add a repeat it fits a lot better, rearranging this to fix the spacing wouldn't be much of a problem either
3. 01:00:352 (1) - Same thing, decrease length by 1/2, it hurts to see you're skipping the awesome guitar sound :c A simple CTRL+G would fix the spacing if you do this

Kyshiro wrote:

Took my god damn time to get to this

Impact

1. Why OD10, OD9 is already questionable for an insane, 10 is just too much b-b-b-but another modder wanted this :< I'm gonna think about OD when I intend to search for BAT
2. 00:48:523 (4,5,6) - Spacing this out just a little bit more would make it a ton better to readyeah i guess
3. 01:01:894 (2,3,4) - Would like to see a direction change here, flows kind of odd imo, try this? http://puu.sh/8s7Iz.jpg I considered it but I can't really find a way to make it work properly with the next circles idk, i don't really like it sorry
4. 01:23:666 (1,2,3) - Would put this like this: http://puu.sh/8s7LQ.jpg just for the looks, gameplay doesn't really change i have other patterns like this tho,I don't really think it's an issue nvm changed anyway because why not

Hard

1. 01:12:694 (5) - ctrl+g this to create a simple jump, since there's a little gap between the hard and the insane it wouldn't hurt to do so
2. 01:30:523 (1) - Might as well do the same here
   Got nothing to complain here, great diff
   sorry, I'm not a fan of such backwards leading reversed sliders =/

Normal

1. 00:48:352 (3) - The whistle on the end of this slider feels off, there's not really something in the song that indicates there should be a whistle here, I think it would be better without it
2. 00:50:752 (2) - ^
3. 00:53:494 (2) - ^ kshro the hitsound modder
4. 00:55:723 - I think it'd play a lot better if you added a note here, would be consistent with the rest too
   did all this

Easy

1. 00:42:523 (2) - Would be cool if you increased the slider's length by 1/2, you can stack it with 00:40:809 (5) - to fix the spacing if you do
2. 00:52:123 (1) - Same here actually, if you decrease this slider by 1/2 and add a repeat it fits a lot better, rearranging this to fix the spacing wouldn't be much of a problem either
3. 01:00:352 (1) - Same thing, decrease length by 1/2, it hurts to see you're skipping the awesome guitar sound :c A simple CTRL+G would fix the spacing if you do this
   did all this

Awesome and clean mapset have my star

1. My goodness, your map is not difficulty spread friendly (especially between Hard and Insane)! >.< Anyways, I personally prefer if the OD and HP spread were like this: 2 -> 4 -> 6 -> 8. However, if you prefer Your OD to be 3 -> 5 -> 7-> 9 then at least make the HP Drain spread to be 1 -> 3 -> 5 -> 7.

1. 00:53:152 - Nothing much to mention on this difficulty, but i feel that you should add a note (or simply make a 3/2 reverse slider) here since this follows with a prominent note owo. Alternatively, you can also extend the slider at 00:52:123 (1) so it ends at 00:53:152.

1. As I did notice some spacing inconsistencies here and there, I didn't witnessed any flow and playability issues while test playing this difficulty except maybe 01:37:380 (4,5,6). If you want to keep, you could at least move 01:38:409 (6) at 268|56 for a more consistent spacing. Other than that, Good standing!

1. Good difficulty, but isn't AR8 too high for this difficulty? I prefer if you reduce to to AR7 for Hard. A good AR spread like 3 -> 5 -> 7-> 9 would be fine!

1. Whoa, talk about huge spread increase compare to Hard difficulty and umm .... OD9? That's too high imo! >.<

1. 00:35:323 (3) - / 00:38:066 (7) - / 00:40:809 (6) - Actually, I don't think they should be 3/4. If you listen carefully, there's a clear sound on the red tick where the slider should finish. I feel like that's wrong to play as it is now and, moreover, the current pattern makes soft-finishes sound way too weird.
2. 00:53:837 (3,4,5,6) - I would go for two sliders (1/1 + 1/2 with repeat) instead of notes, they follow the music better in my opinion but hey notes can work fine as well.
3. 00:56:580 (3,4,5,6,7) - / 00:59:323 (3,4,5,6,7) - I'm not a big fan of 1/4 notes after sliders, but I still suggest a change here since they are the only two cases in the whole map, you can try to use only circles instead. If you don't want to change this pattern on a rhythmic side, consider making this prettier since circles could follow slider's path.
4. 01:02:237 (4,5,6) - / 01:10:466 (3,4,5) - You may have added them in order to vary the patterns, but I don't think 1/4 sliders could fit this song nicely, notes are way much better
5. 01:06:352 (3,4,5) - / 01:14:580 (3,4,5) - / 01:22:809 (3,4,5) - Always about aesthetic, you could apply some little changes on patterns like this (in these cases, I'd stack the notes under slider's tail)

Leader wrote:

Das ist alles, ruf mich zurück an (??)

Irreversible wrote:

Leader wrote:

Das ist alles, ruf mich zurück an (??)

ha.. ha..haha

Leader wrote:

[Insane]

1. 00:35:323 (3) - / 00:38:066 (7) - / 00:40:809 (6) - Actually, I don't think they should be 3/4. If you listen carefully, there's a clear sound on the red tick where the slider should finish. I feel like that's wrong to play as it is now and, moreover, the current pattern makes soft-finishes sound way too weird. There's sounds on both the red and the blue ticks, and I think they feel pretty awesome idk, also I made them pretty quiet so the effect oin the finish shouldn't be too big?
2. 00:53:837 (3,4,5,6) - I would go for two sliders (1/1 + 1/2 with repeat) instead of notes, they follow the music better in my opinion but hey notes can work fine as well. I changed this using 2 sliders, I made them overlap a bit, idk, tell me whether it looks okay pls, since I don't have many overlaps in the map
3. 00:56:580 (3,4,5,6,7) - / 00:59:323 (3,4,5,6,7) - I'm not a big fan of 1/4 notes after sliders neither am I , but I still suggest a change here since they are the only two cases in the whole map, you can try to use only circles instead. If you don't want to change this pattern on a rhythmic side, consider making this prettier since circles could follow slider's path. the direction is intended tho :p check the rest of the map, theres stuff liek this everywhere I changed the patterns anyway.
4. 01:02:237 (4,5,6) - / 01:10:466 (3,4,5) - You may have added them in order to vary the patterns, but I don't think 1/4 sliders could fit this song nicely, notes are way much better people kept pestering me about this, so i guess a change is needed!
5. 01:06:352 (3,4,5) - / 01:14:580 (3,4,5) - / 01:22:809 (3,4,5) - Always about aesthetic, you could apply some little changes on patterns like this (in these cases, I'd stack the notes under slider's tail) nope :p There's barely anything I dislike more than circles stacked below a slidertail

Das ist alles, ruf mich zurück an (??) ♥ ♥ ♥