TestApple wrote:

Modding because neonat is being a big meanie and forcing me to

Estellia- wrote:

どうして...Neonat senpai's maps are so good I'm in no position to mod ><

Ok 5 min map GO!

00:14:270 (5) - This note looks a bit weird here, can shift up + right more don't think I'm moving this one
00:15:413 (5) - A little too blunt for a ~ slider made it curvier
00:24:984 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Star formation here looks a bit lopsided it's 2 separate triangles, that's why it looks weirder
00:31:984 (1,2,3,4,1) - You can make this a 5-point star formation going for certain directional flow
00:42:984 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I suggest you make note 5 two hitcircles and make them jump a bit more adjusted in a way
00:48:984 (2,3,4,5) - You can make this a square, it looks better ok
00:52:556 (3,4,5,6) - Triangle here maybe? reason being last time (5) was closer to make a triangle, but the flow was bad
01:20:127 (4) - Curve here looks a bit unnatural
01:20:698 (1,2,3) - Triangle maybe?
01:27:841 (2) - You can move this further away ok
01:47:270 (1,2,3,4) - It looks lopsided, fix it shifted (3)
02:07:841 (2,3,4,5) - Same^ shifted 4 to make it resemble some pattern at least
02:47:556 (1,1) - These shapes look forced, don't have to make it like this I think I will keep them
03:10:413 (1,2,3,4) - Make this more 'parallelogram' like ok
03:23:841 (4) - This looks kinda obstructive. You can shift this up and make it curve a little to blanket the previous slider didn't really change this one lol
03:24:698 (3,4,5) - It looks weird, but its ok if you keep it there shifted down
03:32:413 (1,2,3,4,5) - 5-point star maybe? not the intended flow
03:37:270 (1,2,3,4,5) - Same^ (It looks a little lopsided) ok
03:41:984 (2,3,4,5) - Make these 4 notes more diamond shaped? tried
04:06:413 (1,2,3) - You can angle them each at 30deg away from each other, because as of now it looks weird. changed somewhat
04:44:127 (1,2,3,4) - A little awkward, but its ok
04:47:698 (5,6) - Move these 2 notes further from the notes before, it has a dramatic factor. moved further then
05:16:127 (1,1) - Oh well~ yeah.

Another grand masterpiece made by Neonat senpaiiii~ I love your style and beat placement! The patterns might seem a bit wonky at times, but its all good~

TestApple wrote:

Modding because neonat is being a big meanie and forcing me to

[Daisuki]

Generally tried not to comment a slider shapes I particularly disliked.

00:36:841 (4) - NC please neo-senpai. DS pretty confusing with your constant inconsistent (heh) DS throughout map. just gonna keep this as a single solo combo then
00:36:984 (1) - Remove NC because ^ refer^
00:55:556 (1) - Tilt slider slightly, perfectly straight downwards with a slant is pretty weird here. ok
00:58:556 (4) - Move up slightly and Ctrl + G. My feeling is that this has a more speedy feel, nicer to play~ I tried to place it like what you said I think
01:20:984 (1,2,3) - Bend 1 slightly backwards to form more of a windmill sorts with 2 and 3. rotated
01:52:698 (5) - NC becuz i lov da bounce
02:19:698 (4) - Make further from 3 or NC please ;-; Neo-senpai are you trying to kill my reading. lol, but the distance is already bigger
03:20:127 (3) - Ctrl + G because flow seems better that way. Seems. ok
03:21:351 (3) - Ctrl + G because flow seems better that way. Seems.it highlights a circle
03:28:413 (5,6) - Ctrl + G because flow seems better that way. Seems. doesn't feel right
03:35;841 (5,6) - NC 5 ;-; no thnx
04:06:698 (2,3) - Ctrl + G either 2 or 3. Feels weird in this form. changed it in a way from previous mod
04:28:127 (4) - CTRL + G PLS NEONAT SENPAI. THIS ONE. THIS ONEEE. k
04:47:698 (5,6) - NC 5. You know why. (・◡・) no thnx

Oh god DS neonat. DS. Eyes too. That or I'm bad at reading and I think that might be the case.

Timorisu wrote:

Modding because you got lucky in my always open queue :3

[General]

BG size must be 1366x768 for widescreen

The cropped glow on most of the SB images is very noticeable https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1765858

[Daisuki]

00:05:841 (3,4) - Blankets are off (very slightly) ok

00:07:127 (7) - 1 up for better triangle? k

00:13:413 (1) - A straight slider would be better imho keeping the shape

00:16:841 (2,3) - CTRL+G maybe don't really think I will

00:24:984 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - CTRL+Shift+D with some CTRL+G wizardry would look better keeping it as 2 separate patterns

00:38:841 (4) - End not perfectly under 2 done

00:48:556 (1) - The end looks very ugly I made it less sharp

00:50:270 (4,5) - http://puu.sh/9OZkX/2dd2e724cb.jpg sort of.

00:57:841 (2) - Move end to x:104 y:232 I shifted somewhat

01:20:413 (5) - x:96 y:116 for consistent spacing in the pattern k

01:30:984 (1) - Blanket's off adjusted

01:39:556 (3,4,5,1) - Space these out a bit further http://puu.sh/9OZzU/e929d5a938.jpg moved 4 and 5

02:20:127 (1) - Make this less curved and rotate it a bit made it less curved

02:23:413 (5,4) - Move these down 3 grids for a better star adjusted pattern

02:26:413 (3) - Not symmetrical not meant to be

02:30:270 (1) - Make this less curved not changing

02:41:698 (1) - ^ ^

02:47:556 (1) - http://puu.sh/9OZL3/a50b9f9343.jpg ^

02:48:556 (1) - ^ ^

03:05:127 (3) - http://puu.sh/9OZPy/cb0236a972.jpg changed shape

03:04:556 (1) - ^ no change

03:08:556 (4) - A normal curve would do k

03:13:698 (1) - http://puu.sh/9OZPy/cb0236a972.jpg no change

03:23:413 (3) - Grid snap the third point and move it down by 1 grid

03:32:413 (1,2,3,4,5) - CTRL+Shift+D 2 separate patterns

03:37:841 (5) - NC since this isn't lyrics

03:42:413 (5) - ^

04:05:698 (3) - Rotate by -11° did by 10

04:19:413 (3) - Make this more curved not changing

04:20:984 (5) - CTRL+G for the last 3 suggestions: having this 2 right and 2 left is to follow the vocals where it changes directions when they sing in a lower tone as well

04:21:270 (1) - CTRL+G

04:20:698 (4,5,1) - If you applied the suggestions above it should look like this http://puu.sh/9P08q/f1c13b357f.jpg

That's about it

Mira-san wrote:

Doing another (mini) mod because this is the best song of µ's ever.

General | Storyboard | Et cetera

Fix the shadow on SB\1.png because that bugs me lol. Also for SB\2.png, but the glow though.

SB\Lyric\44h.png and 44ha.png aaaa

Won't point out small ones because (obviously) they're not noticeable.

Use this BG so it's exactly 16:9.#miracroppower™.

µ's

Daisuki

00:30:270 (1) - Make this better (in shape) not changing this shape
00:52:698 (4) - Stack on (4)? lel not gonna stack because that's too far but I shifted to objects to make it easier to hit (though now further apart)
00:57:556 (1) - Move to x:398 y:170 wow 1 grid unit difference um ok
01:03:984 (4,5,6,7,8) - Could be improved imo. For cleanliness. made it more evenly spaced then
02:34:127 (2) - Move to x:138 y:187 err for stack? ok then

OK moving on.

Turn off kiai on these parts (purpose: awesomeness)
01:33:698 - 01:34:413
03:18:841 - 03:19:556
04:29:698 - 04:30:413

Gaia wrote:

Heya! From my queue

It's a 5 mins song yet you pretty much gave players no rest LOL rip to people who try to fc this
1.8x SV qq

00:13:984 (3,4,5) - spread out more? k
00:39:556 (3) - Ctrl + G I think this is better though
00:52:413 (2,3,4,5,6) - same time interval different distances so i think spread them all out? made changes in previous mod
01:00:984 (4) - ctrl + G? reconstructed that part
01:03:841 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - spread made even in previous mod
01:09:698 (3) - Right a lil more shifted up
01:22:413 (4) - Ctrl +G keeping the distance
01:22:698 (5) - ^ ^
01:23:984 (1) - overlapped a little bit yeh I know but keeping
01:26:270 (1) - curve more? k
01:32:556 (3,4) - isn't perfect mirror of 01:32:127 (1,2) - I think I didn't use mirror
01:57:270 (9) - unnecessary I find it weirder to end on the vocals at the 1/2 beat
02:21:984 (5) - not stacked properly not stacking
02:48:984 (2) - Ctrl + G
02:49:270 (3) - ^ makes it more difficult to go to 02:49:841 (1) so I don't think I will change them
02:51:270 (5) - (224, 68) k
02:53:556 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - Keep distances constant keeping this
03:20:127 (3) - ctrl + G? was initially that direction, till I felt it was weirder
03:24:698 (3,4,5) - oddly shaped triangle I reduced the angle for the bottom circle because of ease of movement
03:26:127 (4) - ctrl + G
03:37:841 (5) - unnecessary
03:41:841 (1,2,3,4,5) - weird shape
03:42:413 (5) - don't need
04:04:984 (3) - more to the right up instead and making next circle lower also
04:34:270 (3) - blanket better nothing to blanket well with
05:02:270 (6) - move up just a lil more k
05:11:127 (4,5) - Ctrl +G shifted them

I tried playing this but after entire day of modding + no warmup my graph was hilarious lol T^T
anyways good luck~~

IamKwaN wrote:

Hi, from my queue here.

General

1. The BG size now isn't standard, resize it to 1366*768.
2. Decapitalize "I" and "P" in the source, you would get something like this: Love Live! School idol project
3. Also, add some tags, for example, names of each member of μ's or "ラブライブ！".
4. Regarding to the storyboard, are these files being used? If not, you need to delete them.
   
   SPOILER

   38a.png
   38b.png
   39a.png
   39b.png
   41a.png
   41b.png
   42a.png
   42b.png
   43a.png
   43b.png

Daisuki

1. 00:25:127 (2,3) - You may want to stack these two. don't think I will stack
2. 00:17:698 (6,1,2,3,4) - I feel uncomfortable when clicking these coz the stresses all lie on slider tails, try something like this: changed all to sliders
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:23:556 (1) - Finish on head. Same applies on 00:23:984 (3). k
4. 00:30:270 (1) - Make this slider slightly more aesthetic and smooth even you are blanketing everything. will try
5. 00:35:270 (2) - Move upwards a bit to improve the flow. moved slightly
6. 00:36:698 - I am kinda doubtful about this sudden halt whereas the ambient keeps going and the only one combo makes the look of these really odd. conflicting suggestions all the time lol @@ I'll see what I can do
7. 00:41:841 (1) - Why is the node in the middle kinked? It would be nice if you copy shape of 00:42:270 (2,3). wanted a different shape lol, I guess no one likes it....
8. 00:57:127 (7) - Move it apart from 00:56:556 (5) to avoid the slight overlap. rotated 00:57:270 (8) to make the pattern more usable
9. 01:00:127 - I suggest placing a SV decrease here till 01:01:127 which fits the atmosphere more. the change isn't too obvious, don't think I will change sv
10. 01:03:984 (4,5,6,7,8,1) - These jumps don't match with the decreasing tense of music. Place something like 01:02:270 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) without jumps. it's still like a lead-in though, I think jumps can be used for that as well
11. 01:45:841 (1,3) - Finish on head, it's difficult to hear the whistles when playing. it's k, not adding
12. 01:50:413 (1) - Suggestion on the shape of slider: but that shape only goes downwards, which is a movement that doesn't seem to fit the vocal, which bends the tune
    
    SPOILER

    
13. 02:24:198 (6) - Delete this, the drums start at red tick. In fact, 02:24:484 (10) doesn't have drum too. don't think I will change this
14. 02:41:127 (3,4) - Finishes on heads. not adding
15. 02:54:841 (2,3,4) - it feels hollow since you miss the drum at 02:54:984. How about this? will still stick to the vocal melody line for rhythm here
    
    SPOILER

    
16. 03:04:556 (1) - This shape really bothers me :3 What exactly is the first half of the slider blanketing? just for shape
17. 03:31:556 (3) - Finish on head. not adding
18. 03:32:413 (1,2,3,4) - Remove these slightly overlaps between circles by CTRL+ALT+S please, it really looks nicer imo. um okay, I guess I can make that happen
19. 03:37:270 (1,3) - Remove these finishes like what u did on 01:52:127 (1,2,3,4,5). removed all except the last one
20. 03:50:413 (1,2,3,4) - You need some finishes here for emphasis. just added some claps
21. 04:15:841 (2,3,4) - CTRL+G these on timeline basis such that stresses lie on slider heads instead of tails. emphasis is actually on the heads now
22. 04:18:127 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - The rhythm is not that tense imo, maybe you should try rhythm like: I'll consider
    
    SPOILER

    
23. 04:41:841 (1) - Finish on head. k
24. Difficulty seems decreasing through the diff, especially the last kiai while most jumps can be found in non-kiai.
    
    Your slider shape makes your map kinda, messy, for example, 03:52:698 (1) - its just a circular slider, why use so many nodes? 02:04:841 (4) - this kind of slider appears many times, you can simply copy a sample without making various types of sliders. Also, long sliders' shapes can be improved too, as mentioned above. will look through

Good luck!

skinnyjimmy wrote:

Hello, here's the mod from my queue!

I LOVE LOVE LIVE! PLEASE GET THIS RANKED

[Daisuki]

00:12:698 (3,4) - I don't see a reason for this big gap, and 3 and 2 are so close because it was the new tone after that held sound

00:27:841 (5,1) - I think these are to close to each other, while being far apart on the timeline I was trying to start slowing down the pace over there to bring in the new phrase in the song, the vocals

00:29:841 (3,4) - I see a lot of stacks in this map, try to avoid stacks in jumpy maps, they really kill the flow, but maybe stacks are your style will look through some of the stacks, I think some just do not fit what I'm trying to do

00:47:841 (3,4) - I also see a lot of circles really close to each other, and the next one is far away, I'm not sure if thats good or not, maybe you should try to keep consistent DS yeh it's intended

01:32:413 (2) - This note behind the previous slider doesn't really fit in with the flow of the rest of the map I was breaking flow to coincide with the feel of the song, but instead of stacking on the head of the previous slider, I decided to have it next to it instead

01:32:841 (4) - Same problem here

02:09:698 (1,2,3,4,5) - This is a good example of what 00:27:841 (5,1) - should look like, it should be spaced out because of the time gaps between them, you have to make the previous notes suggest that there is a gap, and not just rely on reading skills, if that makes sense

02:34:841 (5) - Consider moving this to 40, 220 would not be consistent with the rest of the map though

03:17:556 (2,4) - Doesn't really fit the rest of the map

03:42:413 (5) - Delete this circle, I don't think its needed to emphasize the vocals at this part

I absolutely LOVE THIS SONG! ITS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO GOOD

Hopefully my mod helped you a little bit!

GL

sammy711 wrote:

From BMT modding queue
Love Live !!!
[General]
How about using AR9.2, the BPM of 210 may require a higher AR here not sure about this one
About tags:

muse

(the pronounciation of u's)

kousaka honoka ayase eri minami kotori sonoda umi hoshizora rin nisikino maki toujou nozomi koizumi hanayo yazawa niko

these are the idol in Love Live, I copied these from the ranked version of Snow Halation (https://osu.ppy.sh/s/111587) which Guy mapped

Anyway you know, there is never wrong with more tags.


There are many tags you can also Add in
[Daisuki]
00:20:698 (2,3) - whistle on these two circles k
00:25:127 (2,3) - perfect stack k
00:27:841 (5) - clap here, for that voice of bass is consistent here, the same with 00:26:841 (1,2,3) - k
00:32:127 (2) - add whistle, like what you did 00:29:841 (3)
01:02:270 (1) - normal finish on the slider head, like you do 02:45:127 (1) k
01:13:270 (4) - whistle on the head and on the tail, like 02:56:127 (3,4) (i will stop mentioning that the same with which note from here) only placed on the tail
01:17:984 (5) - whistle
01:45:841 (1) - finish here fits better, for there is a clear sound here. Normal one or Auto one both are OK, but I suggest using Auto one for you had use it 1:46:841 (4) - here k
02:04:127 (1) - I think the place where this slider sits should be considered, not only because that the slider end is out of screen, it is because 02:04:127 (1,3) are touching each other, which made it so strange shifted right
You can try the pattern like this↓, a blanket here and the appropriate distance makes this pattern much beautiful

like this

[img]osu.ppy.sh/ss/1982411[/img]

02:13:841 (3,4,2,3,4,5,1) - neaten this pattern plz, the distance here can be better I made things neater

like this

02:22:413 (1) - finish on the head k
03:23:413 (3,4) - i think touching each other here is not such beautiful here, and the DS is weird, too. By put 03:23:841 (4) - a little bit farther, this pattern could get much improvement.↓ I gauged it my way

like this

03:25:127 (1) - you didn't add finish at 04:32:556 (1) - 01:39:984 (1) - consider whether remove this one or add the other two one. It's up to you finish is already added
04:05:127 (4) - keep the DS, and better stack 04:05:127 (4) - with the slider end of 04:05:698 (3) by rotating 04:05:698 (3) for a little will test it out
04:21:270 (1) - add whistle here
04:48:984 (1) - how about a sliderwhistle here. It fits here much and now that you used one in 04:57:841 (1) - to stress the background music, here should be a considerate place to place another one
05:02:127 (5,2) - Maybe you should stack perfectly here I think it's fine now
05:03:841 (2,3) - You can make this distance be the same with 05:03:841 (2,4) - and 05:03:984 (3,5) - ,for example put 05:03:841 (2) - at (192,64) I don't think I want it too close


I love Love Live as well as this song, thus I hope this could get ranked

1. Fine

Kawaiwkyik wrote:

From BMT queue

[General]

1. Fine

[Daisuki]

1. 00:06:984 (6,7) - I feel so fast here, because 00:06:984 (6,7) - is same ds on 00:05:270 (1,2,3) - , imo need to nc on 00:06:984 (6) - maybe I will put nc on (7) to differentiate it from all the rest
2. 00:30:270 (1) - feel ordinary on this slider orz sorry, but I want to blanket the circles
   example:
   
   
3. 00:34:556 (4) - x468 y136 moved to x484 y104
4. 00:46:841 (2) - blanket with 00:46:270 (8) - better k
5. 00:48:984 (2,3,4,5) - should more fun if you change like this spaced out, swapped 4 and 5
   
   
6. 00:52:556 (3) - x312 y164 k
7. 01:10:984 (4) - stack on 01:11:127 (5) - will try it
8. 01:42:984 (4,5,6) - suggestion: makes it easier to hit I guess
   
   
9. 01:47:270 (1,2,3,4) - imo it's ugly if they overlap here keeping this pattern
10. 01:57:270 (9) - x146 y95 , symmetric with 01:56:556 (4) - keeping 01:56:698 (5,6,7,8,9) constant
11. 02:11:984 (4) - blanket with 02:10:698 (5) - better shifted slightly
12. 02:24:698 - this part can add more whistle :3 added before it instead, at 02:23:413 (5,2,4)
13. 02:38:413 (2) - NC here and 02:38:127 (1) - remove nc k
14. 02:53:841 (4,5) - Ctrl+g, better flow with 02:53:556 (2,3) - breaks the phrasing I'm trying to make
15. 02:54:127 (6,7) - Ctrl+g too ^
16. 03:08:984 (5) - x240 y96 no change
17. 03:19:127 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - can blanket with 03:18:556 (2) - not going to adjust to fit pattern because I like the flow of this already
18. 03:41:841 (1,2,3,4,5) - make a star? no change
19. 05:16:127 (1,1) - needs more time for second spinner
    
    

Nice map, good luck ><

jesus1412 wrote:

[Daisuki]

00:07:127 (1) - Not sure why there's a new combo here but I find that it makes 00:06:984 (6,1) - seem like a 1/1 jump, not a 1/2. everything confuses people with that distance, I guess I will just adjust that as well
00:08:841 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1) - I really dislike this stacking, maybe use back and forth patterns instead or sliders or something? I think this is really hard to read without playing the rest of the map first because the song hasn't given a consistent 1/2 beat before this point and it's hard to decipher a beat from stacked notes. changed pattern
02:09:698 (1,2,3) - Increase the spacing of these, at the moment I don't think it's very readable. It might also help to decrease the spacing between 02:09:556 (4,1) . adjusted in a way
02:58:984 (1,2,3,4) - I dislike how these 1/3 are presented, seems totally unexpected in my opinion. I would change at least the first 2 notes into a 1/3 slider and try and rework the section. If you're going to keep hitcircles make sure the spacing change is EXTREME (i.e huge anti jumps or much larger jumps) to indicate that there is a change in the rhythm. spaced further

Sorry for the short mod, the rest is pretty fine!

Potla wrote:

This is one of my favourite maps and songs too~ xD
Nothing too major, the map looks pretty perfect as-is. \o/

Daisuki

1. Guess it won't hurt to increase the od a bit. Maybe 8.5? You might consider increasing the ar too if you like, but ar9 works. ^_^ Gonna keep it the same
2. 01:04:413 (7) - Add Clap? ok
3. 01:15:698 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - How about claps at 1 and 4 and the rest as usual? Oh well 01:33:984 (1,2,3,4,5,6) sounds better with all claps.
4. 02:24:127 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - I don't think this stream fits the music; maybe change it to 1/2 jumps. I don't think that would be what I want
5. 03:35:341 (6,7,8) - Maybe add claps on these beats? don't think it's necessary
6. 03:17:270 (1,2,3,4) - Increase the sv here or add jumps right after the sliders... Might be interesting. it was the reason for me to put the circle behind the slider, to make it cover more distance
7. 03:41:841 (1,2,3,4,5) - Increase the spacing a bit? I think these beats have more potential. xD too crazy lol
8. 03:57:984 (8,9,10) - Might be better off as a stream, but is pretty cool as is now too! wanted a stream, but the music was too empty to warrant one
9. 04:41:414 (6,7,8) - Maybe make the triple at 6? doesn't fit the song
10. 04:42:627 (4) - This beat looks like an outlier... I guess deleting it and extending the slider works better.
11. 04:58:127 (2) - Won't hurt to increase the spacing? I just feel like the music demands a magnificent jump at this point. Maybe I'm retarded, but whatever. xD increased the spacing by placing it further down, so that movement to 04:58:413 (3,4) is smoother

Well, this map is too much fun... Wish it gets ranked soon~ Good luck~ ^_^