Kerocchi wrote:

Hi The song is cute. Anyway, since a lot of people already modded this, it should be near perfect by now, but here are my suggestions.

General
Your video should be .avi just to be safe. And can you compress it a bit more?
I recommend making combo colors a bit darker.

Easy
01:30:352 (2) - Slider shape looks out of place
01:45:352 (4) - I suggest changing the end point of this slider, as it turns visible before (2) is finished and is overlapped with (2)'s end
00:21:160 (1) - Should last one beat only and start at 00:21:644. Shape needs more curving

Normal
You should use slider repeats more on this difficulty, particularly replacing some 1.5 and 2 beats long sliders
01:33:255 (1,1,1,2) - I think you should replace this with this pattern: a one-beat slider with one repeat, then three circles on next downbeats Changed it. Not to your suggestion, I kept the slider, but the repeat slider was added.
01:24:546 (6,7) - Perhaps convert these into a slider? Fixed.
01:31:320 (3,4) - Add a repeat on 3 and remove 4, the circle looks lonely Fixed.
00:47:772 (8) - Convert into a 2-beat slider to cover the rest of the vocal Fixed.
00:19:466 and 00:20:434 - Add a circle in one, or both of these? Did something nice.
00:36:885 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - The whole combo seems a bit fast and unbalanced with the rest of the map, as with almost every other combo there is a 1.5 to 2-beat slider or 1-beat gap between the notes. Removed some notes.

Hard
The spacing is too large, I think you should reduce it . (somehow I opened AiMod and it says this is Insane..)
00:22:612, 01:06:159 (1) - Slider velocity change is unnecessary. I like this.
In Kiai time, I think you should place a new SV for all sliders in that Kiai but it's up to you.
00:32:772 (1) - It should be moved one beat later and replace (2) to fit with vocals It was like that in the past but have it like this because sliders on red ticks are ugly.
00:47:772 (3) - Same with Normal, change it into a slider Done.
00:50:675 (4,5), 01:47:046 (2,3,4) - not very good flow, large turning angle Perhaps 00:51:643 (1) is questionable, but I feel there's no problem with the sliders.

Insane
Spacing is huge and largely inconsistent in my opinion, but if that makes the map more challenging for you then it's fine.
00:34:466 (7) - If you don't mind spacing break then make it overlap (1) for nicer look and feel True.
00:37:853 (4,5,6) - Too large jumps Fixed.
00:38:579 (7) - Make it overlap (5) Done.
00:41:724 (6,7,8,9) - Awkward jump, and the spacing is a little bit not consistent within the combo It is now consistent, the entire combo is trapezoid.
00:51:643 (6,7,8) - why not make this combo all sliders? Because I feel it's fine right now
01:28:417 (9) - Place it in the middle for symmetry ? Fixed.
01:45:352 (4,5,6) - Awkward placement, keep placing them in triangular configuration looks better Woops! Inconsistent. Fixed.
01:50:191 (12) - Place it in the middle? Fixed.

That's pretty much all Hope you find this helpful and good luck
BTW I think this shall also be a M4M post *evil smile*

Kerocchi wrote:

Hi The song is cute. Anyway, since a lot of people already modded this, it should be near perfect by now, but here are my suggestions. Hi!

Easy
01:30:352 (2) - Slider shape looks out of place I made it symmetrical with 01:29:384 (1), maybe that's better...
01:45:352 (4) - I suggest changing the end point of this slider, as it turns visible before (2) is finished and is overlapped with (2)'s end Remade the pattern
00:21:160 (1) - Should last one beat only and start at 00:21:644. Shape needs more curving No change for now, if someone else mentions this i'll fix.

That's pretty much all Hope you find this helpful and good luck
BTW I think this shall also be a M4M post *evil smile*

1. 00:13:902 (1) - Move it to x:244, y:32,just for blanket better
2. 00:21:160 - Try this rhythm: http://puu.sh/8cbEh.jpg matching the vocals, then you can do something like this 00:21:644 (4,5,6) - http://puu.sh/8cbMp.jpg.
3. 00:44:385 (4) - Move to 116, 104?
4. 00:55:998 (4) - http://puu.sh/8cc04.jpg
5. 01:24:546 (4) - Move the middle node to 188, 232.

1. 00:21:644 (1) - Move to 48,188
2. 00:38:337 (5) - Move to 432,172?
3. 00:44:869 (2,3,4) - Try this: http://puu.sh/8ccOz.jpg
4. 01:43:901 - Try this rhythm: http://puu.sh/8ccZm.jpg

1. 00:15:354 (4) - Move this to 232, 236, then 00:15:837 (1,2,3) - http://puu.sh/8cdm4.jpg
2. 00:22:370 - I'd rather not increase the sliders speed here, the song does not call for it now.
3. 00:22:128 (3) - http://puu.sh/8cdIw.jpg This flows better.
4. 00:22:612 (1,2) - And here you can do this: http://puu.sh/8cdQ8.jpg. If you do < remember to decrease the jump here 00:23:095 (2,1)
5. 00:32:772 - http://puu.sh/8cdYT.jpg Fit better with the vocals
6. 00:53:578 (1,2,3,4) - I think this better: http://puu.sh/8ce6W.jpg
7. 01:02:772 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - i recommend decrease the jumps here, is so hard...
8. 01:06:159 - same I'd rather not increase the sliders speed here
9. 01:25:514 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - Same way of the first.
10. 01:33:014 (1,2,3,1,2) - Also here

LucyS wrote:

Hello, from my queue Hi!

[Eazy]

1. 00:13:902 (1) - Move it to x:244, y:32,just for blanket better Fixed.
2. 00:21:160 - Try this rhythm: http://puu.sh/8cbEh.jpg matching the vocals, then you can do something like this 00:21:644 (4,5,6) - http://puu.sh/8cbMp.jpg.
3. 00:44:385 (4) - Move to 116, 104? Alright, i'll change to this.
4. 00:55:998 (4) - http://puu.sh/8cc04.jpg Yea that looks better, fixed.
5. 01:24:546 (4) - Move the middle node to 188, 232. Done.

Hope it helps, Good Luck !
Any doubts send me a pm.

OscaR CUBE wrote:

Hi..!
Sorry if my mod don't help you so much..

NORMAL

SPOILER

- 00:15:837 (4) - How about change it like this? http://puu.sh/8c4uO.jpg I like it like this. The words "wonderful to do" flow in a legato-esque style
- 00:37:853 - How about a hit circle? Added slider.
- 01:44:626 - ^ Fix.
- 01:44:868 (7) - Change it like this?? http://puu.sh/8c4BJ.jpg

HARD

SPOILER

- 00:20:676 (7) - clap sound? Fixerino
- 00:32:772 (1) - just a hit circle at red tick, maybe?? No, I like the symmetry here.
- 00:34:466 (6) - change it like this? http://puu.sh/8c4L8.jpg No, this matches with vocals.
- 00:55:998 (7) - clap sound? Fixed.
- 01:30:595 (5) - change this to slider until the white tick? This matches with vocals
- 01:32:288 (7) - ^ This matches with vocals

Thanks for your mod!

I can't mod insane so well... sorry..

That's it..
Sorry for my poor english..

Chewin wrote:

Hello! I'm sorry for being late, I've been very busy. Let's see what we have here, then. (: Hello! ^_^/

General Stuff

1. This mapset is pretty cool. But there is a problem, sadly. To make it rankable you must map the 80% of the song (not considering the skipped opening). You mapped 78% = unrankable. HUE CHEWIN IS SO BAD, HE NOTICED THIS SMALL THING. Yea, I did. You guys actually mapped it very nicely, you can add something more during break times to make it 100% rankable.
   I mapped 00:24:547 - 00:31:321 so now it should be fine!

Starger's Easy

1. 00:11:966 (3) - I guess you forgot to add whistle on this slider's head. You should add it like you did for other following downbeats! Fixed.
2. 00:19:708 (3) - This should be the same. New stanza needs to be emphasized here and I'd add the whistle Fixed.
3. 00:21:644 (4) - I wonder why there isn't New Combo here ;P Add it please, it's really needed Fixed.
4. 00:42:933 (3) - Whistle on the end, still missed it Fixed.
5. 00:47:772 (5) - Still, what about to add a whistle on this slider's tail to emphasize the vocal's end better? It sounds pretty cool IMO Yea, it really does! Fixed.
6. 01:36:159 (1) - Silence this slider with 15% volume. Moreover, you should reduce it by 1/1 just how the kiai time has been set I really hope this spinner is not too short now. Silenced it.
7. 01:50:675 (1) - Normal finish on this spinner's end pls, it sounds pretty nicely. The actual drum doesn't. Alright.

I will leave a star icon for now. This mapset can still be improved, especially Hard and Normal. (First of all I'd suggest you to fix the old ugly sliders with new ones). That's it for now. I will totally recheck this when this will be better. You can call me back when it received at least 6+ mods. I'll be glad to recheck this and let it go (!!) with a bubble! Good luck >w< I hope it has been helpful.

CDFA wrote:

mod4mod queue woohoo woo
Easy:
01:36:159 (1) - Add softwhistle Fixed.

Chewin wrote:

Hello! I'm sorry for being late, I've been very busy. Let's see what we have here, then. (:

General Stuff

1. Mh.. Your folder size is too big. To reduce it, first of all you should totally remove the audio from your video file. Actually it's muted yea, but there is still an audio file on it. You can see it from: http://puu.sh/9gLoK/1ae124114b.png This is unrankable and it would be cool too for the folder's size with totally removing it. Will do.
2. The first kiai time on Normal should end on: 00:47:772 to be consistent with other difficulties! Fixed. Oops.
3. This mapset is pretty cool. But there is a problem, sadly. To make it rankable you must map the 80% of the song (not considering the skipped opening). You mapped 78% = unrankable. HUE CHEWIN IS SO BAD, HE NOTICED THIS SMALL THING. Yea, I did. You guys actually mapped it very nicely, you can add something more during break times to make it 100% rankable. Fixed.
4. Timing is wrong. We just need 1 timing section on 10044 at 123,20 BPM. Don't forget to resnap everything after changes. Timing is right. Willing to talk about this.

Normal

1. 00:11:966 (4) - Adding new combo to warn players about the new 1/1 rhythm would be pretty cool here. Add it pls Done
2. 00:11:966 (4,5,6,7,1) - This pattern looks very bad and ugly actually, to be honest. I would suggest you something like this! http://puu.sh/9gMLR/edb152575e.jpg Here's the code: Fixed.
   
   SPOILER

   324,352,11966,1,0,0:0:0:0:
   184,372,12450,1,8,0:0:0:0:
   76,284,12934,1,0,0:0:0:0:
   96,144,13418,1,8,0:0:0:0:
   232,184,13902,6,0,P|300:168|336:88,1,140,0|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

3. 00:17:773 (2) - Make this blanket much better pls. It's so ugly now. It's simply: http://puu.sh/9gMTE/c49a0d30c9.jpg Done
4. 00:21:402 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - But especially 00:23:579 (4,5,6) -looks bad in the way you placed them tbh. First of all I'd add new combo on 00:23:579 (4) for the same reason I mentioned about first point. And, placing them in this way would make it much better to see: http://puu.sh/9gNoQ/8aed758d4a.jpg http://puu.sh/9gNpX/38b4342190.jpg Done.
   
   SPOILER

   88,192,21402,5,0,0:0:0:0:
   88,192,21644,2,0,B|108:288|108:288|156:348|228:256,1,210,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   308,283,22612,2,0,B|356:348|404:288|404:288|424:192,1,210,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   432,112,23579,5,2,0:0:0:0:
   256,152,24063,1,8,0:0:0:0:
   80,112,24547,1,4,0:0:0:0:

5. 00:44:869 (2) - Whistle on the head Fixed.
6. 00:46:804 (6) - New combo and whistle. Also: 00:44:627 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I think you can improve this pattern by yourself ;P Try to improve it with 1 sliderpoint sliders, I see this map is using old manually sliders. Fixed.
7. 00:59:385 (4) - Same, New combo and add whistle Fixed.
8. 00:55:514 (3) - Whistle on the head Fixed.
9. 01:07:127 (5) - New combo and whistle Fixed.
10. 01:22:611 (3) - Remove whistle from the tail and add it on 01:23:578 (4) instead
11. 01:24:546 (6) - Whistle on the head and clap on the tail Fixed.
12. 01:29:384 (2) - This is a copy paste, so, I suggest you the same thing as above to improve the blanket Fixed.
13. 01:33:013 (1,2,3,4,5) - Check my pattern here too, same of above Fixed.
14. 01:36:159 (1) - Same of easy Fixed.
15. 01:42:449 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - This hitsounds are really meh.. I fixed them for you, just copy the code: Fixed.
    
    SPOILER

    40,264,102449,6,0,L|100:300,1,70,4|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
    168,248,102933,1,8,0:0:0:0:
    240,296,103175,1,0,0:0:0:0:
    312,248,103417,2,0,L|372:284,1,70,0|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
    439,233,103900,1,8,0:0:0:0:
    511,281,104142,1,0,0:0:0:0:
    379,65,104626,1,0,0:0:0:0:
    316,120,104868,2,0,P|256:152|196:120,2,140,8|8|4,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
    40,280,106562,5,0,0:0:0:0:
    104,344,106804,2,0,P|176:376|240:312,1,140,8|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
    280,280,107530,1,0,0:0:0:0:
    336,344,107772,2,0,P|408:376|472:312,1,140,8|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
    400,192,108739,5,2,0:0:0:0:
    344,32,109223,1,8,0:0:0:0:
    176,32,109707,1,2,0:0:0:0:
    112,192,110191,1,8,0:0:0:0:
    256,192,110675,12,4,114546,0:0:0:0:

Hard

1. AR +1 is pretty cool here. Fix it, best way for an Hard and for a map like this one!
2. 00:23:579 (1,2) - Finish on (1) and clap on (2)
3. 00:34:466 (6,1) - I didn't get this antijump. I have an idea here. I would flip vertically the whole 00:35:191 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) pattern and also fixing this inconsistent and not needed jump/spacing: 00:36:159 (5,6) . This is what I mean: http://puu.sh/9gOre/a21790ef70.jpg Trust me, it's 100% better! Fixed.
   
   SPOILER

   104,131,35191,5,0,0:0:0:0:
   184,244,35433,1,0,0:0:0:0:
   256,128,35675,1,8,0:0:0:0:
   328,244,35917,1,0,0:0:0:0:
   408,131,36159,1,0,0:0:0:0:
   256,96,36401,1,0,0:0:0:0:
   256,112,36522,1,0,0:0:0:0:
   256,128,36643,1,8,0:0:0:0:

4. 00:39:062 (1) - Whistle on the head to emphasize the vocal Fixed.
5. 00:39:062 (1,2) - Make this spacing bigger pls, it's actually inconsistent. The (2) should be placed further from the previous slider. Fixed.
6. 00:44:869 (2,6) - Add whistles 00:46:804 (1) - and finish here! Fixed.
7. 00:47:772 (3) - Whistle on the end Fixed.
8. 00:51:885 (2,3,4) - I didn't get this small and inconsistent spacing. Make it consistent pls totally not needed and confusing Done!
9. 00:55:514 (5) - New combo Fixed.
10. 01:07:126 (1) - Finish Fixed.
11. 01:32:288 (7) - Forgot clap Fixed.
12. 01:35:190 (1,2) - Same of 00:23:579 (1,2) Fixed.
13. 01:36:159 (1) - Same of other diffs Fixed.
14. 01:42:449 (1) till the end - Can you use the same hitsounds I used for you in that code for the Normal diff, please? Thanks Done!

I will leave a star icon for now. This mapset can still be improved, especially Hard and Normal. (First of all I'd suggest you to fix the old ugly sliders with new ones). That's it for now. I will totally recheck this when this will be better. You can call me back when it received at least 6+ mods. I'll be glad to recheck this and let it go (!!) with a bubble! Good luck >w< I hope it has been helpful. Very! This is actually my first mapset ever and I'm really hyped to improve this. IT surely was a helpful experience

AndreasHD wrote:

Okay! so here goes the mod

[Starger's Easy]
This difficulty is mapped well, and I do not have much to say.

00:39:062 (3) - I can see you're trying to make this perfect, well let me tell you, if you snap the last node to the grid, it will be perfect just drag it slight to the right, and it will snap. Yea, that works, thanks!

00:47:772 (5) - Add whistle on head Sure.

01:06:643 (2,3,4) - Make it like this, it sounds better: Yea, that actually plays abit better. I left 4 a slider though.

Screenshot

01:36:159 (1) - This is a VERY short spinner for 'Easy' .. consider doing something else, or make it longer, because it still sounds good if you end it here 01:37:610 I made it a slider.

_Stan wrote:

M4M and my English is poor, so don't laugh at me when i make mistakes...


at the first, I wanna say the song is so cute and I like your slider‘s arc. BEAUTIFUL

Normal

00:21:644 - you can change the circle's color~ A new part, Fix
00:43:901 (5) - 00:45:595 (3,4) - you can make the two part at the same position I have no idea what you mean
01:21:643 - eeeee, it's same with the beginning, right? Fix

Hard

00:36:401 (6,7,8) - [personal view]overlap it? No, it'd stack anyways, vertical stack plays better
00:51:643 - [personal view]overlap it? Would ruin DS
01:01:562 (2) - eeeeer, this position is kind of confusing Antijumps are fun


that's all,

if I misunderstand your design, please ignore them. Of course, these are my personal views

and this is mine http://osu.ppy.sh/s/182427

Player X wrote:

Hi,
here is my mode.

all difficulties

disable countdown

Countdown is cool

Normal

00:21:644 (8) - new combo Fix
00:24:547 (1) - no new combo No
00:31:321 - insert break time K
00:34:224 (4) - no clap No
00:36:159 (4) - no clap No
00:40:030 - finish K
00:44:869 - remove timing section (no kiai mode) Kiai at choir. Choir sings. Kiai on.
00:46:804 (1) - no new combo Combo is fine
00:48:740 - remove timing section This fixes 1-2-3-4
00:59:385 (1) - no new combo No
01:02:288 - no clap k
01:02:772 (3) - clap kk
01:07:127 (1) - no new combo no
01:31:319 (5) - no clap no
01:42:933 (2) - no clap no
01:43:417 (4) - clap no
01:43:901 (5) - no clap no
01:44:868 (8) - no clap no
01:46:804 (2) - no clap no
01:47:288 - clap no
01:47:772 (4) - no clap no
01:48:255 - clap

Hard

00:20:676 (1) - no combo fix
00:23:579 (1) - no finish added whistle
00:24:547 (1) - finish k
00:32:772 (1) - no clap no
00:34:224 (5) - no clap no
00:44:869 - remove timing section (no kiai mode) no
00:46:804 (1) - no finish no
00:47:772 - remove timing section no
00:53:095 - no clap no
01:04:707 (10) - no clap no
01:07:126 (1) - no finish no

Here you are! thanks! sorry for not taking storyboard hitsounds. they fuck with player's skin sounds.

Yauxo wrote:

Hi there, coming from your q (m4m)

[General]

1. Reminds me so much of ztrot's maps ... somehow first map ever, i've played a lot of osu! as i started, might have reflected in my mapping style! I don't map like this anymore, though.
2. and I dont even know how I'd hitsound this ;w; CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP

[Starger's Easy]

1. I'd lower the volume on the hitsounds @kiai time. They are just too loud imo
2. 00:45:353 (2) - How about moving this one further up? OR do something like this for a better flow
   
   flowstuff

   
3. 01:26:481 (2,3,4) - Imo 4 should have the same distance to 3 as 2 has (actually, its a snapping issue, fix it)
   While youre at it, the overlap on 01:27:933 (3) - is off as well
4. 01:44:868 (3) - spacing issue (spacing should be consistent through the whole diff)

[Normal]

1. 00:19:708 (1) - NC Fixed!
2. 00:21:644 (1) - NC Was already fixed
3. 00:23:579 (3,4,1) - suggestion, how about having it flow in a curve? surely would feel better than a straight line
   
   like so ... ish

   
   Feel like it's fine as is
4. 00:25:515 (3) - ctrl g? Fine as is. This gives a 90 degree flow
5. 00:30:354 (5) - ^? Fine as is. This gives a 90 degree flow
6. 00:33:014 (1) - overlap with 00:30:354 (5) - ? 157/116 Doesn't matter
7. 00:56:240 (5) - 136/176 for better flow Fine as is
8. 01:35:674 (4) - 268/28ish Want to be close to the spinner
9. 01:44:626 (7) - I'd assume that you could NC this Fixerino!

[Hard]

1. Even though it's the most difficult diff in this mapset, AR9 seems very damn high for a 3.15 star diff. Consider lowering this one to 8ish atleast Chewin said AR9 was fine. I like AR9 as well because of the 1.7 distance spacing. Going to keep this.
2. Also, this map really reminds me of ztrot maps, as they're also using alot of symmetrical singletap/jump combos etc (not to mention the mpl songs). I dont really know how to much such, but .. uhm .. I guess? :s Thanks, I guess! Not really my style anymore...
   
3. 00:32:772 (1) - This one seems rather random as you leave a break before it and as it doesnt support any sound. If you want to support the "swoosh", you'd have to start on 00:32:288 (6) - Have fixed!

Gl with your set :3

Starger4ru wrote:

Player X wrote:

Hi, Hi!

Starger4ru wrote:

Player X wrote:

Stranger's Easy

Starger, not stranger x_x

00:14:870 (2) - no whistle No, i sometimes place whistles on 3rd white ticks if they need emphasis
00:20:676 - no whistle ^
00:22:612 (2) - no whistle ^
00:31:321 - insert break time It's too short to be a break, so nope.
00:41:966 (2) - no whistle No.
00:43:901 - no whistle ^
00:44:869 - remove timing section (no kiai mode) No, i think kiai fits.
00:45:837 - no whistle No.
00:47:772 - remove timing section No.
00:48:740 - no whistle No.
00:51:643 - whistle Added.
00:52:611 (5) - no whistle No.
00:54:546 (2) - no whistle ^
01:04:224 - no whistle ^
01:06:159 - no whistle ^
01:08:095 (4) - no whistle ^
01:08:095 - no clap and new timing without "Inherit previons timing settings" ^
01:08:578 - new timing with "Inherit previons timing settings" and volume 5% Added, but 15%
01:22:610 - whistle Fixed.
01:24:546 (4) - whistle ^
01:26:481 (2) - whistle ^
01:30:352 (2) - whistle ^
01:34:223 (2) - whistle ^
01:36:159 - volume of new timing change to 5% No.
01:42:933 (1) - whistle Fixed.
01:44:868 (3) - whistle Fixed.

Starger4ru wrote:

No storyboard hitsounds, because Don didn't want to take them.

Player X wrote:

Why not? I moded it for Don and not you and also I needed very much time for this. This is my 1st mod.
No other user changed the mods of other users.

Player X wrote:

Starger4ru wrote:

No storyboard hitsounds, because Don didn't want to take them.

Hear this because it has very many storyboard hitsounds.

Without storyboard hitsounds it sounds bad.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLNky_NLLoI&t=7m48s

And with storyboard hitsounds it sounds good.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLNky_NLLoI&t=9m42s

By the way, yesterday Don said to me he thinks about it.

Starger4ru wrote:

Player X wrote:

Why not? I moded it for Don and not you and also I needed very much time for this. This is my 1st mod.
No other user changed the mods of other users.

This Easy is made by me for Don's mapset (hence the name - Starger's easy), so I apply and deny changes to it. I didn't change your mod in any way, just answered what I applied and declined. I appreciate all the time you've put into making this mod, thanks for it. It's good for a first mod!

If he accepts it, I'm gonna add them to my easy aswell.

• 00:18:741 (2) - Dunno if you meant to not blanket this, but you could
  00:22:612 (2,3) - switching these goes with the lyrics more, sounds better in my opinion
  00:45:353 (2) - move this to x:344 y:56
  00:44:869 - not sure kiai time is really needed here, but it does add a nice effect
  00:52:611 (5) - move to x:165 y:308, you'll see why
  00:54:546 (2) - move to x:174 y:195, it just puts the 5 from above directly on top of the end of the slider, and looks better in my opinion
  01:21:643 - not sure the why the hitsounds changed here
  01:36:159 - it feels like Kiai time should end here, but I'm not sure
  01:45:352 (4) - make this symmetrical D:
  01:49:707 (4,5) - I think you should make these a 1/1 slider, but it sounds fine either way

• 00:36:159 (4) - could blanket this
  00:38:095 (4) - new combo?
  00:45:595 (3) - move this to x:205 y:186
  01:00:353 (3) - no finish hitsound?
  01:29:142 (1,2) - blanket these better?
  01:30:352 - copy pasterino
  01:31:320 (5) - new combo
  01:46:562 (1,2,3,4) - move these up a bit?

• Your sliders are kinda boring, try changing them up a bit
  00:19:466 (1,2,3) - not sure this needs to be a triplet, since this entire map can be single tapped. you could change to 1/4 reverse slider
  00:37:611 (3) - move to x:373 y:266
  00:38:095 (5) - move to x:140 y:272, these two changes just make the circles under the slider end and beginning, and looks better to me
  00:51:885 (2) - blanket this
  01:04:466 (8,9,10) - not sure this triplet is needed, try a 1/4 reverse slider instead
  01:23:578 (7) - I would make this a new combo
  01:44:868 (2,3) - make these parallel
  01:50:191 (7) - I would make this a 1/2 slider, but I understand if you don't want to to keep the pattern you were going for.

Indeed wrote:

Hello, from my queue~

[General]

Ahhh pony music! ;w; I like it though, is nice.

[Normal]

• 00:36:159 (4) - could blanket this Fixed
  00:38:095 (4) - new combo? Fixed
  00:45:595 (3) - move this to x:205 y:186 Fixed
  01:00:353 (3) - no finish hitsound? Fixed
  01:29:142 (1,2) - blanket these better? Fixed
  01:30:352 - copy pasterino Fixed
  01:31:320 (5) - new combo Fixed
  01:46:562 (1,2,3,4) - move these up a bit? Fixed

[Hard]

• Your sliders are kinda boring, try changing them up a bitFine as is. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
  00:19:466 (1,2,3) - not sure this needs to be a triplet, since this entire map can be single tapped. you could change to 1/4 reverse slider Fixed
  00:37:611 (3) - move to x:373 y:266 Fixed
  00:38:095 (5) - move to x:140 y:272, these two changes just make the circles under the slider end and beginning, and looks better to me Fixed
  00:51:885 (2) - blanket this Fixed
  01:04:466 (8,9,10) - not sure this triplet is needed, try a 1/4 reverse slider instead Fixed
  01:23:578 (7) - I would make this a new combo Fixed
  01:44:868 (2,3) - make these parallel Fixed
  01:50:191 (7) - I would make this a 1/2 slider, but I understand if you don't want to to keep the pattern you were going for. Fixed

Very nice mapset! Good luck on getting it ranked Although I never meant for this to get close to bubbled, it's a nice start that Chewin wanted to check this lol

Indeed wrote:

Hello, from my queue~ Hello!

[Easy]

• 00:18:741 (2) - Dunno if you meant to not blanket this, but you could I think it flows better without blanket.
  00:22:612 (2,3) - switching these goes with the lyrics more, sounds better in my opinion Yes it does! Fixed.
  00:45:353 (2) - move this to x:344 y:56 Fixed a bit differently
  00:44:869 - not sure kiai time is really needed here, but it does add a nice effect I think it's fine
  00:52:611 (5) - move to x:165 y:308, you'll see why I see, moved to x:166 y:310
  00:54:546 (2) - move to x:174 y:195, it just puts the 5 from above directly on top of the end of the slider, and looks better in my opinion I adjusted (5) to stack with end of (2) instead of moving (2)
  01:21:643 - not sure the why the hitsounds changed here They fit the kiai time.
  01:36:159 - it feels like Kiai time should end here, but I'm not sure It's fine where it is right now.
  01:45:352 (4) - make this symmetrical D: Alright, I hope it's better now D:
  01:49:707 (4,5) - I think you should make these a 1/1 slider, but it sounds fine either way It's fine with circles

Very nice mapset! Good luck on getting it ranked

Starger4ru wrote:

Player X wrote:

Why not? I moded it for Don and not you and also I needed very much time for this. This is my 1st mod.
No other user changed the mods of other users.

This Easy is made by me for Don's mapset (hence the name - Starger's easy), so I apply and deny changes to it. I didn't change your mod in any way, just answered what I applied and declined. I appreciate all the time you've put into making this mod, thanks for it. It's good for a first mod!

Player X wrote:

Hear this because it has very many storyboard hitsounds.

Without storyboard hitsounds it sounds bad.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLNky_NLLoI&t=7m48s

And with storyboard hitsounds it sounds good.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLNky_NLLoI&t=9m42s

By the way, yesterday Don said to me he thinks about it.

If he accepts it, I'm gonna add them to my easy aswell.

Player X wrote:

Hi,
I'm back. Did you read my last post? Why enabled you the countdown again?

All difficulties

- Disable the countdown because it confuses the players in this song because the irregular bars.

Don't you play with the skin "NeOsu 3"?

Starger4ru wrote:

And no, I use my own mix skin. NeOsu is pretty good though!

Don wrote:

With NeOsu3

NeOsu3's countdown is bad. Always check things out with default skin.

• [General]
  
  This is a good map just change to hard diff the AR 8 or 7 (or 7.5)
  And but this a preview point here 01:21:401 for all diff
  
  [Easy]
  
  I do saw no real problem
  
  
  [Normal]
  I am not an expert in normal
  
  00:12:934 (3) (4) - Removed is two circle and add a slider ?
  00:55:998- Use this paterne? Screen
  01:24:546 (3) (4) - Removed is two circle and add a slider ?
  
  
  [Hard]
  I find that to be a little too hard for jumps but its still remains a good map
  
  00:34:224 (5) (6) - Removed is two circle and add a slider ? (yes again x) )
  00:36:401 (6) (7) (8) - for those triplet is rather like that: Screen

Shapy wrote:

Hey Form M4M ~

• [General]
  
  This is a good map just change to hard diff the AR 8 or 7 (or 7.5) Like Chewin's AR9 suggestion.
  And but this a preview point here 01:21:401 for all diff Preview point is fine
  
  [Easy]
  
  I do saw no real problem
  
  
  [Normal]
  I am not an expert in normal
  
  00:12:934 (3) (4) - Removed is two circle and add a slider ? I like this the way it is
  00:55:998- Use this paterne? ScreenI like this the way it is
  01:24:546 (3) (4) - Removed is two circle and add a slider ?I like this the way it is
  
  
  [Hard]
  I find that to be a little too hard for jumps but its still remains a good map
  
  00:34:224 (5) (6) - Removed is two circle and add a slider ? (yes again x) )I like this the way it is
  00:36:401 (6) (7) (8) - for those triplet is rather like that: ScreenLooks cool as is

Sorry if my mod is not as complete as the wishes I'm not very good at mapping (sorry for my bad english :/)

Thanks for the mod!
Good luck on getting it ranked ^^

pkmnyab wrote:

sup, from your m4m queue

Starger's Easy

1. 00:16:805 (5) - are you sure you want the gap after this note? I think it would play better if you made it a 1/1 slider, you can also add in the clap sound at the tail of the slider. It would also match that sound in the music that goes back and forth starting at 00:16:805 - since the sound is playing and so is the slider. Yes, I think it's better to leave that sound unmapped.
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:19:708 (3) - this is optional, but you can remove the repeat and add a slider at 00:19:708 (3) - to fill in the gap and also map that sound in the music. No, repeat fits more.
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:55:998 (4) - I feel that you should map the part at 00:56:482 - . Try adding a hit circle at 00:55:998 - and a 1/1 slider at 00:56:482 - . This way you can map the vocal that was left out and the tink sound in the music. Same with 00:59:869 (4) - and other parts, you can replace with hit circle and slider which I think sounds better. Of course this is your decision and you might choose to leave it as it is to make the difficulty easy. I changed only 00:55:998 (4)
   
4. 01:21:643 - hitsounds over here are quite loud, I would reduce the volume a bit so it doesn't stand out more than the music. Try no higher than ~45%, same thing applies for the timing point at 01:42:933 - . Alright, I reduced them to 45% for my diffs for now. Waiting for Don's response. (45% is better imo)
5. 01:45:352 (4) - you're missing a pretty prominent sound in the music and vocal at 01:45:352 (4) - , I suggest you split up this slider into a slider and hit circle, or a repeat slider. Changed this part.

Anyways, have fun mapping.

Fort wrote:

quickmod™ by Fort
italic means my comment
red means some unrankable
blue means strong suggestion
my overall mod is a suggestion


[Timing]
this is kinda weird why you set Timing points in single BPM song?
i think the timing is:
BPM → 124.000
Offset → 1345

since this song is hard to check that offset, but dont worry just use 1 timing points, its okay
delete all of your timing points except that one ↑

[Hard]
so far distance for DT plays, but my first try was FC

FC

your overall in your map is good, using simple pattern, but isnt distance snap 1.7x is far?

so many straight 1/2 sliders in here, maybe curved your 1/2 sliders can make it better look

okay, just it i can say, cant find anything wrong. some patterns are good enough to easy FC in first try, goodluck with your map