1. Hard (4.85 stars, 416 notes)
2. Hard2 (4.82 stars, 55 notes)
3. Insane (5 stars, 593 notes)

nariette wrote:

I love it!

Overall
Is it just me or didn't you use any hitsounds except for the normal hit? It's better to use hitsounds like finish or clap etc. It makes your map more interesting to play and I think it's even a requirement for getting it submitted. It could also be me because at the moment thanks to I don't know my osu is acting really weird (especially mania). Yup, there aren't any hitsounds yet. I usually don't bother to add them until later, this is still a work in progress
For the song settings [general]:
Artist : Pitbull ft. Ke$ha (Blue nightcore isn't actually a thing, it's just to show that it was nightcored by nerondakuro, just like amazon nightcore)
Title: Timber (Nightcore mix)
Tags: In the tags shouldn't be anything that is already mentioned in Artist, Title, creator, etc. Perhaps something saying about the genre or iconic lyrics like "It's going down" or "I'm calling", because you already mentioned Timber in the title. Thank you, will fix


Normal:
Hitsounds yet again. Consider to change the type to soft in the timing menu during the verses. It's also pretty short compared to the hard and insane difficulty.

Hard:
Hitsounds, what I said in the normal difficulty applies here too. Also, some notes overlap that you can't see the notes underneath and only by the approach circle you can see there is another note beneath. For example at 00:04:724 (5,6) - . You should change this so every hitcircle is visible. I don't really think this poses a problem, stacks are pretty common in hard difficulty

I'm not going to say anything about insane because I don't consider myself to be "qualified" to mod it. I don't play insane, I never played it.

For a big part this is actually a really good map, it just needs a few adjustments ^-^

Erina wrote:

nariette wrote:

I love it!

Overall
Is it just me or didn't you use any hitsounds except for the normal hit? It's better to use hitsounds like finish or clap etc. It makes your map more interesting to play and I think it's even a requirement for getting it submitted. It could also be me because at the moment thanks to I don't know my osu is acting really weird (especially mania). Yup, there aren't any hitsounds yet. I usually don't bother to add them until later, this is still a work in progress
For the song settings [general]:
Artist : Pitbull ft. Ke$ha (Blue nightcore isn't actually a thing, it's just to show that it was nightcored by nerondakuro, just like amazon nightcore)
Title: Timber (Nightcore mix)
Tags: In the tags shouldn't be anything that is already mentioned in Artist, Title, creator, etc. Perhaps something saying about the genre or iconic lyrics like "It's going down" or "I'm calling", because you already mentioned Timber in the title. Thank you, will fix


Normal:
Hitsounds yet again. Consider to change the type to soft in the timing menu during the verses. It's also pretty short compared to the hard and insane difficulty.

Hard:
Hitsounds, what I said in the normal difficulty applies here too. Also, some notes overlap that you can't see the notes underneath and only by the approach circle you can see there is another note beneath. For example at 00:04:724 (5,6) - . You should change this so every hitcircle is visible. I don't really think this poses a problem, stacks are pretty common in hard difficulty

I'm not going to say anything about insane because I don't consider myself to be "qualified" to mod it. I don't play insane, I never played it.

For a big part this is actually a really good map, it just needs a few adjustments ^-^

Thanks for the mod!

Kennybaaang wrote:

You got someone to make Ez diff? Message me if you want some help.

nariette wrote:

Thank you for the kudosu! Of course there is nothing wrong with stacking, but it is common to make sure that the underlying hitcircle is visible, even if it's just the outer ring of the hitcircle (not the approach circle), You should do this particularly in normal and easy difficulties. If you have finished hitsounds and done some final editing I could have another look at it if you want to. That would be wonderful! I'm particularly bad with hitsounds so I'd need people to help me with those I'll probably ask you later when I get hitsounds done

If you are looking for someone to make an easy difficulty, I could map a minute, see if you like my style and technique and you can include it (I'll finish it by then of course).

Oh and by the way, your combo colors are the standard colors (If you knew this and were planning to change this, ignore this). You might like these, but note that they will be different for people using different skins. I use a custom skin and my colours are darkblue, green, darkred, darkorange and darkred again. If this bothers you, you can change this. Yes, I was planning on changing this. If you have any color suggestions, feel free to tell me.

Gabe wrote:

Timber ~ ♪

xjoint wrote:

Hi! Random mod here - I'm pretty new to modding but hopefully I'll have some useful comments.

General
There's 2 .osb files in the folder right now. This is a WIP but just in case for later if you didn't notice. I did not notice, I'll change this soon (gotta find out why there were 2 .osb files first)

Normal
I know this difficulty isn't even completed yet, but just some comments on what's there so far.

00:42:801 (3,1) - and 00:44:339 (4,1) - seem a little tricky for this Normal. There's quite a bit of stacking in this difficulty in general - maybe you'd want to consider making it a little easier to read. Changed a little bit, but I agree that it might be too hard here. I'll look for suggestions on other ways to map this part. For now though, the overall rhythm is staying the same.

01:08:955 (2,3) - Kind of nitpicky, but I think it'd look better if the 2 were more to the left so you have a symmetric blanket. Maybe something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1389207 Done (kind of, I suck at blankets

01:44:147 - to 01:50:493 - while I can see how it fits with the music, this segment seems somewhat boring because it's really rectangular with all the straight sliders. Changed!

02:10:878 (2,3) - I think that this part could have better flow. Following the 2 slider then turning up at that angle for the 3 feels awkward - not necessarily too difficult but awkward. Changed!

Hard
02:24:147 (7) - I think it would fit better to have a new combo here. Actually the 7,8, and 1 sound like they belong together. Added NC, but kept the NC on the current 1 because it fits the pattern

Overall I really liked this map! thank you~

Insane

02:26:262 - These jumps on this blue combo feel really unnatural. I think some of it has to do with the fact that the even beats (2,4,6,8 of this combo) are actually stacking, so they get shifted out of the line which makes it really weird. Also the way the distance between the note changes from between 1,2,3,4 to between 4 and 5 is confusing. This part is sort of difficult in a bad way so it might be better to try a different pattern for this.

02:41:935 - and 02:47:801 - Now this could just be me being bad (I have played maps with jumps like this though) but these cross screen back and forth jumps just didn't flow well for me. They were surprising and hard to read, and I felt like I just wanted to go somewhere else with my cursor. It may have to do with the circles stacking, which makes it hard to read since they're so far apart.

Currently, I like both of these as is, and the second one in particular. The second one doesn't usually give anyone much trouble, so I'm not changing for now. I do agree that the stacking makes the first pattern look kind of ugly, I'll consider changing that pattern.

Best of luck finishing up this mapset!

Kennybaaang wrote:

You got someone to make Ez diff? Message me if you want some help.

Erina wrote:

For guest difficulties, I apologize for not making things clear. I don't expect to make easy a guest difficulty (unless maybe a mutual friend asks or something), it was just me kinda talking to myself haha thanks for the offers though!

akinator127 wrote:

I've only played this map on Hard, but I really love it. I could feel the beat of the notes the whole way through and it's just really fun to play. I hope this gets ranked! Good luck sir.

Malte-Sama wrote:

I really liked your insane map because it had so much action and difficult jumps It was one of my favourites and i played it at least every two or three days ^^
But the new one is kinda boring compared to the old insane and it has some jumps which are too insane (just my opinion, but I think that won't get ranked...) :/

Maybe you might re-add the old insane one as another difficulty if you want to keep the new one? ^^
However you will do that, I have my backup of the old insane one and I will keep playing on that (because it's awesome!)