forum

Sagara Kokoro - Hoshizora no Ima

posted
Total Posts
27
show more
TAIN
Hi ! >w<

from your Q.

[Easy]

AR+1

00:00:993 (2) - It seems too bent.This change better.
00:08:128 (2,3) - Blanket
00:14:615 (2) - Slider 00:15:912 (2) - This overlap.
01:20:777 (2) - Do not continue to reverse the slider, I recommend using a circle,slider.. :?
02:12:669 (1,1) - More beautiful blanket.
02:46:399 (3) - Circle 02:48:344 (3) - this overlap.

[Normal]

00:22:723 (2) - Slider 00:23:696 (1) - Placed at an angle such as this.
00:28:236 (1,2) - It'd be better to use the slider.
00:43:480 (1) - NC remove
01:11:696 (1,2,3) - △Snap.
01:20:128 (1) - NC remove
01:20:777 (3) - Do not continue to reverse the slider, I recommend using a circle,slider.
01:33:101 (1,2,3) - △Snap.(beautiful)
01:35:534 (1,2,3,4,5) - Too difficult.(This difficulty is normal..)
02:06:182 (3,4,5) - △Snap.
02:43:155 (1,2) - It'd be better to use the slider.
03:08:939 (1,2,3,4,5) - Too difficult.
03:19:317 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^
03:20:128 (6,1,2) - More beautiful blanket.
03:23:372 (2) - Slider 03:24:669 (1) - Some overlap..
03:47:372 (2,3) - Distance.
03:48:020 (3,4) - ^

[Hard]

HP+1

00:05:858 (1,2,3) - △Snap.(beautiful)
00:13:642 (1) - NC remove
00:13:966 (1) - ^
01:20:128 (6) - NC
00:17:209 (2) - Not properly overlap. x256,y108
00:17:534 (3) - ^
00:35:372 (7) - x88,y207
00:35:696 (8) - ^
01:09:750 (1) - 01:10:399 (3) - This is a little overlap.Placement elsewhere.
01:17:534 (1) - NC remove.
03:24:344 (4) - x486,y213

[Lunatic]

00:04:885 (1) - NC remove.
00:41:858 (9) - NC
01:18:182 (9) - ^
01:34:885 (1) - x401,y280
01:34:885 (1) - x209,y305
01:53:209 (10) - NC
02:07:479 (6) - ^

GL ~ :)
Boncho
Hi!~ from your Queue! ;)

[General]
Correct me if I am wrong but this map has nothing to do with Touhou so why is the last diff named Lunatic?

[Easy]
why is the beat snap divisor 1/1?

00:07:804 (1) -remove NC
00:51:588 (4) - why NC?
00:50:939 (3,1) - blanket it better like this:


01:02:939 (1,2,3,4,5) - why not like this?:


01:25:966 (1,2) - blanket it better like this:


01:31:155 (2) - you cant see a part of the slider, this makes it unrankable. Fix this!

01:33:750 (3,1) - blanket it better like this:


01:35:047 (1,2) - ^same
01:50:615 (1) - remove NC
01:51:912 (1) - blanket it better
02:06:182 (1) - remove NC
02:07:480 (1) - remove NC
02:11:696 (2) - remove NC
02:39:588 (2) - add a circle
03:36:344 (1) - remove NC
03:48:993 (1) - extend slider till 03:53:858?

[Normal]
00:34:074 (1) - Remove NC
00:32:128 (1) - ^
00:43:480 (1) - ^
01:07:155 (1) - ^
01:15:263 (1) - ^
01:35:534 (1,3,5) - delete all 3 circles
02:47:534 (1) - remove NC
03:00:507 (1) - place this circle on 03:00:344
03:01:804 (1) - place this circle on 03:01:642
03:08:939 (1,3,5) - delete all 3 circles
03:19:317 (1,3,5) - ^

[Hard]

00:04:561 (7) - remove NC
00:05:534 (10) - NC
00:05:858 (2) - remove NC
00:10:074 (3) - ^
00:10:723 (5) - NC
00:11:372 (1) - remove NC
00:13:642 (1) - ^
00:13:966 (1) - ^
01:25:642 (1) - remove this circle
01:54:182 (1,2) - remove both circles and put the slider on 01:54:134
02:48:182 (1,2,3,4,5) - seems too hard for a hard difficulty and this is a quite silent part. I recommend you to do the same but with a lower distance snap :D


GOOD LUCK!~
:)
Oriance
i'll mod your map once you updated all of these mods owo...
Topic Starter
jogfi2002

Naryuga wrote:

Challenging for m4m of your queue ( p/2846926 )

[General]
  1. Sorry if these suggestion collides ZLOdeuka-'s, I started modding 2 hours ago ;_; 大丈夫だ!
  2. :idea: As ZLOdeuka- says, try making map with hitsounds! It will require you lots of work but hitsounding is very important part of mapping.
そうですね、あとでサウンドを加える

[Easy]
  1. 00:18:507 (2) - umm this two reversings in (2) might be hard for beginners because it is fairly fast. Try reducing repeats by 1 , then adjust spacing with (3). Example: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1307506 ナイス!
  2. 00:33:426 (2) - this would be a bit hard, too. And actually at 00:34:399 - no vocal or big sound follow this, so I recommend trying reducing repeat, then adjust the collision with (3) for a better flow. Example: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1307518 fixed.
  3. 00:40:561 (1) - remove new combo? this single combo looks just excessive to me fixed.
  4. 01:14:290 (1) - same to the above ^ fixed.
  5. 01:16:885 (1) - ^ fixed.
  6. 01:42:182 (1) - ^ *it can follow the vocal better fixed.
  7. 01:45:426 (1) - ^ fixed.
  8. 01:50:615 (1) - ^ fixed.
  9. 02:11:696 (1) - ^ fixed.
  10. 02:13:966 (1) - ^ fixed.
[Normal]
  1. 00:24:993 (1) - remove new combo, the previous pattern ( 00:22:723 (2) - ) is without newcombo fixed.
  2. 00:34:074 (1,1) - [A]remove new combo from the circle [B]then move the circle 1 grid right to make perfect line with the slider fixed.
  3. 01:15:912 (1,2,3,4,5) - How to make a perfect star: [A]set Beat snap divisor in the rhythm which you want to make (here 1/1) [B]press Ctrl+Shift+D [C]move where you want to put fixed.
  4. 01:35:534 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - this is very hard for this diff as you see the #1 KIAI part. At least deleting (3,5) would be better 君の意見に従う
  5. 03:08:939 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^ ^
  6. 03:19:317 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^ ^
[Hard]
  1. 00:08:128 (2) - as the arrow does not follow the vocal, try put arrow at 00:08:615 - and end 00:09:101 - this sounds better Good idea
  2. 00:42:993 (1,2) - making the same pattern to 00:42:344 (4,5) - will be less confusing fixed.
  3. 00:44:453 (6) - set the direction up to avoid collision with (7). Example: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1307552 fixed.
  4. 01:08:290 (1,2) - as (2) is not following any good sound and the flow does not look so good, try to follow the vocal and find better flow. Example: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1307554 fixed.
  5. 01:38:290 (1,2,3) - umm I prefer normal circles very much and you can put a circle on 01:39:263 - 3を◯にした、新しい◯も増やした
  6. 01:52:885 (1) - place farther from 01:52:561 (5) - to avoid misreading the jumps fixed.
  7. 03:41:534 (1,2) - I prefer circles... :3 短いスライダーはもっとダイナミックだと思うけど…
  8. 03:48:669 - add circle? as Normal diff does so
fixed.

[Lunatic]
  1. 00:51:831 (1) - delete this note and adjust spacing, no sounds here fixed.
  2. 01:08:372 (7) - umm delete? it doesn't fit such a quiet place fixed.
  3. 02:10:561 (13) - should be a single circle :3 fixed.
  4. 02:40:561 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - these notes should be in 1/3, not 1/4! これはすごい!!いい耳持ってるね!
  5. 03:05:696 - add a circle here (x:112,y:340) to follow the drum and better flow of spacings
  6. 03:24:020 (11) - new combo here is required to get more viable fixed.
  7. 03:27:588 - you can make stream from here fixed.
am going to post m4m request in your queue, good luck
詳しいmoddingありがとうございました!
こんばきっとあなたのマップをMODします!
Topic Starter
jogfi2002

Narcissu wrote:

[insane]


雖然整體感覺挺不錯的不過實際上問題很多就只提點建議了

全程50音量肯定有問題 这个得在弄音效的时候再调调了。

tick rate 應該用一樣的,這個我不熟,只是照搬規則 看了下规则,没这个强制要求。

lunatic好像是東方的曲子用的說法 _(:3」∠)_ 有几个人说过了于是我还是改吧……

如果要在前奏使用0.5的變速,那麼我認為你需要remap,因為高潮段明顯比00:10:723 - 要高昂但是你都是1.0的速度,建議0.75。 其实我没太明白你这句的意思,还请解释一下。

要炫酷是可以連續用NC的,不過很多地方的NC肯定是有問題的比如00:04:885 - 现在改了很多,有时我加NC是为了提醒玩家这里有跳或者别的变化。

我感覺節奏有問題,跟鋼琴那00:01:642 - 應該有note,跟鼓那00:10:642 - 應該有連打,然後00:22:399 - 這個折返莫名其妙,00:29:615 - 沒連打不可理喻 _(:3」∠)_ 你说的这几个都改进了,节奏我会再检讨的。

break太多,合計休息時間不要超過曲子的20%,我建議10%,你可以使用人性化的排版來代替休息 唔,放了break的地方都是觉得不做不好要做又没地方休息……

03:16:399 (1) - 03:37:155 (1) - 強烈求不坑 好!这段早就想remap了!

排版還不行,其實一開始我看見SV是1.92我以為是神圖來著的,因為這個曲子的風格是標準萌歌所以排版上我建議你盡量做到在AR0的情況下看上去是這樣的↓↓↓ orz排列一直是我觉得很头痛的事,不知道怎么样排才好看又好玩啊,还得有一定的难度


本來是求M4M來的說…… _(:3」∠)_ 不嫌棄的話可以來mod…… http://osu.ppy.sh/s/111386
对的其实咱知道Lun难度还有很多地方需要改进,只能慢慢来了,先听听大家的意见。

于是我晚点MOD你的图~谢谢
Topic Starter
jogfi2002

sksmwkd125 wrote:

Hi ! >w< hihi~

from your Q.

[Easy]

AR+1

00:00:993 (2) - It seems too bent.This change better. fixed
00:08:128 (2,3) - Blanket fixed
00:14:615 (2) - Slider 00:15:912 (2) - This overlap. fixed
01:20:777 (2) - Do not continue to reverse the slider, I recommend using a circle,slider.. :? fixed
02:12:669 (1,1) - More beautiful blanket. reserve
02:46:399 (3) - Circle 02:48:344 (3) - this overlap. It's OK, I think

[Normal]

00:22:723 (2) - Slider 00:23:696 (1) - Placed at an angle such as this. fixed
00:28:236 (1,2) - It'd be better to use the slider. fixed
00:43:480 (1) - NC remove fixed
01:11:696 (1,2,3) - △Snap. fixed
01:20:128 (1) - NC remove fixed
01:20:777 (3) - Do not continue to reverse the slider, I recommend using a circle,slider. fixed
01:33:101 (1,2,3) - △Snap.(beautiful)
01:35:534 (1,2,3,4,5) - Too difficult.(This difficulty is normal..) fixed
02:06:182 (3,4,5) - △Snap. fixed
02:43:155 (1,2) - It'd be better to use the slider. It is following vocal here
03:08:939 (1,2,3,4,5) - Too difficult. fixed
03:19:317 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ fixed
03:20:128 (6,1,2) - More beautiful blanket. fixed
03:23:372 (2) - Slider 03:24:669 (1) - Some overlap.. fixed
03:47:372 (2,3) - Distance. fixed
03:48:020 (3,4) - ^ fixed

[Hard]

HP+1

00:05:858 (1,2,3) - △Snap.(beautiful)
00:13:642 (1) - NC remove fixed
00:13:966 (1) - ^ fixed
01:20:128 (6) - NC fixed
00:17:209 (2) - Not properly overlap. x256,y108 fixed
00:17:534 (3) - ^ fixed
00:35:372 (7) - x88,y207 fixed
00:35:696 (8) - ^ fixed
01:09:750 (1) - 01:10:399 (3) - This is a little overlap.Placement elsewhere. fixed
01:17:534 (1) - NC remove. fixed
03:24:344 (4) - x486,y213 fixed

[Lunatic]

00:04:885 (1) - NC remove.
00:41:858 (9) - NC
01:18:182 (9) - ^
01:34:885 (1) - x401,y280
01:34:885 (1) - x209,y305
01:53:209 (10) - NC
02:07:479 (6) - ^

GL ~ :)
Thank you very much!!
Topic Starter
jogfi2002

Bonch0 wrote:

Hi!~ from your Queue! ;)

[General]
Correct me if I am wrong but this map has nothing to do with Touhou so why is the last diff named Lunatic? OK, I have changed it to Starry Night.

[Easy]
why is the beat snap divisor 1/1? It does nothing to the players but the tick distance of the editor.

00:07:804 (1) -remove NC fixed.
00:51:588 (4) - why NC? fixed.
00:50:939 (3,1) - blanket it better like this: fixed.


01:02:939 (1,2,3,4,5) - why not like this?: I'm following the piano and don't want to make it too difficult.


01:25:966 (1,2) - blanket it better like this: fixed.


01:31:155 (2) - you cant see a part of the slider, this makes it unrankable. Fix this! fixed.

01:33:750 (3,1) - blanket it better like this: fixed.


01:35:047 (1,2) - ^same fixed.
01:50:615 (1) - remove NC fixed.
01:51:912 (1) - blanket it better fixed.
02:06:182 (1) - remove NC fixed.
02:07:480 (1) - remove NC fixed.
02:11:696 (2) - remove NC fixed.
02:39:588 (2) - add a circle fixed.
03:36:344 (1) - remove NC fixed.
03:48:993 (1) - extend slider till 03:53:858? fixed in all diffs.

[Normal]
00:34:074 (1) - Remove NC fixed.
00:32:128 (1) - ^ fixed.
00:43:480 (1) - ^ fixed.
01:07:155 (1) - ^ fixed.
01:15:263 (1) - ^ Well, this is a reminder
01:35:534 (1,3,5) - delete all 3 circles fixed.
02:47:534 (1) - remove NC fixed.
03:00:507 (1) - place this circle on 03:00:344 reserved.
03:01:804 (1) - place this circle on 03:01:642 reserved.
03:08:939 (1,3,5) - delete all 3 circles fixed.
03:19:317 (1,3,5) - ^ fixed.

[Hard]

00:04:561 (7) - remove NC fixed.
00:05:534 (10) - NC fixed.
00:05:858 (2) - remove NC fixed.
00:10:074 (3) - ^ fixed.
00:10:723 (5) - NC fixed.
00:11:372 (1) - remove NC reserved.
00:13:642 (1) - ^ reserved.
00:13:966 (1) - ^ fixed.
01:25:642 (1) - remove this circle reserved.
01:54:182 (1,2) - remove both circles and put the slider on 01:54:134 reserved.
02:48:182 (1,2,3,4,5) - seems too hard for a hard difficulty and this is a quite silent part. I recommend you to do the same but with a lower distance snap :D Good idea, i didn't notice this.


GOOD LUCK!~
:)
Thanks for your mod~!
Citrus
Hi~M4M
[General]
  • 标题感觉没有必要加Full ver
[Starry Night]
  • NC有点乱,建议重新弄一下
    00:19:723 这里加个note并且加clap
    00:24:993 (6) - 这种变速最好加个NC
    01:27:912 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 我比较喜欢这样
    02:12:020 (2) - 离1和3远一点,有点难读
    02:36:101 (2) - 去掉
    02:40:561 (8) -
    03:06:344 (4) - 放远一点
    音效
    音量50%太低了
    clap音效可以用hitnormal感觉不错
    00:00:831 (1) - 00:10:074 (9) - 这一段的whistle我推荐两种加法,一种是加在长白线上,另一种是加在第三条白线上
    00:12:993 (9) - 结尾clap
    00:18:182 (3) - ^
    00:19:804 (9) - ^
    00:24:993 (6) - 中间clap
    00:26:290 (1,3,5,6) - whistle
    00:28:885 (3) - 开头finish
    00:29:696 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 这种连打可以用hitnormal
    kiai段用24clap即可,whistle可以加在红线
    00:40:885 (6) - 开头finish
    00:41:858 (1) - ^
    01:03:101-01:12:020 同上
    01:15:426 (9) - 中间clap
    01:17:372 (4) - clap
    01:17:696 (7) - clap
    01:23:372 (1) - 开头finish
    01:27:588 (9) - ^
    01:28:560 (6) - finish
    01:30:507 (1) - 结尾clap
    01:32:615 (1,2,4) - clap
    01:33:750 (1) - 开头finish
    01:43:155 (2) - finish
    01:44:128 (4) - 开头finish
    02:04:885 (1) - 开头finish
    02:46:399 (3) - finish
    02:56:777 (3) - 开头finish
    03:17:534 (5) - ^
    03:33:101 (3) - ^
    03:37:317 (2) - ^
    03:38:615 (2) - ^
    03:42:182 (5) - 中间finish
    03:43:480 (5) - 开头finish
    03:44:777 (5) - 结尾finish
    03:45:750 (2) - 开头finish
    03:46:074 (3) - ^
    03:48:993 (1) - 去掉finish,其他难度也是
[Hard]
  • 00:08:615 (4) - 节奏上的建议
    00:28:885 (1) - 在00:30:507结束怎么样?
    00:46:236 (4,5) -
    音效参照Starry Night简化即可
音效方面写得有点乱,不明白的地方可以问我
希望对你有帮助,加油!
_Stan
M4M
我就mod了Hard和Starry Night

HARD

00:09:263 (1) - [我觉得]snap有点远了
00:40:074 (1) - 有点快了, 可能你也是特意这样安排的吧
00:50:128 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 太棒了, 随节奏很有跳跃感
01:15:912 (3) - 有点迷惑 如果安排成如同01:42:507 (1,2,3,4) - 一样 就好了 :)
01:38:290 (1,2,3,4) - 间距有点怪?? -_,-
03:28:561 (6,7) - 这里可以跳跃点, song很欢快

有什么不合适的,没有理解你的设计心思的, 无视就好了。

Starry Night

00:13:966 (1,2) - 右下方移动一下, 这样前后snap都比较合适吧, maybe
00:26:290 - 00:29:209 - 感觉特别好 !!
01:54:507 (4) - 弄远点怎么样 - - , 结尾时点击更有感觉 还是重音
02:42:020 (2) - 这个位置? 特意安排的么
02:42:993 (1) - 这个先不换颜色, 接在上一part, 毕竟重音不是从这里开始的
02:43:155 (1,1,1,2) - 这四个是重音, 分别不同颜色吧,
02:47:372 (6) - 有点突兀
02:56:777 (3) - 这个过度渐进做的好好
03:02:615 (1) - 03:03:912 (1) - 把这两个用re selecton, 更带感,更跳跃
03:25:642 (1,2,1,2,1,2,3) - 真心好棒
03:47:372 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1) - 不管排列 顺序都很好 华丽又带感!!

以上都是个人观点, 若有误解的请原谅

我的图http://osu.ppy.sh/s/182427
Streliteela
你好~M4M
因为我个人作图最难只能做到hard,所以水平最高也只能摸到hard难度请见谅;另外我比较强迫症一些,所以个人主观见解比较多还请多多保函

[General]
整体还行,NM和EZ做的不错,但HD排列还是乱;细节处节奏处理欠佳,建议多看看一些比较喜欢做这类动漫类的麻婆的图研究一下(比如飞球);在图中多使用平行、对称等排列会使图本身干净爽眼。Hard难度明显太受ds限制,建议在有一定空间观念的基础上关掉,并用一些大胆的跳来增加挑战性。现在这个hard难度可能需要局部re,我只是提一些我的建议,仅供参考

[Hard]
我感觉你还可以整体sv再调高一点。。现在这滑条速度有点太慢了
00:01:317 (4) - 调整至x343|y70位置,使34与12平行比较好看;然后后面的部分再调整一下
00:06:831 (5,1,2) - 这里排列感觉太随便了一些,建议重新调整一下
00:17:534 (3,1,2,3) - 做个正方形吧,现在这形状有点违和
00:22:236 - 这一段节奏如果跟歌词的话,这里建议加个note
00:24:344 (4) - 把这个拉长到最近红线处
00:27:912 (6) - 这里你跟了歌词的节奏,但因为钢琴这里的节奏太明显了;而且本来这里歌词节奏密度就比较小,再空节奏感觉很怪,建议加个note
00:31:480 (2) - 这里处理的不好,因为你后面00:31:966 (3,4) - 和00:32:615 (5,6) - 两处节奏类似处都是短滑条+note处理,所以建议这里也处理成这样
00:34:074 (4) - 我个人非常非常反对在hard及其难度以上的图里面用到这种多次折返滑条,虽然对节奏没影响但非常影响打击感
00:36:669 (3,3) - 这两个地方为什么要用0.5x...kiai部分本来就要节奏快一些为什么这两个滑条要处理这么慢?没有必要
00:43:642 (1) - 这里的折返滑条也建议改掉,原因同上文
00:44:453 (4) - 这里你可以用折返,我只是拿出来对比说一下;因为这里歌词本身也是一个长音,所以你用折返滑条,在打击的时候正好也是较长时间按住,和歌词本身节奏搭调,因此可以保留;但前面说的那几处节奏比较短促的就不需要折返滑条了
00:46:236 (4) - 这里也是,折返处理这里的节奏太简单了;建议换成两个短滑条做个滑条梗什么的
00:46:885 (5) - 听这里的节奏好像有做小串连打的可行性啊,这个滑条带过去的话,节奏处理太简单了
00:47:372 (6,7,8) - 这个地方节奏并不是均匀的,是两快一慢;你这三个等间距note节奏就变得有点怪了
00:51:426 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 这地方我只能。。orz了,前面6个note排列拉这么开,这里节奏密集还都挤在一起。。hard读图大丈夫?改
01:12:020 (1,2,3) - 节奏在红线的地方。。虽然放在红线听起来也奇怪但你这么摆同样很奇怪orz (听上去好像没踩到节奏一样orz)
01:17:209 (1,2,3,4,5) - 这样排列本身可以,但需要再调整一下。。这样看着好生硬;因为后面有个炒鸡长的滑条6,这一块都挤在一起然后后面6滑条突然拉开的感觉太糟糕了;而且hard本身不需要这么严格遵守ds,关ds重新考虑排列
01:32:615 - 01:32:939 - 加3个note
01:35:696 (2) - 改掉
01:37:317 (1,2,3) - 这里改成3组二连note
01:39:263 (4) - 这个为什么要拉这么远?把它调整和前面123之间相同间距
01:43:480 - 01:48:831 - 这一段你用了很多stack在一起的note,这样本身没有问题,但kiai部分这种stack太多移动感会削弱很多,建议改掉几组; 后面部分还有几处类似问题,建议都修改一下,不赘述
01:53:696 (1,2,1,2,3) - 这个地方也是。。这好像是你的风格所以我只是说我个人不喜欢这样, 不管节奏疏密都放在同一个地方点啊点orz
02:04:885 (1) - 这一段本身舒缓节奏可以减慢滑条速度,但你本身滑条速度就有够慢的了再变成0.5就太慢了,建议0.75-0.8
02:06:507 (4,5) - 调平行
02:36:020 (1) - 0.5太慢了orz
02:48:182 (1,2,3,4,5) - 逼死强迫症的形状orz
03:47:372 (2,3,4,5) - 都到结尾了。。节奏偷懒嫌疑orz

[Normal]
这个难度明显做的比hard好太多
00:40:561 (2) - 这种note最好和滑条尾分开,新手不好判读
00:43:155 (2) - ^
01:09:426 (2) - ^
01:15:263 (1,2) - 新手噩梦,改
01:34:236 (1,2) - 节奏太密集的note建议不要放,何况是二连简直新手噩梦,改成和后面一样的短滑条就可以了
02:38:453 (1,2) - 额这个问题倒是不大。。不过还是不建议这样放note,bpm本身不低,这样note叠滑条新手可能反应不过来
02:46:885 (1,2) - 观点同上
03:00:507 (1,2,1,2) - ^
03:05:858 (4) - 尽量不要叠尾
03:18:020 (1,2,1,2) - 观点同上

[Easy]
sv可以再调慢一些,不然和normal没什么区别了(不调问题也不是特别大)
其余的问题也不是很大,挺不错的~

Good luck~ :)
Topic Starter
jogfi2002

thou bad wrote:

Hi~M4M
[General]
  • 标题感觉没有必要加Full ver
[Starry Night]
  • NC有点乱,建议重新弄一下 好的。
    00:19:723 这里加个note并且加clap 加得好!
    00:24:993 (6) - 这种变速最好加个NC fixed
    01:27:912 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 我比较喜欢这样 保留。
    02:12:020 (2) - 离1和3远一点,有点难读 调成1.00了
    02:36:101 (2) - 去掉 好的。
    02:40:561 (8) - 好的。
    03:06:344 (4) - 放远一点 好的。
    音效
    音量50%太低了
    clap音效可以用hitnormal感觉不错
    00:00:831 (1) - 00:10:074 (9) - 这一段的whistle我推荐两种加法,一种是加在长白线上,另一种是加在第三条白线上 用了长白线的,感觉不错。
    00:12:993 (9) - 结尾clap
    00:18:182 (3) - ^
    00:19:804 (9) - ^
    00:24:993 (6) - 中间clap
    00:26:290 (1,3,5,6) - whistle
    00:28:885 (3) - 开头finish
    00:29:696 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 这种连打可以用hitnormal
    kiai段用24clap即可,whistle可以加在红线
    00:40:885 (6) - 开头finish
    00:41:858 (1) - ^
    01:03:101-01:12:020 同上
    01:15:426 (9) - 中间clap
    01:17:372 (4) - clap
    01:17:696 (7) - clap
    01:23:372 (1) - 开头finish
    01:27:588 (9) - ^
    01:28:560 (6) - finish
    01:30:507 (1) - 结尾clap
    01:32:615 (1,2,4) - clap
    01:33:750 (1) - 开头finish
    01:43:155 (2) - finish
    01:44:128 (4) - 开头finish
    02:04:885 (1) - 开头finish
    02:46:399 (3) - finish
    02:56:777 (3) - 开头finish
    03:17:534 (5) - ^
    03:33:101 (3) - ^
    03:37:317 (2) - ^
    03:38:615 (2) - ^
    03:42:182 (5) - 中间finish
    03:43:480 (5) - 开头finish
    03:44:777 (5) - 结尾finish
    03:45:750 (2) - 开头finish
    03:46:074 (3) - ^
    03:48:993 (1) - 去掉finish,其他难度也是
[Hard]
  • 00:08:615 (4) - 节奏上的建议 已修正
    00:28:885 (1) - 在00:30:507结束怎么样? 这个保留吧,想留多点时间给玩家反应
    00:46:236 (4,5) - 已修正
    音效参照Starry Night简化即可
音效方面写得有点乱,不明白的地方可以问我
希望对你有帮助,加油!
非常感谢!帮助极大!
我会尽快回你MOD
saisee2010
这是我首次写给别人的MOD,可能会有些错误,请您原谅我吧!
Starry Night 我一看眼睛就很花了 TT
我就给你写一个HARD和Normal难度吧

HARD
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

 00:08:165 -  
 00:12:993 -
 00:28:885 - 应该在 00.30.507 结束吧 
 01:17:209 -  去掉两个吧。
 01:38:290 -  把 Slider弄长一点
 03:01:804 -  改成这样吧。
 03:12:334 -
 
03:13:642 -  
03:21:263 - 三个连点应该更好吧
 03:41:534 - 03:41:858 -  把 Slider拉长一点
Normal
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

 01:15:623 - 或者 
 01:25:642 - 加个Note
 03:00:507,03:01:804 - 这样吧 -^-
 03:12:993 - 新手不好判读,改成这样吧 
 03:21:263 - 又是这样,直接改 -...-   
[/quote]
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
我的图http://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/215403 请MOD我 HARD 或者 INSANE 如果两个都MOD,我十分感谢您 ^^
请使用这个SKIN http://puu.sh/95kna/0069a85571.osk
Topic Starter
jogfi2002

_Stan wrote:

M4M
我就mod了Hard和Starry Night

HARD

00:09:263 (1) - [我觉得]snap有点远了 已经改了
00:40:074 (1) - 有点快了, 可能你也是特意这样安排的吧 没呀跟节奏是吻合的
00:50:128 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 太棒了, 随节奏很有跳跃感
01:15:912 (3) - 有点迷惑 如果安排成如同01:42:507 (1,2,3,4) - 一样 就好了 :) 这里的确有点难读,不过跟后面的节奏不一样
01:38:290 (1,2,3,4) - 间距有点怪?? -_,- 故意的233
03:28:561 (6,7) - 这里可以跳跃点, song很欢快

有什么不合适的,没有理解你的设计心思的, 无视就好了。

Starry Night

00:13:966 (1,2) - 右下方移动一下, 这样前后snap都比较合适吧, maybe
00:26:290 - 00:29:209 - 感觉特别好 !!
01:54:507 (4) - 弄远点怎么样 - - , 结尾时点击更有感觉 还是重音 先保留
02:42:020 (2) - 这个位置? 特意安排的么 对的
02:42:993 (1) - 这个先不换颜色, 接在上一part, 毕竟重音不是从这里开始的 这里主要是想提醒玩家下面要跳
02:43:155 (1,1,1,2) - 这四个是重音, 分别不同颜色吧, 保留
02:47:372 (6) - 有点突兀 已改
02:56:777 (3) - 这个过度渐进做的好好
03:02:615 (1) - 03:03:912 (1) - 把这两个用re selecton, 更带感,更跳跃 我比较喜欢顺着一个方向ww
03:25:642 (1,2,1,2,1,2,3) - 真心好棒
03:47:372 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1) - 不管排列 顺序都很好 华丽又带感!!

以上都是个人观点, 若有误解的请原谅

我的图http://osu.ppy.sh/s/182427
谢谢MOD和夸奖!我会尽快回MOD。
Topic Starter
jogfi2002

Streliteela wrote:

你好~M4M
因为我个人作图最难只能做到hard,所以水平最高也只能摸到hard难度请见谅;另外我比较强迫症一些,所以个人主观见解比较多还请多多保函

[General]
整体还行,NM和EZ做的不错,但HD排列还是乱;细节处节奏处理欠佳,建议多看看一些比较喜欢做这类动漫类的麻婆的图研究一下(比如飞球);在图中多使用平行、对称等排列会使图本身干净爽眼。Hard难度明显太受ds限制,建议在有一定空间观念的基础上关掉,并用一些大胆的跳来增加挑战性。现在这个hard难度可能需要局部re,我只是提一些我的建议,仅供参考

[Hard]
我感觉你还可以整体sv再调高一点。。现在这滑条速度有点太慢了
00:01:317 (4) - 调整至x343|y70位置,使34与12平行比较好看;然后后面的部分再调整一下 已修正
00:06:831 (5,1,2) - 这里排列感觉太随便了一些,建议重新调整一下 已修正
00:17:534 (3,1,2,3) - 做个正方形吧,现在这形状有点违和 已修正
00:22:236 - 这一段节奏如果跟歌词的话,这里建议加个note 已修正
00:24:344 (4) - 把这个拉长到最近红线处 拉了没法对上节奏啊
00:27:912 (6) - 这里你跟了歌词的节奏,但因为钢琴这里的节奏太明显了;而且本来这里歌词节奏密度就比较小,再空节奏感觉很怪,建议加个note 你说得对,已经加上了。
00:31:480 (2) - 这里处理的不好,因为你后面00:31:966 (3,4) - 和00:32:615 (5,6) - 两处节奏类似处都是短滑条+note处理,所以建议这里也处理成这样 已修正
00:34:074 (4) - 我个人非常非常反对在hard及其难度以上的图里面用到这种多次折返滑条,虽然对节奏没影响但非常影响打击感 先保留吧,这里没想到更好的排列
00:36:669 (3,3) - 这两个地方为什么要用0.5x...kiai部分本来就要节奏快一些为什么这两个滑条要处理这么慢?没有必要 已修正
00:43:642 (1) - 这里的折返滑条也建议改掉,原因同上文 已修正
00:44:453 (4) - 这里你可以用折返,我只是拿出来对比说一下;因为这里歌词本身也是一个长音,所以你用折返滑条,在打击的时候正好也是较长时间按住,和歌词本身节奏搭调,因此可以保留;但前面说的那几处节奏比较短促的就不需要折返滑条了
00:46:236 (4) - 这里也是,折返处理这里的节奏太简单了;建议换成两个短滑条做个滑条梗什么的
00:46:885 (5) - 听这里的节奏好像有做小串连打的可行性啊,这个滑条带过去的话,节奏处理太简单了 已修正
00:47:372 (6,7,8) - 这个地方节奏并不是均匀的,是两快一慢;你这三个等间距note节奏就变得有点怪了 这里没看懂
00:51:426 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 这地方我只能。。orz了,前面6个note排列拉这么开,这里节奏密集还都挤在一起。。hard读图大丈夫?改 这个先保留吧
01:12:020 (1,2,3) - 节奏在红线的地方。。虽然放在红线听起来也奇怪但你这么摆同样很奇怪orz (听上去好像没踩到节奏一样orz) 这里有跟音乐啦
01:17:209 (1,2,3,4,5) - 这样排列本身可以,但需要再调整一下。。这样看着好生硬;因为后面有个炒鸡长的滑条6,这一块都挤在一起然后后面6滑条突然拉开的感觉太糟糕了;而且hard本身不需要这么严格遵守ds,关ds重新考虑排列 已修正
01:32:615 - 01:32:939 - 加3个note 已修正
01:35:696 (2) - 改掉 这个先保留
01:37:317 (1,2,3) - 这里改成3组二连note 因为是过渡部分而且是HARD我就没弄成二连
01:39:263 (4) - 这个为什么要拉这么远?把它调整和前面123之间相同间距
01:43:480 - 01:48:831 - 这一段你用了很多stack在一起的note,这样本身没有问题,但kiai部分这种stack太多移动感会削弱很多,建议改掉几组; 后面部分还有几处类似问题,建议都修改一下,不赘述 先保留
01:53:696 (1,2,1,2,3) - 这个地方也是。。这好像是你的风格所以我只是说我个人不喜欢这样, 不管节奏疏密都放在同一个地方点啊点orz 因为高潮已经结束了,最后这样收尾我觉得合适
02:04:885 (1) - 这一段本身舒缓节奏可以减慢滑条速度,但你本身滑条速度就有够慢的了再变成0.5就太慢了,建议0.75-0.8 这里本意其实是配合INSANE的变化来做
02:06:507 (4,5) - 调平行 原本就是不想平行= =
02:36:020 (1) - 0.5太慢了orz 其实我觉得没啥问题……
02:48:182 (1,2,3,4,5) - 逼死强迫症的形状orz 这段先放着,一定要改的
03:47:372 (2,3,4,5) - 都到结尾了。。节奏偷懒嫌疑orz 也是想着最后了所以不搞这么复杂的节奏了……

[Normal]
这个难度明显做的比hard好太多
00:40:561 (2) - 这种note最好和滑条尾分开,新手不好判读 已修正
00:43:155 (2) - ^ 已修正
01:09:426 (2) - ^ 已修正
01:15:263 (1,2) - 新手噩梦,改 已修正
01:34:236 (1,2) - 节奏太密集的note建议不要放,何况是二连简直新手噩梦,改成和后面一样的短滑条就可以了 已修正
02:38:453 (1,2) - 额这个问题倒是不大。。不过还是不建议这样放note,bpm本身不低,这样note叠滑条新手可能反应不过来 已修正
02:46:885 (1,2) - 观点同上 已修正
03:00:507 (1,2,1,2) - ^ 已修正
03:05:858 (4) - 尽量不要叠尾 已修正
03:18:020 (1,2,1,2) - 观点同上03:18:020 (3) -

[Easy]
sv可以再调慢一些,不然和normal没什么区别了(不调问题也不是特别大)
其余的问题也不是很大,挺不错的~

Good luck~ :)
非常感谢!拖了这么久真是不好意思
Topic Starter
jogfi2002

saisee2010 wrote:

这是我首次写给别人的MOD,可能会有些错误,请您原谅我吧!
Starry Night 我一看眼睛就很花了 TT
我就给你写一个HARD和Normal难度吧
谢谢~我尽快回你
MoeAsuka
你好~初次摸图,M4M~

Hard

00:01:966 (2) - 这里用一个折返滑条会不会好一点
00:28:236 (1,2) - 感觉改成两个短滑条比较舒服
00:37:966 (3,1) - 这个重叠看着有点不舒服,稍微分开试试?
00:40:723 (3,4) - 这梗我完全打不了0.0 把这两个note换成短滑条?
01:08:290 (1) - 上下翻转,然后往上移
01:32:615 (1,2,3,1) - 打着很不顺手,这样摆?
01:34:074 (1) - 01:34:723 (1) - 01:35:372 (1) - 删掉 这里只跟人声会好点
01:45:344 (8) - 删掉
01:53:858 (2) - clap
03:19:317 (1,2,3,4,5) - 换成折返滑条

Starry Night

00:10:074 (9,1) - 这个滑条好怪。把00:10:074 (9) - 往左移一点,然后把00:10:236 (1) - 改成连打?
01:17:696 (4) - 和连打拆开,往后面那个滑条的方向移一点
01:33:750 - 多了一根绿线,删掉
01:42:669 (1,2,3) - 间距稍微缩小一点,01:42:750 (2) -靠右
03:16:074 (1,2,3) - 类似上面的,我改的坐标依次为:(124,120),(92,84)(44,92)
03:25:642 (1,2) - 间距太小了
moonlightleaf
[Normal]

00:04:561 (2,1,2) - overlap , 换换别的位置?

00:09:101 (4,1) - 试试↓

00:18:507 (3) - 拆?

00:34:074 (3) - ^

00:39:263 (1) - ^

00:27:588 (5) - 滑条

00:32:777 (5,6) - ^

01:07:804 (4) - ^

01:10:399 (3,4) - ^

00:42:507 (1) - 去掉nc

01:09:750 (1) - ^ 建议2条长白线一个NC 这样子放

00:50:615 (4,5) - 分开吧? 把5放在1上

01:05:209 (3) - 折返?

01:17:209 (5) - 拆

01:42:831 (1) - ^

01:21:101 (6) - 可以一个长滑条

02:48:182 (1) - ^

01:54:507 (1) - 可以放在4上

02:10:074 (3,4) - 试试↓

02:38:290 (5) - (396,202)

02:53:534 (1,2,3,4) - 叠太多了

03:09:750 (3) - 2滑条或者1滑条

03:13:317 (2) - 还不如3个叠一起

03:15:912 (4,5) - 分开放

03:21:263 (1) - 这个不好,因为之前都没有这种2连梗,放前面白线

类似双折返的 可以考虑长滑条或者2短滑条带掉,既容易读又能降星

[Hard]

00:15:912 (1,2,3,4) - 叠好

00:24:831 - 加note 和前面呼应

00:25:804 (7) - 有点远了

00:31:480 (2,3) - DS

00:43:155 (2,1) - overlap

01:44:128 (3,5) - ^

00:44:129 (2) - 叠3上

00:49:480 (3,1) - 删了试试

03:18:344 (5,2) - ^

00:51:831 (3) - 删

01:45:344 (8) - ^

01:08:290 (1) - 前面都是跟噔~噔~噔~噔~,然后这边不跟了 好奇怪 ,别跟人声,跟旋律啊

01:25:480 (6) - 删,和前面1234呼应

01:32:615 (1,2,3) - 貌似太近了?考虑删掉

01:43:155 (4) - 试试↓

01:45:912 (1,2,3,4,5) - 5单点叠这不是很好,尝试别的组合

02:58:561 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^

03:19:317 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^ 5边型什么的

02:13:317 (3) - 绿线0.5x 试试↓

20s break 有点...

03:16:317 (4) - 没音,删

03:21:263 (1) - 滑条前面白线到这

03:24:020 (3,4) - 叠好,或者3折返

03:37:804 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - 虽然没问题 这类在hard里会加star,不是很适合sp 像03:43:155 (5,6)就过渡很好

03:48:020 (3,4,5) - 放别的地方吧

加油 :)
Topic Starter
jogfi2002

Asukasukisuki wrote:

你好~初次摸图,M4M~

Hard

00:01:966 (2) - 这里用一个折返滑条会不会好一点 已改
00:28:236 (1,2) - 感觉改成两个短滑条比较舒服 已改
00:37:966 (3,1) - 这个重叠看着有点不舒服,稍微分开试试? 先保留吧
00:40:723 (3,4) - 这梗我完全打不了0.0 把这两个note换成短滑条? 唔,我也觉得这里做得不好,先放着我以后修改吧
01:08:290 (1) - 上下翻转,然后往上移 已改
01:32:615 (1,2,3,1) - 打着很不顺手,这样摆? 已改
01:34:074 (1) - 01:34:723 (1) - 01:35:372 (1) - 删掉 这里只跟人声会好点 已改
01:45:344 (8) - 删掉 已改
01:53:858 (2) - clap 已改
03:19:317 (1,2,3,4,5) - 换成折返滑条
已改

Starry Night

00:10:074 (9,1) - 这个滑条好怪。把00:10:074 (9) - 往左移一点,然后把00:10:236 (1) - 改成连打? 已改,简化成滑条了
01:17:696 (4) - 和连打拆开,往后面那个滑条的方向移一点 已改
01:33:750 - 多了一根绿线,删掉 已改
01:42:669 (1,2,3) - 间距稍微缩小一点,01:42:750 (2) -靠右 已改
03:16:074 (1,2,3) - 类似上面的,我改的坐标依次为:(124,120),(92,84)(44,92) 已改
03:25:642 (1,2) - 间距太小了 这里的本意是想做一个间距递增的二连
感谢!相当有帮助。


moonlightleaf wrote:

[Normal]

00:04:561 (2,1,2) - overlap , 换换别的位置? 这两个在时间上已经隔得很远了吧……

00:09:101 (4,1) - 试试↓ 纯粹是弯变直的话我就不改了

00:18:507 (3) - 拆? 这里我倒是想跟人声那个长音的,先保留吧

00:34:074 (3) - ^ ^

00:39:263 (1) - ^ ^

00:27:588 (5) - 滑条 最开始我也是用滑条,后来觉得要等距留空所以换成NOTE了

00:32:777 (5,6) - ^ 已改

01:07:804 (4) - ^ 等距留空

01:10:399 (3,4) - ^ 未改

00:42:507 (1) - 去掉nc 已改

01:09:750 (1) - ^ 建议2条长白线一个NC 这样子放 未改

00:50:615 (4,5) - 分开吧? 把5放在1上 那就太跳了啊……

01:05:209 (3) - 折返? 等距留空

01:17:209 (5) - 拆 未改

01:42:831 (1) - ^ 未改

01:21:101 (6) - 可以一个长滑条 也是为了留空,所以这句唱完就空到下一段开始了

02:48:182 (1) - ^ 未改

01:54:507 (1) - 可以放在4上 已改

02:10:074 (3,4) - 试试↓ 未改

02:38:290 (5) - (396,202) 未改

02:53:534 (1,2,3,4) - 叠太多了 已改

03:09:750 (3) - 2滑条或者1滑条 未改

03:13:317 (2) - 还不如3个叠一起 未改

03:15:912 (4,5) - 分开放 未改

03:21:263 (1) - 这个不好,因为之前都没有这种2连梗,放前面白线 已改

类似双折返的 可以考虑长滑条或者2短滑条带掉,既容易读又能降星

[Hard]

00:15:912 (1,2,3,4) - 叠好 已改

00:24:831 - 加note 和前面呼应 已改

00:25:804 (7) - 有点远了 未改

00:31:480 (2,3) - DS 已改

00:43:155 (2,1) - overlap 未改

01:44:128 (3,5) - ^ 未改

00:44:129 (2) - 叠3上 已改

00:49:480 (3,1) - 删了试试 已改

03:18:344 (5,2) - ^ 已改

00:51:831 (3) - 删 已改

01:45:344 (8) - ^ 已改

01:08:290 (1) - 前面都是跟噔~噔~噔~噔~,然后这边不跟了 好奇怪 ,别跟人声,跟旋律啊 已改

01:25:480 (6) - 删,和前面1234呼应 已改

01:32:615 (1,2,3) - 貌似太近了?考虑删掉 未改

01:43:155 (4) - 试试↓ 已改

01:45:912 (1,2,3,4,5) - 5单点叠这不是很好,尝试别的组合 大修的时候改

02:58:561 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^ ^

03:19:317 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^ 5边型什么的 ^

02:13:317 (3) - 绿线0.5x 试试↓ 没看懂……

20s break 有点...

03:16:317 (4) - 没音,删 已改

03:21:263 (1) - 滑条前面白线到这 已改

03:24:020 (3,4) - 叠好,或者3折返 已改

03:37:804 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - 虽然没问题 这类在hard里会加star,不是很适合sp 像03:43:155 (5,6)就过渡很好 全图只有一处这样的,就不改了吧……

03:48:020 (3,4,5) - 放别的地方吧 未改

加油 :)
非常感谢!你的图我明天起来之后再MOD~
Kyle Y
hi, M4M here

here is my modding, I am also new, and DO NOT EXPECT TOO MUCH from me.


[Easy]
I prefer a Easy with long slider.
Tell you one thing, you can use 1/2 to map, but the spacing need 1 beat.
and I prefer to follow vocal

just like...
00:00:345 -

00:07:480 -

00:10:723 -

00:19:480 - missing
00:17:858 (1) - del nc

00:27:588 (3) - circle, and circle at 00:28:236 -
00:28:885 (1,2,3,4,5) - too much circle use slider instead
00:36:020 - 2 beat slider
00:37:641 (2,3) - del and add a slider on 00:37:966 -
00:38:290 - missing
00:43:155 (2) - blanket with 00:44:453 (1) -
00:49:642 (2) - 2beat slider
----------break time------------
01:02:939 - try this

01:12:669 (1) - del
01:11:047 (3) - 1.5 beat
01:21:101 (3) - better not to use 1/2 reverse slider, use long slider instead
01:23:372 (1) - blanket
01:27:263 (2) - I think too cruve

01:28:561 (1,2,3,4,5) - too much circle, use slider
01:31:155 (2) - use red dots...

01:33:101 (1,2) - del or slider
01:35:047 (1) - start at 01:34:885 -
01:43:480 (1,2) - slider
01:44:128 (3) - better blanket
01:44:128 (3,4) - use same slider, (3) rotate 180 to form (4) and blanket each other
01:46:723 (1) - 2 beat slider
01:51:912 (1) - blanket
---------break-----------
02:08:777 (1,2,3,4,5) - same too much circle
02:11:696 (2,3) - slider
02:12:669 (1,2) - use same slider, (1) rotate 180 to form (2) and blanket each other
02:46:399 - 無論如何都是覺得這個應該才是break,02:45:101 (7) - 這個是進入break 前最後一個notes, 到02:56:777 -
反而這個break 02:15:263 - 不太適合
If you really wait to keep it, then I think you need to use very long slider, as this part... music is calm and circle is not quite suitable
I just skip this part, if you keep it as final decision, then call me and I will mod for you with no kuds
---------break (I think)---------
02:56:777 - try this (circle at 03:05:858 - cannot be shown in the picture below)

Notice: 1/2 slider can be use, but not quite common in Easy. Just decide by you is okay.

For the kiai part, it is more or less the same with the 2 kiai time before, then I do not repeatly mod it.

Jump to 03:27:912 -
03:31:804 (4) - also 2 beat slider
03:34:399 (1,2,3) - ^
03:43:480 (1) - ^
03:47:372 (4) - extent to 03:48:669 -

[Starry Night]
00:01:480 - missing notes,
00:01:642 (4) - 1/2 beat slider
00:02:453 (6,7) - seperate and (7) change to slider
00:04:885 (2,3) - seperate
00:08:777 - you skipped this
00:18:182 (3,4) - flowing not quite good
00:18:831 (5,6) - sorry I really hate straight to my own aspect, you can keep it, or try this

00:19:480 (8,9) - flowing, of course you can do this:

00:21:426 (2,3) - same, hate straight line...
00:22:723 (7,8) - ^
00:24:993 - SV should change at 00:26:290 - but not here
00:28:236 (1,2) - I think both of them are 1/2 beat slider
00:30:344 (7) - I will del it as my mapping style
00:30:831 (1,2) - I will del or use slider with SV x0.5
00:40:804 - add circle, if you think bgm at 00:40:642 (4) - is 1/4 sound. then 00:40:804 - should be also
00:42:831 (4,5,6) - (6) not well look, use red dots, and try this

00:47:047 (7,8) - flowing

00:48:993 (3,4) - flowing
00:51:588 (3,1) - blanket
---------break---------
00:52:236 - not a good place for break
-------break-------
01:03:588 (2,3,4) - seperate it
01:11:209 (5,6,7) - ^
01:12:263 - 01:12:588 - I can't hear 1/4 sound
01:15:750 (1,2,3,4,5) - not a good pattern, use maybe hexagon to tackle it (01:16:561 (6) - count also)
01:22:236 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - flowing for (3)->(1)
01:30:344 (5) - if you add here, then why not 01:29:047 - 01:29:372 - 01:29:696 -
suggestion: del it and 01:28:885 (1,2,3,4,1) - form a regular star shape
01:37:642 (3,4) - flowing
01:39:588 (1,2,3) - too curve
01:42:993 (1,2) - jumping please
01:48:426 - no 1/4 sound here, then 01:48:344 (4,1) - combine
01:51:912 (4,5) - 01:52:399 (5,6) - both are bad flow
------------break------------
02:37:642 (7) - seperate
02:37:966 (1) - circle and 02:38:290 - slider here
02:43:804 - SV should be reture to 1.00
02:45:750 - break problem same as EZ, just decide by you.
02:58:074 (1,2,3,4) - 這個pattern 我被2個BN 說過... 說poor flow
02:59:047 (4,5) - bad flow
03:00:020 (7) - cancel reverse, add circle at 03:00:344 -
03:01:317 (4) - no 1/4 sound again, but 03:01:236 - here have
03:07:155 (7,1) - too far, and poor flow
03:14:290 (5) - 03:14:453 - sound skipped
03:15:101 - 03:15:750 - ^
03:17:452 (4,5) - not good as the slider 5 is too curve
03:18:182 (8) - below

03:23:696 (9,10,1,2,3) - try this

03:25:155 (2,3) - poor flow
03:25:642 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - should be constant in ds, as this music neither heavier the beap, nor beat is not extremely high in the 2nd circle
03:31:155 (1,2,3) - blanket
03:33:101 (3) - skipped a lot of beats
03:37:155 (1) - move out of the stream
03:48:506 (2,1) - flowing, and slider is too curve

btw, still have some nc problem. Use this pattern:
nc on the heavy beat, normally big tick, not for the vocal
when you are emphasis the pattern, like square, star etc.
SV change

最後還是感謝你花那麼多時間看了一篇完全沒用的modding
還有感謝你mod 我的圖
EncoreW
M4M

[Hard]

OD7对于这个难度的 Hard来说可能有点高了,建议还是改成 OD6或者 OD6.5

全程50%的音量肯定是不对的,而且从头到尾只有S:C1,除了soft-hitnormal之外几乎没有别的音效了,所以这个肯定要改过

Slider Tick Rate可以考虑改成1,2的话没有太大必要

00:17:047 - 感觉这里似乎是漏音了

00:21:101 (1) - 这里一段我觉得应该降低一些滑条的速度,因为节奏是比较舒缓的,而且和后面的 kiai段用同样的滑条速度这显然不太好

00:30:831 (1) - 这个敌方不太有必要用折返滑条,因为只有 00:30:831 - 00:31:155 - 这两个地方是有vocal的,其中后面一个还应该加点鼓声,但是你这样的话根本体现不出来这种节奏,00:31:317 - 这个地方是没有必要有任何东西的,但是你却把折返滑条拉到了这个时间点,这肯定是不对的,如果换成我的话我应该会把他直接做成一个1/1的滑条,然后降速并且用新的 NC

00:31:480 (2) - 这里用 NC吧,因为 kiai段开始了加上你在这里放了finish的音效,所以非常有必要的

00:34:074 (4) - 这个折返滑条折返一次就够了,没必要有第二次,因为 00:34:074 - 00:34:399 - 00:34:723 - 是有 vocal的,这时候需要滑条折返,但是00:35:047 - 这个地方是没有的,只有一个鼓声,所以需要把他独立开,用一个单独的 note来体现这个鼓声

00:39:101 (4) - 这地方的三连没有什么必要,因为没有任何的 vocal或者鼓声是需要三连来体现的

00:50:128 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 这里我建议每个note都可以用新的 NC,或者每两个一个新 NC也行,并且音量逐个加大,这样更符合鼓点

00:51:426 (1) - 滑条开头放在这里的话,滑条头再用这么大的音量就会感觉有点突兀,事实上我觉得 00:51:426 (1,2) - 这两个都应该减少音量,因为鼓点在00:50:939 (6) - 的时候就已经结束了,到了00:51:912 (3) - 这里才重新开始,这之间的这段时间里面,只有比较安静的 vocal

01:02:615 - 这么一个明显的 finish直接漏掉了这肯定是不行的,只跟 vocal是肯定站不住脚的

01:12:020 (1,2,3) - 鼓点很明显在 01:12:182 - 01:12:507 - 01:12:831 - 这里

01:33:750 (2) - 同理,kiai 开始加上finish音效,理应用 NC

01:38:290 (1,2,3) - 这两个1/4滑条来的有点莫名其妙,而且我觉得应该用 01:39:588 (1) - 类似这个的折返滑条,因为本身 vocal相近

01:52:723 - 这地方肯定要有 note的啊,鼓点没断,这么弄反而让人搞不懂了,而且 00:50:128 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 你在这里是这么下节奏的,那么一模一样的节奏就最好按照之前的方法下

01:53:696 (1,2) - 这里这么安静的 vocal,没有鼓点或者任何其他背景音乐,为什么突然来了两个 clap的音效,音量还这么大的?

01:54:182 (1) - 这个 clap也是毫无来由,相反 01:54:507 (3) - 这个地方不用 finish却什么都不加

02:14:128 (1) - 转盘尾加 finish音效

02:36:344 (2) - 更应该出现在 02:36:182 - 这个地方

02:45:750 (1,2) - 这里的 vocal屙非常舒缓的,所以不建议用这么快的滑条速度

02:57:263 (3,4) - 这两个滑条完全没有必要折返,因为 02:57:588 - 02:58:236 - 什么都没有,而且我觉得这两个滑条改成两个单独的circle会比较好一点,因为02:57:263 - 02:57:426 - 02:57:912 - 02:58:074 - 都是很清晰的 vocal

02:59:372 (6) - 这里我觉得又需要跟住 vocal,因为 vocal非常明显,滑条不需要折返,在02:59:858 - 03:00:020 - 加 circle

03:00:669 (3) - 折返回去之后紧接着又要返回来去接 03:01:155 (4) - 可能不太好

03:06:182 (1,1) - 这几个鼓点根本没跟对,03:06:020 - 03:06:101 - 03:06:182 - 是一组,03:06:344 - 03:06:426 - 03:06:507 - 是另外一组,但是图里的话看上去就像是随手拉了个折返滑条,对节奏完全不管不顾

03:07:155 (2) - kiai 开始加上finish音效,理应用 NC,kiai开始的时候最好都用 NC

03:12:344 (3,3) - 没有必要用1/4的折返滑条,因为 vocal里没有1/4

03:27:101 (1) - 同理,这里也没必要用1/4的折返滑条,因为 vocal里也没有1/4,而且我觉得也应该降低一些音量

03:27:912 (5) - NC,因为比较强的 finish音效

03:36:182 (2) - 只需要折返一次,因为根据音乐来看的话,03:36:426 - 是没有必要用1/4下note的,所以需要在 03:36:507 - 补一个note

03:37:804 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - Hard里出现这么多的连打还是不太好的,何况还是比较高的185BPM

03:41:534 (1,2) - 没必要用1/4

03:48:182 - 03:48:507 - 建议补上 note

03:48:993 (1) - 转盘可以在 03:53:858 - 结束,并且结尾降低音量到10%左右

槽点太多,Hard做的远远比不上Insane,GL
Topic Starter
jogfi2002

Kyle Y wrote:

hi, M4M here

here is my modding, I am also new, and DO NOT EXPECT TOO MUCH from me.


[Easy]
I prefer a Easy with long slider.
Tell you one thing, you can use 1/2 to map, but the spacing need 1 beat.
and I prefer to follow vocal

just like...
00:00:345 - Sorry I'm not going to put anything outside white ticks in an Easy

00:07:480 -

00:10:723 -

00:19:480 - missing Intended to make blank here
00:17:858 (1) - del nc It's far from the previous slider and another word starts here, so I NCed.

00:27:588 (3) - circle, and circle at 00:28:236 - Nice, fixed.
00:28:885 (1,2,3,4,5) - too much circle use slider instead I think it's fine though
00:36:020 - 2 beat slider I just want to emphasize the lyrics 「ひとつ、ふたつ」here.
00:37:641 (2,3) - del and add a slider on 00:37:966 -
00:38:290 - missing
00:43:155 (2) - blanket with 00:44:453 (1) - Fixed.
00:49:642 (2) - 2beat slider Yes it is a 2 beat slider.
----------break time------------
01:02:939 - try this Could be too much

01:12:669 (1) - del Nope
01:11:047 (3) - 1.5 beat No half in an Easy as I said
01:21:101 (3) - better not to use 1/2 reverse slider, use long slider instead
01:23:372 (1) - blanket
01:27:263 (2) - I think too cruve Fixed.

01:28:561 (1,2,3,4,5) - too much circle, use slider
01:31:155 (2) - use red dots...

01:33:101 (1,2) - del or slider Why?
01:35:047 (1) - start at 01:34:885 - No half
01:43:480 (1,2) - slider Nope
01:44:128 (3) - better blanket
01:44:128 (3,4) - use same slider, (3) rotate 180 to form (4) and blanket each other
01:46:723 (1) - 2 beat slider
01:51:912 (1) - blanket
---------break-----------
02:08:777 (1,2,3,4,5) - same too much circle Fixed.
02:11:696 (2,3) - slider
02:12:669 (1,2) - use same slider, (1) rotate 180 to form (2) and blanket each other
02:46:399 - 無論如何都是覺得這個應該才是break,02:45:101 (7) - 這個是進入break 前最後一個notes, 到02:56:777 -
反而這個break 02:15:263 - 不太適合
If you really wait to keep it, then I think you need to use very long slider, as this part... music is calm and circle is not quite suitable
I just skip this part, if you keep it as final decision, then call me and I will mod for you with no kuds
---------break (I think)---------
02:56:777 - try this (circle at 03:05:858 - cannot be shown in the picture below) I used this pattern in Insane but not Easy

Notice: 1/2 slider can be use, but not quite common in Easy. Just decide by you is okay.

For the kiai part, it is more or less the same with the 2 kiai time before, then I do not repeatly mod it.

Jump to 03:27:912 -
03:31:804 (4) - also 2 beat slider
03:34:399 (1,2,3) - ^
03:43:480 (1) - ^
03:47:372 (4) - extent to 03:48:669 -

[Starry Night]
00:01:480 - missing notes,
00:01:642 (4) - 1/2 beat slider
00:02:453 (6,7) - seperate and (7) change to slider
00:04:885 (2,3) - seperate
00:08:777 - you skipped this Skipped?
00:18:182 (3,4) - flowing not quite good
00:18:831 (5,6) - sorry I really hate straight to my own aspect, you can keep it, or try this Fixed.

00:19:480 (8,9) - flowing, of course you can do this:

00:21:426 (2,3) - same, hate straight line...
00:22:723 (7,8) - ^
00:24:993 - SV should change at 00:26:290 - but not here
00:28:236 (1,2) - I think both of them are 1/2 beat slider Good point, fixed.
00:30:344 (7) - I will del it as my mapping style
00:30:831 (1,2) - I will del or use slider with SV x0.5 It's not good to slow down after a quick stream.
00:40:804 - add circle, if you think bgm at 00:40:642 (4) - is 1/4 sound. then 00:40:804 - should be also No sound here to my ears.
00:42:831 (4,5,6) - (6) not well look, use red dots, and try this

00:47:047 (7,8) - flowing

00:48:993 (3,4) - flowing
00:51:588 (3,1) - blanket fixed
---------break---------
00:52:236 - not a good place for break
-------break-------
01:03:588 (2,3,4) - seperate it
01:11:209 (5,6,7) - ^
01:12:263 - 01:12:588 - I can't hear 1/4 sound fixed
01:15:750 (1,2,3,4,5) - not a good pattern, use maybe hexagon to tackle it (01:16:561 (6) - count also)
01:22:236 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - flowing for (3)->(1)
01:30:344 (5) - if you add here, then why not 01:29:047 - 01:29:372 - 01:29:696 - Emphasizing lyrics here
suggestion: del it and 01:28:885 (1,2,3,4,1) - form a regular star shape
01:37:642 (3,4) - flowing Changed to slider
01:39:588 (1,2,3) - too curve
01:42:993 (1,2) - jumping please
01:48:426 - no 1/4 sound here, then 01:48:344 (4,1) - combine Nice, fixed
01:51:912 (4,5) - 01:52:399 (5,6) - both are bad flow
------------break------------
02:37:642 (7) - seperate
02:37:966 (1) - circle and 02:38:290 - slider here
02:43:804 - SV should be reture to 1.00 Nice, fixed
02:45:750 - break problem same as EZ, just decide by you.
02:58:074 (1,2,3,4) - 這個pattern 我被2個BN 說過... 說poor flow
02:59:047 (4,5) - bad flow
03:00:020 (7) - cancel reverse, add circle at 03:00:344 - Nice, fixed
03:01:317 (4) - no 1/4 sound again, but 03:01:236 - here have fixed
03:07:155 (7,1) - too far, and poor flow
03:14:290 (5) - 03:14:453 - sound skipped Actually, sliders have tick sounds
03:15:101 - 03:15:750 - ^
03:17:452 (4,5) - not good as the slider 5 is too curve
03:18:182 (8) - below

03:23:696 (9,10,1,2,3) - try this

03:25:155 (2,3) - poor flow
03:25:642 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - should be constant in ds, as this music neither heavier the beap, nor beat is not extremely high in the 2nd circle
03:31:155 (1,2,3) - blanket
03:33:101 (3) - skipped a lot of beats
03:37:155 (1) - move out of the stream
03:48:506 (2,1) - flowing, and slider is too curve

btw, still have some nc problem. Use this pattern:
nc on the heavy beat, normally big tick, not for the vocal
when you are emphasis the pattern, like square, star etc.
SV change

最後還是感謝你花那麼多時間看了一篇完全沒用的modding
還有感謝你mod 我的圖
非常感谢你详细的MOD,虽然有取有舍,仍然得到很多启发。
以后有机会再M4M吧

T-Mac wrote:

M4M

[Hard]

OD7对于这个难度的 Hard来说可能有点高了,建议还是改成 OD6或者 OD6.5 已修改。

全程50%的音量肯定是不对的,而且从头到尾只有S:C1,除了soft-hitnormal之外几乎没有别的音效了,所以这个肯定要改过

Slider Tick Rate可以考虑改成1,2的话没有太大必要 已修改。

00:17:047 - 感觉这里似乎是漏音了 这里我是想跟着比较明显的那个重拍来放,图也才刚刚开始是不是?

00:21:101 (1) - 这里一段我觉得应该降低一些滑条的速度,因为节奏是比较舒缓的,而且和后面的 kiai段用同样的滑条速度这显然不太好 REMAP的时候改

00:30:831 (1) - 这个敌方不太有必要用折返滑条,因为只有 00:30:831 - 00:31:155 - 这两个地方是有vocal的,其中后面一个还应该加点鼓声,但是你这样的话根本体现不出来这种节奏,00:31:317 - 这个地方是没有必要有任何东西的,但是你却把折返滑条拉到了这个时间点,这肯定是不对的,如果换成我的话我应该会把他直接做成一个1/1的滑条,然后降速并且用新的 NC REMAP的时候改

00:31:480 (2) - 这里用 NC吧,因为 kiai段开始了加上你在这里放了finish的音效,所以非常有必要的 已修改。

00:34:074 (4) - 这个折返滑条折返一次就够了,没必要有第二次,因为 00:34:074 - 00:34:399 - 00:34:723 - 是有 vocal的,这时候需要滑条折返,但是00:35:047 - 这个地方是没有的,只有一个鼓声,所以需要把他独立开,用一个单独的 note来体现这个鼓声 已修改。

00:39:101 (4) - 这地方的三连没有什么必要,因为没有任何的 vocal或者鼓声是需要三连来体现的 已修改。

00:50:128 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 这里我建议每个note都可以用新的 NC,或者每两个一个新 NC也行,并且音量逐个加大,这样更符合鼓点 非常好的建议,已修改。

00:51:426 (1) - 滑条开头放在这里的话,滑条头再用这么大的音量就会感觉有点突兀,事实上我觉得 00:51:426 (1,2) - 这两个都应该减少音量,因为鼓点在00:50:939 (6) - 的时候就已经结束了,到了00:51:912 (3) - 这里才重新开始,这之间的这段时间里面,只有比较安静的 vocal 已修改。

01:02:615 - 这么一个明显的 finish直接漏掉了这肯定是不行的,只跟 vocal是肯定站不住脚的 已添加

01:12:020 (1,2,3) - 鼓点很明显在 01:12:182 - 01:12:507 - 01:12:831 - 这里 这里我是觉得跟那三个鼓点很怪,跟前面衔接不好。

01:33:750 (2) - 同理,kiai 开始加上finish音效,理应用 NC 已修改。

01:38:290 (1,2,3) - 这两个1/4滑条来的有点莫名其妙,而且我觉得应该用 01:39:588 (1) - 类似这个的折返滑条,因为本身 vocal相近 已修改。

01:52:723 - 这地方肯定要有 note的啊,鼓点没断,这么弄反而让人搞不懂了,而且 00:50:128 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 你在这里是这么下节奏的,那么一模一样的节奏就最好按照之前的方法下

01:53:696 (1,2) - 这里这么安静的 vocal,没有鼓点或者任何其他背景音乐,为什么突然来了两个 clap的音效,音量还这么大的? 已修改。

01:54:182 (1) - 这个 clap也是毫无来由,相反 01:54:507 (3) - 这个地方不用 finish却什么都不加 已修改。

02:14:128 (1) - 转盘尾加 finish音效 已修改。

02:36:344 (2) - 更应该出现在 02:36:182 - 这个地方 已修改。

02:45:750 (1,2) - 这里的 vocal屙非常舒缓的,所以不建议用这么快的滑条速度 已修改。

02:57:263 (3,4) - 这两个滑条完全没有必要折返,因为 02:57:588 - 02:58:236 - 什么都没有,而且我觉得这两个滑条改成两个单独的circle会比较好一点,因为02:57:263 - 02:57:426 - 02:57:912 - 02:58:074 - 都是很清晰的 vocal 已修改。

02:59:372 (6) - 这里我觉得又需要跟住 vocal,因为 vocal非常明显,滑条不需要折返,在02:59:858 - 03:00:020 - 加 circle 已修改。

03:00:669 (3) - 折返回去之后紧接着又要返回来去接 03:01:155 (4) - 可能不太好

03:06:182 (1,1) - 这几个鼓点根本没跟对,03:06:020 - 03:06:101 - 03:06:182 - 是一组,03:06:344 - 03:06:426 - 03:06:507 - 是另外一组,但是图里的话看上去就像是随手拉了个折返滑条,对节奏完全不管不顾 确实是没做对,已修改

03:07:155 (2) - kiai 开始加上finish音效,理应用 NC,kiai开始的时候最好都用 NC

03:12:344 (3,3) - 没有必要用1/4的折返滑条,因为 vocal里没有1/4 已修改。

03:27:101 (1) - 同理,这里也没必要用1/4的折返滑条,因为 vocal里也没有1/4,而且我觉得也应该降低一些音量 已修改。

03:27:912 (5) - NC,因为比较强的 finish音效 已修改。

03:36:182 (2) - 只需要折返一次,因为根据音乐来看的话,03:36:426 - 是没有必要用1/4下note的,所以需要在 03:36:507 - 补一个note 已修改。

03:37:804 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - Hard里出现这么多的连打还是不太好的,何况还是比较高的185BPM 已修改。

03:41:534 (1,2) - 没必要用1/4 已修改。

03:48:182 - 03:48:507 - 建议补上 note 已修改。

03:48:993 (1) - 转盘可以在 03:53:858 - 结束,并且结尾降低音量到10%左右 所有难度都已改。

槽点太多,Hard做的远远比不上Insane,GL
大感谢!你的MOD太有用了~
Hard我准备再remap一次
Garven
[General]
Your new combo use feels sloppy and unintuitive. I recommend you keep it more structured by adding a new combo every measure or two.
Please use a different BG that isn't flashing someone's underwear.

[Easy]
There's almost no hitsounding here. It's really boring to listen to. :( Spruce it up a bit!
01:28:561 (1,2,3,4,5) - Why all circles during a really quiet part? Feels odd to spike the difficulty like this.
01:46:723 (1) - Don't use short repeat sliders with more than on repeat like this. It's going to be very confusing as to when the slider is going to end for new players.
02:33:426 (1,2) - I'm not quite sure what you're mapping to with these sliders.
03:24:020 (1) - End isn't snapped correctly
03:48:993 (1) - You should fade the volume out on this spinner

I think I'll just stop at the easy for now. In general it felt very free-form with little attention paid towards making memorable patterns or flow. Try to make the map more interesting!

Good luck!
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply