Armin wrote:

WHY IS THIS IN THE GRAVEYARD D:

Armin wrote:

ErufenRito, where is your Hard. That was funny to play. :<
Anyway if you want I can make a Normal/Easy for you.
Kudosu starx2

Blue Dragon wrote:

Easy
01:16:036 (2) - remove clap, add whistle
01:17:882 (4) - remove clap, add finish
01:53:574 (3,4) - put in the "center line"?
01:55:420 (7,8) - ^
Okay

Normal
Circle size -1, please, too small x.x

01:06:805 (1) - put in the center line? I dont see why... As far as i remmeber, it tried to make a triangle with 01:04:036 (1,2,3), or i dont know... i dont remmeber...

Hard
00:23:420 (6) - add finish on start? Okay
01:59:420 (1,2,1,1,1,1) - seriously, this part is bad x.x I like it >_>

Mukku
<3

Good map, starred.

Garven wrote:

As per Armin's mod4mod request:

[Easy]
At first glance, all I see are two tiny slivers of breaks. >> I guess they're long enough, though.
Wow, that first part is really boring. Try to spruce it up a bit, please~ No thank you.
00:30:805 (1) - This combo runs pretty long. Split it up. Next time, instead of saying this, suggest exactly where the new combo.
00:36:036 (6,7,8,9,1) - Kinda iffy on an easy, but kinda okay. I dunno, heh.
00:47:113 (1) - The combo changes here feel kind of excessive. Maybe remove every other one? Fine...
00:57:574 (1,1) - Okay, this... yeah. Try mapping something else. The 1 after the slider may be hard to notice coming, and it may not be that intuitive as to when that slider is going to stop. Hmm... will wait for more opinions.
01:22:497 (1) - Super-long combo here. Splitted.
01:26:497 (4,5,6,7,8,9) - This bit here almost feels like something that would go in a Normal. Will wait for more opinions.
01:38:805 (1) - Really long combo again. Splitted
01:44:959 (1,1) - Okay, these really don't fit the song at all. Maybe for you, but for me it fits perfectly. Or give a reason why you think that.
01:59:728 (1,1) - ^
02:04:036 (1,2,3,1,2) - Spacing? Maybe find a better shape to form like a pentagon? Im sure they are okay.
02:10:190 (1,1) - Those spinners again. >>
Yeah, just keep an eye out for really long combos.

[Normal]
Kind of a dull beginning again with the long repeating sliders. Oh well.. i guess im an awful mapper then.
00:08:036 (2,3,4) - Lower these one grid. Ops... ahaha
Keep an eye out for really long combos in this difficulty too.
00:28:959 (10,1) - Waaay too close. Okay x:
I'll just say that I don't like the double spinners at all.
01:28:651 (5,1) - Rather close again. Okay x:
01:44:651 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - This might be pushing it for a Normal difficulty. :/ I guess ill wait for more opinions xD
01:57:574 (1) - Accelerated spacing in a Normal? :/ Yeah why not?
02:04:036 (1,2,3,1,2) - Kinda boring.

[Hard]
00:42:190 (6,7) - Maybe reform slider so there's less overlap? Eh.. its okay for me..
00:49:267 (1,2,3,4) - Whenever this comes up, I lose a bit of health for getting all 300's. Make a new combo at 3 or something, please. Its okay for me...
01:59:420 (1,2,1,1,1,1) - Really? Ya rly.

[Mukku's Monogata Hard]
00:58:489 (1,2,3) - Even up the spacing amongst these.
01:02:182 (1,2) - Was kinda weird to hear this rhythm suddenly.
01:57:566 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Wow, uh, that accelerated spacing went a bit far, don't you think? Maybe lessen it a bit?

These ill ask mukku soon xD

The main diffs could use some work, but they're not bad considering the type of song you're working with. And there you go.

Garven wrote:

As per Armin's mod4mod request:

[Mukku's Monogata Hard]
00:58:489 (1,2,3) - Even up the spacing amongst these. Fixed
01:02:182 (1,2) - Was kinda weird to hear this rhythm suddenly. I know but I hope its not a bad thing necessarily :D
01:57:566 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Wow, uh, that accelerated spacing went a bit far, don't you think? Maybe lessen it a bit? I guess you're right. 6 is pretty darn far. Moved 6, 5, 4 closer to each other.

roflninja wrote:

Hi,
might just be me, but the timing feels wierd Hmm... you are right, This map was made long time ago, and my timing abilities definitely is lame. Although now it has a new offset made by me, i would like a new opinion... Oh btw Mukku, i changed the timing in your difficulty too, hope you dont mind

[easy]
try to cut some repeats on the sliders, to many may be hard for newer players >__>
01:00:343 (1) - hidden and a bit hard for a easy imo Changed a bit
01:44:959 (1,1) - make these one spinner? Okay
01:49:267 (1,2,3) - maybe do something like this? Nah, i like them stacked.
01:59:728 (1,1) - make these one spinner? Okay
02:10:190 (1,1) - ^ This one, ill have to say no.
02:15:113 - imo, i wouldnt stack these, it may be a bit hard for new players, and arent they a little close? Now having stacked and low distance snapped object is hard? >_> Its not like new players knows the definition of distance space...

[normal]
01:42:805 (6,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - bah, so close/kinda in the hp bar Hmm... but they are not overlapping with it, so i dont see any problems with it (except for 01:44:651 (1), but im sure that it is okay...

[hard]
increase the note size by one? Nah, unless you give me a very good reason for it.

[mukku]
00:17:874 (2,3,4) - bah, this spacing :|
00:20:643 (5) - why the jump?
00:56:643 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - :| why not use constant spacing? this just seems wierd to me
01:39:105 (1,1,1,1) - all one combo?
Ill tell him soon... if i dont forget again...

pandabun wrote:

Please remove all normal hitsounds, thank you. Nowhere in this song do I find them fitting in this song. Honestly, in my opinion, there should only be whistles, and maybe a few finishes here and there, but the claps are alright and don't bother me as much.
Hmm... I could swear that they fits to those more low pitched notes. Oh well, will wait for more opinions


Easy:

For those few timing sections at the end, you forgot to inherit them. :P Ops :x

roflninja wrote:

[mukku]
00:17:874 (2,3,4) - bah, this spacing :| No ;<
00:20:643 (5) - why the jump? Becouse I felt like it.
00:56:643 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - :| why not use constant spacing? this just seems wierd to me Becouse I like a no-reason-variation in every other second of the map to keep it interesting.
01:39:105 (1,1,1,1) - all one combo? No, I think it is more interesting this way. Both in tag and by colors. It would also result in a 3,5 second combo while the others are around 1-2 seconds.

Takuma wrote:

Please remove all normal hitsounds, thank you. Nowhere in this song do I find them fitting in this song. Honestly, in my opinion, there should only be whistles, and maybe a few finishes here and there, but the claps are alright and don't bother me as much.

Zetsubou Sensei wrote:

Hey.

- Remove the Countdown

[Easy]
Circle Size: -1 Okay
00:14:511 - remove this break (or extend it longer) Okay too i suppose.
00:27:434 (1) - remove the clap color=#0040FF]Okay[/color]
00:47:127 (1) - remove new combo Id rather keep it like this
00:49:281 (8) - add new combo
00:50:204 (1) - remove new combo
00:50:819 (1) - ^
01:00:357 (1) - ^
Id rather keep them like this
01:13:588 - remove this breakOkay
01:59:434 (1) - remove new combo Nah

[Normal]
00:14:511 - remove this break (or extend it)
01:06:819 (1) - remove new combo Nah
01:13:588 - remove this break (or extend it...)
01:51:127 (1) - remove new combo Nah

[Hard]
Circle Size: -2 No thank you, unless a full explanation of why, and providing lots of reasoning on why it is better
01:51:127 (1) - remove new combo Nah
01:58:819 (5,6) - these have different spacing than 3 & 4 Full on purpose, in fact, the whole combo doesnt have same DS.
This difficulty just has some uneven spacing between certain notes (to lazy to list them xD) ...But just look out for them Im pretty sure they were done on purpose by me...

[Mukku's Hard]
01:00:357 (1) - fix this slider and make it straight Mukku gave me permission to do it.


~STAR

NatsumeRin wrote:

Red: You must fix this.
Blue: You'd better do sth with this imo.
Green: Just suggestions.

[General]
this is a 3/4 song... change the timing signature plz... Done, although something strange is that my normal was already in 3/4, maybe i did notice it but forgot to change it xD
offset:-10 Okay. Also mukku, i took the liberty to change offset and timing signature for now.
Audio Lead-in time in [Normal] is 2011ms, different from other diffs (2007), tiny problem but want you to fix. also preview time is at a strange point... is it your offset before? don't forget to reset preview points after changed timing.About the audio lead in, i guess its just a small problem caused by using the bar. And preview time, changed its place, Also, may i wonder why the need of resetting preview point if timing was changed?

[Easy]
00:21:588 (4,1,2) - different spacing? Constant spacing now.
00:49:281 (6,1) - switch new combo. Hmm... Okay
02:07:742 (2,1) - spacing ... too close. Don't really see anything wrong with it...

[Normal]
00:21:588 (2) - emm... consider about the rhythm... maybe reduce repeat once and use a circle there instead? Don't really see what you're what i'm trying to consider.
00:50:204 (1,2,3) - don't think stack them is a good idea... change a way of placing? I do think it's a good idea.
01:06:819 (1) - remove new combo. Fine..
01:29:896 (1,1) - a nice part here, but the spacing..? maybe 1.5x or less, now i guess it's hard for a [Normal] diff. Okay... Lol, never knew it was 2.0x xD
01:45:588 (4) - new combo for reading. Having too many new combos is way more confusing to read imo.
02:04:050 (1,2,3,1,2) - don't think hold the mouse at the same place for 5s is a good thing. Why not?

[Hard]
it's... orz... i don't know how to describe, wow small hitcircle, it's not popular any more... maybe consider change it? Well... There's the mukku version if people wants to play bigger circles... Sighs... size its all that matters in these days... :(
HP-1/-2, too high for now. May consider it in the future.
00:27:434 (6) - a new combo here? Okay
01:29:896 (1,2,3) - no. i don't think players will read it correctly first time. There's always a second time.
01:31:742 (5,6,7) - ……^, and same for next combos.
diff is nice but one thing... all triples are at the same place.... means same beats for the whole song, feel bored .... sigh. I know... I just couldn't help it, Anyways, i tried to put lots of different patterns here... so it wouldn't be so noticeable.

[Mukku's Hard]
01:21:588 (4) - i prefer if you could set it at 5's place (means a jump)... and the next (1) stack on (2), have a try?
01:28:665 (3) - 1 grid left if nazi...
02:23:434 (1...) - these combos... make the spacing farther between every 4 notes to make a fade out effect?

NatsumeRin wrote:

Red: You must fix this.
Blue: You'd better do sth with this imo.
Green: Just suggestions.


[Mukku's Hard]
01:21:588 (4) - i prefer if you could set it at 5's place (means a jump)... and the next (1) stack on (2), have a try? Oh.. Good idea. Fixed :o
01:28:665 (3) - 1 grid left if nazi... Fixed
02:23:434 (1...) - these combos... make the spacing farther between every 4 notes to make a fade out effect? I did not think of that.. VERY nice, added.

James2250 wrote:

Really small circles on Hard and longggg repeating sliders on Easy and Normal makes me sad (and the sliders are just uncreative in general)

Other things I could comment on like AR/OD/HP is too high for Easy etc

But seeing as it has pretty much all been mentioned before and you refused to fix it I am not going to pop now~ Will just see what next modder says

Shinxyn wrote:

Old map o-o~

Hard:
Source: Game
of course, tags are different too
Seems like this diff is the old one
All my 3 diffculties are the old ones, the fact that i forgot to change that, is another issue. Ahaha.


Easy-
01:39:117 (2) - I have no problems seeing this, but it would be nice if you didn't block the repeat at all... no need to change this though Did an horizontal flip.

Would prefer the volume drop at the end be handled better (add more panels while gradually decreasing volume instead of volume drops quickly?) (also Hard doesn't have the timing panel before notes) Modified the timing panels thing in hard, and also, the volume drops by 1 tick


Also, maybe just remove 02:28:963 (1) on all diffs... >_> Done on my difficulties, will have to wait for mukku to do this, and possibly the volume change... hmm..

Should I force pop...? nah, you can do it~ >:D

abalee wrote:

I guess the best BPM is 65 or 130 @ 4/4 ?

NatsumeRin wrote:

[General]
this is a 3/4 song... change the timing signature plz...