Well, here goes...
forum
Masato Nakamura - Staff Credits
posted
Total Posts
33
Topic Starter
Nice beatmap, good to see that you're pretty consistent with beat spacing, and also you've had a go at making some nice looking sliders and utilising both sound sets! There is a bit of a problem with sliders that have the end overlap the start, such as at 00:26:28, 01:05:33 (although it's nice looking) and 01:49:36. The last one isn't so important because the hit radius for the slider is ample enough for it to cover both directions, but the others would probably cause a miss if they weren't familiar with your beatmap. Unfortunately, this means redoing your star. I suggest that you start the slider at the centre of the star on the bottom part, and slightly to the left or right, and then finish on the other side, if you understand what I'm saying. Otherwise, this looks really good. Maybe you might want someone else to check the timing though, I just can't put my finger on why it sounds off. *starred*
Topic Starter
I thought these overlapping start and end points on the sliders might be unfair, but in the end I reasoned there was a 50/50 chance of getting the direction right the first time and after that the player would know where to slide. Still, I understand it can be pretty frustrating.
So, I made the slider at 26:28 a bit larger to distinguish between start and finish, but in order for the previous beat to be centered inside the slider I had to ignore automatic Beat Spacing...just a smidge. The star at 1:05:33 proved to be a much more difficult case, since I found it impossible to keep the two previous beats at correct spacing and still not fall on the slider's path, which ruined its look for me. In the end, I deleted those two beats. I left the final, tiny slider unchanged - initially I wanted a blue circular slider to represent a balled-up Sonic, but the time alotted isn't sufficient to make a big enough shape, so in the end I settled for a small gold ring
About the timing, that was why I submitted the map in Beatmap Help at first; I could tell something wasn't exactly right at some places (for example approximately before the first break and before the last break), but when I tinkered with it, other places would mess up. Perhaps someone else can solve this issue.
EDIT: By the way, I can't see a star by this thread's title at the board...
EDIT 2: Thanks
So, I made the slider at 26:28 a bit larger to distinguish between start and finish, but in order for the previous beat to be centered inside the slider I had to ignore automatic Beat Spacing...just a smidge. The star at 1:05:33 proved to be a much more difficult case, since I found it impossible to keep the two previous beats at correct spacing and still not fall on the slider's path, which ruined its look for me. In the end, I deleted those two beats. I left the final, tiny slider unchanged - initially I wanted a blue circular slider to represent a balled-up Sonic, but the time alotted isn't sufficient to make a big enough shape, so in the end I settled for a small gold ring
About the timing, that was why I submitted the map in Beatmap Help at first; I could tell something wasn't exactly right at some places (for example approximately before the first break and before the last break), but when I tinkered with it, other places would mess up. Perhaps someone else can solve this issue.
EDIT: By the way, I can't see a star by this thread's title at the board...
EDIT 2: Thanks
Whoah, sorry bout not putting up that star, I'm getting sloppy at this modding stuff!
I tried to do the timing, but I'm not sure if I'm any better than you are. Here's my attempt, which is mostly your own timing
00:01:74 146.75
00:34:41 139.84
00:57:13 139.22
01:12:18 134.91
01:26:40 128.00
01:30:15 100.00
01:39:75 112.33
I think you should get someone like Rolled or Peppy to time this, I can probably bug them to get this one done. Very timely on the update btw!
I tried to do the timing, but I'm not sure if I'm any better than you are. Here's my attempt, which is mostly your own timing
00:01:74 146.75
00:34:41 139.84
00:57:13 139.22
01:12:18 134.91
01:26:40 128.00
01:30:15 100.00
01:39:75 112.33
I think you should get someone like Rolled or Peppy to time this, I can probably bug them to get this one done. Very timely on the update btw!
Topic Starter
I think 34:41 might be a bit early for the offset, but the rest seems to work well, thanks! I suppose I'll wait for a second opinion before changing any settings. Such slight changes in bpm are rather difficult for me to nail down perfectly.
Chan's timings are spot on as far as I can see. As for 34410 - its about 6ms early if anything 
. So leave as is in my opinion!
Ganbare ;d
. So leave as is in my opinion!Ganbare ;d
Topic Starter
Timing sections have been tweaked as suggested.
Also, I gotta ask... what does ;d stand for? Is it a wink and a tongue trying to touch one's nose? A wink and a cookie held in one's mouth (like peppy's avatar?) Inquiring minds would like to know.
Also, I gotta ask... what does ;d stand for? Is it a wink and a tongue trying to touch one's nose? A wink and a cookie held in one's mouth (like peppy's avatar?) Inquiring minds would like to know.
Topic Starter
Um...I hope this is not a breach of board etiquette, but it's been ten days since I updated this beatmap based on mod suggestions, so I was wondering if there was anything else I needed to improve here?
For future reference, if I have implemented all current mod suggestions in a beatmap, is there a period of inactivity in its thread after which it is considered "ok" for me to bump it? Or should I stay put, even if the thread slides to the 3rd page and beyond, seemingly forgotten?
For future reference, if I have implemented all current mod suggestions in a beatmap, is there a period of inactivity in its thread after which it is considered "ok" for me to bump it? Or should I stay put, even if the thread slides to the 3rd page and beyond, seemingly forgotten?
mtmcl
Hey sorry I didn't look at this earlier but I've had a little break from osu! and generally anything internet related.
Everything looks pretty much good, except for the following:
01:14:74 - This note should be spaced a bit further from (1), like the previous combo at 01:12:63, it's more distance/beat space intuitive
Otherwise this is pretty close for ranking, though maybe you might want to do another difficulty. I'm impartial on this since it's not a particularly difficult beatmap, but I'll wait on the opinions of other mods/players.
Re-starred
Everything looks pretty much good, except for the following:
01:14:74 - This note should be spaced a bit further from (1), like the previous combo at 01:12:63, it's more distance/beat space intuitive
Otherwise this is pretty close for ranking, though maybe you might want to do another difficulty. I'm impartial on this since it's not a particularly difficult beatmap, but I'll wait on the opinions of other mods/players.
Re-starred
Topic Starter
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
mtmcl
Topic Starter
Ok, I'll work on an easier version as well, then.
UPDATE: Easier version has been uploaded!
UPDATE: Easier version has been uploaded!
mtmcl
EDIT: Easy mode is great. The map is great. But it has come to my attention that the initial offset is late (like in EVERY map). Try 1690. Listen to it in .25x and you'll see what I mean. Be sure to resnap. Fix this and I'm bubbling. Go ahead and double check the other offsets at .25x if you will. I'm sure you'll be able to safely judge any differences.
Topic Starter
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Nice work Sinistro, easy will work for a lot of beginners although normal isn't that difficult. I'd be happy to see this ranked.
Great work on this one, with some nice touches. The loop-the-loop slider made me LOL! The easy version is also a good example of a nicely designed lower-difficulty map. A couple of minor fixes before this gets ranked:
- Easy at 1:10.48 - that beat is incorrectly beat spaced (too close to previous beats), move it to the right a bit.
- Easy at 1:34.80 - long blue slider has incorrect length (notice the tick very close to the end - that shouldn't be there).
Topic Starter
Ah, now I know what was bugging me about that slider! I didn't know one could use the ticks as a clue. Well, the two fixes have been made.
Fun map. Difficult with those sudden time-changes, though that adds to the fun.
Difficult with those sudden time-changes, though that adds to the fun.I can't download this map %) Only this map from the server. Why?
thread link is broken. try the download button here http://osu.ppy.sh/index.php?p=song&s=688kperep wrote:
I can't download this map %) Only this map from the server. Why?
There seems to be a problem with that for me, whenever Osu tries to open the file, it fails and goes to any of my other songs.LuigiHann wrote:
thread link is broken. try the download button here http://osu.ppy.sh/index.php?p=song&s=688kperep wrote:
I can't download this map %) Only this map from the server. Why?
Is that a problem with my Osu, or the file?
hey..i think theres a big problem here..
the song title is Masato Nakamura - Staff Credits not Sonic the Hedgehog-Staff Credits
fix the problem with the song Masato Nakamura - Staff Credits, this is the only song i can't play in OSU to unlock the Video Game Pack vol.1 achievement. Fast Response!!!
the song title is Masato Nakamura - Staff Credits not Sonic the Hedgehog-Staff Credits
fix the problem with the song Masato Nakamura - Staff Credits, this is the only song i can't play in OSU to unlock the Video Game Pack vol.1 achievement. Fast Response!!!
Actually, the thread title is named that. The Beatmap Listing is marked as Masato Nakamura. There's no real effect to changing it or not.rhezimhain wrote:
hey..i think theres a big problem here..
the song title is Masato Nakamura - Staff Credits not Sonic the Hedgehog-Staff Credits
fix the problem with the song Masato Nakamura - Staff Credits, this is the only song i can't play in OSU to unlock the Video Game Pack vol.1 achievement. Fast Response!!!
Adding a Heart to this thread.
If you really want to get the achievement that bad, download the song from a Beatmap Pack.
The download here was broken, (osz contained a 0kb mp3 file and no osu files) so I got the non-broken version (thanks crzynoob) and fixed it. So if you were having trouble before, delete the map and redownload it now, it should work.
I thought that all ranked beatmaps had to have a background?
Things were pretty different 3 years ago you know
Topic Starter
Actually I had one put in (Sonic's title screen) but it disappeared for some reason. After all, I had put a background in my first map, so no reason not to put one in this one too.