GbL wrote:

Blue Dragon wrote:

Please don't give up, GbL! I know it'll be hard to get this ranked now but you still can't give up!

Thanks, but... you can't help me?

I'm probably too busy to mod any maps, but if I manage to clear up my queue soon, I'll get to this x_x but no promises

[quote="Blue Dragon"
I'm probably too busy to mod any maps, but if I manage to clear up my queue soon, I'll get to this x_x but no promises[/quote]

ok

I.. actually wouldn't like this that much if it was mapped today I think but I don't know.. I just get the good old vibes for some reason, so I'll try to help here without going too deep into the style of the map; you could rework curves with the new algorhythm (or just improved beziers) as that'd help quite much at a few parts though.

Considering this map is very old and therefore has a lot of bezier curves, I'd offer my help if you would want these more balanced out or fixed (or generally have any concerns basically), so call me back if you want some of that maybe?
Not going to pick out a lot of curves in specific because of this but I would like to see improvement being done on that because I kind of want to see this ranked, to be honest ._ .



[General]

In every diff, you have a few inherit points that are not snapped to a tick, please change this.


[Easy]

Since this is an Easy, AR4 sounds a bit high - lower to 3, perhaps.

1. 00:19:613 (2) - this spacing is very close to the previous object and having it appear under the slidertrack will be very confusing for new people; try to find a better way to put it
2. 00:22:095 (2) - super evil trap, don't do things like this; it's super unpredictable that this is a slider that goes the exact same path back that you just game, specifically when you're new to the game
3. 00:33:682 (1) - similar to the first suggestion, it doesn't look nice to see this under the slidertrack
4. 00:41:957 (1) - you could make this look way better by using an anchor and an additional bezier point; have an example below
   
   here

   
5. 00:48:578 (2) - ^
6. 00:55:199 (1,2,3,4,5) - having all of this stacked makes it very boring and weird to play, please do something else (a star maybe?)
7. 00:58:509 (6) - new combo here please
8. 01:00:992 (1) - I don't really see what the clap on this hits on so I would suggest removing it; also, I'd probably extend the spinner to 01:08:440, or if you don't want that, at least delay the breaktime until then to give a better transition to the next part of the song
9. 01:29:957 (3) - this goes right through the HP bar and just looks very bad, move it down or reshape it please
10. 01:49:820 (1,2,3,4,5) - same thing as in first kiai time, please unstack these and make some kind of pattern from it
11. 01:53:130 (6) - add new combo
12. 01:55:613 (1) - same thing about this spinner as the one before; remove clap and extend to 02:03:061 or delay the break until then - actually, this is a very long breaktime and I think you should start mapping at 02:16:302 again instead of letting the player wait for over twenty seconds just to play another spinner (that also starts very randomly)
13. 02:33:682 (2) - why is this 0.9x snap? fix to 1.0x please (make an equal triangle with 1 and 3?)
14. 02:46:096 (1,2,3,4) - again, this stack is boring and confusing
15. 02:49:406 (5) - new combo here please
16. 02:59:337 - uhm.. why does the map.. stop.. ?_?

[Normal]

1. 00:14:647 (2) - I personally don't like how you have to go back to where you came from with the cursor here; move to 289|122 or something?
2. 00:17:957 (3) - you have a fair lot of whistles here already, remove this one?
3. 00:22:923 (2) - I'd suggest you use a mirrored version of 1 here for consistency (or the other way around, replace 1 with a mirrored version of this one, your call)
4. 00:24:164 (2,4) - adding whistles here could be nice
5. 00:27:061 - there's so little hitsounding in the part after this, try to get some melody in or something (even a 2/1 whistle would do well with the song)
6. 00:34:509 (1) - I don't understand this NC tbh
7. 00:35:337 (3) - the finish is very sudden here, remove it?
8. 00:49:406 (1) - remove new combo
9. 00:51:061 (1) - ^
10. 00:57:682 (1) - ^
11. 00:59:957 (3) - this is the first time you're using 1/2 in this diff and it comes very sudden, maybe think of a way to make it more natural for beginners; also, why did you stop the kiai here, chorus is still going and the other diffs have it too >:
12. 01:29:957 (5) - well this is just very.. linear.. I don't like it, sorry. I think a curve would do much better
13. 01:42:371 (1,1,1,1,1,1) - returning to the same point over and over again is not very nice here, at least not for me; also, you should delete like, every second new combo in this, probably
14. 01:46:509 (1,2) - please move 2 a bit more away from 1 so they don't have the overlap at the ends
15. 01:48:992 (1) - this is very close to previous 2 considering there's a rather large break in the song; move it further away to prevent early accidental clicks?
16. 01:52:716 (2) - why is this 0.9x snap? fix to 1.0x please
17. 01:59:337 (1) - this finish is very harsh and doesn't fit well, remove it
18. 02:34:095 (1) - no need for this new combo
19. 02:39:888 (1) - ^
20. 02:42:371 (1) - ^
21. 02:44:440 (1) - ^
22. 02:46:095 (1) - ^
23. 02:47:751 (1) - ^
24. 02:49:406 (3) - the overlap with the hitbursts from 1 and 2 is not very nice, try something to reduce this? (or at least make both circles overlap the slider equally)
25. 02:50:647 (1) - no need for this new combo
26. 02:53:751 (1) - overlap with 3 is not nice and hides the reverse arrow
27. 02:59:233 - since you have a gradual increase in volume here and this tick is not used, add a 95% inherit section here?
28. 03:10:716 (1) - this is kind of a jump and it surprised me a fair lot; try to find a way around this? also, I don't think a new combo is needed here
29. 03:11:751 (1,2) - I think this is the only time you stacked something in this diff like this? could be a bit of a trap for newbies
30. 03:22:095 (1) - again the finish at the end sounds too harsh for the section it's in, remove it please

[0_o's Hard]

1. 00:21:061 (3,4,5) - a bit of an overload of finishes here; remove the first two? (or just work with whistles entirely for this combo?)
   
   you could also smoothen 5 out, like this for example

   
2. 00:34:302 (2,3,4) - the tripple finishes again, sounds too harsh to me
3. 00:45:061 (5) - moving the second sliderpoint (like, not counting the start) to 188|344 makes this wave a fair bit more smooth, so please do that
4. 00:50:026 (9) - consider adding a new combo here as this one is getting really long
5. 00:51:682 (12) - wowowowowo that's very few beziers - use like two more and fiddle around a bit, that'll make this way more balanced
6. 00:53:337 (1) - remove new combo
7. 00:56:647 (4) - would suggest you add another sliderpoint here and fiddle a bit to get this smooth
8. 01:04:923 (2) - i'm sure you can make this symmetric
9. 01:06:578 (3) - please place this on the Y-axis
10. 01:21:061 (1,2,3) - man I love those clap introductions
11. 01:21:682 (1) - stack properly with 1-2-3 please
12. 01:26:440 (6) - another wave you could smoothen a fair lot; move the second sliderpoint (again, not counting the start as one) to 252|263, that'll help a fair bit
13. 01:27:475 (7) - similar, move the first one to 488|216?
14. 01:33:061 (6) - this one you can also make a lot better; first point to 182|162, second to 336|235 and end to 256|292 (also stack 7-8-9 on the end properly)
    
    will look like this then

    
15. 01:41:337 (8) - this one is not very balanced either; second point to 161|169 and end to 271|51 will help
16. 02:07:820 (5) - first point to 74|232 will do well here
17. 02:13:406 (3) - would replace this with two circles because the vocals on both the start and end are fairly equal in strength; also I suggest you remove the finish because it's just too sudden
18. 02:37:612 (1) - a new combo for just one object is not so nice, remove it
19. 02:55:819 (2) - well that's a nice waveslider!
20. 02:58:917 (3,4,5,6) - oh my god the finishes (I like them)
21. 03:02:233 (9) - the combo is getting very long again, NC here please
22. 03:04:095 (14) - smoothen this please?
23. 03:08:646 (1) - no need for this new combo
24. 03:15:888 (1) - ^

[Kingcobra's Hard!]

Increase drain by one? It doesn't feel like it'd kill everyone as it is and it'd be nice to have this consistent (or at least not lower) with the other Hard.

1. 00:19:199 (6,7,8) - not exactly pretty; would at least make these not overlap anymore, maybe make them blanket each other
2. 00:21:888 (2,3) - could make a bit of a jump here of sorts to remove the overlap (or at least move it further away so 3's start isn't as glued to 2's slidertrack)
3. 00:24:785 (5) - I don't really understand why there's an achor here
4. 00:25:613 (1,5) - may be picky but I feel like you should arrange this so there's a bit more of distance between those (causes hitburst overlaps)
5. 00:38:854 (1,2,3,4,5) - actually those sliders should start on the white ticks because of the backbeat here which just feels better to have sliderstarts on than ends
6. 00:47:957 (2,4) - I actually would like to see a clap swap here (as in, remove it from 2 and add it on 4's start); the resulting double feels good
   ^if going with this, you may very well add claps on 00:50:026 (4) - (start) and 00:51:475 (7,8) - aswell
7. 00:54:992 (4) - add clap perhaps
8. 00:56:647 (3) - ^
9. 00:57:888 (4,5) - doubleclap makes for a good entrance to the spinner because it gives this uprising feeling
10. 01:01:199 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - give a bit more room between these as to not give them this super narrow feeling (the vocals are quite resonant here, so that'd make sense to do); new algorhythm curves please, the beziers look very unbalanced at this point?
11. 01:19:406 (5) - it's this random anchorpoint slider again!!
12. 01:21:682 (1) - add whistle on end?
13. 01:25:613 (2) - I personally don't enjoy this crumpled slider and the finishes; the song doesn't feature strong beats here
14. 01:28:302 (1) - add whistle on end?
15. 01:29:544 (3) - a little ugly how this overlaps with 2
16. 01:31:406 (3,4,5) - I'd probably replace these with circles because the vocals are fairly equally strong on all these beats and sliders make it so you only play the first one (also, add a finish at 01:31:613 to give like a conclusive feeling to the hitfinish pattern? currently it just drips off into nothingness)
    Kiai is mirrored from the first one so same applies here as before
17. 02:21:268 (1,2,3,4) - these reach a fair bit into the HP bar, please move them down (probably means you will have to move the whole pattern downwards but that should be possible)
18. 02:26:233 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - I could imagine a gradual increase in volume here, would fit well with the whole buildup character for the pre-kiai section
19. 02:51:268 (4) - darn you random anchors, cobra why do you do this to me ;A;
20. 02:52:095 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - this'd be better if each new combo didn't touch the previous one (also, you could redo the curves, hue)
    
    ignore the timestamp and AR mess

    
21. 03:08:026 (5,6) - make this a 90° angle from 4 without gridsnap please
22. 03:12:371 (1) - the overlap of start and end is not very nice here; you could use a new algorhythm-slider to have this done well very easily
23. 03:14:026 (2) - could also use some fiddling; if you want help with those sliders, be welcome to call me back
24. 03:15:888 (3) - using four points (as in, four if you count out the start and end) would make this way smoother, please consider doing that

Well, putting this map for today's standards will be tough work, but I believe we can do this.
Also, adding the bubble pop icon since that didn't exist 4 years ago. And this is technically a popped bubble.

[General]

1. As combo colours estão inconsistentes. Em duas diffs é uma coisa, nas outras duas é outra. Isso não é exatamente unrankeável, mas é altamente recomendado que você deixe igual em todas as diffs.
2. Tira Blue Dragon das tags em todas as diffs (já que não tem mais minha diff). Nesse momento, só o Easy não tem essas tags.
3. Recomendo mudar o Preview Point pra 00:41:130 em todas as diffs.
4. Green sections aren't snapped in any difficulty.

[Easy]

1. 00:17:130 (1) - Seria interessante adicionar um whistle no início desse slider, pra ficar menos vazio e tal
2. 00:19:613 (2) - Eu posicionaria isso num lugar diferente, pq agora tá meio que debaixo do slider e isso não fica legal... Recomendo x:400 y:128.
3. 00:20:440 (1,2) - Acredito que isso seja unrankeável. O slider não pode sair "debaixo" do outro, porque isso não é exatamente legível pra um newbie. Se você quiser manter essa pattern, recomendaria fazer algo assim.
4. 00:22:095 (2) - Whistle no início do slider?
5. 00:27:061 (1) - Um whistle aqui deixaria a pattern mais interessante.
6. 00:28:716 (3) - Aqui também, mesma coisa que ^.
7. 00:30:371 (5) - ^
8. 00:30:371 (5) - New combo nessa nota, pra seguir a lógica dos vocais na música.
9. 00:31:199 (6) - Essa nota tá um espaçada um pouquinho errada, deveria estar em x344 y64.
10. 00:33:682 (1) - De novo, um whistle seria interessante...
11. 00:35:337 (3) - Vou parar de sugerir os whistles, porque acho que já ficou mais ou menos colocada a ideia. Colocar um pouco mais de whistles no mapa pra animar seria bem interessante. Além disso, não curti o finish nesse slider, pra mim ficou meio aleatório com a música...
12. 00:41:957 (1) - Esse clap tá bem aleatório.. um finish aqui ficaria bem melhor. Além disso, quer uma ideia interessante pra deixar esse slider melhor? Adiciona um segundo ponto em x384 y384, pra deixar o slider assim. Ficaria bem melhor e mais bonito.
13. 00:48:578 (2) - Como esse é um copypaste, a mesma coisa se aplica. A diferença é que o ponto novo no slider deveria estar em x128 y384.
14. 00:55:199 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Ultimamente, os mappers não têm costumado stackear notas em Easy diffs. Seria interessante espalhar essas notas (tirando o (4,5,6) ) pra movimentar um pouco o mapa.
15. 00:58:509 (6) - Ao invés de clap, usar whistles pra seguir os vocais ficaria melhor, na minha opinião. Also, um new combo aqui pra seguir os vocais também.
16. 01:00:992 (1) - O spinner deveria começar em 01:01:820 pra seguir os vocais. Não precisa nem diminuir o tamanho dele depois, ele termina melhor em 01:08:440. Mas aí seria legal colocar um finish, ao invés de um clap.
17. 01:24:992 (5) - Seria melhor pro entendimento do mapa colocar a nota em x:416 y:304, ficaria mais lógico pra mim. BTW, pra ficar mais correto com a música, o newcombo deveria estar aqui, ao invés do 01:25:613 (1). Aproveita e tira do 01:27:061 (1) também, não vejo muito sentido naquele newcombo.
18. 01:41:544 (6) - Pra deixar simétrico com o (4), essa nota deveria estar em x:64 y:336.
19. 01:49:820 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Mesma coisa que eu sugeri em 00:55:199 (1,2,3,4,5,6).
20. 01:53:130 (6) - Newcombo aqui.
21. 01:55:613 (1) - Move o spinner pra 01:56:440 e termina ele com um whistle ou finish.
22. 02:16:302 - Já que essa break tá BEM longa, você deveria mapear alguma coisa a partir desse ponto.. Aliás, você deve. Até onde eu sei, breaks muito longas são unrankeáveis e tal >:
23. 02:26:854 (1) - Faria mais sentido com a música se o spinner começasse em 02:27:888 ao invés desse lugar que tu botou.
24. 02:37:820 (7) - Mesma coisa que o 01:41:544.
25. 02:46:096 (1,2,3,4) - Mesma coisa que eu sugeri antes.
26. 02:49:406 (5) - Newcombo, pelo mesmo motivo de antes.
27. 02:51:888 (1) - Esse spinner deveria começar um pouco depois, aos 02:52:716.
    
    Então cara... hoje tem uma regra que impede o Easy de terminar antes que as outras diffs. Então, se você quiser isso rankeado, vai ter que mapear até o final do kiai >:

[Normal]

1. 00:19:199 (2) - Tem um whistle sobrando na track desse slider, só selecionar o slider e tirar o whistle.
2. 00:20:026 (1,2,3,1,2,1,2,3,4) - Cadê os hitsounds que você tava botando no início? Continua com eles pelo mapa inteiro, por favor >:
3. 00:22:095 (1,2) - Seria interessante fazer esses sliders simétricos (ctrl+c ctrl+v).
4. 00:43:613 (5) - Newcombo aqui pra combinar com a música?
5. 00:45:682 (2) - Newcombo deveria estar aqui, não no slider anterior. Bom, como o jeito de dar newcombos aqui é meio antigo, eu vou dar uma ignorada, espero que não tenham nenhum problema com isso depois.
6. 00:51:061 (1) - Mesmo assim, isso não justifica combos de uma nota. Tira esse newcombo, pfv D:
7. 00:59:751 (2,3) - Acho que funcionaria melhor com o resto do mapa se tu fizesse essas duas notas virarem um slider, ao invés. Ficaria mais intuitivo.
8. 01:04:716 (1) - Acho que seria mais legal se o spinner terminasse em 01:08:440, como eu sugeri no Easy.
9. 01:34:095 (1) - combos de uma nota ;_;
10. 01:42:371 (1,1,1,1,1) - Isso fica bem estranho de jogar, na minha opinião... Uma coisa que eu sugiro é pegar cada slider individualmente e apertar ctrl+G pra ele reverter. Fica bem mais interessante de jogar. BTW, acho esses newcombos meio desnecessários..
11. 01:46:509 (1) - Ao invés de colocar o clap no final desse slider, funcionaria melhor colocar ele no início do (2).
12. 01:54:371 (2,3) - Mesma coisa que o 00:59:751.
13. 02:27:888 (1) - Por que não terminar o spinner em 02:31:199? Ficaria melhor com a música, imo.
14. 02:32:026 (1) - Acho que ficaria melhor pra jogar se esse slider fosse posicionado assim.
15. 02:33:682 (2) - Spacing tá meio errado aqui, arruma pls
16. 02:37:406 (4) - Como esse slider tá saindo do grid e também tá fazendo um jump muito grande com a próxima nota, recomendo mover ele pra x176 y40.
17. 02:39:475 (2) - Spacing meio errado aqui também.
18. 02:50:647 (1,2) - Mesma coisa que 00:59:751.
19. 03:05:130 (1) - Recomendo fazer isso com o slider.
20. 03:10:923 (1) - Acho que fazer isso seria mais intuitivo.

[0_hard]

• Well, uhm... I really don't know how to mod this. 2009 style isn't something I want to change in this map, so I'm just gonna list stuff that's probably not gonna be okay for today's standards:

1. 00:43:406 (4) - Runs away from the grid. I don't think that's rankable. Not sure, though.
2. 00:48:578 (6) - I'd newcombo this, as this combo feels a bit too big.
3. 01:41:337 (8,1,2) - Spacing a bit broken here?
4. 01:44:647 (3,4) - I'd avoid this kind of overlapping, not REALLY necessary, though.
5. 02:10:302 (3,4,5) - I think spacing is a bit broken in general in this diff, dunno what happened. Probably intentional because of the symmetry, but yeah, just feels like it.
6. 03:02:439 (10) - Newcombo here to split this big combo?

[Kingcobra Hard!]

1. 01:12:164 (3,4) - this is rankable, but may give you a few problems in the future (ranking-wise). I guess doing something like this would play/look better.
2. 01:22:302 (2,4) - Same thing as I commented on 0_o's diff. These aren't exactly unrankable, but would it be possible to avoid them if you could?
3. 01:25:613 (2) - Not sure about the rankability of this ):
4. 01:35:130 (1,2,3) - Because of the hitbursts and the previous slider, these notes are pretty much completely hidden. I have no idea how to fix this, though. Maybe someone else will give a suggestion, but if not, I guess you'll have to remove the awesome spiral >:
5. 02:38:647 (1,2,3,4) - Maybe move these 4 notes a bit up so the spacing between (4,5) is consistent with the rest of the pattern?
6. 03:12:371 (1,2,3,4,5) - This is why you're my favourite oldschool mapper, Kingcobra. We need more creativity like this nowadays.

Pretty much only the basic stuff, there may me many more improvements to do, but this is the necessary stuff, I guess.

Here's my updated map.

http://puu.sh/7DrfN.osu

Done. Waiting for 0_o's changes.
Thank you Jenny and Blue Dragon

Made a minor adjustment. Use this instead.

http://puu.sh/7E1T5

kingcobra52 wrote:

Made a minor adjustment. Use this instead.

http://puu.sh/7E1T5

done!

Haxpopping this. Sorry, forgot to do it earlier.

Just noticed drain and OD are super low in Normal, suggesting you set them to 3/4 each.
Also, Blue Dragon doesn't belong in the tags, remove his name from every diff.


Also few more things @kingcobra:
00:56:647 (3) - you added a clap too much on the end here since you did it with the whole slider selected, please fix that as the trippleclap sounds overboard.
Plus, for the endkiai spinners, I would suggest you set softsample for the first ones each as the finish is very harsh and doesn't really go with the consistent spinning. (01:04:716 (1) -, 01:59:337 (1) - ; the ones at the very end of the map are fine and actualyl very nice)
01:52:509 (4,5) - missed the doubleclap here
01:55:819 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - those are still beziers; you probably should take the updated ones from the first kiai over to here aswell
02:16:302 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - actually wasn't this part supposed to be symmetric to the respective axises here? (first four combos Y, last four combos X)
02:39:061 (3) - this finish seems a bit random
02:39:268 (4) - would suggest you add another clap here since a doubleclap goes well with the vocal stress in this part
02:54:578 (1,2) - you're missing whistles here
02:59:337 - might want to add another kiai re-trigger here for the additional flash/fountain as this is the last kiaipart for the song

Done. Ninja'd Jenny before she was finished critiquing. Now it's really done.

http://puu.sh/7EvZe.osu

Changed what I felt like changing If that outside-the-grid slider is unrankable let me know, but I don't see it being a problem ingame.

http://puu.sh/7EvwQ.osu

OMG, done.

is that map from 5 years ago and it's going to be ranked NOW are you serious

Yes.

gg 2009, also hi kingcobra

wow this type of mapping brings back good memories.


Might as well mod. I would love to see this map get ranked with this mapping style really.

General:
Since you have a skin, you need to complete a set. You still need to make

hitcircleoverlay.png
approachcircle.png
reversearrow.png
hit50.png

Also apparently
hit0.png's dimensions must be exactly 256x256 (That's what AIBat says at least)

Easy:
Probably use normal hitsound set during kiai, seems way more fitting since it was way louder and powerful than the verses.
00:41:957 (1) - Probably would add finish to slider start. Finish sounds nice with kiai start imo.
00:48:578 (1) - Add finish to start?
00:55:199 (1) - finish?
01:01:820 - End kiai here instead of 00:59:544?
01:27:061 (3) - perhaps move this to 01:26:647 ? It follows the beat on downbeat AND it wll fix your NC pattern consistency.
01:28:302 (1) - Add note here if you follow above. Add NC.
01:34:095 (4) - I would shift this slider to 01:34:923. That feels more fitting since the build up starts there imo. Add note to replace slider instead.
01:36:578 (1) - Also recommend removing few repeats to make sure you can add a note here. Feels better to click as kiai starts. Also add NC and finish. here's a picture http://puu.sh/7FKf6.png
01:39:888 (5) - Add NC to maintain consistency
01:43:199 (1) - add finish to slider start?
01:49:820 (1) - add finish, remove clap?
01:56:440 - End kiai here instead of 01:54:164?
02:32:854 (1) - add finish?
02:39:475 (1) - finish slider start?
02:46:096 (1) - add finish?
03:05:957 (1) - add finish slider start?
03:12:578 (1) - finish?
03:15:888 (1) - While I dont really mind it touches the HP bar because it's a slider, perhaps it may be best to make the arc more to the right instead? You may need to move last few notes, so up to you. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1443622
03:25:820 (1) - End kiai here instead of 03:21:785?

Normal:
00:17:957 (3,1) - Hmm, seems weird that Easy was nice and consistent with NC but normal is already different here. Perhaps just do note note slider combo? I checked and it looked like only here was rather awkward, mostly everything else after this was fine!
00:20:026 (1,2) - Swap NC? new line in song starts at (2)
00:35:337 (5) - NC for consistency?
00:38:647 (5) - ^?
00:41:130 (1) - How about shortening slider by 1/1 and then adding note at 00:41:957? Clicking as kiai/chorus begin feels good. Add finish also!
00:48:578 (2) - add finish slider start?
00:55:199 (2) - finish start?
01:00:578 (1) - Add clap to start and remove clap at slider end?
01:01:406 (2,3,1,2,1,2,1,2) - hmm for these. How about hitsounding it like this? clap, finish, clap, whistle, clap, finish, clap whistle?
01:35:751 (1) - Same suggestion as early? shorten by 1/1, add note at 01:36:578 and add finish?
01:41:130 (4) - Seems weird for this slider since you always added a note or slider end at 01:41:544 + finish. Perhaps replace slider with 3 notes so you maintain consistency here? http://puu.sh/7FLe9.png
01:43:199 (3) - add finish here? Also would NC here since start of new verse in chorus.
01:49:820 (2) - Finish?
01:56:026 (2,3,1,2,1,2,1,2) - Same as earlier? clap, finish, clap, whistle, clap, finish, clap, whistle?
01:59:751 - Why not end kiai here also? Makes sense since you also did it in the beginning.
02:32:854 (1) - omg! You added finish!!
02:37:406 (4) - How about like this? It's very close to HP Bar. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1443646 Only problem is that you might need to move next few patterns, up to you.
02:39:475 (2) - Finish! D:
02:44:440 (2) - Finish to slider start? Maintains consistency with what you've been doing on the "yeah"
02:46:095 (2) - Add finish slider start?
02:52:095 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - Curious why you mapped it differently than first and second chorus. You mapped to music before now you map to vocals. Personally I prefer mapping the music more since it maintains consistency and I usually think the rhythm is easier to follow than vocals in most cases. If you agree then also do clap finish clap whistle clap finish clap whistle pattern?
03:05:957 (2) - I recommend adding a note here and adding finish. Clicking downbeat and chorus/kiai starts is fun imo.
03:10:923 (1) - Probably add finish slider start since you've been doing it.
03:11:751 (1,2,3,4,5) - Hmm, might do a small timeline pattern rearranging here. When you start slider on third white tick and end on downbeat, it tends to be weird imo. You click (emphasize) weak part and then passively end (weaken) the strong part. Picture shows what im trying to say. Perhaps change it to somethign like that? http://puu.sh/7FM48.png
03:17:544 (1) - add note with finish here? again you were having finishes end here and they sound nice imo
03:18:578 (1,1,2,1,1,2) - map to music more here? Also do hitsound if you agree.


0_o o_0 o_O O_ofaceman hard:
I thought it was funny how your SV is lower than Easy but used 2x to fix it.
00:16:302 (1) - Maybe whistle?
00:16:509 (2) - Personally I feel another note here feels comfortable.
00:16:716 (2) - Change to whistle hitsound?
00:16:923 (1) - little spacing error.
00:19:613 (8) - NC for consistency since you did it 00:16:302 (1,2) ?
00:29:544 (1) - add whisle?
00:29:751 (2) - add note?
00:29:957 (3) - Change to whistle?
00:30:164 (4) - Add note since you also added here earlier?
00:32:854 (6) - NC for consistency?
00:47:957 (2,4) - Why not move these up about 4 - 5 grids so it can be a little "move-ier?
01:33:061 (6) - move it to 259 93? That way it will stack perfectly on 01:31:406 (1,2). Unless that was not what you were looking for.
01:34:302 (7,8,9) - Just remember these notes after!
01:59:751 (1) - Perhaps add a note here and add finish here instead. Then just start spinner 1/2 later? I think that's what you were trynig to do when you added finish on (2) but it didn't feel too good for me.
02:42:784 (1) - Hmm, i didn't like the spinner too much, especially in the middle of mappable parts imo, i really liked the slider you did at the first chorus. Maybe do something like that? If you agree, remove finish at 02:42:577 (8) the finish starts early and kinda feels weird
02:52:922 (3,4) - I think these are not stacked properly, one of the notes is one grid off. (Y axis)
03:10:095 (1) - Hmm not liking the spinner here too. I think why I kept pointing it out is because the spinners have been inconsistent in the chorus I suppose. I don't know if you want to keep it or not, though I prefer if you mapped it I suppose. Up to you.

Kingcobra:
00:41:957 (5) - Prefer if you add kiai here and add finish here instead. That's where chorus and finish starts and fits better imo. Also add NC here if you do add a note. I do highly encourage this one at least.
00:48:371 (4) - Hmm, replace this with a note and add 1/2 slider instead? Add finish on slider start of slider. http://puu.sh/7FNx0.png ?
00:58:406 (1) - I think "and" starts at downbeat, so perhaps start spinner 1/4 later and adjust spinner end accordingly?
01:33:061 (9) - wow
01:36:578 (5) - Highly encourage to add note here since you want to "click" and chorus and intense music build up startssssss. Also add finish and NC if you do.
01:42:992 (4) - Same suggestion as 00:48:371. I think its more fitting to add a note on that downbeat instead of sliding it over for that specific part.
02:32:647 (3,4) - Swap finish hitsound? remove at 3 add on 4.
02:34:302 (1) - Actually im really liking these more than the gaps you have in first and second chorus.
02:35:957 (1) - ^ It keeps player engaged in song imo. If its not too much problem or remapping, perhaps also add these slides to first and second chorus? Up to you though if it really requires a lot of remapping.
02:39:475 (5) - finish here?
02:46:095 (5) - imo I think this should be mapped to. it fits nicely with "you got a" *click*"piece!" also finish.
02:57:682 (1) - finish slider end?
03:00:785 (6) - Aw you stopped it here haha. Oh well. I still liked those sliders though.
03:05:751 (4) - Same suggestion as 00:48:371 ?
03:18:578 (1,1,1) - These are really nice!

Anyways its hard to preserve 2009 style for me. I still tried not to change things that will truly bother me 2013-2014 style. I think most were downbeat/hitsound/NC. Not so much patterns. just a little.

anyone can help me with skin?

hitcircleoverlay.png
approachcircle.png
reversearrow.png
hit50.png

Here you go! Good suggestions Raging Bull.

http://puu.sh/7FTyi.osu

ok, done!

add:
hitcircleoverlay.png
approachcircle.png
reversearrow.png
hit50.png

thx kingcobra52

Holy crap a map in pending that I modded 5 years ago. It's like a time machine.

Best of luck getting it ranked.

updated

(You don't need to KD multiple posts of the same person unless there was a considerably larg

Another polishment recheck:



[Easy]

1. 00:41:957 (1) - those I'd rather have like waves with an anchor; click the box below for slidercodes, point coordinates and images
   
   slider

   
   
   start: 26|70
   first bezier point: 0|139
   second bezier point: 77|209
   anchor (red) point: 166|172
   third bezier (the one after the red point): 118|227
   fourth bezier: 125|323
   fifth bezier: 194|359
   end: 256|343
2. 01:27:061 (3,5) - I don't really enjoy how these are at nearly the same spot but I guess it's okay
3. 01:52:303 (4,5) - I suggest you move 4 to 308|205 and 5 to 425|226 as to avoid hitburst overlaps with the coming slider
4. 02:16:302 (1,2,3,4) - I'd rather see a symmetrical building around the Y axis here; image below
   
   here, coordinates inside as usual

   
   
   1: 82|59
   2: 138|291
   3+4: Just copy 1+2, CTRL-H them, then CTRL-G and remove the new combo
5. 02:19:613 (1,2,3,4) - this is not really pretty either but it doesn't seem like you wanted it symmetric anyways?

Rest seems okay now, well done.


[Normal]

Having Normal at Drain 1 seems fairly low; raise to 3 or 4 perhaps.

1. 00:17:544 (2) - remove whistle; three of them in a row are a bit much
2. 00:19:199 (2) - consider removing the whistle on the slidertrack (leave the one on the end though)
3. 00:34:095 (2) - similar to 00:17:544, remove whistle please
4. 00:35:337 (1) - remove new combo here, still belongs to the same string of vocals
5. 00:36:992 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - you could make this a proper circle by playing around with the "Create Polygon Circles" option in the Compose tab (make sure to set beat snap divisor to 1/1 before so it doesn't create 1/2 instead, then enter 7 points into it and play with the offset until you have a pattern as you would like it)
6. 00:38:647 (1) - remove NC aswell
7. 00:46:509 (3) - add clap?
8. 01:34:095 (7) - this is more 1.1x snap than the usual 1.0x you are using here; move this to 32|247
9. 01:42:371 (5) - this just feels too close to 4's sliderbody; also, the straight line doesn't really go well with the curvy slider before - box below
   
   huzzah

   
   startpoint: 409|31
   middle point: 422|83
   third point: 389|159
10. 01:47:751 (2) - this slider ends on a strong beat than it starts on, replace it with two circles please (also, a straight line doesn't really go well with the curve before)
11. 01:49:820 (2) - this is 0.9x snap while it should be 1.0x - please fix this and adjust the rest of the pattern
12. 02:45:268 (1,2,1,2) - these sliders look very unbalanced, I'd suggest you do them anew with the new algorhythm as that'll fix the problem quite easily.
13. 02:51:475 (1) - another one of those 0.9x snaps!
14. 03:11:751 (1) - why's this 1.1x snap? also, please remove the new combo because there's no reason for it here (same vocal string)
15. 03:22:095 (1) - in Easy, the entire spinner is still in the kiai time but here you turn it off earlier; please make this consistent with another any way or the other

[0_o's Hard]

1. 00:16:302 (1) - no need for this new combo
2. 00:29:544 (1) - ^
3. 00:32:440 (1) - ^
4. 01:04:923 (2) - still not quite symmetric (just make the sliderpoints symmetric to the Y-axis and the rest should probably get solved in the process)
5. 02:03:682 (1) - wave would be a little better with the end at 345|80 and the point before at 253|125
6. 02:31:198 (1) - personally I'd remove this NC as I don't count it as an invidual soundpattern or anything but that's your call
7. 02:40:922 (4) - wave would be better with end on 234|97 and the point before at 164|153
8. 02:57:474 (3) - stack this with 2's end xP
9. 03:15:060 (1) - no need for new combo

[Kingcobra Hard!]

1. 00:19:199 (6,7,8) - I'd still like to see these blanketting each other (and 6's overlap with 4 is a bit bleh)
2. 00:32:233 (1,2,3) - actually I expected a finishpattern here like you did it in the previous combos at this point in the music
3. 01:03:682 (1,2) - this pair of sliders is a fair lot closer to each other than the ones before, fix that please?
4. 01:04:716 (1) - silence this spinner end? the finish seems out of place
5. 01:30:371 (5) - please fix this to exact 0.9x spacing - not like it was a super big deal but I felt something was off when playing since the spacing seemed different from 4 to 5 than from 5 to 6
6. 01:58:303 (1,2) - just like 01:03:682
7. 01:59:337 (1) - silence this spinner end? the finish seems out of place
8. 02:16:302 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - man I still want this symmetric ;_;
9. 03:05:751 (4,5) - these may still be a bit close to the HP bar as hitbursts could overlap there and that'd look bleh

e amount of time between the mods)

Jenny wrote:

Also having Normal at Drain 1 seems fairly low; raise to 3 or 4 perhaps.
(You don't need to KD multiple posts of the same person unless there was a considerably large amount of time between the mods)

err, i'm sorry
done about Drain

Edited the post with another recheck, please go through it everyone

updated! special thx for Jenny, good suggestions!

I edited count3, count1, and comboburst to make them much cleaner.

http://puu.sh/7IjhH.zip

After fumbling with that damn circle slider for way too long (symmetric slider points don't cut it) I remembered that fancy new slider algorithm the game uses now and got it looking pretty nice with only a single point in between the ends. Woo!

http://puu.sh/7IpRR.osu

kingcobra52, when i download it, say 'error in file'
can you post here direct link?

yay, done!

I made some adjustments. Try #modreqs and see if anyone there will help out.

http://puu.sh/7MGe8.osu

done

wow 5 years old!! Good luck, have a star XD

I'm not all that experienced at beatmapping, but they say modding can help you learn, so here we go!
(NOTE: all times i refer to a grid, the grid snap is 3)

The slider overlap is unchanged, but I decided to implement the latter. Thanks!

http://puu.sh/7OSrJ.osu

Also I noticed that the hitsound volume at 02:57:888 on Easy and Normal is at 31%. Can you adjust that to 30% to make it consistent?

updated. thanks.
fixed, kingcobra