ztrot wrote:

Two: CNF these sliders are evil and think they should be removed

Larto wrote:

Luxary Remix:
00:05:79 (1) - This speed up feels sort of unnatural. Sure you wanna keep it?

Larto wrote:

Overall:
If you could get an mp3 that is NOT cut off at the end, that would be awesome D: The mp3 is correct, it's normal for the song to finish in that way

Luxary Remix:
00:05:79 (1) - This speed up feels sort of unnatural. Sure you wanna keep it? Luxary don't want change this

Armin Remix:
02:14:19 (1,1,2) - That pattern is so weird, I really suggest moving the second slider ;( fixed

Yumiko's Insane:
00:53:00 (3,4,5) - This pattern sounds and plays awkwardly :< fixed
01:05:84 (9,1) - It MIGHT trip people up how close those notes are to each other. It didn't trip me up, changing it would probably be best. hmm fixed
01:44:36 (1,2,3) - It feels a bit unnatural how these sliders slow down. Up to you if you wanna change it. I don't want change this

CNF:
No problem! And wow, those sliders... They look totally unrankable, but hey, they feel natural to me and they shouldn't trip up players too much, so I'm fine with 'em.

Kyo:
00:12:59 (3,4,5) - Wat... this spacing was weiiird. fixed

Normal:
01:45:11 (2,1) - those notes feel so close to each other. Or maybe that's just me. Up to you. fixed

Okay, this feels a bit hard, but new players should always be able to understand the patterns. And the HPDrain should be low enough for them to be able to make mistakes anyway.

Larto wrote:

aaaaah x.x
I noticed that "Black.png" and "White.png" are too big. make them smaller than 800x600 please :< fixed
Don't Kudosu this, I should have noticed that in my first mod post.

Also, I noticed that on Kyo's diff:
01:37:54 (5,1) - this spacing is pretty confusing. Just saying. fixed
Also, this might confuse people: 02:09:64 (1,2,3,1,2,3) Kyocciola don't want change this

RemmyX25 wrote:

C'nF:
00:56:02 (1) / 00:57:53 (1) / 00:59:04 (1) - I see what you did there, but no. I am not approving these sliders at all.
02:08:53 (1,1,1) - ^
02:14:19 (2) - ^

RemmyX25 wrote:

I'm not too keen on the 6 difficulties, especially when the spread is H I I I I I (see beatmap listing.)

I'd highly recommend tuning some of these, especially [Normal] so that its actually a normal (easy works too), as well as some of the other difficulties so its not all Insane difficulties.

Normal
01:30:10 (1) - Why is this on a blue tick? if anythng, replace the hitcircle before it, and start the spinner there Fixed

KyO's
00:36:36 (7,8,1) - Do these really need to be claps? Doesnt sound attractive imo fixed

C'nF:
00:56:02 (1) / 00:57:53 (1) / 00:59:04 (1) - I see what you did there, but no. I am not approving these sliders at all.
02:08:53 (1,1,1) - ^
02:14:19 (2) - ^ wat? D: ztrot = CnF you Win this Time >.< Other bats like your sliders so they stay

Yumiko
00:12:96 (7) - not distanced snapped properly fixed
00:35:62 (1,2,3,4) - I dont think this is spaced properly either, but this may just be my imagination hmmm fixed

Gemi wrote:

There are a few things that I want to point out. Also, I'd recommend adding an easy difficulty since it is a song that a lot of players would like to play. I can't add an Easy. Max Diff=6, and I don't want delete my friends's difficulties.

[Normal]
Don't remove this difficulty as it is quite good and fills the need of easier maps.

01:35:676 (2) - I'd like this slider to go up-down or down-up instead of right-left to not overlap other notes. fixed

[Kyo's Mix]
I don't like the rhythms of the 2 note series starting at 01:08:086. I'd suggest adding a third note to each of them, but it's up to you.

[Armin's Nexus]
Remove the first Kiai Time. (the one starting at 00:13:724)

[Luxary ReMix]
This difficulty felt a bit unnecessary. There was nothing special in it compared to the others and it didn't feel good enough as it is. I'd strongly suggest removing this one.
Note, I don't suggest this because there are so many difficult maps. To me it is okay to have so many, but this difficulty just isn't anything fun enough imo to deserve to be there.