1. Easy (2.62 stars, 92 notes)
2. Hard (4.84 stars, 177 notes)
3. Insane (5 stars, 256 notes)
4. Normal (4.05 stars, 118 notes)

1. Mako's Easy by Mako Sakata
2. Old Insane by me

Mako Sakata wrote:

Haloooo from my queue~

[General]
All volume -10~20% for some reasons It sounds too loud especialy on finish sound k
Maybe you need this costum hitclap-soft http://puu.sh/7cYve.zip especialy for this calm part 00:14:591 until 00:26:158 thanks
It'll be better if you use Normal sampleset plus drum costum sound or something, since the song is not really "calm" except the part I mention above and last part
You need a better BG resolution (1366x768) since you tick widescreen support, the curent BG a bit cracked if you force tou use widescreen support didn't found any, using 1280x720 now, since it's 16:9 tho
Why -TV size- ? why not like the others (TV Size) but in the album it shows as -Tv size- nvm, fix'd

[Easy]
00:23:989 (2,5,1) - Bad overlap
00:41:338 (1) - Almost out of screen, maybe you can move up a bit k
01:12:423 (1) - Delete clap? k
Maybe you can spread the DS more, the curent one is prety crowded

[Normal]
A bit hard, especially on this part 00:37:724 - until 00:46:399 - because a lot of stacking
I sugest not to have diffrent SV on Normal and why not use 1.00 SV? I think 1.20 on 160 BPM prety fast for Normal
Do you use 0.8 or 1.0 for DS? I find a bit unconcistent on some parts 1x SV * 0.8 DS = 0.8x SV * 1x DS
00:27:242 (2,4) - Bad overlap, move up (2) a bit k
00:25:435 - 00:25:073 - 00:46:037 - 00:46:399 - Useless green lines, delete?
00:33:387 (3,1) - You can blanket that better k
00:50:555 (3,5) - Maybe stack perfectly? sorry, my style :/
01:04:471 (2,3,4) - How about this rhythm? k
Too many stacking make me confuse

[Hard]
00:24:531 (1) - Delete clap? done
00:34:832 (1,2) - Blanket better? i love it the way
00:45:856 (3,2,3,1) - Not look so good ?

[Insane]
01:05:374 (2) - Delete clap fro head and place clap on tail k
01:06:097 (4) - Same as above ^

Good map
Aku buat Easy diff kalo mau dicoba http://puu.sh/7cZub.zip ekstrak aja semua

neonat wrote:

General

The colours of Combo 3 and Combo 4 are too similar. Furthermore, they are right after one another, it is really difficult to differentiate Whether or not there is a new combo other than the object number. You should at least have a separate combo colour in between them, if you want to keep those colours. changed

Easy

00:53:266 (2) - this slider is odd, I think instead have a circle at 00:53:266 and a slider from 00:53:627 to 00:53:989 - (I think it's because of the vocals, at least have a beat at a part of the vocals which I would suggest at 00:53:627 -) done in different way
01:05:917 (5) - remove the finish on the start of the slider done

Normal

00:53:447 (3) - change to a circle at 00:53:447 and a slider from 00:53:627 to 00:53:989 i like it
01:01:941 (2,3) - sounds off, maybe change to a different rhythm here? Like add a circle at 01:01:941 and a slider from 01:02:121 to 01:02:483 and shift 01:03:025 (4) - so that it starts at 01:02:844 and add a circle at 01:03:567 it's following the drum beat

Hard

00:11:338 (1) - this NC seems out of place done
00:38:447 (2) - NC here not 00:38:266 (1) - same with 00:39:893 (2) - and 00:40:615 (2) - etc. done

Insane

I am one who really concerns myself with rhythm, I think this Insane is pretty nice rhythm-wise, that's great. thanks

Good Luck

eeezzzeee wrote:

Hi, from modding queue.

GENERAL
There might be a problem with some of your hitsounds and the music together, sometimes it sounds like theres 2 drums. Some parts of the song sound like there is drums on 1/4,3/4. I think its most apparent at 00:55:073 - 00:57:603 don't understand :/

EASY
Fine!

NORMAL
00:38:266 (1,2) - consider adding a circle at 00:38:085 to match the vocal with no hitsound addition moved, instead of adding note
00:41:158 (1,2) - same as above ^
00:44:049 (1,2) - same as above ^
I think the best effect here would be for one or two of them to have this but not all of them.

HARD
Fine!

INSANE
00:44:953 (5,1) - this part is right on top of itself, maybe change like this i think it's fine, since it's Insane diff

SPOILER

01:14:230 (2,4) - on top of itself again ^

That's all. Best of luck

popner wrote:

From new mapper queue.

[Insane]
00:03:025 (1,2) - put them like this won't affect the spacing consistency: okay

SPOILER

00:06:459 (2) - flows better if: done

SPOILER

00:10:073 (1,3) - try to avoid the overlap by using a new pattern. Example: done

SPOILER

00:16:399 - try to follow the sound here okay
00:28:326 (3,4) - flip them upside down to avoid the monotonous direction:

SPOILER

00:38:447 (3) - you used this kind of slider only for once. Maybe change the shape? okay
01:13:989 (1,2,3,4,5) - well done thanks
01:17:302 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - you can try making a similar pattern as 01:13:989 (1,2,3,4,5) - : nope, i love it xD

SPOILER

[Hard]
00:04:471 (1) - try to make it less curved, or use a new pattern: okay

SPOILER

You can call me back after finding more mods.

toybot wrote:

Found in #modreqs

[General]
01:24:170 (1) - this spinner for all diffs, either should be shortened to 01:29:049 - , or silenced right at the end, it's too loud found other way

[Easy]
I don't really see anything wrong
00:23:989 (2) - whistle at tail? no?
00:55:796 (2) - you should remove the clap on the last beat, sounds off ^

[Hard]
Make all kiai times the same. Since it's all mapped by just you. oh sorry, fix'd

00:20:013 (2,1) - try something like this? sorry, no

SPOILER

00:39:893 (1) - remove nc done
01:00:133 (1) - you could make this more interesting, like a short stream and then hold slider i guess no

SPOILER

I did screenshot here because puush stopped working ><

01:13:868 (1,2,3,4) - these are hard to hear. maybe raise their volume and turn them into drum? because them as soft with that one loud hitsound, like on (1)'s head is annoying. fix'd

[Insane]
00:20:194 (5) - move this to around x488 y116 no
00:28:688 (4) - move this somewhere else, looks bad when both 2 and 4 are on same; maybe move it to the right of 2? fix in other way
01:11:700 (1,2,3,4) - hmm, its a lot smoother movement if you ctrl+g 2 and 4.. okay
01:13:959 (1,2,3,4,5) - same thing about it being hard to hear fix'd

Anyway, nice work! Good luck on rank :p

1. 00:13:688 (5) - add whistle or clap?
2. 00:26:880 (3) - a little be too far from a previous note, how about move this to x=345,y=230?
3. 00:31:399 (1) - kinda same as above, move to x=360, y=192
4. 00:31:941 (1) - ^
5. 00:32:302 (2) - move to x=226, y=75, and rotate 5 deg anti-clockwise?
6. 00:39:170 (5) - move to x=436, y=114?
7. 00:48:387 (5) - add whistle or clap?
8. 00:48:567 (1) - add soft-finish on the head and end of the slider?
9. 00:49:109 (2) - add whistle?
10. 00:58:507 (2) - remove NC?
11. 01:00:133 (7) - ^?
12. 01:10:073 (4) - ^?
13. 01:14:832 (1) - add NC?

dosyeru wrote:

hi,
[Insane]

1. 00:13:688 (5) - add whistle or clap? whistle
2. 00:26:880 (3) - a little be too far from a previous note, how about move this to x=345,y=230? no
3. 00:31:399 (1) - kinda same as above, move to x=360, y=192 ^
4. 00:31:941 (1) - ^ ^
5. 00:32:302 (2) - move to x=226, y=75, and rotate 5 deg anti-clockwise? ^
6. 00:39:170 (5) - move to x=436, y=114? i did it on purpose
7. 00:48:387 (5) - add whistle or clap? whistle
8. 00:48:567 (1) - add soft-finish on the head and end of the slider? kay
9. 00:49:109 (2) - add whistle? a bit noisy, so no
10. 00:58:507 (2) - remove NC? i guess no
11. 01:00:133 (7) - ^? ^
12. 01:10:073 (4) - ^? ^
13. 01:14:832 (1) - add NC? sorry no

that's it, Good insane diff <3

Knotts wrote:

From my modding queue

[Insane]

1. 00:36:097 (6) - Remove clap? nope, bit syncing with song
2. 00:45:495 (1) - Hard to read for me. Maybe add a circle at 00:45:314 ? i guess no, sorry
3. 00:49:109 (2) - wouldn't it make more sense to start the NC here? The music changes here and you can see the circle better. moved 1 grid left instead
4. 01:02:302 (1) - Clap on tail? whistle sounds better here
5. 01:02:483 (2) - Remove clap on head? done
6. 01:05:374 (2) - Remove clap on head? ^
7. 01:08:085 (1) - add clap on tail? whistle sounds better here
8. 01:08:266 (2) - remove clap on head? done

[Hard]

1. 00:53:989 (2,3) - Pretty boring compared to the rest of your map. Maybe do something like this? (pretty lame example) done
   
   screenshot

   
2. 00:56:880 (2) - looks like your map's weirdly timed. The beat and the circle don't match each other at 25%.

1. Design: remove '' Widescreen support'' (This for have SB map)
2. Tag: add ''坂部剛 Sakabe Tsuyoshi '' and '' 渡部紫緒 Watanabe Murasaki cho ''

tellertheworld wrote:

From Teller's team modding queues ( ･´ω･｀)

[General]

• 
  

1. Design: remove '' Widescreen support'' (This for have SB map) done
   
2. Tag: add ''坂部剛 Sakabe Tsuyoshi '' and '' 渡部紫緒 Watanabe Murasaki cho '' any reason for this?

Insane

1. 
   Compose
2. 00:23:808 - the slider should shorten 2/4. I think u can follow the 'di' sound.↓ will thinking of it,since i have no idea with the spacing
   
3. 00:24:170 - add circle↑ ^
4. 00:25:615 (1) - I think that should not use rebound slider here.The rhythm is not change here so do not make SV slow. it's intentional, it's my style anyway ;D
5. 00:35:374 (4,5) - there is not change the rhythm here. I think u dont space here. it's a trap!! /hides
   
   
   Timing
6. 00:14:591 - vol 35% (but may be my hitsound different) x
7. 00:38:447 - vol 35% (but may be my hitsound different) ^
   
   hitsound
8. 00:13:417 (2) - add Clap already?
9. 00:14:953 - mute in the slider end. hmm?
10. 00:37:724 (1) - add Finish already?
11. 00:38:989 (4) - remove Clap no
12. 00:39:170 (5) - add Clap ^
13. 00:48:387 (5) - remove Whistle and add Clap done
14. 01:11:248 (2) - add Clap i guess no

Hard

• 
  General

1. Please remove the green line if u dont need. okay
   
   Compose
2. 01:02:302 - circle here. keep it smooth. it will be harder
   
   hitsound
3. 01:09:531 (1) - add Finish already?

Normal

• 
  General

1. Please remove the green line if u dont need. same as hard

Easy

• 
  General

1. Please remove the green line if u dont need. same as normal
   
   Compose
2. 00:11:158 (1) - start at 00:11:338 - and end in 00:11:700 - i guess it's fine

nice map~ (╯°□°)╯彡
go to rank it~