Raiku wrote:

Raiku here!

I have a few playability related suggestions that I think you may find mildly tasteful:

[Jenny's Extra]

00:22:809 - I find that when confronted with the idea of someone playing with hardrock, the flow is greatly interrupted with the implementation of an anomalous hitcircle at the end of this slidercombo, I went with the idea of continuity with this section by joining the first note of the next section to the end of the slider to improve the flow into the next combo! (http://puu.sh/5yxRU.jpg) - that way it will lose the jumping, impactful introduction into the next part. also, I am not mapping for people to play my maps on hardrock or any additional mod in general and I believe that it's part of those to get to handle the initial difficulty, so denying this.

00:51:537 - I felt that instead of a pair of 2 stacks here, neat doubles that flow into the next section are more appropriate to help the map maintain a level of movement seen throughout the map prior to this! (http://puu.sh/5yxVI.jpg) - the way you mapped it ruins the whole jumpyness within the song and makes it more of a tracing-wiggly flow, which really doesn't suit the doublet sounds; if anything, I'd do it with reversing your 4 and 5, but as said, it doesn't feel that well for me. the notes are stacked because the two sounds they each lie on are extremely alike/similar (if not the same, even), so that suits it better from my point of view.

00:57:131 - Similarly to before, but in this section. I really feel it adds variety to this section and helps maintain that ever so important flow \;D/ (http://puu.sh/5yy32.jpg). - looks nice, does not fit though.

01:11:368 - I feel this should be a repeat slider but in the opposite direction so that you exit towards the next note. I slightly altered the positions of 6, 7 and 8 to aid the flow here, I think you'll like it! (http://puu.sh/5yy9L.jpg) - there is a reason for why this is not just one slider: the clicks are put onto the light "bell"-ish sounds in the song, not the techno-"breakcore" 1/4. if I put a reverse-kickslider here, that'd ruin the player's participation and would screw up what I aimed for with this section.

Oh and as a general rule of thumb, I feel as though some of the fast 4 stacks could be experimented further into grumdesque long slider into to 4 1/8 sliders flowing out of it following the same rhythm, much like in the ghost of 3.13! - I am not grumd and I believe 1/6 are not too hard to do; also, they're too important as beats to simply skip them (-> skipping = making them passive hits (-> holding a slider, because you don't hit them then, only the start))

Massive fan of this diff, really well mapped, very challenging and a great hardrock play. I hope this helps on its way to getting ranked!

JUDYDANNY wrote:

[Muzukashii]

1. 00:12:385 (2) – add finish? I only wanted to emphasize the first beat, and give the second a bit of a "less important" feeling because the vocal is less high-pitched
2. 00:15:097 (12) -^ same logic
3. 00:33:741 (93,95) – how about swap? oh, yes, that makes sense, swapped 00:36:453 (105,107) - too
4. 00:41:707 (128,129,130,131,132,133,134,135,136) – how about? No, I want to keep the symmetry with 00:41:707 (128,129,130,131) - and 00:42:554 (132,133,134,135) - the song goes for the same rhythm at both points
   

JUDYDANNY wrote:

Hello ,mappers~ :3
Here's a Taiko Mod via My Taiko Moding Queue
I am glad if it becomes helpful.

My mod is for suggetions. if you dont like, ignore please.
~Taiko~
d is Red Note.
k is Blue Note.
and, D , K is Big Notes .. d,k.
“+ ?” is I like pattern (※example→ add? , remove?

[General]

1. Kiai time be same like Dekaane's Kantan . its better for me.
   Comparing with Kantan and Futsuu~Inner Oni , They are not same I changed my timing points to Dekaane's
   
2. Saying about Kantan~Muzukashii, Inner Oni
   Unchecked "Widescreen support" like TK'S Oni.OK

[Inner Oni]

1. 00:11:707 (56) – k ok
2. 00:17:639 (102,103,104,105,106) – how about change? k D kkd→kkd k d or k ddk d used kkd k d
3. 00:22:978 (155) – move to00:22:809 (154) – and change k. 00:22:809 (154) - 00:22:978 (156) - which note is more important? It Sounds 154 the best . changed although i dont know what you mean at the end D:
4. 00:27:131 (189,190,191) – add 1/6 .. dd kk? changed!
5. 00:28:148 (197,198,199,200) – kkdd →kddd, or kkkd i think kkdd plays better though D:
6. 00:37:639 (272,1) – 272 delete (1) move to 272’s place . Changed!
7. 00:36:622 (264,265,266,267) – swap is better. Did something like it
8. 00:48:656 (35) – k Changed!
9. 00:52:470 (63) – delete Changed!
10. 01:02:893 (138) – how about k? Changed!
11. 01:14:080 (197) – d? Didnt change ;_;
12. 01:33:232 (321,322,323) – add1/6? Changed!
13. 01:35:266 (340) – k Changed!
14. 01:35:944 (346) – k? Changed!
15. 01:48:995 (446) – why d? k Changed!

That’s all! I thank you for reading it through
Good Luck! Thanks!

JUDYDANNY wrote:

Hello ,mappers~ :3
Here's a Taiko Mod via My Taiko Moding Queue
I am glad if it becomes helpful.

[Kantan]

1. 00:54:080 (21) – slider length change? ~00:54:758 – /*I prefer it cover all the vocal phrase
2. 01:10:351 (40) – delete. cause also pitch changed timing ,01:07:639 - no put. /*Done.
3. 01:45:775 (105,106) – how about delete? I think its hard?.. and more cleared vocalpart. /*I liked this, done.
   

That’s all! I thank you for reading it through
Good Luck!

Spy wrote:

Just short mod.
Column : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

[General]
Tags : smooch →what is this?
If your mania Keys only one key,no need to write the key in diff name.

[S.Star's 7K NM]
00:54:080 (54080|5,54080|1) - Remove one note Remain
00:54:249 (54249|5,54249|1) - Remove one note Remain
00:54:419 (54419|4,54419|2) - Remove one note Remain
00:54:588 (54588|4,54588|2) - Remove one note Remain
00:54:758 (54758|6,54758|0) - Remove one note Remain
00:54:927 (54927|6,54927|0) - Remove one note Remain
01:05:097 - Add a note on 4 Not Fixed
01:05:436 - Add a note on 4 Not Fixed
Thanks For mod~
No change,but i fixed in other place-> http://puu.sh/5AMyW.osu

CoroQuetz wrote:

Taiko mod~
All are suggestions unless in red.


[Cdh's Inner Oni]
Delete unnecessary timing points, 60% hitsound volume Changed!
00:03:910 (15) - k Changed this and other similar parts to k

good luck for rank~ Thanks :3

Simple_Star wrote:

Mania Mod by request,Column:1 2 3 4 5 6 7

[Pew's HD]
00:39:165 - Add 1 More Note - added
00:55:097 - Add a Note at 7 - ^
00:55:266 - Remove 1 of them - no
01:08:487 - Add a Note - ^
01:11:199 (71199|4) - Move to 01:11:029 - ok
01:11:368 - Add a Note - ^
Good Luck~

[Shi-Ra] wrote:

Hello Priti and all other mappers, there are mods for mania diffs by request ^w^

Shi-Ra's Patterns Review:
(notice that columns are following like 0 1 2 3 4 5 6)

Pew's HD

Inside :3

Only some suggestions here, Pew Pew very nice charter~

00:13:571 (13571|2) - move to 3rd column, according to your next going pattern it'll be good transition from one hand to another I think and you can keep distance between notes here - accepted

00:21:199 (21199|0,21283|6) - move these notes to 2nd and 4th columns accordingly, make alternation here more different - fixed

00:26:622 (26622|0) - move to 4th column? it's more suitable for your pattern here, if you wanna keep balance here, it wouldn't ruin it fixed

00:30:690 (30690|0) - move this note to 5th column, it's more suitable here before next going chord fixed

00:49:504 (49504|4) - move to 2nd column, there's no two identical sound it 4th column, so move it to more suitable position - i keep first, this part better 1/2 jack with the music

01:19:419 - you can add one more note here and perform triplet according to the sound there - will ruin the overall pattern this part

01:46:876 - add here at least one more note according to the beat to 3rd column I suggest or to 2nd and 4th columns fixed

[Shi-Ra] wrote:

Hello Priti and all other mappers, there are mods for mania diffs by request ^w^

Shi-Ra's Patterns Review:
(notice that columns are following like 0 1 2 3 4 5 6)
S.Star's NM

Inside :3

00:03:741 (3741|4) - move to 5th column, from this note I suggest you to re-arrange this part to make it more comfortable to play here

after moving previous note, move 00:03:910 (3910|0) - to 3rd column and then move this note 00:04:080 (4080|2) - to 1st column to complete this pattern, I think it's more suitable here

00:04:927 (4927|4) - move to 3rd column and make comfortable transition between right and left part here, placing this note to centre column makes your pattern more balanced

00:23:232 (23232|2,23402|4) - move these notes to 1st and 2nd columns accordingly, that's better pattern transition here before the next going LN, just check it

00:32:893 - add here one more note to 3rd column according to the sound which goes there, it wouldn't difficult here for NM Not Fixed

00:52:046 (52046|0) - move it to 2nd column, I suggest you to move it closer to other notes here coz it'll be easier for players to catch this note after previous grace notes

01:04:093 - add here one more note to 3rd column again, don't ignore centre column here, it's great position for note according to the vocals here

01:32:385 (92385|1) - move to 2nd column, make here comfortable transition between patterns here for both hands

JUDYDANNY wrote:

[Oni]

1. 00:46:622 (271,272,273,274) – k ddk に変えるか,1/4を消してもいいと思います。 - ボーカルを強調するために単発のkで終わりたいのと、それを前提にすると直前にkkdを置くのが一番フィットしているのでこのままです。
2. 00:55:012 (329,330) – 329delete, 330 add finish
   00:55:097 (330) – にfinisher欲しいです.5連だとアクセントには少し足りない気がします、、00:49:673 (292) – にはfinishがありますがここにはなく、また00:55:266 -にノーツがないので少し違和感残ります。 - kdk K に変更しました。 本当は00:55:266 -に何か置きたいですが…
3. 01:14:249 (438,439) – swap? - fixed. 手前のノーツも変更。

woc2006 wrote:

Due to the sound rule we confirmed lately, all mania diffs need proper hitsounds, eg. use drum for strong beat notes.

PROGUY wrote:

Hi there. Here's my mod as requested.
Sorry it had to be a bit late though, I was busy with some irl stuff.
Also holy crap that's a lot of diffs in this set o.o

[General]
01:06:283 Suggestion: Maybe you guys wanna add a small kiai fountain here? :p

[S.Star's NM]
00:22:215 Add another long note in 7th column that's the same length as the one in 1st column.
00:38:995 (38995|3) Change to normal note.
01:05:605 (65605|3) ^


Hope this helps! Good luck!

newtoniorock8 wrote:

awh :'( my diff have been removed.

1. 00:24:080 (4) - Nc, not necessarily required but recommended
2. 00:33:741 (5) - Nc, it's the begining of the kiai
3. 00:40:351 (7) - Nc
4. 01:04:249 (3) - Nc
5. 01:06:368 (1) - until 01:10:860 (7) - Try to rework your combo here, 16notes isn't really acceptable, a nc each stanzas should be basic but ok
6. 01:24:080 (5) - Nc
7. 01:27:809 (1,2) - Remove nc from (1) and add nc (2). Your combo begin before the kiai and finish during the kiai it's strange ...
8. 01:36:961 (6) - Nc

1. 00:11:707 (1,2) - Unstack and move (1) to x=320 and (2) to x=192. More movements and more interesting to play.
2. 00:14:419 (1,2,3,4,5) - Same idea but with a movement to the other side.
3. 00:20:182 (3) - During this stream increase the movement between and try to do something like a "S" . Btw the spacing here is broken 00:21:114 (4,5,6) -
4. 00:21:453 (8,1,1,1) - If it's really an overdose try to put hdash between those notes. For exemple if you change just the two sliders, 00:21:537 (1) - x=336 , 00:22:215 (1) - x=144
5. 00:27:470 (4,5,6,7) - More movement, no change for (4,5) http://puu.sh/5VpnG.jpg
6. 00:30:690 (1,2) - More movement, move (2) to x=480
7. 00:33:656 (4,5) - Add a little jump here
8. 00:35:097 (1) - 00:35:605 (3) - Curve them more
9. 00:37:300 (3) - Curve this one. If you do this there is more movements and the placement of the slider tick is more interesting http://puu.sh/5Vw4H.jpg
10. 00:41:707 (1) - until 00:43:571 (5) - Rework this stream, add more movements, more curves. Currently it's just straight and not funny :s
11. 00:46:707 (8,9) - Ctrl+g, to add a "break" in the movement
12. 00:54:080 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Try to do something more interesting like this http://puu.sh/5Vx3U.jpg
    
    Code for test

    408,228,53741,5,10,0:0:0:0:
    272,228,53910,1,0,0:0:0:0:
    384,168,54080,1,2,0:0:0:0:
    220,168,54249,1,2,0:0:0:0:
    364,108,54419,1,0,0:0:0:0:
    172,108,54588,1,8,0:0:0:0:
    344,48,54758,1,0,0:0:0:0:
    120,48,54927,1,2,0:0:0:0:

13. 00:57:470 (6,7) - More movement, a hdash between those notes should be also acceptable. Move (7) to x= 32 for exemple
14. 00:58:148 (1,2,3,4) - Ctrl+g (3,4) and unstack the notes at left
15. 01:00:690 (5,6,7,8) - Rework the curve here. The current appearance isn't perfect
16. 01:06:368 (1) - 01:14:080 (5) - During all this stream part try to add more little jump, curves or others kind of things like more insteresting for a player that just a straight streams.
17. 01:17:470 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Add more movements, a spacing of 0,30* isn't really interesting or fun. Especially this one 01:18:317 (2,3) -
18. 01:39:504 (3,4) - Ctrl+g (3) and so stack (4) with the head of (3).

1. 00:20:860 (9) - Nc
2. 00:21:876 (2) - and 00:22:554 (2) - Not necessarily required but recommended
3. 01:00:182 (9) - Nc
4. 01:02:893 (4,5,1,2,3) - Nc (4) , remove (1) , nc (3)
5. 01:08:148 (8) - Nc
6. 01:12:385 (6) - ^
7. 01:22:046 (8) - ^
8. 01:25:944 (7) - ^
9. 01:36:792 (9) - ^
10. 01:38:148 (5) - ^

1. 00:02:385 (8,1) - Add a little jump between those notes
2. 00:03:741 (8,1) - ^
3. 00:49:334 (5,6,7) - No hdash here ? The song requires one :s
4. 00:54:080 (1,2,3,4) - Curve this more ? At least tries to force the player to move to catch those notes.
5. 00:57:300 (3,4) - Increse the spacing here, don't change the placement of (3).
6. 01:48:995 (1,1,1) - This ending should be more epic :s

Niokin wrote:

diffs

PROGUY wrote:

Has the above post been applied to the set?

Priti wrote:

PROGUY wrote:

Has the above post been applied to the set?

Yis sir.

1. 00:20:775 (8,1) - can create a bit movement here? to make this and 00:21:453 (8,1) - this similar distance
2. 00:22:893 (1,2) - remove hyperdash. this part is not same hyper than previous, no need to hyperdash this.
   
3. 00:24:588 - note here and 00:25:012 - delete this note
4. 00:28:826 (3,4) - small movement here.
5. 00:28:995 (4,1) - jump here
   
   1

   
6. 00:29:504 (1,2,3,4) - off vocal suddenly... if it is your intention im fine with it, but still 00:29:673 (2) - im feeling like there is a heavy beat inside this slider. maybe you need to think more of the rhythm this part?
   
7. 00:32:385 (1,2,3,4) - suggestion
   
   to create movment at previous 4 and 1, then do a small reverse jump to make it more unique.

   
8. 00:37:978 (2,3,4) - reduce thsi jump, to remove the previous hyperdash.(just 2 grids on both side will be ok)
   
9. 00:38:826 (6) - reduce the spacing inside this slider will be better.
   
   1

   
10. 00:41:876 (1) - to 00:43:571 (5) - looks pretty nice in editor but very normal in actual play yard. next time I suggest just use 1 line to place stream, that will make life easier.
    
    
11. 00:44:080 - 00:44:165 - note, and please 00:43:910 (7,1) - "jumper" this part.
    
    
13. 00:45:266 (3,5) - stack nicely.
14. 00:45:775 (6) - center of the jump
15. 00:45:944 (1) - stack to (3) or (5) (i mean 00:45:605 (5) - ) to remove hyperdash 00:45:944 (1,2) -
16. 00:46:622 (4,5,6,7,8) - and this..... i can see this pattern in most of the unrank maps, but i think need to discuss a bit about it. plays fun but looks really bad...
    
17. 00:52:724 (6,7) - personally i dont like this hyperdash
18. 00:53:402 (8) - ctrl+G
19. 00:54:249 (2,4,6) - stack together better
20. 00:54:080 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - this series of pattern I think, 1,2 make them just jump(means you need to press shift half of the time to catch it), 3.4 make a big white jump, 5,6 make hyperdash. have a try.
    
    example (if it is not clear, 1,2 use x1.0, 3,4 use x1.4, 5,6 use x1.8)

    
21. 00:55:097 (1) - this should be inside the previous increase jump to create better flow
    
22. 00:59:165 (7) - i guess you need to use a stand stack jump here. just small jump+hyperdash not able to performing well here.
    
    
    i mean, do jump like this. but maybe you need to redesign the jump.

    
    
    
23. 01:00:521 (1,1) - remove hyperdash. or you may want to reduce 1 reverse of the slider
    
24. 01:00:860 (1,2,3,4) - i dont know exactly what you want here.. if you just want a calm slider please make the spacing consistant.
25. 01:02:215 (1,2,3,4) - god sudden hyerdash.. think twice before use.
26. 01:13:741 (1) - suggestion
    
    2 sliders to connect the slider and the note. dont know why you leave it blank here...

    
27. 01:40:690 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - dafaq this this pattern is really bad for a rank map. consider change it.
28. 01:48:317 (1,2,1,2) - please only hyperdash the last 2 slider.