lesjuh wrote:

I Love it man (approve extra stage itz awesum)

Only thing is the 1/6 notes in Lunatic @ 01:48:98 (13,14,15,1) Since you're not ranking Extra stage (wich has many more of these 1/6 notes) it would be great if you'd prevent me from missing and raise my score make this more readable with a slider or whatever. Leave it if you want, I only think it's a little confusing because the 1/4 streams have 0,3x spacing.

AND! What are the option images doing in the songs folder? D:

Dangaard wrote:

I would like to have Extra Stage in the ranked mapset rather than going for approval for this single diff. There are maps as hard as this (or even harder) already ranked.
Anyway star for this challenge-map :3

gopice wrote:

very nice map!!! I especially like the extra stage difficulty

But could you please put the stack leniency 1 tick to the right.
It's very hard to read the stacks, especially with the background.

Card N'FoRcE wrote:

Timing: wow, i thought 170,02 was wrong, but it seems to be ok xD

- Lunatic:
00:17:58 (8) - new combo? it doesn't quite fit
00:20:23 (9,10) - new combo at one of these? ^
01:00:63 (15) - new combo? Changed
01:08:40 (7) - new combo? Changed
02:06:27 (8) - ^ Changed
(My point is: there are some combos over 12/15. That's why i pointed them out )

- Extra stage:
fine

Anyway, there's omething that bugs me.
You set the map to Rarely Stack, but when testing or playing osu! doesn't apply that.
Can you check?

i know this is a problem. but i have no idea how to fix it. the only way to fix it is to put stack leniency to 0.1 but then reading becomes difficult for some people.

Anyway, map is awesome and i'll star anyway

EDIT: also, why menu-back.png? It's useless D: removed, thanks xD

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Extra stage:

SPOILER

Combo mod:
00:09:11 (2) - new combo for consistency with first 4 combos
00:11:93 (2) - ^

Lunatic:

SPOILER

The same things as extra stage.

Combo mod:
00:09:11 (2) - new combo for consistency with first 4 combos
00:11:93 (2) - ^

Nice map. Star.

DaRRi MIx wrote:

discussed on irc

what else is

Extra Stage
02:19:51 (7,8) - it's confusing if you put them here, how about move (7) down and move (8) up by some grids?i think its ok
02:27:80 (2,3,4,5,6) - wavy stream is ugly fixed
02:37:51 (2,3,4,5) - i suggest stack them [color=#0000Fdone][/color]
02:52:50 (4) - reverse arrow can't be seen i know.... but ok i'll change
02:57:27 (5,6) - flip vertically done
02:59:33 (4) - just put on 1/4 tick, it's too confusing
03:04:15 (1) - new combo done
03:06:97 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - not making sense im not sure what you mean? they follow the guitar in a 1/6 beat.

Echo wrote:

First off, make the changes to Japanese as suggested by tfxllvna above. At the moment it's really really awkward (google translate? )

BPM: 170.050, resnap all notes. Some sliders will become messed up; you'll need to play through and make sure these are as they used to be. are you sure it is .05? it sounds really off after the middle, and the 1/6 parts sounds like 1/8's now :s. not sure how to fix those anymore.

Lunatic:
00:49:52 (1,2,3) - keep it stacked, but make them all have the same spacing as 4 to 5 done
01:50:22 (4) - shorten by 1 repeat - this makes it more intuitive done, allthough i still think the last repeat goes with the guitar :s

made some additional combo changes to make it look better.

Extra:
both points for lunatic apply for extra done
02:59:30 (4) - move 1/8 earlier would be better I think (and respaced) hmm ok
03:06:97 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I agree with darri, this is wrong. This is most definitely 4/4 time, so use 1/4 snap (beats 1-3 are quavers, beat 4 is a crotchet) to me it sounded like i was following the guitar tones. i think i fixed it now though...

Point out any other places you used 1/6 so I can check them please

1/6 that needs rechecking are
00:49:63 (2,3) -
01:43:32 (11,12,13) -
01:48:96 (13,14,15) -
02:58:47 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - this odd now after the bpm change :s



Somehow I get this feeling that you ran out of ideas when mapping (03:16:85 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) in Extra
true, i will re pattern/re note.

and the huge copy/pasted section in the middle).
please point out from where to where it's copy pasted. im against copy pasta (eventually it happens in the rythm) and will change cause i can't remember copying anything.

01:50:22 (4) - done, allthough i still think the last repeat goes with the guitar :s

Echo wrote:

Sorry about the BPM - I don't know what I was thinking ._. definitely 170.02

Extra:
00:49:51 (1,2,3,4,5) - should be identical to hard? due to slider velocity the spacing becomes different, but i have copied it in now
02:58:47 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - is definitely 4/4 as well i don't know what happened but i think i can hear this now xD
03:07:68 (5) - definitely 4/4 done ^

The other ones are tuplets, so using 1/6 divisor is fine.

(just so you know - I'm going through this at 75% in edit)

about this:

01:50:22 (4) - done, allthough i still think the last repeat goes with the guitar :s

The last repeat does indeed go with the guitar, but how many people will know what the guitar is playing, and at that speed? However, with one less repeat, it becomes identical to the 2 and 3 sliders which is what I think people would be expecting from that slider.
alright

0_o wrote:

Extra Stage
01:12:63 (1,2) - Ctrl-R this, it fits better imo i like how you think ^_^however i only reversed 1, then i put 2 on 1's end point

b]Lunatic[/b]
00:49:52 (1) - Stack on top of 2? *suggestion*
00:52:69 (4,5) - New combo on one of these done
01:48:98 (13,14,15,1) - I would turn this into a 1/4 stream personally But echo approved of my 1/6 :<

*

Gabi wrote:

@Echo: im not sure if cyclone can fix those right now.

0_o wrote:

Are ranked/approved mapsets allowed yet? Because if this had an easier difficulty I bet Lunatic could be ranked...

Echo wrote:

I guess the sliders at the end of Extra could be worked on