Legenda wrote:

Unrankable | Good ideas | My doubts | ♥ Greetings | * Just comments

Lines without icons are Mods.

[Gero's Easy]
♥ Nice diff. No complaints. I tested it with HD+HR+DT and had just 1 miss due to my laziness >< but no 100s. Rhythms where they shall be, flows well, good use of whistles (fits to the song) and so on. Rankable.

[Xin's Normal]
♥ Tested with DT, got just 1 of 100s due to my laziness >< but NO misses. Good rhythms on the song, on beat (nothing off), flows well

[Hard]
♥ Well made and singletappeable ♥
02:02:621 (4) - Move to x:240 y:168, so flow will be a bit nicer than now (; and also for unglueing from 02:03:948 (3)
♥ 02:42:444 (1) - Good use of slowing here

[Insane]
* Testplay → http://puu.sh/4HM3n.osr
♥ No complaints too. It's almost singletappeable too (it's very rare find Insanes suitable to singletapping).

UndeadBananaz wrote:

Hello. From #modreqs.

Gero's Easy

• 02:29:170 (3) - This slider overlaps. The whole difficulty looks so neat and this is pretty much the only thing that strangely overlaps. Just for the sake of keeping it pretty, maybe do something like this: I like how it looks, in addition this overlap is intentional to me, so I'll keep it.

SPOILER

Xin's Normal

• 01:31:293 (1,2,3,4) - I think changing this combo into:

would sound better, because it will follow the style of the previous 3 combos and will feel more comfortable to play. Nice suggestion.. Fixed.

Hard
• 03:15:895 (3,4) - The second slider looks kinda weird and out of place like that, maybe: I like this little overlap, I find it well looking.

SPOILER

Insane
• 00:55:187 (1,2) - I really would have preferd to play it like this (because of the vocals): Reduced (1) in 1/4.

Or maybe without the note on the blue tick if you don't like it, but definitely ending the first slider on the red one sounds better due to the vocals.
• 01:48:285 (1,2) - - I would do the same with these 2 sliders as above. Fixed
• 02:41:913 (1,2,3,4) - You could try to position this stream slightly closer to the previous one. Just move it down a wee bit. I don't find any problem with this pattern, due to the low bpm is pretty easy to follow.
• 02:54:125 (1,2) - Same as the first two points. I'll keep this one because it is not a similar section.

I thought the map overall was excellent. The song is pretty decent as well. Hope this helped. Good luck!

-Kirito wrote:

hi From Kritio's Modding Queuse (Normal / M4M)

[Gero's Easy]
x_x;; Fixed xD Sorry for the spam

\:D/

-Kirito wrote:

hi From Kritio's Modding Queuse (Normal / M4M) Hi!

[Gero's Easy]
x_x;;

[Xin's Normal]
00:29:701 - whistle add?
00:38:196 - ^ Both added (and added some other one for consistency )
00:50:939 (4) - NC add? I don't find it necessary, follows better the music without it
03:17:488 - vol +15%? Used 30% instead.

[Hard]
00:38:196 (5) - NC add? Nice one.. Added.
00:47:754 (8) - ^ I don't find this one really necessary.
01:03:417 (5,6,1) - coordinate move? 5 x:260 y:188, 6 x:256 y:204, 7 x:252 y:220 I did something similar here, but not exactly the same.
01:08:993 (6) - NC add? Nah..
03:04:214 (10) - crtl + h? Okeii.. You're not the first suggesting me that, so I think I'm wrong xD
03:17:488 (8) - vol -25%? Used 30% instead.

[Insane]
00:42:444 (10) - NC add? Hmm.. No.. Is not needed here I think.
01:10:586 (6) - delete the Arrowhead and
01:11:116 (7) - after moving to 01:11:116 - , 1/1 slide to change Prefer to keep that because actually is following vocals

BOX1

01:14:833 (3,4) - part change? I'm following drums in this case.

BOX2

01:31:293 (5) - NC add? Hmm.. k
02:00:762 (7,8) - coordinate move? number 7 x:440 y:148 , 8 x:428 y:124 I personally prefer the current pattern and the current effect on it.
02:09:524 (10) - change as quiet sound? (soft) Used a drum finisher instead.
02:39:789 (1,1) - NC reomove? I use this kind of NCs when I use that kind of patterns so I prefer to keep that because is part of my style
03:17:488 (11) - vol -25%? Used 30% instead.

\:D/

Gero wrote:

-Kirito wrote:

hi From Kritio's Modding Queuse (Normal / M4M)

[Gero's Easy]
x_x;; Fixed xD Sorry for the spam

\:D/

1. 00:28:904 (3,4,1,2,3) - Not sure if a mistake or not but the spacing on this whole pattern is different from each object.

1. 02:27:046 (3,4) - Spacing is a bit too close here, I'd use same distance here as well.