El SolarBeam wrote:

Yeay for M4M in-game request \:D/


[Beginner]

00:28:484 Add NC here, then remove NC at 00:28:929 for consistency No
00:32:484 Still hearing a louder tone, rise the hitsound here to 30% I'll reconsider this
00:40:484 Well, you could modify the volume here by adding whistle to the snaking slider then create a ladder of hitsound volume in each white tick, for example : 40%, 35%, 30%, and last 25% (i know this is troublesome, but bear with it XD) I'll reconsider this
00:43:151 (3) Not a consistent slider with the previous (1), maybe change to normal/reverse slider Yes It's on purpose
00:48:484 I hear an echo here somehow (hear it for the details), so maybe put a circle with a reduced hitsound I hear nothing, I just follow the flute sound so no change
01:14:707 (3) Maybe don't stack this because having quite different tone, so it might break the flow I'll let It be
01:24:040 (1,2,3,4) You could make a hitsound ladder from these as well I'll reconsider this
01:26:707 Reduce the hitsound here.. a little Not necessary
01:48:929 (1,2) This should only has 2 slider tick rate I didn't see anything wrong
01:52:484 Somehow I prefer long slider here instead of spinner (considering the spinner is short as well) But I prefer a spinner
Not many problem with the mapping style, but be caution not to do too many stacking on an easy diff

[Standard]

00:10:262 (1) Lower the hitsound a little Not necessary
00:48:484 Quoting the easy diff in this timing I hear nothing, I just follow the flute sound so no change
00:59:596 (3,1) Blanket perfectly It's suppsed not to be blanked in the first place
01:32:707 Maybe add circle No
Nice diff, just recheck some spacing (I felt there's some x0.9 and the other x1.0, not sure about this) It's on purpose, Since the 1.0 spacing is on kiai time, someone tell me that before

Lizbeth wrote:

in the kiai time spacing is smaller, usually mappers put bigger spacing in kiai time cuz is more "challenging" and blah blah, but switching it to smaller is veeeery confusing and doesnt makes sense in my opinion.

so thanks for reminding
And follow the easy diff for the hitsound volume if you consider changing some easy diff's hitsound fluctuation

good luck all indonesian mappers >.<)/

El SolarBeam wrote:

Yeay for M4M in-game request \:D/

[theramdan's Hyper]

00:18:262 Remove the reverse slider and add 2 circle instead ~ ok
00:39:596 (4) Normal slider sounds better imo (maybe because more slider tick) ~I keep it on soft sampleset
00:40:484 Reduce hitsound here (around 45%) and at 00:41:373 (around 35%) so it makes a hitsound ladder ~ok
01:07:151 (5,6,7,8) Make a hitsound ladder ~ok
01:09:596 Maybe remove circle to reduce strain from getting spinner (1/2 beat difference is not good for diff except insane) ~ok
01:37:373 (7) Another hitsound ladder could be made (from low hitsound to higher one ofc)[i]~ok[/i]
01:40:929 Clap here not sounds fitting imo, and here too 01:41:818 ~ok changed
nice diff, I can't point out that much since there's so manny modders already ;_;


good luck all indonesian mappers >.<)/

YielShelion wrote:

halo~
sejauh ini udah lumayan perfect
...but, wow, udah banyak amat yang ngemod masih perlu mod? D:

theramdans's Hyper

00:11:819 (2) pindahkan ke tengah2 antara sliderEnd 1 dengan sliderStart 3 (x: 264,y: 124) Aku kurang ngerti kak maksud yang ini
01:16:234 (7) pindahkan ke tengah2 lagi (x: 112, y: 164) Ga begitu perlu kak
01:18:040 (4, 5, 6,7, 8, 9) gak terlalu kebawah ya? ._. bisa agak di-tengah-in? Ga terlalu ke bawah kok kak, kalo di manini jg ga kepotong slidernya
01:21:596 (4, 5, 6, 7) agak jauh, coba keempat2nya dipindahin ke x:152 y:172 (http://puu.sh/5F6qc.jpg) Yang itu sengaja kak, dibuat sedikit jump
01:30:397 (7) pindahkan ke (x: 108 y :244) Ga begitu perlu kak
01:50:707 bintangnya penyek =w= Ih ga penyek tau, but fxed some placement of circles though

itu aja keknya, sisanya udah bagus kok :3
moga ranked yak

tellertheworld wrote:

[kapursirih's Another]

open

01:10:707 - circle here(not important)
01:10:929 - ^(not important)
01:11:040 - ^(not important)
01:40:484 - circle here
01:40:707 - slider here 2/4

[LC's EX]

open

01:29:373 - circle here
01:32:484 (1) - something wrong in rhythm

Nice song~
nothing any important mistake~
Good luck for you~

Loli Cjj wrote:

no change because that all was intentional. Not gonna make them overlap. Sorry

On the other hand I think I'll remap this.

360,88,83151,5,8,0:0:0:0:
396,72,83262,1,0,0:0:0:0:
432,56,83373,1,0,0:0:0:0:
472,60,83484,1,0,0:0:0:0:
512,68,83596,1,0,0:0:0:0:

wendao2000 wrote:

quick mod
[General]
add Loli Cjj to tags, coz Saturnalize has ranked beatmap with his old nickname Ok
add Naoyuki Sato Tomoaki Hirono to tags, they both are the composer Ok
add NOMADIC NATION to tags, it's the genre Ok
add also sunny park rhythmin jubeat saucer to tags, coz this song appear in pop'n music sunny park, pop'n rhythmin & jubeat saucer too Ok

bagaimana kalo ganti diff name sama kayak mapset ini? Kayanya ga perlu deh

[Beginner]
Rating 8/10 || quitely clean
clean, grats from me (:

[Standard]
Rating: 7/10 || slider 3x repeat sedikit mengganggu juga sih :/
OD+1, biar balance
01:34:485 (1,2,3) - woah woah, 1/4 in Standard (Normal)?
rest fine

1. 00:17:818 (1,2) - swap NC
2. 00:23:596 (4) - NC. Stacking maybe give confusion to newbie player.
3. 00:48:929 (1) - perfectly stack on (347, 158)
4. 00:56:485 (3) - move to (256, 260)
5. 01:17:818 (3) - move to (148,180) for perfect triangle
6. 01:52:484 (1) - blanket. 6th slider point move to (44,232)
7. 01:52:484 (1) - this part is loud than before part and after part. make more high sound as 50%

1. 00:38:707 (4) - NC for emphasis
2. 00:43:151 (4) - NC?
3. 01:09:596 (1) - whistle on not end of slider but head of slider
4. 01:13:151 (2) - Normal Clap on end of slider
5. 01:43:596 (6) - NC
6. 01:44:929 (1,2) - swap NC
7. 01:50:707 (3) - finish on not end of slider but head of slider
8. 01:56:040 - same on Easy Diff modding

1. 00:17:373 (3) - finish
2. 00:21:819 (2) - little blanket. 1 grid up 2nd slider point
3. 00:31:596 (4) - finish
4. 00:34:263 (2) - finish on head of slider
5. 00:39:152 (3) - S:C1 finish
6. 01:15:152 (6) - NC?
7. 01:30:707 (8) - distance is 1.19x. fix to 1.0x

1. 00:07:596 (2) - S:C1 finish on head of slider
2. 00:16:707 (1,4,5,8) - how about adding whistle?
3. 00:39:151 (6) - finish
4. 01:00:040 (6) - drum finish
5. 01:06:262 (5) - perfectly stack on 01:04:484 (1)'s location
6. 01:14:707 (6) - NC?
7. 01:29:373 (7,1) - swap NC

1. 00:55:596 (1) - drum finish

Pjecoo wrote:

Hi.
From My queue.
You don't have to take my mod seriously.

Normal:
01:12:929 - Put here circle? If I put circle there, It'll ruin the curent rhythm
01:54:262 (1) - Remove NC. No, the previous NC that has cymbal was NC so to keep concistency

I looked at your other diffs. And I didn't find any problem (at least for me).
I like the song. I remember I modded something like this. Anyways, nice mapset.
Hope that'll helps
If not, then sorry.
Good Luck!

hanyuu_nanodesu wrote:

Hai kak, ketemu lagi~
New modder, sorry for bad mod
Yay, happy song~! ^^

[Normal]
00:51:596 (1) - Unnecessary spinner? Too fill the empty space, I don't want to put drain time there
01:26:707 (4) - Pindahin ke x:72,y:348 ? Ok
01:35:596 (2) - Blanket Ok
01:52:484 (1) - Dipas-in lagi sama note berikutnya? http://puu.sh/8YWZj/8a11a9787e.jpg Ok

[Hyper]
HP ---> 5 Ok, I geuss HP 6 just too hard
01:26:151 - Add a note, jadiin triplet? Sure, sound good

[Sakata's Another]
01:12:040 (8) - Blanket Ok
01:21:373 (5) - Stack properly Ok

Okeh itu aja, ngga nemu banyak Udah bagus mapnya ^^

btw, aku add friend ya kak ^^

Regou wrote:

Oh hi, from BMT modding queue
[Hyper]
00:18:040 (6,1) - Make the jump smaller to improve diff spread (Optional, it works well in fact) I decrease some jumps
01:06:707 (1,2,3,4,5) - It is not a perfect star ;w; Fixed, honestly I don't know to make good blanket or any shape jumps
omg that kiai it is way too hard for hyper. It is ever harder than the one in another OMG hahaha XD, will consider to reduece later, well in kiai time I increase the SV but still use 1.5 DS
dat spacing QWQ....
01:49:818 (3,4) - omg that is way too hard for hyper
This diff isn't bad at all. What I concern is that it is way too difficult lol

[Normal]
01:00:929 (1,2) - Improve blanket. Same as the next copy&pasted pattern Fixed
01:09:818 (1,2,3) - Make them into perfect triangle? It's already good triangle with 1.00 DS
01:38:262 (1,2) - Improve blanket. The current one is good
01:40:040 (3) - oooo the shape can be improved Fixed into curve one

That's all! Good luck~

Yauxo wrote:

[EX]

1. I suck at cs5 modding D:
   
2. 00:07:151 (5,1) - have either 5 go into the same direction as 1 goes or the other way around. would look better imo - intentional triangle slider 00:06:262 (3,4,5) - so no
3. 00:24:484 (1) - remove NC - no, It's for the changing accent
4. 00:26:262 (3,2) - fix overlap - done
5. 00:32:262 (7) - this gap feels really weird and I think it'd be better mapped out - I'm not going to do it, I want to make a kind of stop.
6. 00:52:929 (1) - fix this positioning, assuming its not intended - unfortunately, it is.
7. 01:08:040 (1) - spinner? - I would prefer hold note rather than spinner (too bad it's illegal). Also spinner ruins the buildup sound.

Yauxo wrote:

Hi there, coming from your request in my Modding Q
(I'll just assume that the pink was written in red and not in pink itself) Pink in Red !

[General]

1. lovely song o: <3

[Normal]

1. If your mappingstyle is made out of blankets, try to map them as perfect as possible! Dont be scared to take gridsnap off to do this. Infos in the blanket box
   
   Blankets that can be improved

   00:16:484 (3,4,1) - 3 and 4 have a different spacing as 4 and 1 have. 1 can also be improved
   00:19:596 (2,3) -
   00:21:373 (4,1,2) -
   00:28:485 (6,1) -
   00:32:040 (1,2) - to check the correct blanketing, place a circle on 1's end and check the approach circle
   00:34:707 (1,2,3,4) - ^
   00:40:484 (2,3) -
   00:46:262 (3,4) -
   01:00:929 (1,2) -
   01:04:039 (4,1) -
   01:13:817 (2,3) -
   01:24:040 (1,2) -
   01:28:484 (3,4,5) -
   01:35:151 (1,2) -
   01:38:262 (1,2) -
   01:41:373 (4,1) -
   01:43:151 (2,3) -
   01:45:818 (1,2,3) -
   01:48:484 (4,1) -
   01:48:484 (4,1) -
   01:52:040 (2,1) - slightly off, no big deal imo
   01:52:484 (1,1) - Fixed some
2. 00:02:262 (1,1) - I dont think that these NCs are necessary here For the first part, I follow one stanza to make new combo, I think It's not a problem here since the combo I make is consitent for both diffs
3. 00:13:818 (3) - Move this one either up or down to create more flow. A straight line this can be more fun! :3 Sure
4. 01:09:818 (1,2,3) - change 1 so that 1 2 and 3 create a perfect triangle Fixed
5. 01:28:484 (3,5) - overlap is incorrect. ctrl+g to see the slider's endpoint and move the overlap to the coord afterwards

Fixed

[Hyper]

• 
  
  Blankets that can be improved

  00:56:484 (5,1) -
  01:04:484 (1,3) -
  01:24:040 (3,1) - Fixed some

1. 00:02:262 (1,1) - Same combo related issue as in Normal For the first part, I follow one stanza to make new combo, I think It's not a problem here since the combo I make is consitent for both diffs
2. 00:10:707 (1) - remove NC That's an anti jump so most people will NC that
3. 00:24:929 (1) - ^ ^
4. 01:00:484 (1) - ^ ^
5. 01:04:040 (1) - ^ ^
6. 01:08:040 (1) - spinner here maybe, as the sound slowly builds up? I prefer leave It that way, a drain should be ok
7. 01:10:484 (4) - move this one up as you have it 01:17:596 (4) - It's Intended
8. 01:30:707 (13,1) - reduce the DS between those to fit the DS the jumps before have Inteded a jump stream on that part
9. 01:32:484 (6) - change this one into 1/2 repeatable. Its this way in the EX as well I hear a 1/3 drum sound on that one, so It's not a problem
   
   SPOILER

   
   if image is not showing: http://puu.sh/99b4D/95ca43c7dd.jpg

Gl with your mapset, looks pretty much finished already :3 Yeah I know, find a BAT is super hard and I hope will get one soon

paraoka wrote:

from modding queue.

there's so many modders

[Hyper]
i know can't use red line with green line in same. - 00:00:485 I use that green line to have diffrent SV in the first part, since It sound more soft there, so I geuss It's ok

01:32:484 (6) - unclap at slider start and 2 reverses. No, It will sound weird, and I follow the drum backsound instead

other diff pretty done.

it's best map during do mod map. :3 Thank you so much for checking
gl rank and get my star X3 Thanks

-[ Asuna ]- wrote:

Hi~
tau dapet dari mana.. tiba'' pengen modding..
asal cari aja.. dpt'a map indo :3 yowes..
gk banyak yang bisa dibantu.. tapi berharap ini membantu..

[Normal]
01:18:707 (4,5) - blanket ? kalo diblanket tetep 1.0x ds kok..
yang lain udah bagus.. :3 Biarin aja kak, nanti beloknya jadi ga natural

[hyper]
01:32:484 (6,1,2,3) - how about this ? benerin hitsoundnya juga,, Nada yang sekarang juga udah bagus kok, aku ngikutin loli soalnya dan nadanya pas sama lagunya

SPOILER

01:37:374 (4,1) - kasih pergerakan di 01:37:818 jadi pendekin slider dan add slider Aku ga ngerti sama yang ini kak

SPOILER

dan mungkin polanya gini.. :3

SPOILER

actually i'm not pro at another and extra.. >w< c teehee..
noob Std.. lagipula dilihat dari pola juga udah bagus..

oce.. good luck hope this helped.. meski.. agak kurang bersemangat.. karna nganggur nih.. gk ada kerjaan :3

Fort wrote:

quick mod by Fort
translate to Indonesian cause you're indonesian right xD


[Another]
Percobaan pertama -> http://puu.sh/9Amn0/1b621ca9b7.osr
Percobaan kedua -> http://puu.sh/9Amxv/eb4ddce686.osr

Pertama, sebaiknya diffname diubah jadi Susilo's Another, karena jika Sakata's another kemungkin org lain akan bingung antara Mako sakata dengan susilo sakata Biarin aja kak, lagian itu kemauan pembuat diffnya kasih nama kaya gitu, lagian ga ada salahnya kan Sakata juga termasuk nama user id dia, not a big deal

Kedua, keliatannya diff ini masih dikatakan insane, karena star rating dibawah 4.00 (saya juga enggak tau kenapa bisa seperti itu, mungkin karena low BPM) Memang engga susah kak, itu tau salah satu alasanya

Ketiga, diff ini kurang feel, dikarenakan combo colours tidak diatur. pergantian SV juga kurang bisa dibaca oleh pemain, jadi diusahakan gunakan combo colours (misalnya warna terang untuk SV cepat, warna gelap untuk SV lambat) Aku di sini engga pake warna spesifik buat berubahan SV, karena aku pandang ga perlu jadi aku cuma pake warna in-general aja

untuk masalah pattern sebenarnya sudah dapat dikatakan rankable atau siap di rank, saya hanya menyarankan hal diatas tadi agar lebih perfect lagi Beatmapnya

imoutosan wrote:

From queue

[Easy]
00:20:040 (3) - fix blanket
00:21:818 (1) - ^
00:50:262 (4) - x339 y90 Fixed all

[Normal]
00:52:484 (1,2,3,1) - I guess this isn't suit for a Normal diff.
01:23:151 (5,6,1) - ^Will ask bat about that thing, thanks for noticing

[Hyper]
00:16:484 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - This part is too difficult for a Hyper diff imo. reduce the spacing plz (especially the triplets) I guess that's ok, it's Hyper you know
01:15:373 (7,8,9) - stack properly Fixed
01:16:040 (10,1) - jump is too large. also flow isn't very well. remove the reverse and add a note at 10's end? That's a jump, I put that downward on purpose and it flow naturally from down to up
01:50:818 (1,1,1) - I don't think it's a good idea to use this pattern in Hyper. It's just confusing. I don't think so

[Ex]
00:15:151 (2) - 2nd grid x290 y154 Fixed
00:25:151 (3) - 60% vol could be better Fixed
01:00:929 (1,2) - seems too close compared with other patterns It's ok, I believe Saturnalize does some measurment there
01:22:855 (1,2,3,4,5) - I'm sure sliders beginning at redlines will be better. also the music doesn't have 1/3 here. Probably ok, but will ask bat to make sure on that thing, thanks for noticing

Well done map. Maybe there's a difficulty gap between Normal and Hyper but I think it's fine. star