forum

Ray Greene - My Best Friends

posted
Total Posts
86
show more
Lust
From my queue! Sorry this is late

[Easy]
  1. 00:29:968 (4,1) - better as a blanket
very nicely put together!

And that was all I could really find, take my star!
Topic Starter
Lanturn

Lust wrote:

From my queue! Sorry this is late

[Easy]
  1. 00:29:968 (4,1) - better as a blanket
very nicely put together!

And that was all I could really find, take my star!

ahh, well thanks for the star. 4,1 is actually already blanketed although it doesn't quite look like it. Thanks for taking a look at the map though :3
Asphyxia
Hi there! This is a placeholder for a mod so I can remember :3



[General thoughts]

  1. Well, I'm not an expert at this but shouldn't you have widescreen support on? Not sure ._.
  2. Inconsistency in Kiai Times:
[Easy]

  1. 00:16:284 (1) - I think here's a small distance problem? Also, if you would make the slider more curvy it would fit better :3
  2. 00:51:981 (4) - Have you ever thought about doing it like this? It would make a cool blanket between 00:51:386 (3,4) - and it would fit your style well!
  3. 01:34:817 (2) - Move this sliders end few grids down to make a better blanket!
  4. 02:33:418 (3) - How's this?
  5. 02:30:741 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - This combo is quite long compared to your other ones, I'd recommend NC'ing somewhere 02:36:392 (5) - here.
  6. 02:44:424 (4) - You should add a NC here since you added a NC 01:22:323 (1) - too?
  7. Well done!
[Normal]

  1. 00:17:177 (2) - I was thinking something like this, what do you like?
    If you apply this you would need to fix some spacing erros with the next objects but it shouldn't be a problem.
  2. 00:36:512 (2) - Well, just a curve suggestions, see below if you like it ^^
  3. 01:37:196 (1) - Similar suggestion as above
  4. 01:42:551 (6) - You probably should NC this, I don't think it belongs to 01:41:658 (5) - this combo anymore.
  5. Great!
[Hard]

  1. 01:20:241 (4,5) - Should be a better blanket?
  2. 02:10:216 (1) - I don't think this NC is really necessary.
  3. This difficulty was really well made!
Nice choice of music, I really enjoyed it! Gonna throw you a star to help. Hope this helped and GL for rank :3
Topic Starter
Lanturn
Thank you for the mod. I'm going to be getting to this in a few moments.

Widescreen suppport isn't used because a lot of the pictures are 4:3 and I'd have to zoom in the pictures really far to actually make them fit.

Finishing rest of the mod right now :)
Asphyxia

Asphyxia wrote:

Hi there! This is a placeholder for a mod so I can remember :3



[General thoughts]

  1. Well, I'm not an expert at this but shouldn't you have widescreen support on? Not sure ._. I mentioned this above, because of the 4:3 pictures I used and zooming too much would ruin the quality a ton.
  2. Inconsistency in Kiai Times: Fixed thanks. somehow my normal missed the last kiai fountain. There is probably a good chance I accidentally deleted it when I was playing with hitsounds last week.
[Easy]

  1. 00:16:284 (1) - I think here's a small distance problem? Also, if you would make the slider more curvy it would fit better :3 Changed quite a bit here. Some shapes and all that. Should look much better now.
  2. 00:51:981 (4) - Have you ever thought about doing it like this? It would make a cool blanket between 00:51:386 (3,4) - and it would fit your style well! Made some changes around this point as well. a few more return circles which should look better
  3. 01:34:817 (2) - Move this sliders end few grids down to make a better blanket! Fixed this, thanks.
  4. 02:33:418 (3) - How's this? it does look nice, but I wanted to somewhat try to follow the idea of 02:29:551 (5,1) - although it didn't end up. I tried shifting this around a bit more. Should be better.
  5. 02:30:741 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - This combo is quite long compared to your other ones, I'd recommend NC'ing somewhere 02:36:392 (5) - here. oh. Yeah definitely. I NC'd at the lead-in parts such as "All the times" and "We will go"
  6. 02:44:424 (4) - You should add a NC here since you added a NC 01:22:323 (1) - too? Yes, I fixed this with the mod just above this.
  7. Well done! Thank you :)
[Normal]

  1. 00:17:177 (2) - I was thinking something like this, what do you like?
    If you apply this you would need to fix some spacing erros with the next objects but it shouldn't be a problem. instead of this, I changed it around differently. Should look good now.
  2. 00:36:512 (2) - Well, just a curve suggestions, see below if you like it ^^ Sure, that works good. that slider felt too straight I agree XD
  3. 01:37:196 (1) - Similar suggestion as above Actually, instead of that, I went and curved it more than what I originally had. I like how it looks from this.
  4. 01:42:551 (6) - You probably should NC this, I don't think it belongs to 01:41:658 (5) - this combo anymore. Big error on my part, and I know why.. I recently changed a part here, and I guess I goofed up on double checking the combos.. Fixed!
  5. Great!
[Hard]

  1. 01:20:241 (4,5) - Should be a better blanket? Sure, fixed this up a bit.
  2. 02:10:216 (1) - I don't think this NC is really necessary. True I guess. Changed.
  3. This difficulty was really well made! Thanks
I fixed one section near the end I didn't like as well.. other than that, it should be good to go and up to date.

Nice choice of music, I really enjoyed it! Gonna throw you a star to help. Hope this helped and GL for rank :3 Thank you!

Thank you for the mod :)
The-Gabe
Couldn't find anything to say about your Easy and Normal difficulties. :)

Hard

00:07:657 I would add 1 circle here. It sounds better IMO
00:10:037 and another one here.
00:27:886 ^
00:35:620 ^
00:45:139 ^
00:55:253 ^
00:59:417 ^
01:03:582 ^
01:08:937 ^
01:18:456 ^
01:25:000 ^
01:56:532 ^
02:10:811 ^
02:47:101 ^
02:54:836 ^
03:07:329 ^
03:18:633 ^
03:18:931 ^
03:20:121 ^
03:21:311 ^

Please respect my suggestions..... :) Awesome map you got overall.
Umi

dkun wrote:

Strolling through #modreqs~ Please call me back when you have more mods and over +15! :o
>3</
Topic Starter
Lanturn

-Umi- wrote:

dkun wrote:

Strolling through #modreqs~ Please call me back when you have more mods and over +15! :o
>3</
<3 Map needs more mods though :(

Will get to YOURS' mod in a few minutes.
Topic Starter
Lanturn
YOURS

YOURS wrote:

Couldn't find anything to say about your Easy and Normal difficulties. :)

Hard

00:07:657 I would add 1 circle here. It sounds better IMO Definitely not. There is no audible instrument here
00:10:037 and another one here. Same as above
00:27:886 ^ ^
00:35:620 ^ ^
00:45:139 ^ ^
00:55:253 ^ I don't want a note here because the vocals stand out way to much and gives off the empty feeling when there isn't any.
00:59:417 ^ ^
01:03:582 ^ ^
01:08:937 ^ This needs the spacing after the long stream.
01:18:456 ^ ^
01:25:000 ^ Vocal gap
01:56:532 ^ The way I have the 1/4 slider set up would make it strange to play, so no additions
02:10:811 ^ ^
02:47:101 ^ Breathing room to set up for the stream, and also the vocals end before this
02:54:836 ^ 1/4 slider finish
03:07:329 ^ Vocal Gap
03:18:633 ^ For the rest of these, I only follow the vocals and no drums, so I can't add anything here. This matches up with my Easy / Normal difficulties as well as I want to keep them similar.
03:18:931 ^
03:20:121 ^
03:21:311 ^

Please respect my suggestions..... :) Awesome map you got overall.

Sorry... But this mod really doesn't help at all. Adding notes will not make a map better. I don't think its fair to give KDs for this mod as there personally isn't anything I could use.
Itachi_Uchiha
Easy
  1. 00:18:961 (3) - Improve the curve a bit (Here is a code :O)
    SPOILER
    256,180,18961,2,0,B|344:124|344:124|296:8|176:40|152:136,1,350,0|12,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
  2. 00:34:132 (4) - ^
    SPOILER
    492,180,34132,2,0,B|453:244|406:243|347:227|323:182|323:182|280:252,1,280,0|4,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
  3. 02:29:551 (5,1) - Overlay out of nowhere - It looks a bit messy
  4. 02:32:228 (2,3) - ^

    Relatively flawless easy - Can´t say much about it^^ Well done

Normal
Really good diff - Can´t say anything helpful - Maybe it looks a bit too pushed - Spacing +0.2 and adjust it maybe?

Hard
  1. 00:19:556 (6,7,8) - ctrl+j and then readjust? Plays better in my opinion^^
     
    Awesome diff - Sliders are really nice and individual - Only thing to mention is, as I already said, maybe a bit much Kiai

    And because of super short and ultra useless mod - Take a Star^^
Topic Starter
Lanturn
Itachi_Uchiha

Itachi_Uchiha wrote:

Easy
  1. 00:18:961 (3) - Improve the curve a bit (Here is a code :O) Moved some stuff around here. Should be better. Made the slider after a bit nicer.
  2. 00:34:132 (4) - ^ fixed this, and changed the previous slider a bit as well.
  3. 02:29:551 (5,1) - Overlay out of nowhere - It looks a bit messy I like the overlay how it is, so I wanted to keep this.
  4. 02:32:228 (2,3) - ^ Same as above.

    Relatively flawless easy - Can´t say much about it^^ Well done

Normal
Really good diff - Can´t say anything helpful - Maybe it looks a bit too pushed - Spacing +0.2 and adjust it maybe? I don't think it's neccessary. The spacing should be fine enough as is and it lets me blanket stuff nicely.

Hard
  1. 00:19:556 (6,7,8) - ctrl+j and then readjust? Plays better in my opinion^^ Fixed, I agree this is much better.
     
    Awesome diff - Sliders are really nice and individual - Only thing to mention is, as I already said, maybe a bit much Kiai

    And because of super short and ultra useless mod - Take a Star^^

Thanks for mod and star :)
Moway
Wheeeeeeeee

this song is so corny i love it

nazi mod coming, prepare your butt i am so sorry

[General]

tags: Add "Heroes", "Puzzle", "League" to the tags. This song was in Pokemon Heroes as well as Pokemon Puzzle League so those tags are pretty good I think.

I think you'll be alright on the kiai times, maybe remove it for the fade out, but apart from that I don't think the kiai use in this song is a big problem.

dat storyboard tho

[Easy]

00:16:284 (1) - move the 2nd midpoint back a bit, right now I think the curve is a bit too bunched toward the slider end.
00:26:398 (1) - lower the 2nd red point a bit for a better blanket on that 2nd curve of the slider.
00:34:132 (4) - red point to (316,176) for a better blanket I think, or somewhere around there.
01:06:854 (4,5) - nazi blanket fix here
01:22:323 (1) - this slider is a bit ugly to me, and it doesn't have any blanket interaction with any other sliders so I think for this one make it into a more regular S-shape, which looks nicer as a stand alone slider.
01:30:057 (1) - I don't think this spinner is necessary. Leave it out and let the player have a longer break.
01:32:437 - if you take the previous suggestion, add a circle here.
01:57:127 (1,2) - I think the blanket interaction between these sliders could be improved.
02:04:266 (3) - adjust the bottom curve on this one a bit so that it blankets 02:05:754 (1) a bit better. http://puu.sh/5sCN7.jpg
02:08:133 (1,1) - There might not be enough time here between the spinner and the next object. I think you could end the spinner at 02:09:918, which is another strong beat and it would be okay.
02:24:197 (4) - a bit nazi here, but move this to (304,132) to be a perfect reflection of 02:23:602 (3).
02:24:792 (1) - (376,66) XD
02:30:741 (1) - make the finish here louder, right now it is at 30% thanks to the red line
02:34:905 (1) - remove finish from the slider head
02:36:392 (2,3) - fix up this blanket a bit, this one will look much better as a perfect blanket
02:39:665 (1) - remove the finish from the slider head too, I think having them there takes away from the finish on the real strong part, which is the end.
02:44:424 (1) - I don't particularly like this slider, as it makes you miss mapping the strong vocal parts at 02:45:019 - 02:45:912. You should consider mapping this part out more so that these parts are played.
02:52:456 (3) - shorten this to end at 02:53:051. I think this will be okay because you map it like this at 02:33:418 (3) and I think it is better for matching the vocal.
02:55:431 (1,2) - making this a blanket formation would fit well with the rest of what you are doing in this diff.
03:16:254 (3) - this one you can shorten as well. Keep these consistent with the rest of the map.

[Normal]

00:03:195 (2,3) - I actually prefer these as a slider. I think it matches that corny DJ sound better.
00:15:689 (7,8) - I don't really like this stack that much in terms of game play. If we compare it to the similar parts in this section (00:20:449 (4), 00:25:208 (7,8)), this stack feels much less kinetic and flowing. I would unstack these because I think the kiai-ish sections of the song are better when they flow (unless specific musical elements dictate otherwise, which I don't think is the case here)
00:29:075 (2,3,4,5,6) - this is pretty nazi, but watch your spacing here. Even though the differences are small, I noticed them pretty instantly. Then agian, that might be because I'm weird. Regardless, might as well fix these up.
00:29:968 (5,6) - I would consider making this a slider, as having all these circles in a row is not super great.
00:48:411 (6) - you could remove the first finish here, I think it is a bit too noisy. Alternatively you could lower the volume as well, but I prefer just the clap for the slider head here.
01:03:880 (5) - NC here? seems to fit pretty well
01:30:057 (1) - I kinda feel the same way about this spinner as with the one in Easy.
01:59:804 (1)- this NC feels a bit unnecessary so I'd say remove it.
02:17:355 (4) - a bit of NC inconsistency here. I would say NC this one, and match the comboing pattern set with 02:11:108 (1,2,3,1).
02:22:115 (3) - NC here also. The other alternative is removing some NCs in this section to make the combos the same length.

[Hard]

00:03:195 (2,3) - same suggestion as the Normal
00:24:018 (5) - Maybe move this up for some more circular flow. http://puu.sh/5sE0g.jpg
00:28:183 (1) - maybe put a bit more bend on this one
01:30:057 (1) - same spinner suggestion
01:50:285 (1,2) - I kind of miss the stream here like at 01:07:449 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9).
01:53:260 (3,4) - The way this is mapped sort of misses out on the theme of really-emphasized-vocals. Consider mapping it like this: http://puu.sh/5sE8U.jpg. This puts the vocal on the slider which I think matches your overall structure better.
02:08:133 (1,2,3,4,5) - did you intend for the spacing to be this way? I suggest that you make these equally spaced, right now it looks a bit sloppy to me.
02:29:551 (1,2,3,1) - I think a bit more spacing here will give these much more impact, which is really important because this is the big climax of the song.
02:34:013 (6,7,8) - Just wondering here if the 1.00x spacing was intentional. I think every other time you have a slider with 1/4 notes afterward, the spacing is 0.5
02:51:564 (3,4) - Here is the same thing as 01:53:260 (3,4). The mapping solution will be the same as there.

That's all from me, just some little stuff. I think you're about ready to call dkun.
Topic Starter
Lanturn
Moway

Moway wrote:

Wheeeeeeeee

this song is so corny i love it This was my childhood!.. Now you know how I ended being like I am =P

nazi mod coming, prepare your butt i am so sorry Nazi mods are the best mods actually, because they're useful.. I guess?

[General]

tags: Add "Heroes", "Puzzle", "League" to the tags. This song was in Pokemon Heroes as well as Pokemon Puzzle League so those tags are pretty good I think. Sure. I miss puzzle league now....

I think you'll be alright on the kiai times, maybe remove it for the fade out, but apart from that I don't think the kiai use in this song is a big problem.

dat storyboard tho <3

[Easy]

00:16:284 (1) - move the 2nd midpoint back a bit, right now I think the curve is a bit too bunched toward the slider end. Done
00:26:398 (1) - lower the 2nd red point a bit for a better blanket on that 2nd curve of the slider. Got this as well.
00:34:132 (4) - red point to (316,176) for a better blanket I think, or somewhere around there. I'm honestly writing this after I made the changes, but I know I took this one :P
01:06:854 (4,5) - nazi blanket fix here and this one..
01:22:323 (1) - this slider is a bit ugly to me, and it doesn't have any blanket interaction with any other sliders so I think for this one make it into a more regular S-shape, which looks nicer as a stand alone slider. haha, one ugly slider rejected.. to be honest I don't even know why I kept that one.
01:30:057 (1) - I don't think this spinner is necessary. Leave it out and let the player have a longer break. Sure, did this for all diffs as well.
01:32:437 - if you take the previous suggestion, add a circle here. ^ and added.
01:57:127 (1,2) - I think the blanket interaction between these sliders could be improved. Fine. They can hug each other better.. I made them more even so it should be better.
02:04:266 (3) - adjust the bottom curve on this one a bit so that it blankets 02:05:754 (1) a bit better. http://puu.sh/5sCN7.jpg This one is a pain.. I think I somehow got it though
02:08:133 (1,1) - There might not be enough time here between the spinner and the next object. I think you could end the spinner at 02:09:918, which is another strong beat and it would be okay. alright, sure.
02:24:197 (4) - a bit nazi here, but move this to (304,132) to be a perfect reflection of 02:23:602 (3). Symmetry can never be nazi'd, fixed.
02:24:792 (1) - (376,66) XD It was already there! =o
02:30:741 (1) - make the finish here louder, right now it is at 30% thanks to the red line Raised to 40% I think
02:34:905 (1) - remove finish from the slider head Lowered the volume of this finish.. I still kept the finish though. I love it <3
02:36:392 (2,3) - fix up this blanket a bit, this one will look much better as a perfect blanket Perfectly wrapped and tucked in now!
02:39:665 (1) - remove the finish from the slider head too, I think having them there takes away from the finish on the real strong part, which is the end. Lowered volume a bit more on this, 30 45 60 now.
02:44:424 (1) - I don't particularly like this slider, as it makes you miss mapping the strong vocal parts at 02:45:019 - 02:45:912. You should consider mapping this part out more so that these parts are played. its true.. but I wanted something long so it kind of gives a breath of air to the new players... that or I really am just lazy. I'll just pretend its the former.
02:52:456 (3) - shorten this to end at 02:53:051. I think this will be okay because you map it like this at 02:33:418 (3) and I think it is better for matching the vocal. Yes, done.
02:55:431 (1,2) - making this a blanket formation would fit well with the rest of what you are doing in this diff. I don't remember what I did here, but I think I changed this around.
03:16:254 (3) - this one you can shorten as well. Keep these consistent with the rest of the map. Yes I can, and will.

[Normal]

00:03:195 (2,3) - I actually prefer these as a slider. I think it matches that corny DJ sound better. Just for you I'll change it <3
00:15:689 (7,8) - I don't really like this stack that much in terms of game play. If we compare it to the similar parts in this section (00:20:449 (4), 00:25:208 (7,8)), this stack feels much less kinetic and flowing. I would unstack these because I think the kiai-ish sections of the song are better when they flow (unless specific musical elements dictate otherwise, which I don't think is the case here) This took a little bit of reworking, but I think I got it! Basically went anti-clockwise with it.
00:29:075 (2,3,4,5,6) - this is pretty nazi, but watch your spacing here. Even though the differences are small, I noticed them pretty instantly. Then agian, that might be because I'm weird. Regardless, might as well fix these up. see below?
00:29:968 (5,6) - I would consider making this a slider, as having all these circles in a row is not super great. eh. I liked the circles, but honestly you're right. I swapped a couple of them to 1/2 sliders.
00:48:411 (6) - you could remove the first finish here, I think it is a bit too noisy. Alternatively you could lower the volume as well, but I prefer just the clap for the slider head here. As you guessed probably, I lowered the volume a little.
01:03:880 (5) - NC here? seems to fit pretty well Done
01:30:057 (1) - I kinda feel the same way about this spinner as with the one in Easy. Sure. The extra few seconds does help.
01:59:804 (1)- this NC feels a bit unnecessary so I'd say remove it.
02:17:355 (4) - a bit of NC inconsistency here. I would say NC this one, and match the comboing pattern set with 02:11:108 (1,2,3,1).
02:22:115 (3) - NC here also. The other alternative is removing some NCs in this section to make the combos the same length. Managed to fix all this NC problems. Should be fine now.

[Hard]

00:03:195 (2,3) - same suggestion as the Normal Not for this one. I like the current setup.. so no crazy dj slider :(
00:24:018 (5) - Maybe move this up for some more circular flow. http://puu.sh/5sE0g.jpg omg yes, thank you for this suggestion.
00:28:183 (1) - maybe put a bit more bend on this one It ends up ugly no matter how I try to adjust this.. but I think I got a good bend now.
01:30:057 (1) - same spinner suggestion yes
01:50:285 (1,2) - I kind of miss the stream here like at 01:07:449 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9). I actually thought I was using too many long streams, which is why I made the slider streaming here. I like how it ended up actually.
01:53:260 (3,4) - The way this is mapped sort of misses out on the theme of really-emphasized-vocals. Consider mapping it like this: http://puu.sh/5sE8U.jpg. This puts the vocal on the slider which I think matches your overall structure better. You... you're right.. How did I not see this before? Fixed, fixed and fixed the other one.
02:08:133 (1,2,3,4,5) - did you intend for the spacing to be this way? I suggest that you make these equally spaced, right now it looks a bit sloppy to me. figured the problem out.. needed to space the even notes out a bit more.
02:29:551 (1,2,3,1) - I think a bit more spacing here will give these much more impact, which is really important because this is the big climax of the song. Sure, a bit more distance can't hurt, and yeah, definitely fits.
02:34:013 (6,7,8) - Just wondering here if the 1.00x spacing was intentional. I think every other time you have a slider with 1/4 notes afterward, the spacing is 0.5 I don't remember why I actually left that one. When I mapped the first time, I had all the streams spaced normally, then ended up changing a lot of them to half. I guess this one didn't make it somehow... Time for it to move on to 0.5
02:51:564 (3,4) - Here is the same thing as 01:53:260 (3,4). The mapping solution will be the same as there. ;_; fixed.

That's all from me, just some little stuff. I think you're about ready to call dkun.

Big thanks! I need more mods now, I'm sure there is a ton more things to fix X_X;
Coro
I was wondering if you accept guest diffs?
I want to make Taiko diffs for this~
Mao
M4M Request

[Easy]

00:34:132 (4) - How about replacing the straight end with a curved one? (http://puu.sh/5sS8p.jpg)
00:46:626 (3,4) - Blanket could be better ><
01:03:880 (1,2) - ^
01:19:051 (2) - Make the straight part of this one longer and the curved one shorter :/
01:50:285 (3,1) - Better blanket suggested ._.
02:04:266 (3) - I guess 3 grey points in the curve would be enough...
02:30:741 (1) - Move the grey point on the curve a little bit upwards.
02:41:152 (2) - Try something like this http://puu.sh/5sStE.jpg here

[Normal]
00:31:753 (3) - Try to remove the strait part at the beginning of the slider and make the curve smoother.
00:31:753 (3) - Make both sides have the same length.
00:46:924 (4) - Try something like this http://puu.sh/5sRWL.jpg
01:21:430 (6) - I guess a simple curved slider would have fit here xD
01:58:317 (4,5) - Probably it's just me, but the blanket could be better here.
02:39:070 (7) - Hmh, I don't know if this is that well playable for a Normal player. And the look of it isn't good either...

As I said before, it's probably just me but I suggest rechecking your blankets here...
[Hard]
00:30:265 (8) - Place the NC on this one instead of 00:30:563 (1) -
00:30:563 (1) - Try to remake this sliders using more than one grey point to get a smoother curve (Example: http://puu.sh/5sRoF.jpg&#41;
00:37:405 (3) - This slider looks a little bit "squeezed" in my opinion. You don't have to but I highly suggest reforming this one.
00:51:683 (6) - This would look way better with 2 grey points in the curve (http://puu.sh/5sRut.jpg). So it would also form a better blanket with (5)
01:13:399 (1,2) - Try to make a smoother S-shape
01:19:646 (3,4) - Just a little suggestion here: How about let (3= overlap with (4)? Something like that http://puu.sh/5sRCv.jpg would look and flow quite nice.
01:36:899 (7,8,1) - NC on (7) instead of (1)
01:37:196 (1,2,3) - Try to get a better slider blanket with (1) and (3) :/
02:00:994 (3) - Place a finish on the start
02:03:076 (6) - Just my opinion: Replace that slider. It looks...not so nice xD
02:32:228 (3,4) - Try to get a blanket with these 2
03:17:146 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Interesting stream. Wasn't playing that well :| Don't you think it's too hard for a hard diff? o:

Man, you seem to like symmetry xD

Even though the mapset looks older than it is (probably because of the lack of rotation and too much symmetry) I like it. I hope my mod helps you and of course good luck :D
Topic Starter
Lanturn

CoroQuetz wrote:

I was wondering if you accept guest diffs?
I want to make Taiko diffs for this~
I don't plan on adding any guest diffs for this mapset sorry. Thanks for the offer though.

@Mao. I'll get to your mod as soon as I get home from work later today.
Topic Starter
Lanturn
Mao

Mao wrote:

M4M Request

[Easy]

00:34:132 (4) - How about replacing the straight end with a curved one? (http://puu.sh/5sS8p.jpg) added a small curve on this. Not as much as you were suggesting though.
00:46:626 (3,4) - Blanket could be better >< Fixed.
01:03:880 (1,2) - ^ Done.
01:19:051 (2) - Make the straight part of this one longer and the curved one shorter :/ Fixed this when scrolling through the song, changed the shape completely.
01:50:285 (3,1) - Better blanket suggested ._. sure. Fixed.
02:04:266 (3) - I guess 3 grey points in the curve would be enough... The points were added from the last mod. To keep this shape I need them.
02:30:741 (1) - Move the grey point on the curve a little bit upwards. I personally like the shape it is already.
02:41:152 (2) - Try something like this http://puu.sh/5sStE.jpg here Keeping my original shape. thanks though

[Normal]
00:31:753 (3) - Try to remove the strait part at the beginning of the slider and make the curve smoother. Not positive what you're asking here, but I altered this slightly.
00:31:753 (3) - Make both sides have the same length. same spot? I'm leaving this how it is for now.
00:46:924 (4) - Try something like this http://puu.sh/5sRWL.jpg I like how mine is set up right now. it gives off the impression by looks that its a 3/4 slider. Just a personal thing I guess.
01:21:430 (6) - I guess a simple curved slider would have fit here xD who knows how I made it look like that, but it pretty much is the correct shape anyways. No need to change this :P
01:58:317 (4,5) - Probably it's just me, but the blanket could be better here. It should be fine how it is.
02:39:070 (7) - Hmh, I don't know if this is that well playable for a Normal player. And the look of it isn't good either... no no no.. I love this slider, and I think it fits really well with the song. No change.

As I said before, it's probably just me but I suggest rechecking your blankets here... Couple things here and there, just makes me wonder how long I actually made this difficulty. It was sometime when all I could think about was hitsounds I'm sure, and forgot about my blanketing that I had when I made Hero no Jouken :P

[Hard]
00:30:265 (8) - Place the NC on this one instead of 00:30:563 (1) - For consistency and my style of comboing, I prefer not to NC on a lead-in stream.
00:30:563 (1) - Try to remake this sliders using more than one grey point to get a smoother curve (Example: http://puu.sh/5sRoF.jpg&#41; I altered this a bit, didn't add any extra nodes though.
00:37:405 (3) - This slider looks a little bit "squeezed" in my opinion. You don't have to but I highly suggest reforming this one. I'll just straighten out the end then.
00:51:683 (6) - This would look way better with 2 grey points in the curve (http://puu.sh/5sRut.jpg). So it would also form a better blanket with (5) Did this my own way, but it'll be blanketed much better now.
01:13:399 (1,2) - Try to make a smoother S-shape I personally like them better than just a simple S shape. It creates more of a turning point when used sharply at the head.
01:19:646 (3,4) - Just a little suggestion here: How about let (3= overlap with (4)? Something like that http://puu.sh/5sRCv.jpg would look and flow quite nice. Figured something out here to do.
01:36:899 (7,8,1) - NC on (7) instead of (1) Same as beginning.
01:37:196 (1,2,3) - Try to get a better slider blanket with (1) and (3) :/ It was really fine how it was, but I adjusted it slightly to make the bottom curve of the (1) a little longer.
02:00:994 (3) - Place a finish on the start No finish noise in the actual music here, so not adding one.
02:03:076 (6) - Just my opinion: Replace that slider. It looks...not so nice xD It's a work of art :( No change.
02:32:228 (3,4) - Try to get a blanket with these 2 Jump section, so no, and it connects nicely enough anyways.
03:17:146 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Interesting stream. Wasn't playing that well :| Don't you think it's too hard for a hard diff? o: Not at all. I swap between .5 and 1. on these kinds of streams, and I think how this is laid out is pretty nice.

Man, you seem to like symmetry xD Compared to most maps, this is nothing at all lol. Just a basic way of mapping really.

Even though the mapset looks older than it is (probably because of the lack of rotation and too much symmetry) I like it. I hope my mod helps you and of course good luck :D lack of rotation? and more or less not enough symmetry to be honest. The only reason why it would give off an older feel is because some of the sliders are unique and can't be found other maps, which was my goal for this project.

Thanks for the mod. Getting to yours in a minute.
-Teina-
[Hard]
SPOILER
01:36:304 - And 01:36:453 - move 1/4beat before
01:41:361 (4) - move to X:336 Y:298 may be well
02:29:998 - move 1/4beat after,And
02:29:551 - this silder add 1/4beat if you move the 02:29:998 -
01:03:880 - And 01:04:326 - I feel than it is strange but i can't know how to set
03:24:583 - end of spinner

timing:
150741,594.942984630639,4,2,1,30,1,1 Do not use the red line
03:21:757 - end of kiai time

To M4M , if you like my beatmap's song
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/126489
Topic Starter
Lanturn
tellertheworld

tellertheworld wrote:

[Hard]
01:36:304 - And 01:36:453 - move 1/4beat before 01:36:453 - is actually placed on the correct drum beat. It just sounds weird having a blank where drums are playing since I mapped directly to them, so no change.
01:41:361 (4) - move to X:336 Y:298 may be well I actually like having it a bit further away here, since it's being pushed from the (3) reverse.
02:29:998 - move 1/4beat after,And
02:29:551 - this silder add 1/4beat if you move the 02:29:998 - If you delete the notes, you can tell what sounds I was following there. No change as well here.
01:03:880 - And 01:04:326 - I feel than it is strange but i can't know how to set They match the sliders at 01:01:500 (1,2) - I personally like how they are right now.
03:24:583 - end of spinner No thanks, I'd rather end it on 'friends' instead of the earlier 'best'

timing:
150741,594.942984630639,4,2,1,30,1,1 Do not use the red line I have to use this red line to reset the metronome, otherwise each new measure would start on the middle white tick instead of the big one.
03:21:757 - end of kiai time :P If anywhere, it would actually be at 03:18:336 - but I prefer to end it where it is currently.

To M4M , if you like my beatmap's song
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/126489

No changes, but thanks for trying.
Fatfan Kolek
Easy
01:33:032 - 01:34:222 This slider looks strange to me.
02:30:741 - 02:34:013 (1, 2, 3) These sliders doesn't fit to your normal mapstyle, because they're hitting each other. (Just a suggestion)

Normal
00:51:683 - 00:52:576 This slider looks to angular to me.
02:03:076 - 02:03:671 It's a small bit to near to 3 compared to your other sliders. Don't know if a change there is necessary.
02:06:646 - 02:07:538 In my opinion you shouldn't do that square. It doesn't fit that much to your mapstyle. I would set another slider there.
02:20:032 - 02:20:627 ^ Like I said at first.
02:39:070 - 02:40:260 This slider is not exactly between (5) and (6). It's too near to (5). ^^

Hard
00:54:063 - 00:54:955 This slider looks strange to me. A bit too angular.
02:03:076 - 02:03:671 Change the slider. It seems different from the others.
02:27:172 - 02:27:767 Make one curve instead of two.
03:17:146 - 03:18:336 I would change the stream. Make it just like all the others.

I'm a noob at modding, but I tried my best. :<
I like this song very much and I hope it'll get ranked soon. :)
Topic Starter
Lanturn
Fatfan Kolek

Fatfan Kolek wrote:

Easy
01:33:032 - 01:34:222 This slider looks strange to me. I'll try a different shape then, Hopefull it doesn't look even worse XD
02:30:741 - 02:34:013 (1, 2, 3) These sliders doesn't fit to your normal mapstyle, because they're hitting each other. (Just a suggestion) Its true, I just wanted a bit more variety in my map so I decided to go with this. No changes.

Normal
00:51:683 - 00:52:576 This slider looks to angular to me. It does look a bit odd, but I personally like the way this one turned out. If more comment on this I'll change it but for now, I'd rather leave it as is.
02:03:076 - 02:03:671 It's a small bit to near to 3 compared to your other sliders. Don't know if a change there is necessary. Small nudges, should be a bit better now.
02:06:646 - 02:07:538 In my opinion you shouldn't do that square. It doesn't fit that much to your mapstyle. I would set another slider there. Actually, you are completely right. This should look much much better now. thanks!
02:20:032 - 02:20:627 ^ Like I said at first. hehe. I'll keep this one in mind as well, for now I'll leave it.
02:39:070 - 02:40:260 This slider is not exactly between (5) and (6). It's too near to (5). ^^ Nudged over correctly, thanks.

Hard
00:54:063 - 00:54:955 This slider looks strange to me. A bit too angular. I nudged a the first gray node over slightly, but the rest I kept the same. I personally like how the slider changes from a curve to sharp angles when the finish hits.
02:03:076 - 02:03:671 Change the slider. It seems different from the others. Ahh.. that's two people that don't like this slider now X_X; Tried a new shape I guess.
02:27:172 - 02:27:767 Make one curve instead of two. This is supposed to be a mini version of the upcoming stream which also had two curves. No changes.
03:17:146 - 03:18:336 I would change the stream. Make it just like all the others. Haha, Actually I really like this one. I don't plan on changing it unless more people really bug me about it.

I'm a noob at modding, but I tried my best. :< This one was actually pretty decent for the amount you've modded, keep it up!
I like this song very much and I hope it'll get ranked soon. :) Thank you! :)


Thanks for the mod <3
Azer
Gah, I'd mod this but I really dislike the song :(

...

Gah, I'd give you a star but..

I'll come back here in a few days and throw some, sorry ;A;
Hinsvar
Hi; modding your map here!

*Bolded = Unrankable or strongly suggested; red = Highly suggested or questionable (still weaker than the bolded ones); black = Minor suggestions/rants; blue = Notes/advices to avoid/fix repeated problems. Also note that hitsound suggestions on a diff may apply on similar parts of the song and the other diffs of the mapset.

>Easy
  1. 00:02:006 (1,2) - Not really a problem, but I'd like to see their shape being the same; it's slightly different now lol
  2. 00:33:537 (3,4) - You can improve the blanket here by dragging that red node on (4) by one grid to the left.
  3. 00:57:930 (4,1) - Umm, spacing inconsistency?
  4. 01:06:854 (4,5) - Again, the blanket here can be improved, by dragging the node on (5)'s tail by one grid down.
  5. 01:22:323 (1) - Skipping the cymbal at 01:22:918 makes playing this slider awkward. Make the rhythm look like this? The repeat at 01:23:810 also follows the vocal really well, so why not?
  6. 01:34:817 (3) - Drag the node on the tail one grid up to make the blanket better? (Yeah, sorry for ranting about really minor things.)
  7. 01:58:614 - I know you're following the vocal here, but ignoring that cymbal makes the slider uncomfortable to play. Oh well, might be just me.
  8. 02:21:222 - You've been constantly going on a 1/1 rhythm, so why pausing it here? Map this tick too?
  9. 02:29:551 (5) - Uh, drag the last node down by two grids, again, to make the blanket better?
  10. 02:44:424 (1) - Similar to 01:22:323 (1), except replace the "cymbal" with "strong vocal".
>Normal
  1. 00:31:753 (3) - Move the very last node to (404,56) to create a nicer flow?
  2. 00:54:360 - ...Well, I guess I'll just say that skipping cymbals with a slider makes things feel awkward, even though you want to follow the vocal. I'm sure enough this isn't just me, so... (Not gonna say if there's a similar case; would be too much~)
  3. 01:11:019 - Add a note to follow the cymbal (and add a finish with a lowered volume, ofc)? It feels weird to leave one unmapped here, you know.
  4. 01:54:450 (5) - Move to (352,296) to improve the flow?
  5. 02:44:424 (7,8,1) - Move them two grids left AND down? This is so that (7) will be correctly placed while playing (it will be not in the place it is in the editor because of the stacks). You might need to play a bit with the spacing at 02:45:019 (1,2), though.
  6. 03:03:462 (1,2) - The blanket looks weird because it's wider on the left and more narrow on the right. You know what to do, right...
>Hard
  1. Well, I know the song only has 100.85 beats per minute, but don't you think there's a little bit too much 1/4 streams here?
  2. 00:15:987 (9) - Uh, any reason why is the spacing kinda inconsistent around here?
  3. 00:42:164 (4,5,6) - Might as well make it stay 1.0x around here; will make the spacing look more consistent and thus nicer to play + it will look neater, IMO. Yep, you can keep the jump after them.
  4. 00:51:683 (6,1) - Is 1.09x necessary here? Going with the normal spacing will make this pattern look tidier.
  5. 01:08:044 (5) - I'm sure enough the cymbal is played at 01:07:895 (4), so remove the finish here and add one at (4) instead.
  6. 01:43:443 (3,4,5,1,2,3) - I don't like the flow here, mainly because of the movement you need and the spacing changes. Just saying.
  7. 02:33:418 (5,6) - Uh, I don't really like the flow here actually. I believe you can just use 02:32:823 (4) that is rotated by 90 degrees counter-clockwise and move it to (204,108)... or do something similar to that.
  8. 03:03:462 (1) - To improve the blanket, move the middle node to (80,124) and the last one to (132,196)?
Well that's it I guess :P

Good luck on the way 8-)
Topic Starter
Lanturn
Hinsvar

Hinsvar wrote:

Hi; modding your map here!

*Bolded = Unrankable or strongly suggested; red = Highly suggested or questionable (still weaker than the bolded ones); black = Minor suggestions/rants; blue = Notes/advices to avoid/fix repeated problems. Also note that hitsound suggestions on a diff may apply on similar parts of the song and the other diffs of the mapset.

>Easy
  1. 00:02:006 (1,2) - Not really a problem, but I'd like to see their shape being the same; it's slightly different now lol Sure, copy pasted the (1)
  2. 00:33:537 (3,4) - You can improve the blanket here by dragging that red node on (4) by one grid to the left. Alright do... wait what? I swear the previous mod asked me to move it one to the right... now to the left?.. Anyways, I left this one alone, because I think it does actually look better in its original position.
  3. 00:57:930 (4,1) - Umm, spacing inconsistency? One of those "not sure how that happened" moments. Thanks, fixed.
  4. 01:06:854 (4,5) - Again, the blanket here can be improved, by dragging the node on (5)'s tail by one grid down. Actually, I like it where it is currently, no change.
  5. 01:22:323 (1) - Skipping the cymbal at 01:22:918 makes playing this slider awkward. Make the rhythm look like this? The repeat at 01:23:810 also follows the vocal really well, so why not? The reason for this is to create the notion that it's coming up to the ending of the kiai, so something lengthy and soft was used here. I personally like how this one turned out so I'd like to keep this. I already have SC:3 hitting the finish anyways on the tick.
  6. 01:34:817 (3) - Drag the node on the tail one grid up to make the blanket better? (Yeah, sorry for ranting about really minor things.) Dragged the end up one node, and the middle node one to the right. Also I'm glad I get these kind of suggestions. One thing that I want to make sure gets done right is all the sliders look fine enough for everyone, blanketing and just overall looks. I've changed a lot and its really improving.. so keep sending those suggestions :p
  7. 01:58:614 - I know you're following the vocal here, but ignoring that cymbal makes the slider uncomfortable to play. Oh well, might be just me. Yeah, I wanted to map to the cymbals as well but I decided to stick heavily to the vocals. This creates some uniqueness in the map as you already know, this map is 1/1 heavy already, so it could use a little change, and this was my answer to it. It does play well to me, but I'm still not sure to others yet.
  8. 02:21:222 - You've been constantly going on a 1/1 rhythm, so why pausing it here? Map this tick too? I actually don't map this in any other diff. Just because of how awkward the vocals make it sound. I'll try to come up with a different solution maybe, but for now. I like it how it is.
  9. 02:29:551 (5) - Uh, drag the last node down by two grids, again, to make the blanket better? Done
  10. 02:44:424 (1) - Similar to 01:22:323 (1), except replace the "cymbal" with "strong vocal". Same reason as I mentioned earlier really. I just would rather have something here more or less to add a bit of uniqueness instead of constant 1/1 beats. This also lets newer players 'rest' up I guess? not very valid reasoning but.. I'll just say that :?
>Normal
  1. 00:31:753 (3) - Move the very last node to (404,56) to create a nicer flow? Figured this out without changing the slider end. Moved the notes further up. I want to keep the slider how it is.
  2. 00:54:360 - ...Well, I guess I'll just say that skipping cymbals with a slider makes things feel awkward, even though you want to follow the vocal. I'm sure enough this isn't just me, so... (Not gonna say if there's a similar case; would be too much~) I definitely understand what you are saying, and to me, I'd rather map it, but if I actually map it, it will create a bit of awkwardness to the player or at least in my head. | changing this up conflicts with 00:51:683 (4) - so Its necessary I follow the rhythm here. I do this a bit in the song to other spots but I have reasonings behind each one.
  3. 01:11:019 - Add a note to follow the cymbal (and add a finish with a lowered volume, ofc)? It feels weird to leave one unmapped here, you know. This one is a major problem as well. It actually hits closer to 01:11:092 - area and not on the direct spot of 01:11:019 - I also skip this in my easy and hard, though my hard has it on a tick. Long story short, I don't feel comfortable mapping to it directly.
  4. 01:54:450 (5) - Move to (352,296) to improve the flow? Done. Why wasn't this here earlier? >_>
  5. 02:44:424 (7,8,1) - Move them two grids left AND down? This is so that (7) will be correctly placed while playing (it will be not in the place it is in the editor because of the stacks). You might need to play a bit with the spacing at 02:45:019 (1,2), though. I just changed this whole section around so I didn't have the stack.
  6. 03:03:462 (1,2) - The blanket looks weird because it's wider on the left and more narrow on the right. You know what to do, right... Ever so gently... Fixed.
>Hard
  1. Well, I know the song only has 100.85 beats per minute, but don't you think there's a little bit too much 1/4 streams here? Yes and no. Yes because I don't really care for 1/4s altogether, but no for the reason of being different from normal, and also to help follow all the drums better. all the 1/4s here have purpose so they definitely fit and are called for. I personally think this is a good balance how this diff turned out. I don't use as many jumps compared to most hards anyways.
  2. 00:15:987 (9) - Uh, any reason why is the spacing kinda inconsistent around here? Minor jump, but I know what you mean anyways, changed to 1.22 spacing instead of odd amounts.
  3. 00:42:164 (4,5,6) - Might as well make it stay 1.0x around here; will make the spacing look more consistent and thus nicer to play + it will look neater, IMO. Yep, you can keep the jump after them. I moved (4) a bit to make it 1.05 so it would build up to the 1.12. Yes, 1.05, not 1.06...
  4. 00:51:683 (6,1) - Is 1.09x necessary here? Going with the normal spacing will make this pattern look tidier. Not really sure if the extra little spacing will matter since its a jump coming up, but I changed this to 1.00
  5. 01:08:044 (5) - I'm sure enough the cymbal is played at 01:07:895 (4), so remove the finish here and add one at (4) instead. Oh, you're right. Sounds a bit strange now, but its better to be correct.
  6. 01:43:443 (3,4,5,1,2,3) - I don't like the flow here, mainly because of the movement you need and the spacing changes. Just saying. I was actually quite confident this was a good setup here. For now I want to keep it but if others mention this then I'll do something.
  7. 02:33:418 (5,6) - Uh, I don't really like the flow here actually. I believe you can just use 02:32:823 (4) that is rotated by 90 degrees counter-clockwise and move it to (204,108)... or do something similar to that. I actually really like how this is. I'll keep this in mind though.
  8. 03:03:462 (1) - To improve the blanket, move the middle node to (80,124) and the last one to (132,196)? done, thanks. Not sure how I missed this blanket either.
Well that's it I guess :P

Good luck on the way 8-)

Thanks a lot for the mod :)
RandF
From my queue~

[General]
  1. For SB, the maximum dimensions for tall or wide scrolling images are 640x1440 and 1920x480 respectively.
    please recheck Ranking Criteria
  2. 03:08:817~03:25:475- at this part, it is no problem to remove Kiai-time, imo
[Easy]
  1. For Easy-diff, you should add more break time.
  2. 02:00:994- finish ?
  3. 02:36:392 (2,3) - DS is correct?
  4. 02:54:241- finish position is 02:54:538 ?
[Normal]
  1. 01:17:861 (8,2) - avoid overlap
[Hard]
  1. Good!
Your SB is very wonderful! I hope to remake to suit osu's rule ;)
Your mapping is so cool~☆
~Good Luck~
Topic Starter
Lanturn
RandomEffect

RandomEffect wrote:

From my queue~

[General]
  1. For SB, the maximum dimensions for tall or wide scrolling images are 640x1440 and 1920x480 respectively. I will get to this when I get back home from work. Thanks for showing me this. I didn't even realize I went out of the limits for SB dimensions. I would assume Widescreen storyboarding would have better dimensions for images now as well, but this is only a standard def one.
    please recheck Ranking Criteria
  2. 03:08:817~03:25:475- at this part, it is no problem to remove Kiai-time, imo I personally like how I have the Kiai setup. I know I use it a lot, but I'd rather be consistent with it and use it during these epic parts.
[Easy]
  1. For Easy-diff, you should add more break time. I think a break after 1:30 of playing for 5ish seconds is more than enough. There really isn't any other spot for a break anyways.
  2. 02:00:994- finish ? No finish here. Nothing in the background music to warrant for it
  3. 02:36:392 (2,3) - DS is correct? Yes, I use .7 on this map, so 6.9 is right.... =\
  4. 02:54:241- finish position is 02:54:538 ? It is in the right position.
[Normal]
  1. 01:17:861 (8,2) - avoid overlap Fixed, thanks.
[Hard]
  1. Good!
Your SB is very wonderful! I hope to remake to suit osu's rule ;)
Your mapping is so cool~☆
~Good Luck~


I'll remake the pictures when I get home from work today, and upload your updates. thanks :)
YoshinoSakura
From my queue
Sorry for my late, 'cuz i almost forget that ;)

[General]
nice storyboard!
03:13:576 may stop at here because the volumn reduces here

[Easy]
00:06:765 (1) - blanket can be better
00:13:012 (2,3) - somehow too close
00:26:398 (1) - also not beautiful blanket
01:59:507 (3) - imo,change it to 1/2 slider is better than using sliderticks
02:12:298 (2) - blanket can be better

[Normal]
01:07:152 (4) - why no clap on this
01:23:810 (4) - blanket can be better
02:53:348 seems that a note is missing here
there are some strange place where the soundeffect's volumn reduces for no reason,better change it.

[Hard]
add some whistles?For example 00:37:405 (3)
01:01:500 (1,2) - this is strange,there's no same music or vocal here
01:03:880 (1,2) - ^
02:19:884 A note here might be better
02:29:551 (1,2) - really not fit,just do it as regular
02:35:500 (1,2,3,4,5) - blanket can be better
02:49:184 (4,5) - 1/4 sliders can be better(long downbeats here)

Nice map
GL

Edit:Damn I forget to update :o ,just take my mod as advice
Topic Starter
Lanturn
615915887

615915887 wrote:

From my queue
Sorry for my late, 'cuz i almost forget that ;)

[General]
nice storyboard!
03:13:576 may stop at here because the volumn reduces here

[Easy]
00:06:765 (1) - blanket can be better Fixed
00:13:012 (2,3) - somehow too close ? nothing wrong with it.
00:26:398 (1) - also not beautiful blanket Somewhat fixed.. It may have ended up like it used to though XD
01:59:507 (3) - imo,change it to 1/2 slider is better than using sliderticks Not doing it in an Easy.
02:12:298 (2) - blanket can be better meant to be more symmetric with the previous slider than a blanket. leaving as is.

[Normal]
01:07:152 (4) - why no clap on this doesn't call for one. the previous three are much stronger than this. I also skip it in Hard.
01:23:810 (4) - blanket can be better Sure, tried to fix this.
02:53:348 seems that a note is missing here nah, might be just the held vocals you are thinking of. An extra note wouldn't serve any purpose.
there are some strange place where the soundeffect's volumn reduces for no reason,better change it. every part is intentional. I use the lower volume in some spots so the hitsounds don't take over.

[Hard]
add some whistles?For example 00:37:405 (3) I was stuck on if I should actually use whistles or not, in the end, I decided not to. They really stick out in the song and don't actually fit, so I decided to pass.
01:01:500 (1,2) - this is strange,there's no same music or vocal here Intentional, you can hear that one instrument in the music and it takes priority over the little tick noise, so I mapped it like this. I don't plan on changing this.
01:03:880 (1,2) - ^ ^
02:19:884 A note here might be better There isn't anything playing at this time.
02:29:551 (1,2) - really not fit,just do it as regular drums are actually played like this, so it wouldn't work to change them to simple 1/2s
02:35:500 (1,2,3,4,5) - blanket can be better wasn't trying to blanket this. the old slider is long gone by this point.
02:49:184 (4,5) - 1/4 sliders can be better(long downbeats here) After using them in a previous map of mine, I really really don't like using 1/4 sliders for streaming unless they fit. I prefer these how they are right now, and actually wish I could use them more.

Nice map Thanks :)
GL

Edit:Damn I forget to update :o ,just take my mod as advice Don't worry about it, all of your suggestions were in different spots anyways :P


Thanks for the mod~

Working on the storyboard now!
Topic Starter
Lanturn
Everything is all done as of now...

I left te wo tsunagou.jpg as its original size due to it being a scrolling image that needs more than the horizontal width. (261kb and peaks at 2.02sb load)

Guess this map is pretty much ready for ranking now.. (After the BATs slap me around some~) thanks again all the modders :)
Umi

dkun wrote:

Strolling through #modreqs~ Please call me back when you have more mods and over +15! :o
where are u ? :o
LZCSC
( ^0^)/from BMT\(^0^ )

General
your rhythm is great!!but the note you set and blanket isnt careful i think,and slider some times is strange,i dont think it have a good look.

Easy
  1. 00:09:591 - this green line is useless
  2. 00:41:867 (2) - this is better looking i think
  3. 01:22:323 (1,1) - better looking
  4. 01:46:715 (1,2) - isnt Perfect symmetry
  5. 02:02:481 (2,3) - isnt blanket perfect
  6. 02:20:627 (1) - more suit the rhythm with this look
  7. 02:29:551 (5,1) - bad looking!!
  8. 02:32:228 (2,3) - ^
Normal
  1. 01:16:373 (5) - ctrl+G?
  2. 01:18:158 (1,2) - 01:19:051 (2) - 's head is to close to the body of 01:18:158 (1) - for better looking
    01:18:158 (1) - change like this and 01:19:051 (2) - like this
  3. 01:23:810 (2,1) - isnt blanket perfect
  4. 01:46:715 (1) - bad look ,what about this
  5. 02:18:842 (7) - this thythmis a little bit unsuitful i think,what about this
  6. 02:49:779 (1,2) - bad looking,some times a easy and careful blanket is the best
  7. 03:02:570 (6,1) - make this symmetry
  8. 03:08:817 (1,2) - isnt perfect,if you change 03:08:817 (1) - ,dont forget 03:07:627 (5) -
Hard
  1. 00:13:607 (4,6) -
  2. 00:16:284 (1,2) - blanket more careful
  3. 01:09:234 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - that's great
  4. 01:32:437 (1,3) -
  5. 01:53:557 (4,5) - blanket more careful
  6. 01:57:127 (2,3,4,5) - why not 120' to each others
  7. 02:10:959 - add a circle?more suit i think
  8. 02:12:893 (5) - what about this slider end at 02:13:339 - and add a circle at 02:13:488 -
  9. 02:16:463 (3) - if you acceppt ^,change like^
  10. in fact,i think this time 02:10:959 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - this rhythm like is very cute,so why let it go,if i were you i will catch it
  11. 02:45:912 (3,4) - i dont think its better than a easy blanket

nice map!! :) :)
Good Luck!
Topic Starter
Lanturn
LZCSC

LZCSC wrote:

( ^0^)/[from BMT]\(^0^ )

General
your rhythm is great!!but the note you set and blanket isnt careful i think,and slider some times is strange,i dont think it have a good look. This map isn't made to be the most beautiful thing in the world. I actually intended the design of this to give a more 'old' feel to it because this song is very very old itself. I want to to be compared to a 2008/2009 map but have a modern day rhythm. This is why I didn't use a number of these suggestions because I'm not trying to beautify or blanket everything 100%.

Easy
  1. 00:09:591 - this green line is useless Removed.
  2. 00:41:867 (2) - this is better looking i think Changed.
  3. 01:22:323 (1,1) - better looking Alright.
  4. 01:46:715 (1,2) - isnt Perfect symmetry Control+G twice on the first one fixed it.
  5. 02:02:481 (2,3) - isnt blanket perfect Nudged the end over slightly
  6. 02:20:627 (1) - more suit the rhythm with this look nah. the vocals fit this slider pretty well actually.
  7. 02:29:551 (5,1) - bad looking!!not at all bad looking.
  8. 02:32:228 (2,3) - ^ Nope. Just because there are some overlaps doesn't make it bad. It's fine.

    Normal
    1. 01:16:373 (5) - ctrl+G? No.The flow would be counteracted with the setup then. See the (1)
    2. 01:18:158 (1,2) - 01:19:051 (2) - 's head is to close to the body of 01:18:158 (1) - Slighty adjusted this my own way.
    3. 01:23:810 (2,1) - isnt blanket perfect It's fine. No need to change anything.
    4. 01:46:715 (1) - bad look ,what about this I like it how it is.
    5. 02:18:842 (7) - this thythmis a little bit unsuitful i think,what about this Nope. This fits perfectly with the music.
    6. 02:49:779 (1,2) - bad looking,some times a easy and careful blanket is the best Nope. I altered it slightly, but I left it mainly as is. Not caring about blankets for these, as it creates some rise and the blankets would ruin their purpose.
    7. 03:02:570 (6,1) - make this symmetry No reason to.
    8. 03:08:817 (1,2) - isnt perfect,if you change 03:08:817 (1) - ,dont forget 03:07:627 (5) - Small adjustments.
    Hard
    1. 00:13:607 (4,6) - Pass on this as well to stick to my classic feel.
    2. 00:16:284 (1,2) - blanket more careful Nudged the tail over slightly then.
    3. 01:09:234 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - that's great Thanks.
    4. 01:32:437 (1,3) - Changed to match somewhat similar to what you had.
    5. 01:53:557 (4,5) - blanket more careful not intended to be a 100% full blanket. but it is symmetry balanced.
    6. 01:57:127 (2,3,4,5) - why not 120' to each others It doesn't really need to be? They aren't touching the center anyways.
    7. 02:10:959 - add a circle?more suit i think Pass on this. No reason to it.
    8. 02:12:893 (5) - what about this slider end at 02:13:339 - and add a circle at 02:13:488 - No to this rhythm change. I follow the drums and vocals mostly, with one or two exceptions, and changing the rhythm like this wouldn't really suit the mapset as a whole.
    9. 02:16:463 (3) - if you acceppt ^,change like^
    10. in fact,i think this time 02:10:959 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - this rhythm like is very cute,so why let it go,if i were you i will catch it ^
    11. 02:45:912 (3,4) - i dont think its better than a easy blanket Not changing this. It's probably one of the best felt parts in the song actually.

nice map!! :) :)
Good Luck!

Thanks for the mod. Hopefully you can understand by how I want this map to feel more 'old' looking than today's maps. :3
HabiHolic
░░░░░░░░░░░████
░░░░░░░░░░█░░░█
░░░░░░░░░█░░░░█
███████▄▄█░░░░░██████▄
▓▓▓▓▓▓█░░░░░░░░░░░░░░█
▓▓▓▓▓▓█░░░░░░░░░░░░░░█
▓▓▓▓▓▓█░░ BATs Rank This ░░█
▓▓▓▓▓▓█░░░░ Please! ░░░░█
▓▓▓▓▓▓█░░░░░░░░░░░░░░█
▓▓▓▓▓▓█████░░░░░░░░░█
░░░░░░░░░░░████████
samplefish
can we watch more pokemon

Topic Starter
Lanturn

samplefish wrote:

can we watch more pokemon

Yes. I need more hilarious puns from Brock <3
Heanday
Ranked please :o
Eni
Revived from the grave!

░░░░░░░░░░░████
░░░░░░░░░░█░░░█
░░░░░░░░░█░░░░█
███████▄▄█░░░░░██████▄
▓▓▓▓▓▓█░░░░░░░░░░░░░░█
▓▓▓▓▓▓█░░░░░░░░░░░░░░██
▓▓▓▓▓▓█░░ BATs Please Rank ░░█
▓▓▓▓▓▓█░░░░░░ This! ░░░░░█
▓▓▓▓▓▓█░░░░░░░░░░░░░░█
▓▓▓▓▓▓█████░░░░░░░░░█
░░░░░░░░░░░█████████
Topic Starter
Lanturn
I'll revive this again in a month :P

Unless a BAT wants to mod this before then :D
happy30
Hey there!
you asked in #modreq for a BATrequest.
I looked a bit over your map and I think the map needs some tidying up before it can be shown to BATs for easy rank~
Here's my mod to help you.

[Easy]
Sliders go a bit too fast for my taste, the spacing seems a little too small too, which hurts the flow imo. Somehow I think the patterns look better with circle-size 2.5
Oh well,
00:35:917 (1) - This note is a little too far from the previous sliderend. make the prev/next both 0.70x?
02:20:627 - add a clap
03:21:906 (1) - make the end softer in volume.

[Normal]
00:55:550 (1) - this is a pretty boring slider, there's much more room in the song to come up with a more interesting pattern here. Even for the sake of symmetry I would change the rhythm to make it a bit more interesting.
01:01:500 (1,2,3,4) - inconsistent spacing.
01:06:259 (1,2,3,4,5) - try to make this a little neater, like:

01:16:373 (5) - let this slider start 1/2 later and remove (6)? It would fit a lot better with the vocals here.
02:14:678 - add finish
03:21:906 (1) - make the end softer in volume.

[Hard]
00:03:790 (4) - Could you move this a grid or so up to make the spacing in this combo equal?

During the first kiai there are a lot of spacing inconsistencies. The spacing varies between 1.00x and 1.35x.
00:11:525 (1,2) - this might be understandable as a small jump, but 00:14:499 (5) - seems a little off since 00:13:309 (3) - has a normal 1.00x prev/next.
If this was intended, it's not really an issue in readability, but at least make the inconsitency consistent. Meaning that you should have a 1.2x prev/next at 00:19:259 (5) - as well, to be consistent with 00:14:499 (5) -

00:15:540 (7) - make prev/next equal.
00:20:746 (9,10,1) - I would put the NC on the first note of the stack. Especially since yellow is a much brighter color, and the past triples were spaced out I think this might confuse players.
00:26:101 (1,2,3) - I strongly suggest that the spacing in this combo should be equal. the blanketing looks nice, but the spacing makes the combo look messy!
00:29:968 (7) - the spacing here is inconsistent.
00:30:265 (8,9,1) - If you applied the other suggestion of NC on the first note, add it here too.
00:43:652 (7,8) - I don't really feel this jump here. It would play better in my opinion if this was just spaced 1.00x
00:44:544 (8) - add a finish on the end?
00:48:411 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - I don't really like the spacing increase and curve of this stream. how about this?
00:57:930 (5) - instead of this long slider,I think it would be nicer if you map the drums in the song, they offer room for nice hitsounding.
01:00:905 (4,1,2) - spacing looks messy and is inconsistent, maybe also make all sliders parallel?
01:07:152 (4) - add a clap?
01:13:101 (9) - move this a bit down to make prev/next equal
01:16:373 (5) - spacing again >_<
01:16:968 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - try the slider-to-stream tool to make a nicely curved stream!
01:22:174 (7) - prev/next are not equal, always disable grid snap with streams.
01:36:006 (3) - again, not really fond of the spacing inconsistency here.
01:36:899 (7,8,1) - NC suggestion as before.
01:43:741 (4) - make prev/next equal here too, the jump is fine though.
01:44:931 (2) - ^
01:47:608 (2,5) - these sliders are kissing, can you make them not touch eachother?
01:50:285 (1,2) - why suddenly these sliders instead of a stream? it's a bit anti-climatic. Try to keep things consistent :P
02:00:994 (3) - finish on start?
02:02:779 (5) - prev/next ><
02:03:969 (7) - ^
02:05:159 (1) - ^
02:05:456 (2,3) - why did you use the short slider here? I think 2 regular notes plays better, like you used at other similar parts.
02:05:754 (3) - I personally don't really like this long slider that much, I would place regular notes at 1/2 intervals to emphasize the lyrics here!
02:28:064 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - as well as for this stream, try the slider to stream tool.
02:35:203 (9) - prev/next
02:39:070 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - ^
02:43:234 (5) - again with the inconsistent spacing.
02:44:722 (8,9,1) - NC suggestion here too~
02:45:614 (2) - spacing
02:47:399 (1,2,3) - aaaahhh. It's the final kiai. please make it a normal stream to build up that tension! lol
02:54:241 (10) - delete the finish on start?
02:59:000 (8,9,1) - NC suggestion
03:08:519 (2,3,1) - ^
03:11:792 (5) - spacing
03:13:576 (1,2,3,4) - this combo looks rather messy to me, the spacing is too inconsistent and doesn't really make it flow like it should. especially 4 and 5 don't really flow into eachother, and the jump from 5 to 6 is rather big too. I would rethink the patterns here if I were you.
03:21:906 (1) - make the end softer in volume.
Topic Starter
Lanturn
happy30

happy30 wrote:

Hey there!
you asked in #modreq for a BATrequest.
I looked a bit over your map and I think the map needs some tidying up before it can be shown to BATs for easy rank~
Here's my mod to help you.

[Easy]
Sliders go a bit too fast for my taste, the spacing seems a little too small too, which hurts the flow imo. Somehow I think the patterns look better with circle-size 2.5 Yeah, The SV is a bit fast, and the spacing is a bit small, but I'm fine with it. It plays Easily enough and it really isn't worth a remap over. I'm perfectly fine with it. I did lower the CS to 2.5 though.
Oh well,
00:35:917 (1) - This note is a little too far from the previous sliderend. make the prev/next both 0.70x? Nice catch, fixed.
02:20:627 - add a clap Fixed.
03:21:906 (1) - make the end softer in volume. I don't think I can go softer than 5% X_x

[Normal]
00:55:550 (1) - this is a pretty boring slider, there's much more room in the song to come up with a more interesting pattern here. Even for the sake of symmetry I would change the rhythm to make it a bit more interesting. The main purpose of this slider was to avoid a complex rhythm due to the vocals. I think it is fine as is.
01:01:500 (1,2,3,4) - inconsistent spacing. Fixed.
01:06:259 (1,2,3,4,5) - try to make this a little neater, like: Sure, spruced this up a bit.

01:16:373 (5) - let this slider start 1/2 later and remove (6)? It would fit a lot better with the vocals here. I think this would cut off the drums a bit too much personally, and it really cuts off the symmetry if I do this. Might seem a bit Lazy this way, but I honestly like what I've come up with here. Players are still expecting to hit the drum note anyways from the previous ones.
02:14:678 - add finish Actually supposed to be a clap, neverthless, thanks for pointing out the missing hitsound.
03:21:906 (1) - make the end softer in volume. Same as Easy. I can't lower it past 5%

[Hard]
00:03:790 (4) - Could you move this a grid or so up to make the spacing in this combo equal? I moved the (2) before it so it'll be equal, and also dropped (3) up 1y

During the first kiai there are a lot of spacing inconsistencies. The spacing varies between 1.00x and 1.35x.
00:11:525 (1,2) - this might be understandable as a small jump, but 00:14:499 (5) - seems a little off since 00:13:309 (3) - has a normal 1.00x prev/next.
If this was intended, it's not really an issue in readability, but at least make the inconsitency consistent. Meaning that you should have a 1.2x prev/next at 00:19:259 (5) - as well, to be consistent with 00:14:499 (5) - I moved 14:499 to 1.0 just to simplify this.

00:15:540 (7) - make prev/next equal. Done. Yay me, and streams with distance snap over a year ago >_<.
00:20:746 (9,10,1) - I would put the NC on the first note of the stack. Especially since yellow is a much brighter color, and the past triples were spaced out I think this might confuse players. This is just a personal NC preference. I don't really like making lead-in notes the start of an NC. I've never noticed this blinding effect when I play through it, but I'll keep this in mind. I don't think there is a problem with it though.
00:26:101 (1,2,3) - I strongly suggest that the spacing in this combo should be equal. the blanketing looks nice, but the spacing makes the combo look messy! I actually like this setup. It's all 1.35 spacing from back at the previous (8) and slows itself down to create the 1/1 spacing at 1.0 DS. after starting on the (3)
00:29:968 (7) - the spacing here is inconsistent. Fixed this, and fixed 00:31:455 (2) -
00:30:265 (8,9,1) - If you applied the other suggestion of NC on the first note, add it here too. Ah nope, personal preference.
00:43:652 (7,8) - I don't really feel this jump here. It would play better in my opinion if this was just spaced 1.00x Eh. I thought it fit pretty well. I went with a 1.2 DS here so blanket nicely, so it's still a minor jump.
00:44:544 (8) - add a finish on the end? Clap fits better, changed the finish from Easy though (inconsistent)
00:48:411 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - I don't really like the spacing increase and curve of this stream. how about this? I'd rather keep what I have, but I tidied up my version a bit. The reason being is that I alternate between 1.0 and 0.7 streams throughout the song so I'm trying to keep variety.
00:57:930 (5) - instead of this long slider,I think it would be nicer if you map the drums in the song, they offer room for nice hitsounding. I actually really love that slider, so I want to keep it. It matches the vocals extremely well in feeling.
01:00:905 (4,1,2) - spacing looks messy and is inconsistent, maybe also make all sliders parallel? I don't really see anything here that I want to change. I'm happy with all the slider positions, and how they're laid out.
01:07:152 (4) - add a clap? I actually find this better to play without the clap. Kind of like a fade-out to hectic start feel. Not sure how to explain it better though.
01:13:101 (9) - move this a bit down to make prev/next equal Done.
01:16:373 (5) - spacing again >_< Actually, this is intended for only myself from a year ago would know the reason.
01:16:968 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - try the slider-to-stream tool to make a nicely curved stream! If only I knew this thing existed way back in time. Anyways, done I guess.
01:22:174 (7) - prev/next are not equal, always disable grid snap with streams. For sure :P
01:36:006 (3) - again, not really fond of the spacing inconsistency here. Eh. I'm actually fine with this spacing.
01:36:899 (7,8,1) - NC suggestion as before. Same as above as well :3
01:43:741 (4) - make prev/next equal here too, the jump is fine though. I'd like to keep them different, but with the next mod, I made slight changes so that 01:43:443 (3,4) - are mirrors of 01:44:633 (1,2) -
01:44:931 (2) - ^
01:47:608 (2,5) - these sliders are kissing, can you make them not touch eachother? Nudged it up a little.
01:50:285 (1,2) - why suddenly these sliders instead of a stream? it's a bit anti-climatic. Try to keep things consistent :P Because I overuse streams a lot in this song, so I wanted a little bit of variety. This is also why I do it later on as you mentioned as well.
02:00:994 (3) - finish on start? Nope, much like the mod earlier, it feels better with claps instead of finishes.
02:02:779 (5) - prev/next ><
02:03:969 (7) - ^
02:05:159 (1) - ^ Fixed these.
02:05:456 (2,3) - why did you use the short slider here? I think 2 regular notes plays better, like you used at other similar parts. Variety. It's really the only time in the song I use it. I changed this around though and made it circles :D
02:05:754 (3) - I personally don't really like this long slider that much, I would place regular notes at 1/2 intervals to emphasize the lyrics here! Very true. I think the original reasoning for this was 1. to prepare for the upcoming onslaught of streams by giving a 1/1 break, and 2. to prepare the drums. Who knows what I was thinking in the past though. I honestly feel like I should keep this as is so it doesn't get so cramped up.
02:28:064 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - as well as for this stream, try the slider to stream tool. Fixed this and the previous with it.
02:35:203 (9) - prev/next done.
02:39:070 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - ^ I manually fixed this one. It's too stupid to use a slider tool to create with. :D
02:43:234 (5) - again with the inconsistent spacing. This one was intentional, but now that I look at it. It's dumb, removed the extra spacing.
02:44:722 (8,9,1) - NC suggestion here too~ I'll just go hide in the corner >_<;
02:45:614 (2) - spacing Fixed this section.
02:47:399 (1,2,3) - aaaahhh. It's the final kiai. please make it a normal stream to build up that tension! lol lol. I honestly like the reverses so I want to keep them.
02:54:241 (10) - delete the finish on start? This can actually be heard in the background.
02:59:000 (8,9,1) - NC suggestion
03:08:519 (2,3,1) - ^ Same, going to stick with my preferences on them.
03:11:792 (5) - spacing I'm fine with this 1.12 to 1.24 increase.
03:13:576 (1,2,3,4) - this combo looks rather messy to me, the spacing is too inconsistent and doesn't really make it flow like it should. especially 4 and 5 don't really flow into eachother, and the jump from 5 to 6 is rather big too. I would rethink the patterns here if I were you. Alright. Changed this around quite a bit.
03:21:906 (1) - make the end softer in volume. Same as Easy/Normal 5% already.

Thanks for the huge mod :) A lot of the problems were definitely from my inexperience as a mapper a year ago, but I should have cleaned them up myself rather then have people point them out to me. Anyways I appreciate the time!
Pho
Hey there, just a random mod flying by~
There's not much left to do, so i try to point out some last fixes maybe. :D

[Easy]
00:50:791 (2,3) - I'm not sure if distance changes within in an easy map are appropriate. Maybe NC at 3 to make it clear or equalize it.
01:27:082 - add a clap HS here.
01:55:640 (5) - nazi stuff, but maybe push down the end point of this slider a bit to align better with 01:57:127 (1) - http://puu.sh/aZMvD/a0f938acd8.jpg
02:02:481 (2,3) - check the blanket here again http://puu.sh/aZMxR/c51b7d434a.jpg
02:12:298 (2,3,4) - ^, i think this isn't symmetrical yet. The middle anchor of slider 3 should be put a little 4 pixels to the right.
02:49:779 (1) - 30% vol. on this note seems a bit too low for me, maybe push it up to 50%? This goes for all diffs.
02:53:943 (4) - maybe add a finish HS here.

[Normal]
00:05:575 (2,1) - I think it would look better if it where symmetrical, http://puu.sh/aZN3d/dfb11f4658.jpg but this is just my opinion.

[Hard]
00:48:411 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Hmm, I don't really like the current shape of the stream. Try to make a rounder one which also aligns to the green circle: http://puu.sh/aZNWX/b8206cbd5a.jpg -> http://puu.sh/aZNYq/c36ae4f1e4.jpg
01:25:298 (1) - Add a clap HS here.
01:53:557 (4,5) - this bow pattern blanket isn't correct yet http://puu.sh/aZOk1/13393bc08b.jpg
02:20:032 (1,2) - have you thought about blanketing these? Maybe like http://puu.sh/aZOrT/332d6d037d.jpg
02:50:671 (2,3,4) - I'm sure it would look better if you make it symmetrical here. http://puu.sh/aZOGX/048ff8e1ba.jpg

Now this is just a nostalgic song. *-* Please get this ranked soon.
Hope this small cleanup helps to enhance your chances of getting bubbled, good luck! :)

Greetings,
paseli
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply