[General]
Remove Drake Bell from the tags since it is already the artist and its findable. And I think Josh too.
In CtB you should use the same OD as AR.
[quote="from
wiki":39af9]
Overall Difficulty should have the same value as the Approach Rate. This is just a standardized value, as OD does not affect gameplay nor the amount of fruits a spinner has, just the max score of a difficulty.
[Cup]
I know this is just a cup but
00:2:828 and 00:21:290 is missing a note (circle). I think it will work well with the rhythm. The first isn't necessary, but I also hear a part of the vocal at the second one.
00:22:674 - place here a circle, sounds better to me.
00:21:290 (6) - Add NC here and remove from 00:22:905 (1) - here. Of course, just if you applied what I wrote above.
00:35:597 - You should place a circle here for better rhythm.
00:37:443 - And to here. It will goes with the "you" part.
[Salad]
How about AR6 here? And 7 or 8 on Platter.
00:28:674 (5) - Remove clap from here or 00:29:597 (6) - add here too (maybe the second one is the better). With this the rhythm which is same get some consistency.
00:39:982 - I think you should place a note here. I works well with the rhythm.
[Platter]
I think AR7 (or 8) is acceptable for this difficulty. And it still works well with the song.
00:48:059 (5) - This should be just a single note. This slider is sounds too much for me.
This diff should be a bit more jumpy. Since this is the hardest one. I highlight you some places where you should map some jump pattern to make the map a bit harder.
00:20:597 (5,6) - Between these. I think you should place (6) a bit to the left side.
00:27:520 (5,1) - Here too. There should be a tiny jump.
00:28:443 (2,3) - And between these two too.
00:35:136 (3,4,5) - Same as before. A tiny jump should be here.
00:40:905 (1,2,3,4) - This part also be a bit more jumpy. Add some space between 1-2 and 3-4 too, since the rhythm is the same.
00:44:597 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^
00:46:674 (2,3,4,5) - Here too.
I know this is just a platter, but since this is your hardest diff it should be harder a bit. For me the platter is only at an acceptable level when I need some try to fc it. Not impossible but is shouldn't be fcable at the first try. Currently your Platter is too easy. You need to work better with the rhythm.
[]
In general I think your mapset is okay, but you mapped it too easy. Cup and Salad are on the acceptable level but you should make Platter a bit harder (or alternatively map a harder diff, but with this song that will be a bad idea). You don't need to map uncatchable jumps but there should be jumps where they belongs. And when you are mapping CtB you should think in horizontal your map is even looks good for a standard mapset which is why all diff is too easy. When you place a note (or slider), you need to think about how they will look on a horizontal pattert. So even if you place a slider horizontal it will be diagonal same if you place it diagonal. If you place a horizontal slider and at the end place a note it will always come straight after the slider makes it borring especially if there should be a jump.
Thats all I think.
tr;dr You should make at least the Platter a bit harder.