Thank for mod. ^^

IRC mod by request


Nice Map and SB~ Shoot Star

Tari wrote:

IRC mod by request

IRC Mod

19:23 Oyatsu: done~
19:23 Oyatsu: Can we continue?
19:23 Tari: Ok
19:23 Tari: I will mod normal now
19:24 Oyatsu: update plz
19:25 Tari: oh
19:25 Tari: must fix source
19:25 Tari: its Cafe Sourire
19:25 Tari: not Care sourire
19:25 Oyatsu: ah
19:25 Tari: Cafe sourire*
19:25 Oyatsu: @@
19:25 Oyatsu: ok
19:26 Oyatsu: S-> s @@
19:28 Tari: Change s -> S
19:29 Oyatsu: done~
19:29 Oyatsu: really it isn't problem ><
19:29 Tari: ok I start modding now
19:30 Tari: 00:19:031 (4) - Can you move down and little bit right? for better blanket
19:30 Oyatsu: wait
19:30 Tari: In Normal
19:30 Tari: ?
19:30 Oyatsu: ok
19:30 Oyatsu: fixed
19:31 Tari: 00:38:695 (3) - Add whistle to end?
19:34 Tari: 01:07:434 (3) - and maybe move down more?
19:34 Oyatsu: fixed before
19:34 Oyatsu: this not fix
19:35 Oyatsu: I think make that not balance
19:35 Tari: 01:32:140 (2) - make symmetrical?
19:35 Tari: http://puu.sh/3DW3f.jpg
19:36 Oyatsu: fixed
19:37 Tari: 01:37:686 (1) - and move this 2 grid up?
19:37 Oyatsu: fixed
19:38 Tari: 01:38:190 (2) - and move to x:384 y:216 better here
19:38 Tari: perfect symmetry
19:38 Oyatsu: fixed
19:40 Tari: well that all for normal
19:41 Tari: move to hard?
19:41 Oyatsu: ok
19:42 Tari: 00:06:174 (5,6) - Maybe try this: http://puu.sh/3DWjC.jpg
19:43 Oyatsu: fixed
19:44 Tari: oh you add jump
19:44 Tari: :O
19:44 Oyatsu: yes
19:45 Tari: 00:19:031 (5) - curve more so it look like this : http://puu.sh/3DWpi.jpg
19:45 Oyatsu: Seems quite ugly ><
19:46 Oyatsu: I will consider
19:47 Tari: 00:27:098 (4) - maybe add jump here: http://puu.sh/3DWug.jpg 
19:47 Oyatsu: fixed
19:50 Tari: 01:03:401 (1) - Move to here http://puu.sh/3DWCo.jpg
19:51 Oyatsu: fixed
19:52 Tari: 01:14:241 (3,4,5) - try this: 01:14:241 (3,4,5) - 
19:53 Oyatsu: ?
19:53 Tari: oh
19:53 Tari: http://puu.sh/3DWIf.jpg
19:53 Tari: Sorry
19:53 Tari: ><
19:53 Oyatsu: ^^
19:53 Oyatsu: fixed
19:54 Tari: 01:16:258 (2) - no stack?
19:54 Tari: confusing click orz
19:54 Oyatsu: fixed
19:55 Tari: 01:18:274 (3) - Add whistle?
19:55 Tari: to start
19:55 Oyatsu: fixed
19:57 Tari: 01:37:182 (4) - Decrease spacing?
19:57 Tari: Jump too big 0.0
19:58 Oyatsu: fixed
19:59 Tari: 01:18:274 (3,4,5) - maybe try this? http://puu.sh/3DWWN.jpg
20:00 Oyatsu: fixed
20:01 Tari: 00:56:342 (6,7) - I like this pattern better http://puu.sh/3DX1N.jpg
20:02 Oyatsu: I prefer mine will better
20:03 Tari: well that all for hard
20:04 Tari: now insane ok?
20:04 Oyatsu: ok
20:05 Tari: I think maybe HP-1? for insane, song is slow
20:05 Oyatsu: ?
20:05 Oyatsu: Hp= Hard? ><
20:05 Tari: HP Drain Rate in "Difficulty" 
20:05 Tari: drop by 1 
20:06 Oyatsu: Hard, HP+6
20:06 Oyatsu: Isane, HP+7
20:06 Oyatsu: If -1
20:06 Tari: ok ><
20:06 Oyatsu: Isane=Hard 
20:06 Tari: I understand
20:06 Oyatsu: ok
20:08 Tari: 00:25:964 (4,5,6) - Maybe try this? http://puu.sh/3DXhO.jpg
20:09 Oyatsu: I unchange
20:09 Oyatsu: sorry
20:12 Tari: 00:46:258 (4) - Move up better blanket?
20:12 Tari: 00:48:527 (5) - and move down and right more better blanket too ><
20:12 Oyatsu: fixed
20:13 Oyatsu: fixed
20:14 Tari: 00:50:039 (2,3,4,5,6) - try this pattern? http://puu.sh/3DXty.jpg
20:14 Oyatsu: 1 pattern I like
20:15 Oyatsu: unchange
20:16 Tari: 01:06:174 (4) - Move slider end to right?
20:16 Tari: for better stack
20:16 Oyatsu: fixed
20:17 Tari: 01:18:527 (3) - Same here, move slider end down for better stack
20:17 Oyatsu: fixed
20:19 Tari: 01:11:468 (2) - Add finish?
20:19 Oyatsu: fixed
20:20 Tari: 01:27:602 (3) - Maybe add whistle to start?
20:21 Oyatsu: fixed
20:22 Tari: 01:35:417 (1) - and whistle to slider end?
20:22 Oyatsu: fixed
20:22 Tari: Ok
20:22 Tari: I finish my mod!
20:22 Tari: :D
20:22 Oyatsu: Go! Post!
20:22 Tari: I will give you star
20:22 Tari: its good map :O
20:22 Oyatsu: Thank you alot for modding ^^

Nice Map and SB~ Shoot Star

Thanks for mod, Tari

hi ~
Duca daisuki desu <3






Good Luck

Thanks for modding, Xinely ^^

Hi Hi ~

Red = Unrankable or you should fix somethings.
Green = Just chat or General things
Blue = Please consider it. your pattern or something seems to really strange. high level suggestion.

General

Easy

Normal

Hard

Insane

That's all nice mapset ~ GL anyway

Thank for mod and star~, scanter-san. Almost fixed. ^^

Sorry Oyatsu! /lazy for mod

EDIT: Delete from me blacklist (Queue if you remember)

Hi, thx M4M
[Insane]
00:27:476 (2) - Move to (158,339)?
00:46:258 (4) - Try this http://puu.sh/3FDXr.jpg
00:59:871 (8) - clap
01:03:653 (9,10,11) - Those note don't fit this song. Try this rhythm. Of course, you can use slider. http://puu.sh/3FE4N
01:18:527 (3) - Move to (360,271)
01:19:535 (1) - Move to (205,122)
01:20:291 (2) - finish?
01:22:560 (4) - finish!
01:30:123 (9) - clap!
01:31:384 - finish!!
01:31:132 (2) - clap!!

[Hard]
00:30:627 - Add Hitsound on slider tick?
00:32:644 (8) - clap
00:40:585 - remove clap and 00:40:711 - add clap
01:31:132 - clap
01:32:140 - clap

[Easy]
01:39:703 (1) - you should move this spinner end at 01:43:737 -

good luck

Modding upon request~
Duca~ look at my sig xD

Black is suggestion
Blue is highly recommended
Red is unrankable

[General]
you have two .osb files, probably a result of title change; delete the one that is not in use
Great SB! One suggestion though: ask BATs to display the artist/title scroll at 00:08:947, fits nicely with the song and your SB setup
Also Easy/Hard seems to end at 01:43:863 whereas Normal/Insane ends at 01:43:737, you need to end your spinners at the same spot across all diffs

[Easy]
00:22:560 (2) - move this a bit up to form a triangle with 00:20:543 (4,1)
00:43:737 (4) - blanket here can be improved ><
01:22:560 (1) - a perfectly symmetrical slider here would look alot better since its the only object between 2 spinners
01:27:602 (1) - this is too soon after spinner for Easy, either delete this note or shorten the spinner to 01:26:594 to give players more time to react
01:31:636 (5) - NC pattern is kinda messed here, NC is supposed to be on this slider and 01:35:669 (3)
01:38:190 (1) - it would fit the music better if you deleted this note and started 01:38:695 (2) at 01:38:443

[Normal]
00:07:434 (5) - two whistles on this slider sounds quite abrupt, would suggest you to remove one
00:35:165 (2) - should have a S:C2 finish on the start to math the other diffs
00:47:770 (2,3) - this is a bit flow disturbing, move 00:48:022 (3) up for a better oval flow
01:11:972 (4,5) - positioning it like this would look alot better here: 01:28:106 (2,3) - make these align properly, seems to be your intention anyways
01:32:140 (2) - move 1 grid right would make this symmetrical on the y-axis like 01:30:375 (6) (also move everything afterwards 1 grid right and you get a nice symmetry on 01:36:678 (5,6,1,2) as well)

[Hard]
00:04:157 (6) - i expected a whistle on the repeat here to cover the bell sound in the music
00:15:501 (3,4) - these are actually very hard to play, since most players would assume they have the same number of repeats, which is not the case. Remove a repeat on 00:16:006 (4) and construct a 1/2 slider starting at 00:16:510 and ending at 00:16:762, and u can delete the circle there.
00:37:182 (1,2) - try ctrl+g on these two, flows alot better imo
00:40:207 (2) - remove the clap on the end, sounds really weird when heard so close with the clap on 00:40:711 (3)
00:42:728 (4) - forgot a whistle on the end
00:50:543 (2,4) - perfectly stack the two ><
01:03:905 (2,3) - same as 00:15:501 (3,4)
01:11:468 (1) - remove NC to keep consistent with the first part of the kiai

[Insane]
00:18:527 (5,1) - its better if you did a 1/2 slider at 00:18:527 and a 1/1 slider at 00:19:031 to follow the vocals here
00:27:098 (1,2) - stack these properly, the way you have it right now makes the stack look abnormal due to stack leniency in game play
00:34:913 (5,1) - these two sliders should have the same curve according to your placement here
00:49:283 (1) - from here on you should NC every 4/4 measure to prevent combo colours from going past 10
00:50:795 (5,6,7) - these should have the same spacing to mirror the effects of 00:50:039 (2,3,4)
00:59:871 (8) - forgot clap here
01:01:888 (4) - the overheld slider here doesn't make alot of sense since there is no vocal hold present, end it regularly at 01:02:140 to capture the vocal start there
01:04:661 (10,11) - these should have whistles on them to indicate that they are following the pianos instead of the drums, or else they wont make alot of sense when players try to hit them
01:20:291 (2) - add a finish since there is finish in the music (you can reduce the volume for it if you see fit)
01:22:560 (4,5,6,7) - shoudn't this be a spacing increase? seems more reasonable considering your previous spacing changes
01:31:258 - add a note to cover for the drums?
01:38:947 (1,2) - this could easily be misread as 3/4 spacing due to the large jump you did for 01:37:686 (1,2,3) with equivalent distance, a good solution is to add a note at 01:38:695 indicating that the rhythm has changed, or else you should reposition your notes in this section

I wrote up the mod and then i pressed back space by accident orz, what you see is what i can still remember from the top of my head. Please excuse me if some stuff doesnt sound right to you ><

Must say the map/SB is done really well, here is a star and good luck on ranking~

Thank you for modding

Hi. m4m
















Good luck.


Edit : OMG.. post bug shit.. if you don't understand part, pm me please.

Thank for modding, Glogu-chan ><

hi
from me queoe

[Easy]

The place that you should fix is not found.

[Normal]

The place that you should fix is not found.

[Hard]

1. 00:19:031 (5,6,7,8,9) -I felt sense of incongruity for those relations, distance of 5 and 6,6 and 7,7 and 8, 8 and 9.
   Because it is half-done, i suggest that you make the same distance.

1. 01:11:468 (1,2,3) - Because distance is near though a timing is long, it is hard to swat it.
   
   I suggest that make it in this way.

   ↓First, i moved a position of 01:10:711 (5)
   ↓Next,i moved it to put a position of 01:11:846 (2) on 01:10:711 (5) .Finally i alined 01:12:224 (3) .

[Insane]

1. 00:16:006 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,1) - fix the flow

1. 01:21:552 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - -I felt sense of incongruity for those relations, distance of 1 and 2,2 and ......3 and 4, 4 and 5.lol
   Because it is half-done, i suggest that you make the same distance.

sorry i can't found many place you should fix

i love this map <3

i shoot kudosu star!

EnixYuki wrote:

[Hard]

1. 00:19:031 (5,6,7,8,9) -I felt sense of incongruity for those relations, distance of 5 and 6,6 and 7,7 and 8, 8 and 9.
   Because it is half-done, i suggest that you make the same distance. 1 way to increase distance. Maybe this I learn from Gloria Guard ><

1. 01:11:468 (1,2,3) - Because distance is near though a timing is long, it is hard to swat it. I understand your way but it is also quite hard to jump. SOrry Unchange
   
   I suggest that make it in this way.

   ↓First, i moved a position of 01:10:711 (5)
   ↓Next,i moved it to put a position of 01:11:846 (2) on 01:10:711 (5) .Finally i alined 01:12:224 (3) .

[Insane]

1. 00:16:006 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,1) - fix the flow

Nothing, I think they are fine

1. 01:21:552 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - -I felt sense of incongruity for those relations, distance of 1 and 2,2 and ......3 and 4, 4 and 5.lol
   Because it is half-done, i suggest that you make the same distance.

Increase distance as I said.

sorry i can't found many place you should fix

i love this map <3

i shoot kudosu star!

Thank for your advise. Although I unchange but also thank for star~ ^^

Yo.

[Storyboard]
Well.. Some things that I've noticed about your SB. It's really nice, but you can make it even better!

1. First of all, there's only one thing that really bugs me. In "compose" tab and during testplay/gameplay there's a white line in the right edge of screen. This line is flashing and it's really annoying sometimes. 01:09:577 - here's the screenshot. But it happens a lot, test your map and you'll see it.
2. Try to make fade effect for SB/FG/9 a bit longer. It disappears too fast an dit doesn't look really nice. I thing it's better if you start fading on 99451 (01:39:451)
   
   It looks really good. Hope to see more of your works soon.

[General]

1. Are you sure that epilepsy warning is needed here? I'd disable it because there's no any strobing effects!

[Easy]

1. 00:00:880 (1,3) - nazi - this overlap is not visible during gameplay, but it flows a bit strange. What if we'll try to make blanket slider with (2). It's still the same symmetrical and well-spaced pattern, but it flows much better!
2. Start all spinners in this diff 1/2 later. So, beginners will have some time to prepare for spinners and it'll fit with music better! Try it!
3. 01:36:174 (2,1) - I don't really like gap between these two beats. It's different from your regular rhythm, so it may confuse beginners. So, I've changeed rhythm here for you, here's the screenshot.
   Note: what exactly is changed? 01:37:182 - (2) ends here + 01:37:686 - 1/2 slider + 01:38:443 - 1/2 slider with repeat
   
   Good job!

[Normal]

1. Set OD/HP to 4 to get better balanced diff spread. It will fit with your patterns much better. Try it in action, and I promise - you'll like it!
2. 00:27:602 (5,1) - nazi - blanket here could be a little bit better. It's not a big deal, but I think you should do it!
   Note: feel free to poke me if you want code for any of my suggestions! I'll be happy to provide you with this codes
3. 00:54:577 (3) - Instead of this sldier, we can make something that will represent music much better. try 1/2 slider with repeat. It'll help you to emphasize clap sound and vocals!
4. 01:05:922 (2,3) - these sliders are cute, but that overlap confuses me a bit. You don't use such patterns often, so it looks a little bit strange. What if we'll try to make a blanket slider? example!
5. 01:37:686 (1,2,3) - some of loud beats are ignored, and some quite ones are mapped. It sounds kinda weird to me, so I strongly recommend you to use Ctrl+G for 01:37:686 (1,2)
   Note: don't forget to fix spacing and hitsounds if you agree!
   
   Rhythm in the end confused me but overall diff is fine.

[Hard]

1. 00:19:535 - How about making this tick a little bit louder. It'll fit better with vocals. Anyway, try it before saying "no"!
   Note: 00:25:837 - same. Well, it happens some more times. I think you can fix such patterns yourself, if you agree.
2. 00:19:031 (5) - 00:31:132 (4) - have you missed New Combos here? It sounds like you should place NCs here to emphasize vocals/music changes and to make comboing more consistent!
3. 01:02:392 (3,4) - blankets are a bit messy and DS is strange. It's too low for jump and too big for regular spacing. If you want, make spacing more consistent. So, it'll look like this
4. 01:38:695 - consider mapping this beat to get more consistent and enjoyable rhythm. It sounds kinda empty without it.

[Insane]

1. Try to use consistent spacing for all 1/4 patterns. It'll help us to read/understand your patterns better + it looks much neater.
2. 00:04:535 (7) - this circle feels more like overmap. I'd recommend you to remove it, but it's up to you.
   
   Nothing else. Nice diff. Well, just one more thing..think about using AR9, it'd fit better with your pattern.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Good luck!

Hello Oyatsu! BeatofIke here and mod request via in-game! :3

[General]

1. Why do you have 2 .osb files? You only need one! Go to File > Open Song Folder and remove the usused .osb file. I would keep a back-up in case you removed the wrong one.
2. Optional, but you could add "Cuffs" in your tags since the game was published and developed by them.
3. About the storyboard, I didn't witness any repetitive strobes or flashes. Therefore, it is not necessary to display epilepsy warning. I would disable it as it is not needed!
   
   Maps that use repetitive strobes, pulsing images, or flashing colors in the storyboard must use the epilepsy warning. There is one built-into the editor, which will display a visual warning at the beginning of the map and also mark the map's online thumbnail with a warning icon. Also, it helps to make a note of the flashing/strobes/etc. in the map's thread. This warning is absolutely needed so that players with epilepsy can avoid any danger.

[Easy]

1. 00:15:501 (3) - The rhythm feels empty with the hit circle alone. I recommend to turn this hit circle into a 1/1 slider (ending at 00:16:006) to complete the rhythm/musical section.
2. 00:22:560 (2,3) - For better readability, I would recommend to rearrange the notes like this as it has better polarity:
   
3. 01:18:527 (3,1) - Optional, but I think it would be better if you remove the spinner and map this part, since it's still part of the kiai section. How about rearranging the patterns like this? If suggested, add a new combo on slider 5 and remove the combo on the next note.
   
4. 01:36:174 (2,1) - Comparing to the music rhythm, I would recommend to rearrange the rhythm like this:
   

Feedback: The main thing I noticed in this map is the excellent hitsounding and storybording. With a little rearranging here and there, I think it will be ready for ranking!

[Normal]

1. I would increase the Overall difficulty to 4 or 5 for a more competitive gameplay.
2. 00:36:174 (4) - I believe you forgot to add the soft-whistle here as you added one on your Easy difficulty.
3. 00:53:821 (2,3,4) - Personally, I would rearrange this rhythm like this as it fits better with the music.
   
4. 01:18:022 (2) - Optional, but you could improve the curve of this slider shape. Here is an example:
   
   Image and Code

   
   

   200,168,78022,2,0,B|112:136|112:204|24:168,2,180,8|0|4,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

5. 01:31:636 (1,2) - This combo is too short lol. For an alternative, I would remove the combo at 01:34:157 and add a new combo at 01:35:669.

Feedback: Again, excellent hitsounding. Keep up the good work! :3

[Hard]

1. 00:47:644 (3,4) - The slider pattern could be improved. Her is an example:
   
   Image and Code

   
   

   348,156,47644,2,0,P|324:96|336:44,1,120,2|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   404,72,48274,2,0,P|336:40|256:56,1,160,8|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

2. 01:13:737 (2,3) - Eh, I do not understand this rhythm. What part of the music are you following? A better way to fix this is to simply replace the first slider with 2 hit circles. Seems like you are trying to follow the vocal lines, so I would recommend to rearrange the notes similar to this.
3. 01:22:812 (7) - This slider is offbeat due to the slider reverse and it's techincally unrankable. A good way to fix this is to replace this with a 1/2 reverse slider instead. It goes well with the vocal lines as well, so I would recommend it.

Feedback: Good map, but there were a few offbeat sliders here and there. The map has decent flow, but it could be improved with a few more quality mods. Hitsounds didn't let me down yet! :3

[Insane]

1. 00:16:006 (5,6) - Nothing major, but this spacing between these notes is inconsistent (0.9x spacing). Change the spacing to 0.5x.
2. 00:49:157 (9) - I would remove this note, since there are no instrument playing here.
3. 01:37:434 (7) - Consider adding a note here to finish the rhythm. The rhythm feels incomplete without it.

Feedback: Hitsounds, you pass! Similar to Hard, the maps has decent flow and a few overmapped sections. In addition, the blanklets could use some improvement as well. Good luck! :3

osu! needs more Duca! Good luck with your map!

Thank for mod Bakari ^^






Thank for mod ^^, Beato

from my queue





nice SBs lol Good luck~

HelloSCV wrote:

from my queue

Easy

00:30:627 (3) - missed clap fixed

Normal

00:39:199 - SC:2 finish is needed for consistence (and you added finish here on other diffs) ah yes
01:16:510 (6) - whistle on start fixed
01:22:056 (1) - finish? yes at end

Hard

00:15:501 (3,4,5) - no claps are purpsed? nope
00:32:644 (5) - ^ ^
00:34:409 (4,1) - this slider arrow is hidden even default skin is changed :/ I don't think so
01:04:409 (3,4) - need claps (if you fix 00:15:501 (3,4,5) - this) nope
01:30:880 (1) - delete NC and 01:31:888 (3) - add NC here 1 anti-jump. I keep sorry

Insane

00:07:686 (1) - this NC isn't need imo fixed
00:19:409 (2) - i think moving this note to 00:19:535 (2) - here is better? (or at least make 3/4 slider) I make as vocal
00:35:417 (6) - NC and 00:35:669 (1) - delete NC fixed
00:49:031 (8) - maybe need clap fixed
01:03:401 (8,9) - reverse rhythm? nope
01:04:661 (10,11) - is this rhythm intentional? but i think this rhythm fits better http://puu.sh/3HTkQ.jpg I don't think so
01:10:459 (1) - delete NC (for consistnece) ok
01:19:031 (4,1) - stack perfectly? -nazi yes

nice SBs lol Good luck~

Thank you for modding

IRC modded this =w=

For you =w=
Thank you~

Nothing to Say.really good diff


AR+1 ?
01:20:039 (3,4,1,2,3) - You like this? more beautiful.

180,288,80039,2,0,P|220:328|280:332,1,120,8|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
384,268,81048,2,0,P|399:213|374:159,1,120,8|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
264,108,82056,6,0,P|208:120|173:169,1,120,8|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
168,229,82812,1,0,0:0:0:0:
180,288,83064,1,8,0:0:0:0:

01:37:686 (1,2,3) - More better rhythm,follow with lyrics,like this.



00:04:913 (1) - Move x264 y188 try this.
00:06:174 (5) - 00:06:426 - here add whistle
00:24:577 (7,8) - try this. my suggestion.

236,184,24577,1,8,0:0:0:0:
324,260,24829,2,0,P|336:216|324:168,1,80,0|4,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

00:38:190 (4) - add whistle
01:01:888 (2) - end point add whistle?
01:37:686 (1,2,3,4) - you like this?



00:09:199 (1) - remove note?
00:10:207 - 00:14:745 - 00:42:224 - add whistle
00:19:409 (2,3) - slider follow better?

01:03:401 (8) - add Nc
01:29:619 (8) - ^

Satellite wrote:

Nothing to Say.really good diff


AR+1 ? this is a calm song. I think +4 for normal is fine
01:20:039 (3,4,1,2,3) - You like this? more beautiful. fixed. Thank for code ^^

SPOILER

180,288,80039,2,0,P|220:328|280:332,1,120,8|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
384,268,81048,2,0,P|399:213|374:159,1,120,8|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
264,108,82056,6,0,P|208:120|173:169,1,120,8|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
168,229,82812,1,0,0:0:0:0:
180,288,83064,1,8,0:0:0:0:

01:37:686 (1,2,3) - More better rhythm,follow with lyrics,like this. fixed



00:04:913 (1) - Move x264 y188 try this. fixed
00:06:174 (5) - 00:06:426 - here add whistle fixed
00:24:577 (7,8) - try this. my suggestion. Nice

236,184,24577,1,8,0:0:0:0:
324,260,24829,2,0,P|336:216|324:168,1,80,0|4,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

SPOILER

00:38:190 (4) - add whistle fixed
01:01:888 (2) - end point add whistle? fixed
01:37:686 (1,2,3,4) - you like this? fixed



00:09:199 (1) - remove note? Nope
00:10:207 - 00:14:745 - 00:42:224 - add whistle fixed
00:19:409 (2,3) - slider follow better? fixed

01:03:401 (8) - add Nc yea ><
01:29:619 (8) - ^ fixed


Good luck star~

Maybe All fixed. Thank for useful mod, Sate-san

Hi, from ask in game :'d









Gl !

Black - Suggestion
Blue - Highly recommended to fix
Red - Unrankable

[General]

Fixed some issues in .osb file (Inconsistency, not finished fades etc.) Duca - Kokoro no Tane (Short Ver.) (Oyatsu).osb
Increase volume at Kiai time on 70~80%. It's important to make volume of hitsounds and whole map's consistent so you hear both the same, but I hear only clap hitsounds here, but not normal hits.
It's not unrankable, but should be. Artist is: デュッカ and romanised artist: Duca. I'm 100% sure.
Source should be CAFE SOURIRE as says its official website. If you want to know if I'm sure, here's screen. I know other beatmaps has "Cafe Sourire", but official sources are just always 100% sure.
00:51:804 - Using soft-hitclap2 is kinda unnecessary on all the difficutlies at kiai time it totally doesn't fit the music.
Use your soft-slidertick2 more often on places like these:

1. 00:30:375
2. 00:39:703
3. 00:53:821
4. 00:54:829
5. 01:12:980
6. 01:13:989
7. 01:17:014
8. 01:32:140
9. 01:35:922

(I've written places from hard, there are some more on easier diffs, you should know which I mean, if not, call me and I will find them all), but please, this is think which I really want to see fixed so consider it and I will be happy.

[Insane]

00:04:031 (3,4,5,6,7) - This stream is unsymmetrical. I think it should be consistent with slider's shape so try these coordinates:

1. 00:04:031 (3) - 322;153
2. 00:04:157 (4) - 343;144
3. 00:04:283 (5) - 365;141
4. 00:04:409 (6) - 387;143
5. 00:04:535 (7) - 408;151

00:02:896 (1) - CTRL+G to fix flow break. Jump from 00:02:896 (1) to 00:03:653 (2) has better way after this and jump from 00:01:888 (5) to 00:02:896 (1) forces you to make unnatural movement, so it's bad flow.
00:15:501 (2,3,4) - You've used different snap than other streams have while you're following the same sound. Try this:

1. 00:15:501 (2) - 123;135
2. 00:15:627 (3) - 138;118
3. 00:15:753 (4) - 153;101

Btw. Angle is consistent with 00:14:493 (7) so it also makes symmetrical pattern.
00:19:031 (1) - 1/4 Slider sounds strange here. 1/3 slider fits better since it follows piano better.
01:20:543 (3) - CTRL+H, CTRL+J, CTRL+G and move on 153;219 to fix flow issue.

Nice Insane, a bit overmapped, but still it's nice to play.

[Hard]

00:48:274 (4) - CTRL+H, CTRL+J, CTRL+ G and move on 401;89 to fix flow break.. Don't worry about DS. Flow > DS
00:57:728 (3) - Move its end on 283;294 to make better blanket with 00:56:846 (7)

I think I don't have to say anything at these 3 diffs. They're just nice, but if you fix issue in normal about slider ticks, I will like them even more.

[Normal]

00:09:955 (1) - I don't think this is good idea. It will confuse newbies because they'll have tendence to start on 00:09:451 because there is a drum sound. I'd move it there and add a note on 00:10:459
01:07:434 (3) - Fix the overlap by moving on 39;196. I know of DS, it's okay.
01:29:115 (4) - It looks way better when they're exactly above themselves, just try how it looks when you move it on 200;183

[Easy]

00:38:695 (2) - Move this note on 189;124 to make perfect blanket with previous slider.
00:43:737 (4) - Move center point on 132;189. Same reason as ^.
00:50:291 (1) - Same problem as normal

Really nice map. Good luck with ranking.

Thank you for you guys. I'm lazy to reply. Sorry if you hope I reply ><

Hi from your req

Easy

00:08:443 - add note? or 00:07:434 (4) - one more repeat this? seemed there have a sound.
00:23:821 (3) - I know what you want to follow. But it's a little strange because other objects are put constantly. So, how about start from 00:23:569 - or add note there and shorten (3) slider?
00:40:459 - use SC2 as 00:39:703 -
01:38:695 - ^?

Normal

00:06:174 (3) - whistle?
00:07:434 (5) - use one circle on this? It seemed that 1/8 slider is a little strange.
00:47:770 (2) - whistle?
01:27:602 (1) - How about this rythem?
Hard

AR-1?
00:19:031 (1) - change to this form? 00:29:871 (3) - How about this rythem? 00:46:762 (4) - move to x:232 y:272?
01:07:812 - add note?
01:21:552 (3) - clap on finish

Insane

00:01:384 (3) - remove whistle
00:01:636 (4) - whistle
00:02:644 (6) - How about change to 1/16 slider to follow the melody?
00:14:997 (1) - lengthen (1) to 00:15:375 -
00:20:543 (4,5,6) - I think shouldn't be stack here, so move to x472 y:248?
00:38:190 (3) - How about this form? 01:20:291 (2) - switch to whistle?
01:21:552 (1) - same as Hard
01:39:073 (2) - add one more repeat seems better for me.

good luck

Thank for mod, wring-san. Fixed some stuffs

[General]
does the song have "(Short Ver.)" in the title? if not, suggest to delete it.

[Insane]
01:03:401 (1,2,3,4) -
suggest change to this patten. you might need to add hitsound.


[Hard]
00:20:039 (2,3,4) - no jump please, i thought it's 3/4 when first play.

abalee wrote:

[General]
does the song have "(Short Ver.)" in the title? if not, suggest to delete it. fixed

[Insane]
01:03:401 (1,2,3,4) -
suggest change to this patten. you might need to add hitsound. fixed


[Hard]
00:20:039 (2,3,4) - no jump please, i thought it's 3/4 when first play. fixed

Thank for modding

Hello! Drive-by modding~

[Insane]
I can't find anything wrong with this map. That's a good thing, right? So I'll just shower you with compliments instead, okay?

00:03:653 (2,3,4,5,6,7,1) - This is the point where I realized, wow, you must be a professional mapper. I pulled out my wallet and started tossing bills at the screen, because I'd pay you to map like this not really I'm poor sorry Skeptics at this point might yell, "OVERMAPPED" but not me. I believe in you.

00:16:006 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,1) - I really like the spacing on your streams. But um, this might just be me, maybe I'm blind, idk, but I think the start of this stream (the 5-circle) isn't placed on the stream curve. I think the positioning is off a bit, slightly too far up. pleasedonthurtme

00:18:527 (5) - Nice hitsound.

00:36:678 (4,1,2,3,4) - I'm really amazed at how well your sliders interact with one another. You utilize so many different spacings here but the sliders all seem to fit together so perfectly.

00:46:762 (5,1) - The corner is the perfect spot for this stack. I don't think it could have worked anywhere else.

00:49:283 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Hnnnnng accelerated spacing into repeat slider. This is like, my osu-fetish.

00:53:316 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - I love this combo, especially towards the end. The central jump (9,10,11) just completes it so well. Also your sliders have really, really nice curves. You arrange those gentle slopes in such a beautiful way. Er, please don't take that the wrong way.

01:03:401 (1,2,3) - The pieces here fit together so well. Like Legos. Or Tetris.

01:07:182 (6,7,8) - What is this called? There has to be a name for this specific kind of slider/hitcircle placement. Because it's just awesome. I'll call it the Oyatsu-Central-Slider-Stack-Jump from now on, until someone corrects me.

01:10:459 (6) - Let me just say that I love you for not stacking the beginning of this slider onto the 3-circle in this combo. Most mappers would be like omigosh, DISTANCE SNAP and slap it right on top of the 3-circle. But not you. <3

01:30:375 (3,1) - Okay, so about that last comment I made about the stack in the corner, and how it couldn't have worked anywhere else on the screen? I lied. Because somehow you managed to pull it off here as well. Somehow everything you do is fantastic. You're fantastic. Did anyone ever tell you that you're fantastic?

[Hard]
This is a very enjoyable map! I usually don't have this much fun playing through a map that isn't of 5-star difficulty. Your arrangement of map elements is aesthetically stunning, which, combined with your high degree of skill (or perhaps supreme intuition) at placing jumps, makes for extremely satisfying play.

01:11:468 (1,2,3) - It might be a good idea to arrange this in a way that isn't as linear. The vocal rhythm here gives you a lot of room to maneuver with your jumps, and linearity here is a bit boring in my opinion. Maybe this is the perfect opportunity to sneak in your patented Oyatsu-Central-Slider-Stack-Jump...?!

01:31:132 (2,3,4) - This plays somewhat awkwardly for me. I think it's the positioning of the long slider following the somewhat unexpected (in terms of the vocal rhythm) repeat slider. Another thing that I think is an issue is the skipped downbeat in the middle of the long slider, which is followed by a hitcircle after only 1/2 of a beat. I think that skipping over the downbeat here causes the player to expect a longer delay following the slider release. I can't really explain it too well I guess, but for me this section is just a bit strange.

[Normal]
Approach Rate up to 5 (+1). AR4 is much too slow; and in fact seems to make the timings a lot harder to read. There's just too much going on on the screen at one time with AR4. AR5 fixes this issue of information overload, imo.

00:51:300 (4,5) - I think you should space these two out a bit more. The long slider here prepares the player for a jump, should you choose to execute one, and it just so happens that the music would fit perfectly should you decide to execute a jump here (transition of focus from vocal melody to percussive elements, ex. open hi-hat into snare). That is to say, maybe you should make this a jump.

01:08:695 (4) - As above. In this difficulty, you seem to have chosen to stick with a single distance snap. Your jumps in Insane were so beautiful! Why not try and replicate some of that same beauty here, for newer osu players to enjoy?

[Easy]
Like with Insane, I don't see any issues here. But I mean, there's always very little room for error when you're dealing with a class of difficulty whose maps consist of 95% white ticks...

So I hope you'll forgive me for going a bit light on the compliments on this one, ahaha...

00:00:880 to 01:39:451 - Excellent work!

[General]
Overall, this is very incredible mapping! You now have +1 adoring fans. Here I normally wish the mapper good luck in getting their map ranked, but you're not really gonna need that, so I'll just wish future modders good luck in finding anything to mod about.

Thank you for letting me play through your maps, Oyatsu-of-the-Heavenly-Jump. OTL

THat is a mod? I don't really think. Fixed a stuff in Hard

Hi there

[General]
* There are 2 OSBs in this beatmap folder, remove the wrong one


[Normal]
00:07:434 (5) - Move to X:380 and Y:28 for better flow. Because the tail slider will lead to (5) if you move them and the path of flow wouldn't be off
00:47:266 (1) - Remove new combo for your combo pattern?


[Hard]
00:42:224 (3) - Reverse this section to create an oval flow


[Insane]
00:03:653 (2,3,4,5,6,7,1) - Since this is a calm part, I don't think the stream would be fit in here... Consider to make another pattern
01:03:401 (1) - Remove new combo for your combo pattern?


Good luck

Leorda wrote:

Hi there

[General]
* There are 2 OSBs in this beatmap folder, remove the wrong one


[Normal]
00:07:434 (5) - Move to X:380 and Y:28 for better flow. Because the tail slider will lead to (5) if you move them and the path of flow wouldn't be off
00:47:266 (1) - Remove new combo for your combo pattern?


[Hard]
00:42:224 (3) - Reverse this section to create an oval flow


[Insane]
00:03:653 (2,3,4,5,6,7,1) - Since this is a calm part, I don't think the stream would be fit in here... Consider to make another pattern
01:03:401 (1) - Remove new combo for your combo pattern?


Good luck

All fixed. Thank you for modding, Leorda

Just a lot of suggestions and opinions.





Don't be intimidated with all the suggestions. I just point a lot of things out, but it doesn't mean the mapset is bad or anything :<
However, I still would like to wait a bit before doing anything too hasty. I might come back later to check.

Also, generally you shouldn't ask for bubble. If I believe it can be bubbled, I will decide after modding :S

THank you for useful mod

iCo's mod is here~

[General]

Nice Song&Mapset Star~

Nothing much to find o.o

[Easy]

00:43:737 (4) - make a better blanket

[Normal]

00:07:308 (5) - I don't think blue ping in normal is rankable... not too sure

[Hard]

Nothing to find. Nice diff

[Insane]

00:05:291 (3,4) - make a better blanket

00:56:342 (3,4,5,6) - make these jumps neater. They look scattered

No fix anything but thank you for star ><