Nomizu Iori - Ma.Ka.Se.Te Tonight (TV Size) [Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
37
show more
Topic Starter
meetmeetdee

TKS wrote:

hi.

[ General]
  1. "魔・カ・セ・テ Tonight" is correct unicode title. OK
    also, is the official source of "TV Size" exist? I am not really sure, but I follow the ranked version
  2. add "これはゾンビですか?" to tags. OK


[ Kantan]
  1. SV:1.2? bpm181 is not too slow. i think SV1.4 is too fast for Kantan player. OK

  2. 00:22:671 - i recommend triplet here like kkd. i feel that 5-plet is a bit weird on this part. OK
  3. 00:39:246 (58) - change to d in the same way as 00:33:942 (48) - OK
    because you have used kkd just before 00:36:594 (53,54,55) - , if you change this pattern to a different pattern,that should be fine.
  4. 00:57:809 (79) - del. just a over sound for Kantan imo. OK
  5. 01:00:129 (83) - del. i dont feel that sense. this part has a relatively quiet melody. so triplets are a bit weird imo. OK
  6. 01:02:118 (88) - i recommend change to spinner this one. current slider has a complex rhythm for Kantan. Spinner may be too short at that point, I use another pattern
  7. 01:14:052 (20) - => 01:12:726 - move here. it would be fit the music. OK
  8. 01:16:373 ~ 01:20:350 - im not sure about these sliders. just, i felt a converted map from a standard map. anyway, you should put some notes. OK



[ Futsuu]
  1. 00:12:063 ~ 00:16:041 - current patterns are a bit over on this part. also, i feel unbalanced. how about this? OK
  2. 00:26:815 (55) - => 00:26:152 - move here and change to d. triplet doesnt fit the this part. OK
    00:42:726 (91) - ^ OK
  3. 00:29:467 (62) - del. same reason as above. OK
    00:45:378 (98) - ^ OK
  4. 01:23:997 (197) - del? you should put a breakpoint. OK



[ Muzukashii]
  1. 01:15:378 (273) - maybe you should change to k for the snaredrum sound. OK

    i couldnt find anything.



[ Oni]
  1. 00:18:527 (91,92) - i think that you should delete these notes. OK
  2. 00:22:671 ~ 00:23:997 - the same way as above. current pattern is a bit over imo. OK
  3. 00:31:124 (4,5,1) - change to kkk? the snaredrum sound is really stronk. OK
  4. 01:15:958 (80) - i didnt feel a sense on this twins of sudden. move to 01:15:875 - ? OK
  5. 01:18:444 (99) - same reason as above. maybe move to 01:18:527 - ? OK



this map set is really not bad. however, i think that set still needs more modder. anyway i wish you good luck!
Thanks for your mod :)
kanpakyin
As per your request:

[Oni]
  1. 00:07:588 (19,20,21) - I would say ddk sounds better here, ddk fits the drum perfectly, imo
  2. 00:16:373 (79) - how about adding a kat here to fit the drum as well as the pitch?
  3. 00:17:533 (86) - kat here? As you were using kat at (85) and (87)- both of them are in the same pitch.
  4. 00:25:986 (136) - kat?
  5. 00:27:975 (3,4,5) - This triplet doesn't fit the music at all. As you can hear the music, there are nothing to support the triplet. I would say simple 1/2 or even 1/1 should be enough for here.
  6. 00:27:975 (3,4,5) - ^
  7. 00:29:301 (1,2,3) - ^
  8. 00:32:284 (1) - kat to fit the drum sound?
  9. 00:33:444 (4) - kat? Same as previous explanation
  10. 01:16:870 (87) - kat here?
  11. 01:27:642 (5,6,7) - ddk sounds better, imo.

[Lunasa's Oni]
  1. 00:26:152 (152) - It would be great if you could change this note to big don, as it can accentuate the strong beat on the background music.
  2. 00:44:881 (281) - Change it to kat so that it can be consistent with your previous pattern. Also, it can fit the pitch.
  3. 00:53:665 (327,328,329) - This triplet is weird, and doesn't fit the music, to be honest.
  4. 01:05:102 (391) - I think a kat would be better than a don here, as the pitch is pretty higher then previous notes. Kat could accentuate the pitch.

[Muzukashii]
  1. 00:18:362 (58) - I would say adding a kat here would be great. As it fits the drum there.
  2. 00:32:284 (119) - ^
  3. 01:05:102 (233) - Why don't change this to kat just as you've done it in oni so that it could be fitted to the pitch better.

[Futsuu]
  1. 01:04:770 (139) - Changed this to don just like what you've done in other diffs, in order to fit the music.
  2. 比我ge感覺就係好多1/2都係隔硬黎....同個music唔係好夾

No problem found in Kantan. Good luck.
Topic Starter
meetmeetdee

kanpakyin wrote:

As per your request:

[Oni]
  1. 00:07:588 (19,20,21) - I would say ddk sounds better here, ddk fits the drum perfectly, imo OK
  2. 00:16:373 (79) - how about adding a kat here to fit the drum as well as the pitch? OK
  3. 00:17:533 (86) - kat here? As you were using kat at (85) and (87)- both of them are in the same pitch. OK
  4. 00:25:986 (136) - kat? OK
  5. 00:27:975 (3,4,5) - This triplet doesn't fit the music at all. As you can hear the music, there are nothing to support the triplet. I would say simple 1/2 or even 1/1 should be enough for here. OK
  6. 00:27:975 (3,4,5) - ^ OK
  7. 00:29:301 (1,2,3) - ^ OK
  8. 00:32:284 (1) - kat to fit the drum sound? OK
  9. 00:33:444 (4) - kat? Same as previous explanation OK
  10. 01:16:870 (87) - kat here? OK
  11. 01:27:642 (5,6,7) - ddk sounds better, imo. OK

[Muzukashii]
  1. 00:18:362 (58) - I would say adding a kat here would be great. As it fits the drum there. OK
  2. 00:32:284 (119) - ^ OK
  3. 01:05:102 (233) - Why don't change this to kat just as you've done it in oni so that it could be fitted to the pitch better. OK

[Futsuu]
  1. 01:04:770 (139) - Changed this to don just like what you've done in other diffs, in order to fit the music. OK
  2. 比我ge感覺就係好多1/2都係隔硬黎....同個music唔係好夾 可能我還不太懂map吧,有例子嗎?

No problem found in Kantan. Good luck.
Thanks for your mod :)
[I]MMoRTal[S]
From my queue

00:22:505 (74) - d
00:33:776 (124,125) - Ctrl+G
01:16:041 (275) - k
01:16:870 (280) - d
00:05:269 (4) - k
00:15:875 (77) - k
01:11:152 (44) - d
01:11:400 (46) - k
01:08:914 (418) - k
01:14:964 (461) - add d
01:27:809 (562,563,564) - remove finish

Good Luck ~ :):)
Charlotte
Hi from Charlotte's Taiko Modding Queue

d
k
D(big d)
K(big k)

Kantan

OD4→OD3

Slider is felt over many (1/4 roll is tired)

Futsuu

Good

Muzukashii

01:01:621 (222) - change k
01:16:870 (280) - change d

Oni

00:20:848 (107,108) - ctrl + G
00:34:026 - add d

Lunasa's Oni

Good

Nice map :) Go Go Ranked!
Topic Starter
meetmeetdee

[I]MMoRTal[S] wrote:

From my queue

00:22:505 (74) - d OK
00:33:776 (124,125) - Ctrl+G Nope, there is a drum sound in 00:33:942 -
01:16:041 (275) - k OK
01:16:870 (280) - d OK
00:05:269 (4) - k no, not really a largae change in music there
00:15:875 (77) - k nope, the music is going downward there
01:11:152 (44) - d OK
01:11:400 (46) - k OK

Good Luck ~ :):)

Charlotte wrote:

Hi from Charlotte's Taiko Modding Queue

d
k
D(big d)
K(big k)

Kantan

OD4→OD3 OK

Slider is felt over many (1/4 roll is tired) may consider it later

Futsuu

Good

Muzukashii

01:01:621 (222) - change k OK
01:16:870 (280) - change d OK

Oni

00:20:848 (107,108) - ctrl + G Nope
00:34:026 - add d nope

Lunasa's Oni

Good

Nice map :) Go Go Ranked!
Thank for your mod :)
bbj0920
Hi, from my modding queue

Kantan
00:06:096 (4) - k
00:31:953 (45) - D
00:39:909 (60) - k
01:16:373 (111) - K
01:21:676 (122) - k
01:24:328 (127) - ^

Futsuu
00:16:041 (30) - D
00:23:997 (48) - k
00:26:649 (55) - K
00:34:273 (73,74) - reverse
00:42:560 (93) - K
01:13:721 (167,168,169) - k k d

Muzukashii
00:16:041 (50) - D
00:16:704 (52,53) - reverse
00:37:588 (139) - K
01:07:754 (243,244) - reverse

Oni
00:26:649 (140) - D
00:36:594 (7) - No finisher here
00:37:588 (13) - K
00:53:002 - Add a note (k)

Lunasa's Oni
00:28:638 (167,169) - No finishers plz
01:05:102 (392) - k
Dainesl
Mod req from Nwolf's Queue~ not modding LunaticP's Oni.

Before we begin: Replace the Kiai Time's beginning timing point with a new 181 BPM 4/4 section, because the measures don't match up right atm.

Perhaps make the OD and HP + 1 or at least + 0.5 because 3/3 is a bit too low for a Kantan especially considering the HP Drain is extremely lenient.
00:04:770 (1,2) - Maybe invert these? it seems nicer to me to have d k D as a buildup
00:14:715 (20) - I was thinking maybe it would give more impact if this was replaced with, say, a few notes, because it brings out the instruments a bit more imo e.g. this
00:22:008 (32,33) - Invert these? It gives more emphasis to the vocal because of pitch relevancy imo.
01:02:118 (87) - I recommend replacing this with a spinner because it gives more buildup and also streaming at 181 BPM for a Kantan for this long is kinda weird.
01:10:406 (99,100,101) - this pattern would really sound nicer as ddk or dkk because it seems to support the small vocal and instrumental buildup happening now, preferably ddk because it gives more emphasis to the k
01:14:384 (107,108,109) - This pattern would sound nicer as kkd instead; gives more emphasis to the d this time, because the vocal keeps going lower
01:21:013 (120,121,122) - Refer to 01:10:406
Again, perhaps make the OD and HP slightly higher? too lenient atm imo.
00:04:770 (1,2) - Refer to Kantan
00:13:389 (21,22,23) - Maybe remove 22 so that you can make 21 a k without it playing awkwardly for a Futsuu? It'd help with the main instrument pitch relevancy imo. Or, if you want to follow the drums in the background, perhaps make 23 a kat for effective buildup while still keeping it simple, for the calm part anyways~
00:31:953 (68) - Remove the finisher on this; it plays kinda awkwardly for a Futsuu and is also inconsistent with 00:16:041 (30) - and the Kantan.
01:02:118 (140,141) - Like in the Kantan, perhaps replace with a spinner for more effective buildup?
00:04:770 (1,2,3) - See other diffs
00:05:433 - to 00:14:384 - is very repetitive, perhaps you could change some patterns to be simple yet not the same traditional "ddk" setup with another d inbetween the two already existing ones for slightly more difficulty. Then we have 00:14:715 (41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50) - which is so much more complex than the beginning section that I believe it might catch players off-guard considering the BPM is 181. The pattern is like 10 notes long with a triplet in the middle of it, perhaps you should break it up by removing 44, it keeps the triplet a bit more separate like it should be and the new second part of that pattern will have only one don, signifiying a new section, giving a bit more emphasis to the map :3
00:31:953 (118) - Refer to Futsuu.
01:08:417 (245,246,247) - Perhaps make this just 2 1/2 notes since this sounds really weird as a triplet; kinda overmapped if you ask me
The second half of the Kiai seems to have quite a lot more triplets than the first, remove some of them for a more balanced difficulty curve?
00:31:953 (3) - Maybe make this a kat for more variety with simple patterns + emphasising the cymbal sound a bit more because the kat signifies a new section
00:36:594 (7) - Why a sudden finisher in this diff that appears in none of your other diffs? Remove it for consistency with other diffs, or if you don't want to remove it, put a finisher on 00:37:588 (13) - for emphasising the cymbal sound a bit more.
01:15:710 (77,78,79,80,81) - This kinda sounds weird as it is to me, not sure why this pattern specifically but it would feel better as d d k k (on 1/2) because it just seems like it fits with the instruments a bit more.
01:25:489 (1) - Make this a 1/2 beat longer for consistency with other diffs?

lol short mod on Oni

good luck for rank!
Topic Starter
meetmeetdee

bbj0920 wrote:

Hi, from my modding queue

Kantan
00:06:096 (4) - k d is better
00:31:953 (45) - D not necessary
00:39:909 (60) - k OK
01:16:373 (111) - K it will be quite difficult design for kantan
01:21:676 (122) - k OK
01:24:328 (127) - ^ OK

Futsuu
00:16:041 (30) - D OK
00:23:997 (48) - k d is better
00:26:649 (55) - K Too difficult
00:34:273 (73,74) - reverse OK
00:42:560 (93) - K Too difficult
01:13:721 (167,168,169) - k k d current one seems ok for me

Muzukashii
00:16:041 (50) - D OK
00:16:704 (52,53) - reverse OK
00:37:588 (139) - K not really
01:07:754 (243,244) - reverse OK

Oni
00:26:649 (140) - D OK
00:36:594 (7) - No finisher here no
00:37:588 (13) - K no
00:53:002 - Add a note (k) no

Dainesl wrote:

Mod req from Nwolf's Queue~ not modding LunaticP's Oni.

Before we begin: Replace the Kiai Time's beginning timing point with a new 181 BPM 4/4 section, because the measures don't match up right atm.

Perhaps make the OD and HP + 1 or at least + 0.5 because 3/3 is a bit too low for a Kantan especially considering the HP Drain is extremely lenient. OK
00:04:770 (1,2) - Maybe invert these? it seems nicer to me to have d k D as a buildup k d seems better imo
00:14:715 (20) - I was thinking maybe it would give more impact if this was replaced with, say, a few notes, because it brings out the instruments a bit more imo e.g. this OK
00:22:008 (32,33) - Invert these? It gives more emphasis to the vocal because of pitch relevancy imo. OK
01:02:118 (87) - I recommend replacing this with a spinner because it gives more buildup and also streaming at 181 BPM for a Kantan for this long is kinda weird. OK
01:10:406 (99,100,101) - this pattern would really sound nicer as ddk or dkk because it seems to support the small vocal and instrumental buildup happening now, preferably ddk because it gives more emphasis to the k OK
01:14:384 (107,108,109) - This pattern would sound nicer as kkd instead; gives more emphasis to the d this time, because the vocal keeps going lower OK
01:21:013 (120,121,122) - Refer to 01:10:406 OK
Again, perhaps make the OD and HP slightly higher? too lenient atm imo. OK
00:04:770 (1,2) - Refer to Kantan ^
00:13:389 (21,22,23) - Maybe remove 22 so that you can make 21 a k without it playing awkwardly for a Futsuu? It'd help with the main instrument pitch relevancy imo. Or, if you want to follow the drums in the background, perhaps make 23 a kat for effective buildup while still keeping it simple, for the calm part anyways~ I tend to remove both 22 and 23 and change 21 to k
00:31:953 (68) - Remove the finisher on this; it plays kinda awkwardly for a Futsuu and is also inconsistent with 00:16:041 (30) - and the Kantan. OK
01:02:118 (140,141) - Like in the Kantan, perhaps replace with a spinner for more effective buildup? OK
00:04:770 (1,2,3) - See other diffs ^
00:05:433 - to 00:14:384 - is very repetitive, perhaps you could change some patterns to be simple yet not the same traditional "ddk" setup with another d inbetween the two already existing ones for slightly more difficulty. Then we have 00:14:715 (41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50) - which is so much more complex than the beginning section that I believe it might catch players off-guard considering the BPM is 181. The pattern is like 10 notes long with a triplet in the middle of it, perhaps you should break it up by removing 44, it keeps the triplet a bit more separate like it should be and the new second part of that pattern will have only one don, signifiying a new section, giving a bit more emphasis to the map :3 modified
00:31:953 (118) - Refer to Futsuu. OK
01:08:417 (245,246,247) - Perhaps make this just 2 1/2 notes since this sounds really weird as a triplet; kinda overmapped if you ask me I think it is fine
The second half of the Kiai seems to have quite a lot more triplets than the first, remove some of them for a more balanced difficulty curve? Trying to make it more balance
00:31:953 (3) - Maybe make this a kat for more variety with simple patterns + emphasising the cymbal sound a bit more because the kat signifies a new section d is better for the drum sound there, k seems odd for me
00:36:594 (7) - Why a sudden finisher in this diff that appears in none of your other diffs? Remove it for consistency with other diffs, or if you don't want to remove it, put a finisher on 00:37:588 (13) - for emphasising the cymbal sound a bit more. OK
01:15:710 (77,78,79,80,81) - This kinda sounds weird as it is to me, not sure why this pattern specifically but it would feel better as d d k k (on 1/2) because it just seems like it fits with the instruments a bit more. seems fine imo
01:25:489 (1) - Make this a 1/2 beat longer for consistency with other diffs? I want to give a break for player instead of hit the next note immediately

lol short mod on Oni

good luck for rank!
Thanks for your mod :)
Nwolf
woof from queue :3

[General]

01:05:765 - Add a red bar here so the main beat bar is at the right spot again!

[Kantan]

00:04:770 (1) - Delete this note to make the drums at the beginning more emphasised, sounds better imo

[Futsuu]

00:04:770 (1) - Same as Kantan
00:13:058 (19) - The normal pattern seems to be ddd k - (note) but you didn't follow it here... prefer the note to be 00:12:229 - here to have consistent rhythm, to avoid confusion
01:06:759 (9) - Kat maybe for snare rhythm and vocals
01:08:583 (14) - Should be 01:08:914 - here
01:11:234 - 01:11:400 - Additional dons would be nice here, to reduce the ND difference between Futsuu/Muzu and 01:12:395 (23,24,25) - consistency
01:16:538 (37) - Again, move to 01:16:870 -
01:19:190 (45) - ^ to 01:19:522 -

[Muzukashii]

00:04:770 (1) - Same as lower diffs
00:50:185 (186) - Change to kat, same pitch as 00:48:859 (183) -
01:18:693 (288) - Change to kat again, consistency and snare rhythm
01:21:013 (298) - ^

[Oni]

00:04:771 (1) - Same as previous diffs
00:05:186 (3,4) - eh... no. Why is this necessary? Doesn't play that well with the upcoming big note and takes away the emphasis of this note
00:22:339 (114,115) - Trade those, sounds nice and you did that previously
00:42:892 (1) - kat because snare rhythm

[Lunasa's Oni]

Rhythm is nice, though I am not really a fan of the 1/4 doublets in this diff

Can't really find anything in this diff~


Good luck!
Topic Starter
meetmeetdee

Nwolf wrote:

woof from queue :3

[General]

01:05:765 - Add a red bar here so the main beat bar is at the right spot again! OK

[Kantan]

00:04:770 (1) - Delete this note to make the drums at the beginning more emphasised, sounds better imo OK

[Futsuu]

00:04:770 (1) - Same as Kantan OK
00:13:058 (19) - The normal pattern seems to be ddd k - (note) but you didn't follow it here... prefer the note to be 00:12:229 - here to have consistent rhythm, to avoid confusion OK
01:06:759 (9) - Kat maybe for snare rhythm and vocals OK
01:08:583 (14) - Should be 01:08:914 - here OK
01:11:234 - 01:11:400 - Additional dons would be nice here, to reduce the ND difference between Futsuu/Muzu and 01:12:395 (23,24,25) - consistency OK
01:16:538 (37) - Again, move to 01:16:870 - OK
01:19:190 (45) - ^ to 01:19:522 - OK

[Muzukashii]

00:04:770 (1) - Same as lower diffs OK
00:50:185 (186) - Change to kat, same pitch as 00:48:859 (183) - OK
01:18:693 (288) - Change to kat again, consistency and snare rhythm OK
01:21:013 (298) - ^ OK

[Oni]

00:04:771 (1) - Same as previous diffs OK
00:05:186 (3,4) - eh... no. Why is this necessary? Doesn't play that well with the upcoming big note and takes away the emphasis of this note OK
00:22:339 (114,115) - Trade those, sounds nice and you did that previously OK
00:42:892 (1) - kat because snare rhythm OK


Good luck!
Thanks for your mod :)
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply