I was busy all of yesterday and the first half of today, so I just started to watch anime, which meant I have about 10 series to catch up on. I will update the large chart after I watch everything, but I highly encourage all of you to add new shows (alphabetical order would be nice), and add your votes.
Note: If I have a lot of time and motivation, I will change the format of the chart to make it easier for all of us to update
Love Lab: For a low budget comedy show, the jokes were quite amusing. Basically low quality animation with rapid fire jokes about love and lack of common sense. Not much else to say, but try an ep
High School DxD New: Beware: Lots of fanservice ahead! Well welcome to the next season of High School DxD which will probably cover volume 3 and 4 of the light novel. As you might expect, there is a lot of fanservice in the show, in fact almost every perverted thing in the novel is shown in this episode... Beyond that, everything happened as it should, plot was fairly accurate and done well, and animation wasn't too bad (though tehre wasn't much to show off besides fanservice). Freud had his crazy speeches again, but as stated earlier, this first episode really didn't have much to show. Still, since I am bias toward the show, I'll give it a green regardless of the current location in the plot since everything else seems fine. Okay I'll be less biased and give this a blue.
Kiniro Mosaic: Where do I begin? We get bad CG, followed by some decent pics for 30s, and then the rest is just cheap animation. I have no idea what the art people were doing. Did someone get fired, or something get too hard to do... Afterward, we get lik 15-18min of awkward english humor. It was just too awkward for me to laugh. The only redeeming point is that some of the ending jokes were actuallly funny. Since this played out like an intro ep, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt and try them again next week.
Blood Lad: This was underwhelming. I know the start of the comic is not that strong, but there was really nothing to entertain me in this show. The animation wasn't that great, the jokes weren't noteworthy, and I just stood there wondering when anything will happen.Since I know the manga is exactly like that, I might revisit this thing in the future, but for most people just read the manga, you'll have more fun than watching a lackluster animation
Fantasista Doll: This show has decent animation, and basically nothing else. It was really refreshing to see decent character sprites and semi-detailed backgrounds, but this show has like nothing going for it. A nonexistant plot, little/no jokes, and some terribly done action scenes. Seriously, mc's doll is losing, gets knocked down, stands up, says is going to finish this, swords starts glowing, and then she wins for no explainable reason other than a shining rapier that really didn't look that special. There were many other problems with the battle scenes, but in short, don't waste your time here.
Gen'ei o Kakeru Taiyou - Il Sole Penetra le Illusioni: Super depressed people turning into monsters and causing issues. Your temporary sister? has issues with your personality and tries to strangle you. Cliche plots getting overdramatized, count me in. Really wish the character sprites and fighting scenes looked better, but I am okay with this.
Uchouten Kazoku: What was PA Works thinking? This comedy show is a fairly blatant showing of how PA Works struggles with the genre. Jokes that lacked tension, interesting characters that can't get you entranced in their actions, and more. Combined with a lower budget art style that blurred many colors together, this show can easily put me to sleep.
Ro-Kyu-Bu SS: It has Ogura Yui in it. Done.... Oh yeah, they improperly use the word halation.... whatever. Same as first season bascially, so watch if you want.
Genshiken Nidaime: What is the point of watching the anime if you are going to be panning stills all day long....Well another low budget show that barely made me laugh. Probably better to just read the manga....
Kami nomi zo Shiru Sekai: Megami-hen: It seems like the animation quality increased a bit from last season, but wasn't as entertaining. Maybe because I know the plot already, but not really feeling it. (then again I didn't like the previous seasons) Oh well, I'll hang around for another ep.
Teekyu 2: I don't recall watching season 1, but a super fast paced low budget comedy series where I can barely tell what is going on is not my definition of fun. Dropped.
Makai Ouji - Devils and Realist: Lets see, badly orchestrated battle scenes + typical plot + low budget... another drop.
Watashi ga Motenai no wa Dou Kangaetemo Omaera ga Warui!: Yay, Silver Link with their bizarre artistic takes....at least for the op. Overall, I think Silver Link did a decent job with the super low budget they gave the show. However, I am not a big fan of the series because some of those jokes are cringe worthy....