You're saying there are too many maps for players to play?
Ryuukun wrote:But making the guidlines too harsh will result in too many players with too less mappers.
I don't think these are ranking criteria because they are subjective.
Echo wrote:imho people need to learn how to map
new, inventive patterns
mapping is an art, just like drawing, music, etc.
if you don't pick the right song, don't map imaginatively, don't add interesting effects to give your map that extra oomph, your map will suck, and no one will want to look at it, no matter how many stars you have
Also, any map has the destination of the graveyard, approval, or ranking. The pending and help forums are not where maps are supposed to stay.