Lally wrote:

Hi from my Queue o3o

[General]

1. remove taiko from tags since is not needed (ex.from a latest ranked taiko mapset: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/112299 ) "Part of Ao no Senritsu Taiko Maps." Changed.
2. theblackcase.jpg is 960x640 use abigger bg :C like 1024x768. Aww but that's the only size available in the best quality <x>

[Oni]
AiBat-chan:

1. 00:25:917 (126) - Unsnapped circle.
2. 00:28:994 (143) - Unsnapped circle.
3. 01:25:728 (425) - Unsnapped circle.
4. 01:28:805 (443) - Unsnapped circle.
5. 01:31:882 (461) - Unsnapped circle.

le almighty full map jk at 1/4 initiate~

Placement:

1. 00:38:419 - add a k here i think it flows better the music and because this point feels really empty here Nope, deep bass here
2. 00:43:803 (205) - remove the clap here also to became a d here because the violin is stronger here 00:43:708 (204) - and it goes to a lower with the bass 00:43:803 (205) - here to create a bit the constrast with the music a dkd pattern is better here 00:43:612 (203,204,205) -
3. 00:46:689 (218,219,220) - same suggestion as this one ^
4. 00:49:766 (234,235,236) - same ^

I'll just make it ambiguously colored so you can stop worrying. Added bonus: more suited as 6★ yay

[Muzu]

1. 01:18:130 - add a d here it feels bettew with the prev pattern 01:15:149 (22,23,24) -
2. 01:24:284 - same here ^
3. 01:30:438 - same ^
   The above three sets of note should correspond to 01:11:880 (11,12) in the first iteration. 01:15:149 (22~24) has been made consistent with 01:21:303 (47~49) and 01:27:457 (74~76) (4th iteration's buried within ending bass)
4. 01:32:746 - i would add a k here for following the piano or hope it's a piano btw to have a pattern at the end kkk feels better Nope, bass here
   

Futsuu and Katan are for me ok o3o
really nice and simply mapset o3o good luck with it

Nardoxyribonucleic wrote:

Hi tetsutaro, M4M from modding queue.

[Kantan]

Nicely mapped.

[Futsuu]

These are not difficult for Futsuu, consider changing them ?
00:30:726 (47) k
00:31:880 (50) ^
00:34:957 (55) ^
Nope. See fellow 5★ Futsuu Shunyu ~happy excursion~
Optional:
01:23:611 (138) k
01:26:111 (146) d
01:29:765 (156) k
Oh hell no. Compare with 6★ Futsuu Angel Dream

[Muzukashii]

00:07:650 (21) use k ? same as Oni Nope, (20) and (21) at same pitch
00:53:803 (28) ^ ^
00:59:957 (51) ^ ^
01:33:323 add d here ? Nope, cut to 4★ Muzukashii instead, referring to Soul Calibur II Brave Sword, Braver Soul
Not much to say, I appreciate the mapping patterns.

[Oni]

00:01:496 (3) use k ? It seems to fit the pitch. See Muzukashii
00:07:650 (32) ^ ^
00:35:342 (176) k ? to follow the patterns you have made according to the rhythm. See above mod by Decipher
00:41:303 (189,190,191) kkd Unnecessary handswitch unfit for 6★ Oni.
00:42:073 (194,195,196) kdd Back violin, period.
00:59:957 (287) use k ? ^

Good luck~

tetsutaro wrote:

@Zenx: This is the first mod in a long time that I need some time to ponder over.

Intro/chorus: Larges are used for emphasis and to separate the percussion and melody. See 6★ Oni Miku Miku ni Shite Ageru [Shite Yan Yo] at 47s. It's more of a personal choice of flow here though and I see your reasonable point.

Miku Miku ni Shite Ageru (Shite Yan Yo) 6★ Oni

00:40:438: It sounds weird for me to have a 3/4 split here. If I have to change here, I would extend the even-number iterations to a full 1/2 ddkddk, like what I have done for now.

Ending: Not really that I am trying to follow the prominent violin here, but that does give me ideas for other patterns. Again more of a personal choice and you are not wrong.

OnosakiHito wrote:

[ Oni]

SPOILER

General:
01:21:688 - Not a must, but consider using another Kiai here. It would work without as well, but since the tone in this whole section becomes higher and your note density(+ pattern constellation) is still the same, you only have the possibility to emphasize this part with the kiai(SV change would be also possible, but fits not well in this song I guess) - same goes for the lower difficulties.

Notes:
00:22:842 (107,108,109) - Mh, might be me since I'm used to this pattern, but I feel like kkd would fit better here. As 1/2 it would be a d d due to the background sound, but since you mapped with 1/4, kkd would possibly represent this 1/4-sounding better (tbh, I don't know how to call these sounds in english).
Huh kkd is taking the percussion route while kdd is closer to the melodic parts, which I was going for. Let's have a bait-and-switch here to make this 6★ more legit then. (hey

00:34:188 (170,173) - Or only (170) you might want to change to don. If I'm not wrong, you mapped to the contrabass. Its tone becomes deeper up to the end, where it is really deep, so the constellation I suggest might fit here well. Additional changing 00:35:342 (176) - to kat would make the last part look like the reversed pattern of the previous one.
The thing has a name!? And *checks Wikipedia* yes it is the contrabass there. Anyway if you explain it that way it would be an awesome pattern, but I would contend that (153)~(160) also take the reversed form for symmetry.

Everything is pretty solid. I like the map. I like the style. Has an TNT feeling, but better. I also like how you kept the patterns similar, but still with small changes. I can see your experience which you gained from TNT. Great map!

[ Muzukashii]

SPOILER

00:41:303(x) - Maybe a an additional kat here. Overall patterns are fine, I don't mind the said "copy-paste" style, fits here very well. But it would have some effect on the user(I guess), showing that the next part is coming and current one ends. Also, it would fit to the 1/4 sound.
I did this <00:36:880 (180,181,182,183,184,185)> in Oni, so now putting notes there don't mess up the leverage. But referring to a previous mod ( p/2386392 ) I think it is triple or none, so triple.

00:43:611 - This is fine as it is and I know that we map sometimes in a way which makes the Taiko fungate as own instrument in the song, but still, you wanna consider having k k d k k d here. Reason should be known.
00:49:765 - ^ (this might even fit better, since most of the people hit the slider as don -> kkdkkdddd...)
Self-reference reversal (I just make up the name) FTW! Note that the 00:47:649 (14) has k -> d for I-don't-know-why-I-put-it-like-that-that-was-stupid reasons.

00:50:726 (21) - Broken Slider. - I will ask peppy about this. For now there is nothing we can do against it.
I don't quite see how this is broken, but thanks for helping sort things out.

Nice structure of Muzukashii, same as in Oni.

[ Futsuu]

SPOILER

01:32:842 (165) - Not a must again, but maybe have a kat. Previous parts had much more kats, but here the usage of kats falls down to zero. Nothing urgent, though.
*looks up on Muzu and Oni* *looks down on Kantan* mkay, another for the why-you-put-that-that-was-stupid pit.

I wish, people would map their Futsuus as easy as we do. This will be another great example for new mappers.

Before I continue with Kantan, let me say something about the spread in this set (important for other Taiko BATs as well):
This is a prime example for a spread which is not common in our community. tetsutaro used the basic knowledge of the beatsnap divisior in different difficulties which is roughly said as being 'Kantan - 2/1 notes; Futsuu - 1/1; Muzukashii - 1/2; Oni - 1/4'. While people often use more notes as required in lower / higher difficulties(which often leads to addition diffs. to ensave the spread), tetsutaro just used his knowledge about the beatsnap divisor which made the spread between all difficulties high (more or less) but consistent.

With that said, I would give this spread a go. But before we do so, you should delete some notes in the Kantan, @ tetsutaro. Many patterns are similar to Futsuu.

[ Kantan]

SPOILER

General:
The kiais are just slightly different to Futsuu, but let's don't be that strict in this case, huh? If we would make the kiais easier, you would need to make the whole Kantan easier as well, so the kiais appear to be harder again(though, when I think about it, this would be the best solution when considering the spread - also a great example that a Kantan can be super easy, but well, it's your decision). I would appreciate it at least.

Notes:
00:17:073 - Use less kats here, since it is mostly similar to what you did in the Futsuu, while Muzu compared to Futsuu has something totally different.
Recalling from the gist in Cytus EASY (Level 4) (video), at least one diff will have to maintain that pattern from 27s~33s and Kantan will be the one. Adding dons across the second half of this interval to resemble 35s onwards, also reinforcing Futsuu's 5★ rating.

00:42:073 - Same here. The patterns are similar to Futsuu which makes voltages in the overall spread.
Again referencing Cytus EASY and adding to Futsuu instead. Kantan remains following the general contrabass and Futsuu now takes on a simplified version of the prominent strings (like 58s onwards in the video)

00:50:919 (60) - No, personally I'm not sure about this. But consider to make the slider shorter up to 00:52:073 ? I'm a bit worried about how close the upcoming note to the slider is.
Good point there, Kantan sliders are usually shorter in cases like this in authentic charts. Also moved start forward to match the actual note.

01:09:380~01:21:688 - Same as before, about the similarity between F and K. Afterwards coming part is harder than this one, so it would be fine. Futsuu becomes harder at this point as well (01:21:688). More ramping up in Futsuu.

Basically this is more of a problem of reinstating Futsuu as a more legit 5★ Futsuu. Kantan is nicely at 3★ Kantan IMO.

That's it.

Overall really nice set. I enjoyed all difficulties, and the spread is smart (even though I'm not sure if this was done intensionally by you - but experienced Taiko mappers often have a decent feeling for these kind of stuff, right? Heh). Just consider once again to make the Kantan overall easier than now. It is not a must, but it would ensave the ranking process and make my work easier, Haha. If you should decide to follow my recommendation, I would mod(recheck) the Kantan once again and give it a bubble right after my mod and your check since I'm confident about your mapping anyway.

Call me back and have some stars for your nice work!

POONwing wrote:

8 months have passed and still not ranked? why?
-Very good note charts in general, the rhythm of the notes is comfortable
---
About Oni:
You put a few mines like xox x and x oxx and makes it a hard 6★ (difficult in terms of FCing in 6★)
0,0

1. 00:19:765 (90) - 00:25:919 (126) - i think these notes should be k. i know, these d are your intentional pattern. so, is this aware of the Taiko no Tatsujin?:3 but this point has a clearly higher pitch (and has the snaredrum sound)

1. 00:25:342 (25,26,27,28) - i feel kddk here. can be more fit a pitch.
2. 00:28:419 (35,36,37,38,39,40) - so same reason as above. maybe kkdkkkd here?
3. 00:38:419 - add d here. will be good accent with 00:35:342 (58) -
4. 00:50:726 (21) - this slider has lost one point by bug. its plays weird to me. so you can set end point to 00:51:520 .(on 1/16 line)
   
   current slider
   fixed slider

TKS wrote:

hi. Thanks for the pop!

[ Oni]

1. 00:19:765 (90) - 00:25:919 (126) - i think these notes should be k. i know, these d are your intentional pattern. so, is this aware of the Taiko no Tatsujin?:3 but this point has a clearly higher pitch (and has the snaredrum sound)

(90) OK snare focus for the cluster
(126) I am following that prominent instrument (I cannot name). Changed the cluster to katsu-triple base like around it

[ Muzukashii]

1. 00:25:342 (25,26,27,28) - i feel kddk here. can be more fit a pitch.
   Not really though, I am mapping to this instrument (I cannot name)
2. 00:28:419 (35,36,37,38,39,40) - so same reason as above. maybe kkdkkkd here?
   So same reason as above too.
3. 00:38:419 - add d here. will be good accent with 00:35:342 (58) -
   (58) is the legacy from the violin before. After 00:35:534 the focus changes to the bass percussion.
4. 00:50:726 (21) - this slider has lost one point by bug. its plays weird to me. so you can set end point to 00:51:520 .(on 1/16 line) OK, if a BAT approves of this workaround
   
   current slider
   fixed slider

Kantan, Futsuu are fine to me.

tetsutaro wrote:

\ / Rank tomorrow is infinity times better than not yet ranked (because divided by zero thing and I just cursed the maths world right)

--Also is too many ranked a thing?--

cdhsausageboy wrote:

Waiting this to be ranked for a long time XD gratz tetsutaro~

also why taiko in tags *runs*

TKS wrote:

cdhsausageboy wrote:

Waiting this to be ranked for a long time XD gratz tetsutaro~

also why taiko in tags *runs*

still it helps when searching in the client. xD

OnosakiHito wrote:

Finally, congratulation tetsutaro! Hope to see in 6 years a new map of yours. lmao