Charles445 wrote:

To me it's like a claptick, or using a storyboarded hitsound.

The topic here is created in a bias fashion, but regardless of that, I still think that the slider slide hitsound manipulation should be allowed, as it is merely hitsound manipulation, something that we do on a daily basis anyway. The mapper has creative control over the sounds on a map.

Seph wrote:

voted for dashes

Charles445 wrote:

Because the original poll sounded biased and didn't cover the issue at hand.
These three look pretty good actually. Support, against, and neutral.

LKs wrote:

Charles445 wrote:

Because the original poll sounded biased and didn't cover the issue at hand.
These three look pretty good actually. Support, against, and neutral.

nah the curretn fails to cover things. and failed to indicate who in which position is voting. This won't change the result in a little bit degree tho

Makar wrote:

You are missing something here. The original poll had options for "okay, good, fine" were descriptions of sliderslide sound, while only "bad" was used in the options that opposed slidierslide sound (first mistake). The original poll's last 2 options (in the after the second wave of dashes) were both options that supported the fact that the rule shouldn't be made by saying it is "okay" (second mistake). Including things such as "I use it" vs "I haven't used it" is also bias, because it is generally a public assumption that experience = knowledge and stronger opinion. Those that oppose sliderslide sounds will not use it as frequently as those that support it. Thus, a fake idea is given to the random people that see these results, as "I have experience with using sliderslide and I think its okay" is assumed to be more significant than "I have never used this technique, but I think it's bad"

I don't understand what the thread is talking about or care about the conclusion

LKs wrote:

no, that's just your opinion, no one else suggested that I have experience = my opinion is more important. This shouldn't be your way to think about a pool.

LKs wrote:

Also, plz don't post irrelevant posts again, your deeds has significantly disturbed the pool and you transfered the 3rd option into a nonsense one.

I don't understand what the thread is talking about or care about the conclusion

This option is totally useless and will dramatically drops down the efficiency of the pool. A person without a clear opinion is not suggested to vote, and that option influences nothing while people count the total votes. you made a big mistake on making a ballot here

EDIT: also, you have remade the pool several(3+) times, that's enough for any extra requirements, now the pool should has met your expectation, if anyone still touch the pool I will lock this and regard this total consideration as a long denied april joke you gave me

Makar wrote:

LKs wrote:

no, that's just your opinion, no one else suggested that I have experience = my opinion is more important. This shouldn't be your way to think about a pool.

Again, this is generally the public assumption, when the observer is uninformed.

18446744073709551616 wrote:

didn't catch the meaning

Maybe sliders should be forbidden too. lol
And 3 claps are illegal in the near future.

Why not unrank the AR10 maps? I think that seems nicer than this topic.

SPOILER

DakeDekaane wrote:

^Oh boy.

I get LKs' point, and somehow agree with it, but there's no reason to forbid a custom sliderslide, if the use of it is clearly wrong, it should be pointed in modding process.

Just throwing my 2 cents.

LKs wrote:

I wondered why too. now it seems this thread has finished its mission and the request of adding this into the RC has been denied

Loctav wrote:

LKs wrote:

I wondered why too. now it seems this thread has finished its mission and the request of adding this into the RC has been denied

Lol, the poll isn't even expired. Calm yourself and wait for more opinions.
I'm waiting, that's why I didn't move this thread
Also I hope that you've spread the link to more people but to supporters you already knew from he Chinese sub community.
Please spread this thread in #modhelp and other sub communities to gather more opinions.
sure, go spread it, ppl will appreciate you. but you are not allowed to attack me
For now, this looks like a poor attempt to kill a discussion before it even started.
we have discussed this for weeks, in case you don't know

Loctav wrote:

You shouldn't interpret my appearing and interventions of your doing as attack, everytime. Don't be so sensitive.
Also rules are not decided by a poll. They are decided by factual evidences, discussions and compromises. Tho I am tempted to remove the poll. And I will probably do it, since we don't "vote" rules or it's denial.

Loctav wrote:

My factual evidence is regardless. I don't even wanna reply to you seeing this. Are you aware of the condition? This is a formal critic on the useage and process of this board.
We do not decide rules by votings.
I didn't say we do, right?
I assume this is a launched off showcase to gather opinions, which aren't one (refer to the shitposts in 2nd page)
I don't want to suspect you anything, but many votes are probably happening, because of fellow runners.
Then edit your post and apologize, lemme see your sincerity. I don't know every chinese in the thread, unfortunately, this just indicates chinese are more involved in making a new changes

In my eyes, rules in GENERAL don't need a poll, they need discussion.
Again, sigh, I even doubt you read the op or not
Also the way you discuss is too selective. Please go and evaluate the arguments of your opponents and try to understand WHY they think it's wrong. Try to get their point (this goes for everyone here).
I said you're free to add opinions to the op, and sayings in brackets are what been said by particular people
We don't act like "I dislike because FREEEEEEDOM!" Or "I dislike because I am always right and this is how I roll"

Thus I removed the poll. Please keep on discussing with EVERYONE who posts factual evidences for any side if this rule.
You don't have the right to, this only tell us you fear for the result and public opinions

I am not supposed to participate, I just supervise this board, so people keep doing things FORMALLY correct. Adding a poll is FORMALLY incorrect, that's why I'll remove it.

peppy wrote:

Forbidding a hitsound? Why?

This can be judged on a per-map basis.

orioncomet wrote:

peppy wrote:

Forbidding a hitsound? Why?

This can be judged on a per-map basis.

^ I agree.
On side topic: I would not agree to anything about custom sliderslide/SB sound being added to rules.
It's like peppy've said, it's per-map basis, (or difficulites, imo.)

Anyways guys, please calm down.