1. Easy (1.69 stars, 77 notes)
2. Hard (4.53 stars, 138 notes)
3. Insane (4.95 stars, 216 notes)
4. Normal (2.8 stars, 86 notes)

happy623 wrote:

hi from #modreq XD
just take a little look on Easy and Normal diff

Red is unrankable
Blue is strongly recommended to change it

[General]
Your background size is kind of weird. It is 8:5 now but the requirement is 16:9 or 4:3. For 16:9, the maximum size is 1366*768 while that of 4:3 is 1024*1768. So, you better change the picture or resize it.
Add "opening" in Tags? Fixed both

[Easy]
- OD-1? Done

SPOILER

- Easy diff should not have any unsnapped notes or sliders, please fix it
- Also, try not to stack notes or sliders together, it will make new player confused with them, try to unstack them all

SPOILER

- useless inherited points, please delete it Fixed
- Well, I think you may need to remap this diff since there many reverse sliders and stacked notes in Easy diff Taken (while taking into consideration the reds above

[Normal]
- try to delete some useless inherited points? Done
- Consider the unsnapped objects whether they are really suitable to be unsnapped. Fixed some. Others are stacks or after-stack spacing so I didn't change.
- 00:02:781 (1,1,1) - remove NC
- 00:27:487 (5) - NC
- 00:31:017 (7) - NC All done (Though I like the NC spam on first three sliders)
- 00:31:017 (1,2,3,4) - those sliders may confuse players Fixed by removing note 3 and moving sliders 4 and 5 (now 3 and 4)

Uchiha_sorayuki wrote:

hi #modreqs

__________________________________
Easy
HP -2 Fixed

00:31:017 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - too hard for easy diff Removed 4th note
00:34:546 (1) - the spinner ends at 00:36:752 - and fill some after the spinner Spinner fixed. Added some notes after the spinner, though I would have left that portion blank if possible
00:58:370 (1) - i think you can change this to some notes, the spinner is too soon Done
01:11:605 (1) - change to some enjoyable notes
01:14:252 - add something Fixed both

___________________________________
Normal

00:13:370 (1,2,3) - these are confusing for normal diff, many case like this in this diff Fixed, as well as similar problems (stacking slider endpoints?)

___________________________________
hard

01:06:201 - delete this note There's a faint sound here. I'll be keeping this for a while, or until another mod suggests removing this note.
01:12:708 - too offbeat By this you mean a beat too much, right? Done
01:23:958 (1) - ends at 01:27:267 - How come I didn't notice this? Thanks for pointing out

___________________________________
Insane

00:58:370 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - make them constant Was originally intended to follow drum volume. Anyway, fixed.

nice song XD XD

• Easy

1. 01:13:811 (2) - move this down a bit to x:260 y:184 to stack with the (2) slider before it, it's okay to stack because this is a slider
2. 00:41:605 (3) - NC

• Normal

1. 00:31:458 (2) - I think the NC should start here instead of the (1) circle before it. And I think it's better to not stack this slider, different beats and vocal imo
2. 00:41:605 (3) - NC (again because it's the only 4 combo slider on this part of song, the other has only 2 slider)
3. Here, from 00:45:134 (1) - to 00:48:002 (4) - I don't think it's good to stack the sliders and circles like that imo, I guess it's better to make patterns using that circles

• Hard

1. 00:07:991 (1) - Shouldn't the slider ends at 00:08:737 ? Fit nicely
2. 00:10:723 (3) - NC, starts another vocal
3. 01:00:245 - add another note here for triplet? Fit better

• Insane

1. 00:36:752 (7) - NC here, new vocal
2. 00:50:870 (5,1,2,3,4,5) - I suggest you to make a pattern here, instead of not pattern-ish. The star pattern is possible here, but I'm sorry I can't provide screenshot for now, I can add tomorrow if you want

AnreFM wrote:

Hello from #modreqs
Sorry I'm late though
Anyway, these are just suggestion, feel free to object

• Easy

1. 01:13:811 (2) - move this down a bit to x:260 y:184 to stack with the (2) slider before it, it's okay to stack because this is a slider
2. 00:41:605 (3) - NC All done

• Normal

1. 00:31:458 (2) - I think the NC should start here instead of the (1) circle before it. And I think it's better to not stack this slider, different beats and vocal imo Fixed (moved slider and changed shape to fit on the lower screen)
2. 00:41:605 (3) - NC (again because it's the only 4 combo slider on this part of song, the other has only 2 slider) Fixed
3. Here, from 00:45:134 (1) - to 00:48:002 (4) - I don't think it's good to stack the sliders and circles like that imo, I guess it's better to make patterns using that circles Am keeping this one until another mod points this out. Just in case, I've prepared a replacement pattern which clears all but the final stack in the range.

• Hard

1. 00:07:991 (1) - Shouldn't the slider ends at 00:08:737 ? Fit nicely Fixed (was originally intended to replace the 8-note stream)
2. 00:10:723 (3) - NC, starts another vocal
3. 01:00:245 - add another note here for triplet? Fit better Fixed

• Insane

1. 00:36:752 (7) - NC here, new vocal
2. 00:50:870 (5,1,2,3,4,5) - I suggest you to make a pattern here, instead of not pattern-ish. The star pattern is possible here, but I'm sorry I can't provide screenshot for now, I can add tomorrow if you want Fixed (So hard to purge a star there XD)

Well I guess that's all I can find, hope my mod helps
Sorry if it doesn't though
Anyway good luckk :D

zorefire wrote:

modd request

Easy Modd

• [Easy]
  

1. 00:04:546 (2) - maybe try that. Don't try to repeat the same pattern. Done.
   []
   
2. 00:11:384 (2,1) - maybe you should try this? Keeping my current pattern for various reasons:
   1. The length and time placement of slider 2 makes the ends and ticks follow the vocals.
   2. I want to keep uniform spacing in this portion.
   3. Sort of breaks the flow, and makes placement of note 3 look worse than it is now.
3. 00:18:443 (1) - try adding finished and remove whistle. Good idea.
   []
   
4. try that? Done, though the spacing concerns me in this fix.
   []
   
   
5. 01:23:958 (3) - remove and make the slider like that? ... What to change? I don't see anything wrong here.

P.S - I will do a complete revamp of Normal for you since it's faster that way I will be back soon.
I will fix things and send you the file if you don't like what I did you can revert your file back to its original way by updating the beatmap. Looks like there's too much to change in Normal.

jamo716 wrote:

Nice map dude!

Eyenine wrote:

zorefire wrote:

modd request

Easy Modd

• [Easy]
  

1. 00:04:546 (2) - maybe try that. Don't try to repeat the same pattern. Done.
   []
   
2. 00:11:384 (2,1) - maybe you should try this? Keeping my current pattern for various reasons:
   1. The length and time placement of slider 2 makes the ends and ticks follow the vocals.
   2. I want to keep uniform spacing in this portion.
   3. Sort of breaks the flow, and makes placement of note 3 look worse than it is now.
3. 00:18:443 (1) - try adding finished and remove whistle. Good idea.
   []
   
4. try that? Done, though the spacing concerns me in this fix.
   []
   
   
5. 01:23:958 (3) - remove and make the slider like that? ... What to change? I don't see anything wrong here.

P.S - I will do a complete revamp of Normal for you since it's faster that way I will be back soon.
I will fix things and send you the file if you don't like what I did you can revert your file back to its original way by updating the beatmap. Looks like there's too much to change in Normal.

Updated.

Thanks for the mod!
.
.
.
.

jamo716 wrote:

Nice map dude!

Why, thank you, sir!

osu_gangster wrote:

Random mod~
Don't hate me if I'm wrong xD

[General]
I think BPM offset is 2754 (but not sure...) Too early, especially at midsong

[Normal]
reduce the stacking? :/
01:23:296 (3) - Whistle? (Dun sa 2nd at 3rd endpoint)
01:23:958 (1) - ^ Noted all

[Hard]
00:18:443 (1) - Whistle/Finish?
01:23:958 (1) - Whistle Fixed all

Go i9! !

1. Kiai should be the same in all diffs.
2. Timing feels wrong. Maybe you should ask someone to check it.
3. BG picture's size should be 1024 x 768.

Leyko wrote:

Hey! From #modreqs.
No animu bg? What is this madness? :O Because bg image from source anime is too mainstream

[General]

1. Kiai should be the same in all diffs. Fixed. Except for the last kiai cut (spinner mid in ENH diffs). Because mid spinner burst is ...
2. Timing feels wrong. Maybe you should ask someone to check it. This is the best I got. Waiting for timing checkers from the thread (it's alive, right?)
3. BG picture's size should be 1024 x 768.A widescreen bg is intended ... so, 1366x768

[Easy]
00:10:723 (1) - Add whistle.
00:23:958 (1) - Add finish.
00:41:605 (1) - Move 1 grid to the left, so it won't touch the previous slider.
00:43:370 (1) - Remove NC.
00:49:767 (2) - Add whistle.
00:50:208 (1) - Add finish.
01:20:429 (1) - Distance. >3< Fixed all

[Normal]
00:13:149 - Add a note.
00:29:914 (1) - Remove NC.
00:45:576 (2,3,4,5) - This part feels too empty. Maybe add notes in between them?
00:51:090 (1) - Add finish.
01:06:090 - Add a note.
01:20:208 - ^ Fixed all (again)
New star rating = 2.8 (+.19)

[Hard]
00:16:458 - Add a note. Intended to add more color to that part right? Done
00:41:384 (5) - Add NC.
00:43:149 (1) - Remove NC. Consistency check. Done.

[Insane]
HP -1 please. ;_; 8 is too brutal. Didn't feel the brutality of HP8. Fixed
00:52:193 (1) - Finish on the beginning. Done

That's all. Good luck! :3 :3

1. consider adding a video? It might be better, I will send you the file via PM
2. use normal sampleset in kiai?
3. Combo colour should be consistent with all diff except guest diff

1. consider adding some claps?
2. 00:58:353 (1) - please do not stack it with 00:56:588 (3) , it is not rankable, in addition, it may confuse new player
3. 01:02:103 (4) - put it at x:256 y:76 can be a nice blanket
4. 01:08:059 (1) - same as the stacking problem

1. 00:26:147 (1) - remove NC
2. 00:51:073 (1) - this spinner is quite short, try to change it to be a slider?

1. 00:07:948 - useless inherited point
2. 00:08:941 - ^
3. 00:18:426 (1) - finish?
4. 00:34:529 (5) - try to stack it with 00:33:647 (4) ?
5. 00:45:779 (4,7,10) - NC to this 3 notes?
6. 00:58:573 (1) - stack with 00:57:250 (4) ?

1. 00:32:543 (2) - put it at x:276 y:208 ?

happy623 wrote:

Sorry for a big late
I have a remod now QwQ

[General]

1. consider adding a video? It might be better, I will send you the file via PM Thanks! Will add on the next update.
2. use normal sampleset in kiai? Am giving this a thought, but in the meantime, I'm keeping this, or until another mod suggests the same. Soft sample set is to me easy to toy with, thus making hitsounding more colorful.
3. Combo colour should be consistent with all diff except guest diff Fixed

[Easy]

1. consider adding some claps? Added some, though I was quite uncertain where to add them.
2. 00:58:353 (1) - please do not stack it with 00:56:588 (3) , it is not rankable, in addition, it may confuse new player Fixed
3. 01:02:103 (4) - put it at x:256 y:76 can be a nice blanket Ooh, a blanket.
4. 01:08:059 (1) - same as the stacking problem Fixed

[Normal]

1. 00:26:147 (1) - remove NC
2. 00:51:073 (1) - this spinner is quite short, try to change it to be a slider? Fixed both

[Hard]

1. 00:07:948 - useless inherited point
2. 00:08:941 - ^
3. 00:18:426 (1) - finish?
4. 00:34:529 (5) - try to stack it with 00:33:647 (4) ?
5. 00:45:779 (4,7,10) - NC to this 3 notes?
6. 00:58:573 (1) - stack with 00:57:250 (4) ? Fixed all

[Insane]

1. 00:32:543 (2) - put it at x:276 y:208 ? Fixed

sorry for the shortness It's fine
Diff is not bad now
star for encouragement
keep going Thanks

S e e U wrote:

[Insane]
00:35:081 (2) - add circle
00:35:522 (4) - ^ EX) http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/781631 er... Nope. Those circles won't be doing a thing on those 1/4 ticks. If for more difficulty, no.

01:00:338 ~ 01:01:882 - add circle ^ I'm following the vocals here, since it overpowers the high-pitched instrument, so no. Oh, you suggests the circles to be in the 1/4 ticks, right?

Legenda wrote:

→ Unrankable things, must fix
→ My human doubts, things to consider
→ Tips & Tricks to make your map better
♥ → Greetings
* → Just comments, not mods
Naked Lines → Mods

* No complaints in General.
* No complaints at Easy and Normal.

[Hard]
01:00:228 (5) - This note feels overmapped.

[Insane]
* 00:44:896 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Complex patterns a bit hard to read, but OK.
* 00:46:662 (1,2,3,4) - ^

Alarido wrote:

Hi ^^
A Free Mod from Coffee Party Queue -- ROUND V

Legenda wrote:

→ Unrankable things, must fix
→ My human doubts, things to consider
→ Tips & Tricks to make your map better
♥ → Greetings
* → Just comments, not mods
Naked Lines → Mods

* No complaints in General.
* No complaints at Easy and Normal.

[Hard]
01:00:228 (5) - This note feels overmapped. Note deleted.

[Insane]
* 00:44:896 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Complex patterns a bit hard to read, but OK.
* 00:46:662 (1,2,3,4) - ^

That's it ^^

Good luck on Rankling as soon as possible, perfect ♥
Nice song.
(Currently I can't star graved maps
Att.

sheela901 wrote:

[General]
Add more tags like: anime. Thanks for pointing out

[Easy]
00:06:294 (3) - Move this somewhere to make a triangle Done

[Normal]
00:02:764 (1,2,3) - Make something else? Will be keeping this for now, or until another mod points this out.

[Insane]
01:19:750 (7) - Copy 01:19:309 (6) and paste and Ctrl+J, Ctrl+G I'd like to keep it this way.

Sorry if it isn't enough. Good Luck!