Gabe wrote:
Hi there Katsuri.
OHSHIET, I FORGOT THIS MOD. BUT I HAVE FINISHED THE MOD FOR INSANE THREE WEEKS AGO. I hope these suggestions weren't mentioned D:!
Insane
I enjoyed the flows on this beatmap. The hitsounds are pretty good, the pattern, mostly the sliders are awesome. Thanks Gabe!
- 00:23:751 (1) - It's me or you've forgot to add a Normal Sampleset at the end of this slider? It sounded weird since you've added normal samplesets at every upbeats and seems like you've skipped this one. If it was intentional, you should add it because if not, it won't keep the consistency with your Normal Samplesets and it may sound a bit weird if you skip it. Ohhh my bad!
- 00:24:371 (2) - I think it would have a better flow if this slider isn't completely making an overlap with the previous slider. I actually think you should move the slider (2) some ticks downs. Anyways, look on the spoilerbox if you think that's a good idea, but to be honest, I prefer if it's not completely stacked.
ExamplesWell, I think it looks better if it's like that: aaaa ok thank you!
Than that:- 00:32:647 (6) - I like what you did there with the same form as the previous slider, but I think you should make a better flow here with the previous and the two next objects. With these two sliders, you could make a circle form with it, but not a completely round form. (Hope you understand). By doing this, the slider (2) will make a blanket with the slider (1)'s end and the slider (1) will make another blanket with the slider (1). After that, you will make another blanket with the circle (3) and for the end, you stack the slider (1) from the other combo and you stack it with the beginning of the slider (1). I guess it will make an awesome blanket. Just before you don't understand what I've mentioned, here's what I actually wanted to say: I have to say no here, I really enjoy those kinds of overlaps!
ExamplesLol @mouse button enabled- 00:54:371 (9,10,11,1,2) - This sounds a bit weird and the finish on the red tick makes it worse. I would like you to reverse the timeline emplacement of the slider (1) and the circle (2), because the Finish sound shouldn't be in the red tick. Also, the circle (8,9) shouldn't be stacked since she restart to sing at the circle (9). It would be better if the emplacement emphasize the vocals if (9,10) and (11, 1) are stacked. Here's an example of what I've did: changed before
- 01:38:854 (3) - I think you should delete the whistles because as I can hear on the next objects that should have whistles like this one, doesn't have one. (That sounded a bit weird) Anyways, you should delete these whistle to keep the consistency. Should be the same thing with 01:40:509 (2,3,4) - (You understand?) I kept the whistle but made them consistent during the section, thank you for reminder!
- 02:25:406 (3) - It will look better if this slider isn't overlapped with the previous slider. Here's an example: Yes fixed(and added a wave)
- 02:35:337 (3,4) - These circles can be hidden by the previous slider. When I first seen it, it made me a bit confused.. aaaa fixed!
TheVileOne wrote:
General
Preview times must be the same in all difficulties. done
Insane
I had a lot of fun. I will rate this song very highly when it's ranked. Haha thanks!!
00:49:199 (3,4) - This should be 1.1 I don't get the point here, it's 1.1x spaced, I think.
00:56:440 (4,1) - For some reason I find this angle awkward to hit. Yes I did too, changed!
01:14:439 - Maybe a note here, to fix the spacing. Added the note to make a jumpy spacing, not fix it. (:
01:32:647 (3,4,5) - I can't play this. I would prefer this spaced out. ehhh, I think I fixed. I actually don't know how I could space it without looking ugly.
02:37:613 (5) - Isn't perfectly aligned with previous slider. the perfect alignment for the previous slider would have this at x 489 y 195. ehhh, I'd rather keep it this way, the "perfect alignement" wouldn't influde in none gameplay/design
03:20:647 (1,2,3,4) - Why does the note part of the curve flatten right after the slider? Make it so that the curve from the slider seamlessly flows into the note curve. Done thanks!
Thanks you two for the mods!!