Naoko Mitome, Chika Sekigawa - Castle Bleck

posted
Total Posts
92
show more
Topic Starter
Royston

Sonnyc wrote:

Easy:

00:30:174 (4) - Imo, NC will be better okay, fixed.
00:54:982 (2) - 1 Grid down done
01:30:749 (1) - Make this a Soft-Finish as other diffs.

Normal:

01:37:672 (1) - Make this a Auto-Finish as other diffs.
01:40:268 (1) - Imo, it will be better if you started at 01:40:124 agreed, fixed

Hard:

01:02:482 (3) - Spacing? fixed
01:05:078 (5) - ^ fixed
01:26:710 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - A perfect square will be better.

472,232,86711,5,8,0:0:0:0:
384,40,86999,1,0,0:0:0:0:
176,88,87287,1,8,0:0:0:0:
272,280,87576,1,0,0:0:0:0:
472,232,87864,1,8,0:0:0:0:
384,40,88153,1,0,0:0:0:0:
Um, I think the code is what I already had. xD Either that or I screwed something up
01:40:268 (1) - Imo, it will be better if you started at 01:40:124 fixed
Regarding the finish/soft-finish stuff I was a bit confused at first since they all sounded the same. Then I realised the issue - I actually had a normal-hitfinish.wav in the folder that sounds like the default soft-hitfinish. I think I had it like that because originally the map had a normal clap + soft-finish hitsound on the same note, and I couldn't get both of them to play with additions.

But now that it's removed I should be safe in removing the file and adding soft-additions to where all the finishes are (except for at 01:12:288, because I think a normal finish actually fits there).

Hope that makes sense, anyway it should all be fine now. :P Also fixed an incorrectly snapped slider in Hard.
Kokatsu
I want this ranked. :<
Topic Starter
Royston

Kokatsu wrote:

I want this ranked. :<
Me too man, me too. :(
Sonnyc
:#
Elly-chan
Accepted Request From ♫ ~ Project Thorough Modding ~ ♫

[Easy]
  1. 00:22:675 (3) - Add a new combo here since there was a downbeat previous that ended on a slider; emphasizes the new verse of the music. After, add a new combo on 00:24:983 - so the combo doesn't get too long.
  2. 00:22:675 (3) - You should add a clap here; 'keeps consistent with your hitsound pattern and there's a sound just like a clap in the BGM that you have previously added claps to.
  3. 00:23:829 (1) - "You should add a clap here; 'keeps consistent with your hitsound pattern and there's a sound just like a clap in the BGM that you have previously added claps to."
  4. 00:26:713 (1) - I think it would be better to add in a whistle here as well if you're trying to follow the main rhythm with whistles. It sounds better imo.
  5. 00:28:444 (3) - Add a clap, 'fits in better with the music rather than nothing.
  6. 01:26:134 (1) - You forgot to add a whistle here to keep consistent with your hitsound pattern.

  • HP Drain Rate +1; it's too low at the moment being just one, and it aligns better with the Overall Difficulty, which is set to two.

  1. 00:16:618 (3) - To lead into the next slider better and to add more variation (seeing the last three sliders previous were straight, and after this slider there are much more straight ones on their way as opposed to curves), I suggest that you make this a curved slider instead and reposition the end point so that it leads in better as I first mentioned.
  2. 00:33:348 (1) - To emphasize the musical phrase better, I would suggest that you shorten this slider and add notes afterwords accordingly, as such here. (more emphasis will be given to 00:34:501 - and a note you couldn't hit seperately with the slider, 00:33:924 -).
  3. 01:05:366 (4) - Yet again, to throw in some variety and tidy up the flow, I would suggest you add a curved repeat slider here instead like so.
  4. 01:07:097 (2) - Imho, this could fit the music much better if you split the slider up into two mini-sliders to hit notes that should be emphasized (that you did end up emphasizing around 01:11:423 (2, 3, 4) -), 01:07:385 - and 01:07:674 -.
  5. 01:31:326 (2, 2) - Can you make these blanket (1) better? It feels just a tad bit odd to play without the blanket when it could obviously be improved.
Topic Starter
Royston

Elly-chan wrote:

[Easy]
  1. 00:22:675 (3) - Add a new combo here since there was a downbeat previous that ended on a slider; emphasizes the new verse of the music. After, add a new combo on 00:24:983 - so the combo doesn't get too long. added the first one, but I don't think the longer combo is that much of an issue. Happy to change it if it is, though
  2. 00:22:675 (3) - You should add a clap here; 'keeps consistent with your hitsound pattern and there's a sound just like a clap in the BGM that you have previously added claps to. done
  3. 00:23:829 (1) - "You should add a clap here; 'keeps consistent with your hitsound pattern and there's a sound just like a clap in the BGM that you have previously added claps to." done
  4. 00:26:713 (1) - I think it would be better to add in a whistle here as well if you're trying to follow the main rhythm with whistles. It sounds better imo. soft whistle right? added
  5. 00:28:444 (3) - Add a clap, 'fits in better with the music rather than nothing. personally I think it sounds better as is
  6. 01:26:134 (1) - You forgot to add a whistle here to keep consistent with your hitsound pattern. nah, I deliberately didn't put one there. :p

  • HP Drain Rate +1; it's too low at the moment being just one, and it aligns better with the Overall Difficulty, which is set to two. changed

  1. 00:16:618 (3) - To lead into the next slider better and to add more variation (seeing the last three sliders previous were straight, and after this slider there are much more straight ones on their way as opposed to curves), I suggest that you make this a curved slider instead and reposition the end point so that it leads in better as I first mentioned. sure, changed
  2. 00:33:348 (1) - To emphasize the musical phrase better, I would suggest that you shorten this slider and add notes afterwords accordingly, as such here. (more emphasis will be given to 00:34:501 - and a note you couldn't hit seperately with the slider, 00:33:924 -). good point, fixed!
  3. 01:05:366 (4) - Yet again, to throw in some variety and tidy up the flow, I would suggest you add a curved repeat slider here instead like so. I'd rather keep this slider the same shape as 01:02:482 (2) and 01:09:692 (3) to allow newer players to see this slider and go "oh, it's this rhythm again"
  4. 01:07:097 (2) - Imho, this could fit the music much better if you split the slider up into two mini-sliders to hit notes that should be emphasized (that you did end up emphasizing around 01:11:423 (2, 3, 4) -), 01:07:385 - and 01:07:674 -. Hmm, I kinda like how the slider ticks from this longer slider go with drum in the background. But I agree that your suggestion would fit the main rhythm a lot better, so changed
  5. 01:31:326 (2, 2) - Can you make these blanket (1) better? It feels just a tad bit odd to play without the blanket when it could obviously be improved. Oh god you have no idea how much I suck at blanketing stuff. Anyway, I restructured it in a different way, that I think it plays better than it does currently.
Thanks very much. Easy difficulty has been updated.
Topic Starter
Royston
...
Madlollipop
Hugh... Or Urgh...
The timings at the start MIGHT not be 100% accurate, maybe they should not even be there, I found it quite hard to hear to be honest. But well listen to it at like 50-75% in the timings tab to hear if you think it is right. Very well timed other than the beginning where, if you want to keep it simple and have your timings, its slightly off.
http://puu.sh/2Tn3T.osu
Topic Starter
Royston
Thanks for the help. And yeah, the beginning does seem somewhat off. I'm hesitant to add too many timing sections in case I have to make more changes down the road... I'll wait and see what the next BAT thinks before I screw around with the timing but I'll be keeping your timings handy for the future.
Erreberto
i wanna this ranked ç_ç
Topic Starter
Royston
I may come back to it, one day.
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply