NM (second bn request) Link : beatmapsets/1301193 Notes: gzdongsheng going check whole map and currently the set abandoned many times by BNs. would be great if you can take cover in. THANK YOU!
Queue closed. A list of all requests, whether they were accepted or rejected, and why, can be found in the list below. Maps rejected this round can be re-requested next round.
Rejected M4M requests can still get a mod from me if the mapper wants more details on why they were rejected. In this case the request will be more like a regular M4M request than a Mod 4 Nomination request. Contact me if you still want the mod and I'll mod first.
AWMRone - Nageki no Hana I'm already checking this. You didn't have to req smh.
Kim_GodSSI - FULLFLAVOR ONDO Incredibly fun jacks. I absolutely hate the song choice though.
Tropicar - HUGE W Ending spikes a bit but otherwise very clean LN map. Very fun to play.
Delayed Accepted, but expect me to take extra time.
Hugged - Comeback (Extended Mix) Way above my skill level. I will need a lot of time for this.
doctormango - <</nttld.:beings>> ~Truth in Uncertainty~ I like the LNs. I'll get back to this after I get full BN.
riunosk - Xronial Xero Hard jacks, I like. I'll check this when I can get fully warmed up for 4K.
Archaic84 - N Very clean dense JS. I'll check this when I can get fully warmed up for 4K.
Maybe Accepted only if I'm done with other requests. Re-request through queue, or contact me through PM or discord next month if I haven't gotten to these by the time the queue reopens.
Zwhykoler - The Lonely Tower 10K based. Just barely doable for me.
Seiran- - lost found melody Great use of anchors and jacks, but not quite hard enough.
hemoo - I'm Your Daddy (Extended Edition Bluray Box Set Mix) Pretty clean but a little easy.
Noch Einen - Omae no koto nanka suki janai kara na!!! Generally enjoyable map. Nice use of LNs. A little too easy in general, and the difficulty curves up a bit too much towards the end for my taste though.
AncuL - Odo Flows really nice, but not challenging enough.
FAMoss - Encounter Very clean if not for the minijacks and some awkward bursts. Not quite hard enough.
Conditional Reject for now, but will reconsider if some changes are made. Re-request next cycle after changes.
Monoseul - Scattered Faith Generally pretty bad difficulty curve design. Most of the map's difficulty comes from jumptrillable rolls, while the rest of the map is pretty underwhelming in comparison. Buff easy parts or nerf hard parts and I'll reconsider.
Tomoyuki Hamada - Vicious Heroism Almost an enjoyable CJ map. Might reconsider if you improve burst transitions, and SVs (or just get rid of them.)
Ricca - PSYCHO+HEROES Pretty bad difficulty spikes towards the end. Some awkward bits here and there. Otherwise clean concept. Get some testplayers.
Angki - Einherjar Joker I like the LNs, even though some anchors in them are a little awkward. Not really a fan of how you mixed SVs, LNs, and dense JS in a single map though. Might like it more if you stuck to a clearer concept.
Falcon - China Way too easy. Great longjacks though. Will be happy to take if you made a denser version of the current top diff.
Rejected Hard reject. Unlikely to accept even if re-requested.
Xinhong1003 - Cynical Night Plan Too easy
Crisper - Post Shelter Too easy
Shiro_122 - Ki ga Kurutta Noise Too easy
Wildcard_Chase - KillerToy Honestly not really interested in memorization SVs.
keksikosu - T+ VS SHARK JS and LNs don't mesh too well together even though individual sections are very clean. A bit too easy overall too.
Utawaennosora - Guitar to Kotoku to Aoi Hoshi (Full ver.) Too easy
Please refer to my profile for BN check progress. If nothing goes wrong the queue will reopen on December 31st. I'll see you all again in a month.
Removed M4M as it was getting a bit inconvenient to track. I'm less likely to accept 4K maps this round as I already have a good number of them from last month. The queue will be open for 24 hours.
Link : beatmapsets/1866675#mania/3839807 Desc : Ocean Blue is an entry-level 7K wavy chordjack, I have GDs from Reihynn (Avel), Ilham, and Blocko. Notes: I already have a BN which is Rivals_7 (check their Trello for confirmation) but currently I don't have a 2nd BN.
Link : beatmapsets/1000007#mania/2092173 Desc : a jack oriented 7k mapset Notes: the set has not been modded too much overall because i just couldnt find people that could mod this also second nominator is Akasha
Queue closed. A list of all requests, whether they were accepted or rejected, and why, can be found in the list below. Maps rejected this round can be re-requested next round.
Maybe Accepted only if I'm done with other requests. Re-request through queue, or contact me through PM or discord next month if I haven't gotten to these by the time the queue reopens.
Subtlr - Ocean Blue I love chordjacks but the map is super easy.
Noch Einen - Omae no koto nanka suki janai kara na!!! Same as last time.
by-ad - Isetsu Higanbana Daiichi - Gensho no Amaryllis - The map isn't quite hard enough but bonus points for antimeta. Higher priority than other maybe requests.
Conditional Reject for now, but will reconsider if some changes are made. Re-request next cycle after changes.
Kurchito - A Miserable Pile Of Secrets I like the jacks, but the LN section kind of undermines that map's concept as a jack map. I might reconsider if you're willing to make the map completely rice oriented.
Rejected Hard reject. Unlikely to accept even if re-requested.
keksikosu - Loneliness Too easy.
Please refer to my profile for BN check progress. If nothing goes wrong the queue will reopen on January 31st. I'll see you all again in a month.
Link : beatmapsets/1777999 Desc : mostly jumpstream stuff, stamina demanding set. and a big one Notes: spread is designed as EENNHHIIXX. lower ENHI is guideline-strict, while upper ENHI does not. intended to keep the gap rather fair
Link : beatmapsets/1899428 Desc : the first artcore song! this is a 4K+6K NHIX + NHIX spread.it's a rice based map and have some LNs in both top diffs. Notes: 2nd BN is AWMRone :3
Link : beatmapsets/1626034#mania/3319809 Desc : hard 7K map collab marathon with Schopfer (LN 210 stream and double stair) Notes: Another BN is Muse Dash and I also pay many in this map hope u like it owob
Link : beatmapsets/1885413#mania/3882071 Desc : pretty hard short map. almost a full rice. should be easy to check Notes: i don't really think that we need to ask for mods.. if you will accept, i can ask for it. hope you like it, not so much BNs love such songs
Link : beatmapsets/1910399#mania/3940484 Desc : Short 2-minute song, fat 10K spread! Has hitsounds AND keysounds. Nothing too special about the actual charting, just trying to get more 10K leaderboards out there for people to compete. Notes: [Sick]CatCat might be BNing, but it will probably be a while until he gets to it. I may find a different BN in the meantime.
Queue closed. A list of all requests, whether they were accepted or rejected, and why, can be found in the list below. Maps rejected this round can be re-requested next round.
Seiran- - Grievous Lady -nothing is but what is not- Schopfer God. I don't really like how half the map is filler but I can see how the song left you few choices.
Delayed Accepted, but expect me to take longer
Rivals_7 - KINGWORLD Very clean dense HS. I would probably like it even more you made it entirely rice oriented but this isn't too big of a deal. I'll start my check within a month after Quenlla's check.
Maybe Accepted only if I'm done with other requests. Re-request through queue, or contact me through PM or discord next month if I haven't gotten to these by the time the queue reopens.
shizehao - felys final remix The map is clean but it's also pretty easy. Bonus for AWM second BN.
Conditional Accepted only under certain conditions.
Hugged - Retribution What the hell gorilla 10K set. Accepting only if you can get a 1st BN that can guarantee playability for the set as I absolutely cannot play this.
Rejected Hard reject. Unlikely to accept even if re-requested.
YUCInoback - Guitar to Kodoku to Aoi Hoshi Too easy.
Flade - SCUNTHORPE Too easy.
cai_ji_ccc - Alice in Misanthrope -Ensei Alice- Too easy. Also big spike at the end.
Please refer to my profile for BN check progress. If nothing goes wrong the queue will reopen on February 28th. I'll see you all again in a month.
Link: beatmapsets/1851195#mania/4006424 Desc: a standard lower diff with playability as top prority, and a slightly complex harder diff that's kinda the opposite.. Note: I am still waiting for a couple more mods. The map is on ham's waitlist but I don't think that's a guaranteed bn check...
Link : beatmapsets/1890147#mania/3893839 Desc : a technical hybrid 4k map that's more leaning to the lns Notes: been looking for bns for this, got none currently (edit: AWMRone accepted for 1st)
Link : beatmapsets/1800930 Desc : trying to give hard map for new players and myself (on mapping 4k). HEAVENLY does like mixing concept (trying to mesh ryu's idea vs my stream & simple chordjack Notes: currently on hold req is from Ryax
Link: beatmapsets/1898205#mania/3915356 Description: the map is a very fast and difficult rise map that has little lns Notes: most of the modding has been through dms
Queue closed. A list of all requests, whether they were accepted or rejected, and why, can be found in the list below. Maps rejected this round can be re-requested next round.
AWMRone - TremENDouS 5K boss map 5K boss map Just know that I will complain about the ending spike and I won't be nominating if it doesn't get nerfed (or if the rest of the map gets buffed.) No compromise on this one. Individual sections are amazing though.
Tropicar - GIMME DA BLOOD You're lucky that your last map that I nominated is just about to be pushed out of recent 6 noms. Generally very clean map.
Delayed Accepted, but expect me to take longer
YyottaCat - Z:iRNiTRA I'd take this right away but I nominated one of your maps a little too recently. I'll do this one after all the other requests if you're ok with it. I should mention in advance that the ending spikes a lot due to increases in density and complexity so you should probably nerf it in the meantime, either through density nerfs or by reducing bracketing. Epic map though.
tyrcs - Fallen Symphony I nominated one of your maps pretty recently so I'll do this one last. Only complaint I have about the map is basically the same as with Uta's - the implicit jacks in delay sections lol. Except this time you have even less of them so they stand out even more. Otherwise super clean.
Maybe Accepted only if I'm done with other requests. Re-request through queue, or contact me through PM or discord next month if I haven't gotten to these by the time the queue reopens.
KoshiK-h - CICADA3302 Honestly not to my taste. Jack use feels a little awkward and messy to me. Putting this under maybe but considering the number of requests I got this round don't expect too much.
Conditional Accepted only under certain conditions.
richardfeder - Symphonic Love I've wanted to nominate one of your maps for some time but I should mention two things just for this map: 1. The double spacebar pattern is unfathomably based but they aren't used often enough. They should either be isolated/simplified, or used more extensively throughout the map. 2. A lot of the SVs are impossible without memorizing, which I dislike a lot. I'm accepting this request only if the issues above can be fixed.
BKwind - Amnéhilesie Way too hard for me. Accepting only if you can get some high level 10K players to mod this. I did notice that you asked for mods at the 10k+ discord so you probably got this.
Rejected Hard reject. Unlikely to accept even if re-requested.
KeseaN - Surprise Too easy. See queue rules.
Noch Einen - Deadly Force I already have a map to check from you. Also too easy.
Worthlessnut9 - Motherless Miscarriage Burst usage is pretty messy imo. The map jumps up and down in difficulty a lot.
pashalka - DAW WARS (Eurobeat Remix) Too easy. See queue rules.
YuanLiang - We are DREAMERS!! Too easy. See queue rules.
Please refer to my profile for BN check progress. If nothing goes wrong the queue will reopen on March 31st. I'll see you all again in a month.