Ekaru wrote:

01:48:591 (11) - This looks *ahem* inappropriate in OpenGL mode.

NotShinta wrote:

Hard:
Tick rate 2, kthx. The sliders aren't very confusing, but 2 pretty much makes them work.
00:28:345 - I'd rather you increase the volume of this slider, I must say it is awkward as is. 50% works well?It's 60% at that part, what do you mean with increasing to 50%?
01:28:845 - I found it weird that you didn't map this section. It's pretty much as intense and mappable as the last section.Dunno, I kinda feel like it works.
02:16:841 (1) - Add a whistle? (or delete, since the rest of the combo is to vocals, but nah)Meh, nah
02:40:216 (5,6) - arghWeakling, can't stand a stream and a overlap like that

Ekaru wrote:

01:48:591 (11) - This looks *ahem* inappropriate in OpenGL mode.

I NEVER KNEW YOU HAD SUCH A DIR-DY MINDBleh I figure out something better later.

Aaah this mod post is terrible I'm sorry

Soul-less wrote:

Ruining a mapModding here like a modder!....Wait this sounds wrong. D:

[General]
-Nuke due to slider speeds!! But seriously, I hope there won't be people going like "I can haz over 1337 slider speed, look at tis map!"
- Mp3 bit rate 256kbqs? The maximum bitrate allowed is 192kbps. Hmm. Oh god how did I make that mistake <.< fixed
- Might wanna check notes snapping since lots of your notes are snapped slightly early(4ms earlier compared to time line, Or just look at [Hard] -> AIMod. @@).Ugh fixed

[Easy]
- Kiai time's beats seems less denser.I guess, I think it works though

[Normal]
- 00:19:845 (7) - Don't think the clap's needed here.Done
- 00:35:845 (6) - Same as above.Done
- 00:43:345 (5) - Same as above(Slider end's clap).Done

[Hard]
- 00:28:345 (10) - Why do I think of curving the end of the slider, due to the vocal. (Probably after playing 01:48:591 (11) too.)I tried but I like it better how it is, sorry
- 01:06:841 (2) - A clap here, feel like doing some double claps interval.No to all the hitsound ideas
- 01:07:841 (6) - Same as above.
- 01:10:591 (5) - Hmm....a whistle here, no?
- 01:14:591 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Yep, double claps matching the pattern above.
- 01:18:591 (1) - A clap in the mid? Since you're doing quite a large part of 2 quarters clap.
- 01:22:841 (4) - Add a clap here? I personally prefer a double clap here, and below too.
- 01:23:841 (6) - Yep, also a clap. Due to the repeating sliders before(And suggestions above too).
- 01:26:591 (1,2,3,4) - Consider make them curvy instead? Seeing all similar sliders sets are of the same pattern.No
- 02:16:841 (1) - Hmm. It plays well, but it's like an odd one out, being the only one starting on red line.
- 02:40:091 (4) - Don't think the whistle is needed. Hmm.Yeah... removed

First time ruining modding a MAT's map. Feel free to ignore if those suggestions are bad.Well it was a the best modding

1. normal and easy offset - 615
   hard - 595 + many unsnaped objects
   (615 is better for me)
2. 640x480 image isn't good. I found this one: http://de.academic.ru/pictures/dewiki/1 ... 847a06.JPG. Is it fit?

gyt wrote:

heh, random bad mod as always

[General]

1. normal and easy offset - 615
   hard - 595 + many unsnaped objects
   (615 is better for me)Woops my mistake
2. 640x480 image isn't good. I found this one: http://de.academic.ru/pictures/dewiki/1 ... 847a06.JPG. Is it fit?

I'm kinda attached to that BG

[Hard]
01:00:095 (8) - replace clap to finish at the repeat? (it fits to finish hitsounds before). Also maybe remove clap at the end?I like how it is
01:36:591 (1,2), 01:39:591 (9,10) and others like this - strange spacing. Use a usual stack maybe?I like how it is, I tried regular stacking but it didn't work as well.
01:40:341 (11) - replace clap to finish at the end?No
02:12:341 (1) - add finish (or whistle) at the start?No
02:15:341 (7) - add finish (or whistle) at the repeat and the end - it isn't good without hitsoundsDone
02:20:341 (6) - replace claps to finishes?No
03:15:095, 03:15:845 - add circles - it will be much better, IMO (now it's a bit weird)I think it's better as it is.
03:23:716 (7) - this circle doesn't follow music for me - move it to 03:23:845? No I it's fits better this way imo.

[Normal]
00:41:865 - add circleNah
01:00:115 (8) - replace clap to finish at the end?No
01:07:615 (2) - remove clap at the end?Mp
01:08:615 (1) - remove whistle - it works in hard, but not here , imoYeah...
01:13:615 (3) - remove clap at the end?No
01:16:615 (1,3) - remove whistleDone
01:40:365 (7) - replace clap to finish at the end?I like how it sounds right now
01:56:615 (1) - add whistle at the end?No
01:58:365 (3) - add whistle at the start?Yes
02:12:365 (7) - add finish (or whistle)Done whistle
02:15:865 (7,8) - replace to finishes (or use whistles only)Changed round a bit.
02:20:615 (7) - remove clap at the end?No

[Easy]
00:28:615 (5) - replace current hitsounds too finish?Done
00:54:615 (3) - hm, add whistle?Dune
00:59:615 (4) - replace clap to finish at the end?Removed the clap but didn't add a finish
01:40:615 (1) - add whistle?Done
02:16:615 (5) - add finish?
02:19:615 (4) - add whistle at the repeat + maybe remove clap at the end?Nah
02:24:615 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - hey, where hitsounds?Oh woops
03:04:865 (2) - move 2 grids up. Also you may make something like this http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/81127 Nah

oh these hitsound suggestions are boring, star!

Crimmi wrote:

Modding, CrimmiStyle!

[Easy]

~ Nothing.

[Normal]

I know you'll say No, but:
00:27:865 (6) - It sounded a little off, it sounded better on the white tick i'm not sure.It might sound a bit weird but it sounds way more of on the white tick and red tick for me
00:42:615 (4) - Align with (1).Done
00:49:115 (2) - Align with (3).Ok
00:50:365 (4) - Replace clap with whistle?No
00:52:865 (2) - ^No
00:53:865 (4) - ^Nah on everyting here..
00:54:865 (6) - ^
00:55:865 (8) - ^
00:58:865 (6) - ^
01:38:365 (4) - ^
01:39:615 (6) - ^
01:54:865 (5) - ^
01:57:865 (2) - ^
02:15:365 (6) - Add a whistle?Done
02:17:615 (3) - Replace the clap with a whistle?Changed other stuff instead

[Hard]

OD +1?Ok
00:28:365 (10) - same as 00:27:865 (6) in [Normal].No
01:37:115 (2) - could you stack this neatly under (1)?It's looks neater right now.
01:40:115 (10) - ^
02:20:115 (5) - ^

Star for you =]

Interesting song, *Adds to music folder*

SapphireGhost wrote:

Hi Xgor!

[General]
- Unsnapped kiai. Please fix ~
- I would prefer Tick Rate 2 on all difficulties.


[Breaks]

This looks better in a box.

- Here are some suggestions to keep the breaks consistent on all difficulties.
Break 1: Drag to 00:20:615 on [Normal] and [Hard].
Break 2: Drag to 00:28:990 on [Easy].
Break 3: Drag to 00:36:615 on [Normal] and [Hard].
Break 4: Drag to 00:44:615 on [Normal] and [Hard].
Break 5 and 6: Cool!
Break 7: Drag to 02:04:615 on [Easy].
Break 8: Cool!

Done most of those stuff

[Hard]
02:40:115 (4,5,6) - Why the random 1/4?Well I think it works kinda well with the map, and it is following the drums.
03:28:115 (2) - Noo... this is the only note under a slider in the entire map. Do you have to have it here? ;_;Yes <.< I think think is the place that worked the most imo, Having it slightly more under makes it confusing and all the other ones make it feel kinda out of place imo. (And I think how you are not supposed to move there makes it neat.

Very nice map, as I expected. Good job, Xgor! Have a star from me.

MMzz wrote:

~

kevin840310 wrote:

GOOD!
<Hard>
0:28:365---look strangeUmm what.
1:36:615---longerLike 1/8 longer or what?! I can't make it much more that that and it makes most sense this way
1:39:615---^
1:52:615---^
1:54:365---^
2:19:615---^

Hope I can help you!

Blue Dragon wrote:

General
Maybe add the relation of the image and song to the tags (if there is really one)?Explained in IRC, not needed


Easy
00:48:615 (1,3) - I hate symmetry modding, but it looks like you were going for symmetry here Oh crap fixed

Your easy diffs never cease to amaze me

Normal
01:41:615 (1,3) - Since you used a whistle on (5), I think it would be better to whistle (1,3) tooAdded on (1) but not on (3)

Hard
Couldn't find anything

Your maps are always <3 to me.

Tonoicutzu wrote:

//suggestions

[Easy]
01:56:615 (1,2) - aw. my eyesWhat?

[Normal]
00:59:365 (7) - looks really ugly. try this http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/90939 Changed it a bit but your's wasn't centred so my new one is a bit prettier

[Hard]
try AR +1No I like it with 6 AR

Saten-san wrote:

General
Not really necessary, but you can delete the .osb viewtopic.php?f=6&t=38547 ....

Easy
02:18:115 (2) - 1 grid downI did one grid down Level 4, I guess you ment level 3 but 4 looks more pretty

Normal
02:01:615 (4,5,6) - symmetric mode on The point with that pattern isn't that is should be centered to the grid, I did make (5) symmetric though
02:11:365 (6) - last slider point, 1 grid up~I don't see how that helps, I did make it symmetric though
02:46:365 (2) - Stack with the following (2)?No, That wasn't the intention.

Hard
00:18:115 (6) - align with (2)Oh god how did I make that mistake... I did remap that pattern though so it didn't matter much now
00:18:365 (7,8,9) - fix spacing if you changed what I said aboveSame thing as above with the remapping part.
00:41:365 (3) - 1 grid leftYeah... I guess it looks better
00:42:365 (7) - ^
00:42:615 (8,9,10,11) - 2 grids leftNo, it looks better right now.
00:51:115 (7) - move this 1 up and 1 leftMmm sure, done
00:57:615 (4) - 1 grid downOk
01:37:115 (2) - custom stack?Yess, I like my custom stack.
01:38:115 (5) - 1 grid upWoops fixed.
01:40:115 (10) - custom stack?Yes.
01:53:115 (2) - ^
01:54:865 (6) - ^
02:19:365 (3) - 02:19:365 (3) - 1 up and 1 rightDid it my style
02:20:115 (5) - custom stack? Yeah, I think you're doing it on purpose~Yup
02:26:990 (2) - stack properlyI like my segment sliders D:
02:27:365 (3,4) - ^
02:28:115 (5) - ^
02:34:990 (2) - ^
02:35:365 (3) - ^
02:35:740 (4) - ^
02:36:115 (5) - ^
02:38:615 (1,2,3) -
03:28:115 (2) - stack properlyIt's stacked properly :<


Nice map btw

Jag tänker på dig~~ ♪

Giorgos wrote:

I am not stubborn,I say it because you FIXED their mods,no matter what you fixed,but you fixed it. I remember how people gave me kudosu because they fixed only one circle - and that's fair,because I spent my time for modding this map and because they fixed one of these things that I said.
And what about stars - I always give stars for maps,because it's not hard for me to do it. And the rest of people who don't give stars because of their pride and principles just disrespect other people.
It's not a right place for this conversation,so let's stop this. I just told you what I think about it.

1. The breaks in your map are short. As you use the letterbox during breaks, It is kinda ugly to have a letterbox which appears and disappears in less than 3 seconds :/ Disabling the letterbox would be a good idea.

1. AR1 is not enough ! It makes the objects appear too slowly, it is boring, AR2 or AR3 would be better
2. 02:40:615 (1) - This kind of slider are not a good idea in easy difficulties because they are hard to read for new players. Consider changing it.

1. 01:46:365 (5) - This slider should follow the vocals because the others objects of the pattern follow the vocals. So, reduce it by 1/2 ?
2. 02:41:615 (3) - There is nothing in the music which justify this 1/4, extand it by 1/4 would be more appropriate.
3. 02:46:615 (1) - This slider seems a bit early due to the vocals which start 1/4 later. I think you have to change this pattern, maybe to something like this ? :
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 03:24:615 (1,2,3,1,2) - Why have you stop to add clap here, that breaks the rhythm.

KuraiPettan wrote:

I promised you a mod yesterday in #modreqs, here it is~

General

1. The breaks in your map are short. As you use the letterbox during breaks, It is kinda ugly to have a letterbox which appears and disappears in less than 3 seconds :/ Disabling the letterbox would be a good idea.Good idea, done.

Easy

1. AR1 is not enough ! It makes the objects appear too slowly, it is boring, AR2 or AR3 would be betterWell I guess AR 2 fit's better, especially the intensive parts
2. 02:40:615 (1) - This kind of slider are not a good idea in easy difficulties because they are hard to read for new players. Consider changing it.

Normal

1. 01:46:365 (5) - This slider should follow the vocals because the others objects of the pattern follow the vocals. So, reduce it by 1/2 ?I use slider tick to follow the vocals 1/2 before I end and there is vocals also when I stop
2. 02:41:615 (3) - There is nothing in the music which justify this 1/4, extand it by 1/4 would be more appropriate.Umm the main guitar is undoubtedly enough to justify the 1/4 usage here.
3. 02:46:615 (1) - This slider seems a bit early due to the vocals which start 1/4 later. I think you have to change this pattern, maybe to something like this ? :The whole thing with that is to be like how it was before the chorus and 01:26:615 (1,2,3), I think it would be weird if I changed it into something else.
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 03:24:615 (1,2,3,1,2) - Why have you stop to add clap here, that breaks the rhythm.Woops my mistake

That's all, good luck to rank it with these sliderspeeds xD