• 
  [Normal]
  00:47:349 (1,3) - mb make it identical, but flipped horizontally, no?
  01:37:837 (1,4) - The slider, which is bent upwards appears again, mb flip vertycally the second slider?
  [Hard]
  00:47:349 (1,2,3,4) - jump looks some strange, mb make these 00:48:081 (3,4) - closer?
  01:26:861 (1,2) - fix blanket
  01:55:397 (1,2) - I do not quite understand why there is more distance here than 01:57:593 (4,5) - here?
  02:01:983 (2,1) - mb fix blanket?

Pata-Mon wrote:

滑条身最好给个静音音效，这么安静的曲子现在这样有点吵

[normal]

1. 00:40:032 (3,4) - 用后面00:44:422 (3,1,2) - 同样节奏感觉更好
   
2. 00:42:959 (1,3) - 不太建议这种挨着的 三角排列
   
3. 00:51:739 - 这里vocal开始 用一个1/1折返会比较好
   
4. 01:44:422 (4) - 跟01:40:032 (3,4) - 一样拆开？
   
5. 03:05:641 (4,5) - ds大了
   
6. 03:34:178 (1) - 一般不要用多次折返

[Hard]

1. 00:39:300 (2,3) - 00:41:495 (2,3) - 第一个跟后面对比跳太大了．后面甚至没跳
   
2. 00:54:666 (4,5) - 滑条尾之间用00:53:934 (2,3,4) - 一样的ds吧
   
3. 01:01:983 (3,4) - 这里用了正常ds，但01:00:520 (1,2,3) - 前面都是跳了下的
   
4. 01:17:349 (5,1) - 这个应该要比01:15:886 (1,2,3,4) - 这种更值得跳
   
5. 03:03:995 (3) - 你整个图都没有放这种overmap，感觉不太有必要
   
6. 03:09:300 (3,1) - 可以稍微跳下

GL

PantyDev wrote:

Hello, i'm from modding queue(NM)
omg this song is so peaceful and beautiful!

• 
  [Normal]
  00:47:349 (1,3) - mb make it identical, but flipped horizontally, no?
  01:37:837 (1,4) - The slider, which is bent upwards appears again, mb flip vertycally the second slider?
  [Hard]
  00:47:349 (1,2,3,4) - jump looks some strange, mb make these 00:48:081 (3,4) - closer?
  01:26:861 (1,2) - fix blanket
  01:55:397 (1,2) - I do not quite understand why there is more distance here than 01:57:593 (4,5) - here?
  02:01:983 (2,1) - mb fix blanket?

Mod turned out to be too short, however I could not find any mistakes anymore , sry.

Kibbleru wrote:

wow, we on modding v1? damn 1 year ago map
My English Skill is poor, so may my reply has some problem with expressing; ;

general
i think you can add a drum hitsound for stuff like 01:13:691 - 01:18:081 - 01:37:837 - 01:38:568 - 01:40:032 - etc.. just whistle and finish is too simple imo.
I just want to make the hitsound simple to let the player who plays this map can enjoy the music, so I think it's ok, sorry; ;
hard
01:31:252 (1) - can u do circle + spinner? spinner start doesn't really give any emphasis
02:08:568 (1) - ^
01:44:422 (3) - can u make the first curve smoother?

SPOILER

02:21:556 - i would recommend a 1/8 repeat starting from here 02:21:739 - isn't really mapped to anything
All fixed

normal
01:51:007 (1) - 03:07:836 (1) - 03:21:007 (1) - these spinners suck, you're skipping over so many musical elements with them, and the vocals are always just going "haaaAaaAAAAaa" anyways so there's no point using a spinner here in particular. Please map them out

reply: At the time I mapped this map, I just want to make this map simple and clear to make the player can fully enjoy this beautiful music and this simple map.So I tried to make the map easier than other map. Already fixed.

for the one at 03:21:007 (1) - do something similar as hard diff please
fixed

Kibbleru wrote:

looks good. bubbled

edit: rebub over some minor stuff in hard

16:01 Sun Rainbow: 好
16:02 bossandy: Normal
16:03 Sun Rainbow: ok
16:03 bossandy: 00:52:471 (1) - Sounds a bit weird with no whistle hitsound 
16:03 bossandy: maybe add whistle at slider's end?
16:03 Sun Rainbow: fixed
16:03 bossandy: KK
16:03 Sun Rainbow: yep
16:03 Sun Rainbow: 01:00:520 (1,2,3) -
16:04 Sun Rainbow: add some whistle here
16:04 bossandy: Yap 
16:04 bossandy: That's waht I want to point xD
16:04 Sun Rainbow: 01:07:105 (3) -
16:04 Sun Rainbow: here too
16:04 Sun Rainbow: lol
16:04 bossandy: Sure
16:06 bossandy: 01:37:105 (1) - This sounds a bit odd to me , to follow the music better , I would like to delete this slider instead 
16:07 bossandy: 01:37:105 (1) - since this slider sounds like a 1/6 slider for me haha
16:07 Sun Rainbow: 01:37:105 (1) -  silder->note
16:07 bossandy: Oops 1/3 slider
16:08 Sun Rainbow: 1/4 maybe
16:08 Sun Rainbow: you can check it in hard at the same time lol
16:08 bossandy: Sure
16:08 Sun Rainbow: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10845949
16:08 bossandy: Yap , sounds better 
16:10 Sun Rainbow: ok owo~
16:10 Sun Rainbow: 01:41:495 (5) -  maybe i should add  a whistle here?
16:10 bossandy: 03:07:836 (1,2,3,4) - maybe some whistle here 
16:10 Sun Rainbow: It looks like i forget to add it ; ;
16:10 bossandy: yes
16:11 bossandy: add it ! 
16:11 Sun Rainbow: fixed 03:37:836 -
16:12 bossandy:   03:29:787 (1,2) - Maybe remove both whistle on the slider just leave the finish sounds?
16:12 bossandy: Sounds too strong imo
16:13 Sun Rainbow: remove whistle and make the volume here 13%
16:14 Sun Rainbow: 03:36:373 (1) -
16:14 Sun Rainbow: I added a finish here
16:14 bossandy: Well done
16:14 bossandy: Beautiful :D
16:14 bossandy: do the same thing in Hard too
16:14 Sun Rainbow: Thank you QuQ
16:15 bossandy: Hard~
16:15 Sun Rainbow: opened
16:15 bossandy: 01:09:300 (1) - Remove whistle like Normal?
16:16 bossandy: oh remove finish sorry
16:17 Sun Rainbow: fixed
16:17 bossandy: 01:37:105 (1,2) - 
16:17 bossandy: Try this
16:17 bossandy: https://imgur-archive.ppy.sh/qfh1Lv7.png
16:18 bossandy: Current ins't follow music well 
16:18 bossandy: imo
16:18 bossandy: try playback rate 25~50%
16:18 bossandy: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10845980
16:19 Sun Rainbow: It sounds more comfortable :O
16:19 Sun Rainbow: fixed
16:19 bossandy: :D
16:21 bossandy: OK
16:21 bossandy: Looks fine for me now
16:21 Sun Rainbow: o.o
16:22 Sun Rainbow: any problem or i update it now?
16:22 bossandy: Update it then I can recheck right away
16:22 bossandy: ohh
16:22 bossandy: wait
16:23 bossandy: Disable Countdown ?
16:23 bossandy: This song is soft and relax , I don't think u need it xD
16:24 Sun Rainbow: omg
16:24 Sun Rainbow: disabled
16:24 Sun Rainbow: thank you for noticing me that
16:25 bossandy: np , just some minor change , update it , I can check it right away!
16:26 Sun Rainbow: Maybe you should check my hitsound again cuz i added and remove some whitsle by my own
16:26 Sun Rainbow: ops
16:26 bossandy: OK
16:26 Sun Rainbow: I should restart my osu
16:26 Sun Rainbow: wait
16:26 bossandy: KK
16:28 Sun Rainbow: uploaded
16:29 bossandy: Do u have metadata prove that Rominazed title is "All In The Past" or "Ju Wang Yi"?
16:30 Sun Rainbow: The BG
16:30 bossandy: oh my
16:30 Sun Rainbow: BG is from official mv
16:30 bossandy: sorry xD 
16:30 Sun Rainbow: official mv screenshot
16:30 Sun Rainbow: lol
16:30 Sun Rainbow: dont mind xD
16:30 Sun Rainbow: There
16:31 Sun Rainbow: There's two rominazed title in BG
16:31 Sun Rainbow: but osu is a English-main game so I choose "All In The Past"
16:31 bossandy: I got it , it makes sense
16:31 Sun Rainbow: ok owo
16:34 Sun Rainbow: 02:59:056 (1) -
16:34 Sun Rainbow: I removed the whistle at this slider end
16:35 bossandy:  in Hard?
16:35 Sun Rainbow: yes
16:35 bossandy: OK!
16:36 Sun Rainbow: Thank you for understanding ; ;
16:38 bossandy: oh my
16:38 bossandy:  02:50:276 (1,1) - 
16:38 bossandy: Need more recovery time 
16:39 Sun Rainbow: 02:50:641 (1) -
16:39 bossandy: Same as 02:50:276 (1,1) - 
16:39 Sun Rainbow: I started it at there now
16:40 bossandy:  Screenshot to let me get that xD
16:40 Sun Rainbow: how about that
16:40 Sun Rainbow: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10846056
16:42 bossandy: I mean
16:42 bossandy: U need to leave more time between
16:42 bossandy: 02:50:276 (1,1) - 
16:43 Sun Rainbow: wait normal or hard or both?
16:43 bossandy: so that newbies have enough time to react the object after spinner
16:43 bossandy: Normal
16:43 Sun Rainbow: Oh
16:43 bossandy: 02:50:276 (1) - 
16:43 Sun Rainbow: I fixed it at hard /.\
16:43 bossandy: xD
16:43 bossandy: End this spinner
16:43 bossandy: 02:50:276 (1) - 
16:43 bossandy: here 02:52:471 - 
16:44 Sun Rainbow: fixed!
16:44 bossandy: 1 stanza time 
16:44 bossandy: Yeahhh
16:44 Sun Rainbow: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10846073
16:44 bossandy: yes!
16:45 Sun Rainbow: owo fixed and any other problem?
16:45 bossandy: 03:25:397 (1,1) - 
16:45 bossandy: also here
16:45 bossandy: end here 03:27:592 - 
16:45 bossandy: probably
16:45 Sun Rainbow: 03:27:592 - end at here
16:45 Sun Rainbow: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10846078
16:45 bossandy: Tap
16:45 bossandy: Yap
16:46 Sun Rainbow: and I added a whistle
16:46 bossandy:  Sure
16:46 bossandy: OK
16:46 bossandy: Looks fine now 
16:46 bossandy: update again xD
16:47 Sun Rainbow: updated
16:48 bossandy: reDL
16:48 bossandy: 02:08:568 (1) - 
16:48 bossandy: D: 
16:48 bossandy: Normal 
16:48 bossandy: Finish
16:49 Sun Rainbow: omg D:
16:49 Sun Rainbow: fixed
16:49 Sun Rainbow: QAQ
16:49 bossandy: OKKKK
16:49 bossandy: last update
16:51 Sun Rainbow: updated
16:51 bossandy: OK
16:51 bossandy: Everything looks fine for me 

• Discussion in game , changed some minor things below

1. Fixed two spinner to have more recovery time between spinner and next object
2. Added and remove some whistle and finish to make them more appropriate

bossandy wrote:

Chatlogs

16:01 Sun Rainbow: 好
16:02 bossandy: Normal
16:03 Sun Rainbow: ok
16:03 bossandy: 00:52:471 (1) - Sounds a bit weird with no whistle hitsound 
16:03 bossandy: maybe add whistle at slider's end?
16:03 Sun Rainbow: fixed
16:03 bossandy: KK
16:03 Sun Rainbow: yep
16:03 Sun Rainbow: 01:00:520 (1,2,3) -
16:04 Sun Rainbow: add some whistle here
16:04 bossandy: Yap 
16:04 bossandy: That's waht I want to point xD
16:04 Sun Rainbow: 01:07:105 (3) -
16:04 Sun Rainbow: here too
16:04 Sun Rainbow: lol
16:04 bossandy: Sure
16:06 bossandy: 01:37:105 (1) - This sounds a bit odd to me , to follow the music better , I would like to delete this slider instead 
16:07 bossandy: 01:37:105 (1) - since this slider sounds like a 1/6 slider for me haha
16:07 Sun Rainbow: 01:37:105 (1) -  silder->note
16:07 bossandy: Oops 1/3 slider
16:08 Sun Rainbow: 1/4 maybe
16:08 Sun Rainbow: you can check it in hard at the same time lol
16:08 bossandy: Sure
16:08 Sun Rainbow: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10845949
16:08 bossandy: Yap , sounds better 
16:10 Sun Rainbow: ok owo~
16:10 Sun Rainbow: 01:41:495 (5) -  maybe i should add  a whistle here?
16:10 bossandy: 03:07:836 (1,2,3,4) - maybe some whistle here 
16:10 Sun Rainbow: It looks like i forget to add it ; ;
16:10 bossandy: yes
16:11 bossandy: add it ! 
16:11 Sun Rainbow: fixed 03:37:836 -
16:12 bossandy:   03:29:787 (1,2) - Maybe remove both whistle on the slider just leave the finish sounds?
16:12 bossandy: Sounds too strong imo
16:13 Sun Rainbow: remove whistle and make the volume here 13%
16:14 Sun Rainbow: 03:36:373 (1) -
16:14 Sun Rainbow: I added a finish here
16:14 bossandy: Well done
16:14 bossandy: Beautiful :D
16:14 bossandy: do the same thing in Hard too
16:14 Sun Rainbow: Thank you QuQ
16:15 bossandy: Hard~
16:15 Sun Rainbow: opened
16:15 bossandy: 01:09:300 (1) - Remove whistle like Normal?
16:16 bossandy: oh remove finish sorry
16:17 Sun Rainbow: fixed
16:17 bossandy: 01:37:105 (1,2) - 
16:17 bossandy: Try this
16:17 bossandy: https://imgur-archive.ppy.sh/qfh1Lv7.png
16:18 bossandy: Current ins't follow music well 
16:18 bossandy: imo
16:18 bossandy: try playback rate 25~50%
16:18 bossandy: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10845980
16:19 Sun Rainbow: It sounds more comfortable :O
16:19 Sun Rainbow: fixed
16:19 bossandy: :D
16:21 bossandy: OK
16:21 bossandy: Looks fine for me now
16:21 Sun Rainbow: o.o
16:22 Sun Rainbow: any problem or i update it now?
16:22 bossandy: Update it then I can recheck right away
16:22 bossandy: ohh
16:22 bossandy: wait
16:23 bossandy: Disable Countdown ?
16:23 bossandy: This song is soft and relax , I don't think u need it xD
16:24 Sun Rainbow: omg
16:24 Sun Rainbow: disabled
16:24 Sun Rainbow: thank you for noticing me that
16:25 bossandy: np , just some minor change , update it , I can check it right away!
16:26 Sun Rainbow: Maybe you should check my hitsound again cuz i added and remove some whitsle by my own
16:26 Sun Rainbow: ops
16:26 bossandy: OK
16:26 Sun Rainbow: I should restart my osu
16:26 Sun Rainbow: wait
16:26 bossandy: KK
16:28 Sun Rainbow: uploaded
16:29 bossandy: Do u have metadata prove that Rominazed title is "All In The Past" or "Ju Wang Yi"?
16:30 Sun Rainbow: The BG
16:30 bossandy: oh my
16:30 Sun Rainbow: BG is from official mv
16:30 bossandy: sorry xD 
16:30 Sun Rainbow: official mv screenshot
16:30 Sun Rainbow: lol
16:30 Sun Rainbow: dont mind xD
16:30 Sun Rainbow: There
16:31 Sun Rainbow: There's two rominazed title in BG
16:31 Sun Rainbow: but osu is a English-main game so I choose "All In The Past"
16:31 bossandy: I got it , it makes sense
16:31 Sun Rainbow: ok owo
16:34 Sun Rainbow: 02:59:056 (1) -
16:34 Sun Rainbow: I removed the whistle at this slider end
16:35 bossandy:  in Hard?
16:35 Sun Rainbow: yes
16:35 bossandy: OK!
16:36 Sun Rainbow: Thank you for understanding ; ;
16:38 bossandy: oh my
16:38 bossandy:  02:50:276 (1,1) - 
16:38 bossandy: Need more recovery time 
16:39 Sun Rainbow: 02:50:641 (1) -
16:39 bossandy: Same as 02:50:276 (1,1) - 
16:39 Sun Rainbow: I started it at there now
16:40 bossandy:  Screenshot to let me get that xD
16:40 Sun Rainbow: how about that
16:40 Sun Rainbow: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10846056
16:42 bossandy: I mean
16:42 bossandy: U need to leave more time between
16:42 bossandy: 02:50:276 (1,1) - 
16:43 Sun Rainbow: wait normal or hard or both?
16:43 bossandy: so that newbies have enough time to react the object after spinner
16:43 bossandy: Normal
16:43 Sun Rainbow: Oh
16:43 bossandy: 02:50:276 (1) - 
16:43 Sun Rainbow: I fixed it at hard /.\
16:43 bossandy: xD
16:43 bossandy: End this spinner
16:43 bossandy: 02:50:276 (1) - 
16:43 bossandy: here 02:52:471 - 
16:44 Sun Rainbow: fixed!
16:44 bossandy: 1 stanza time 
16:44 bossandy: Yeahhh
16:44 Sun Rainbow: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10846073
16:44 bossandy: yes!
16:45 Sun Rainbow: owo fixed and any other problem?
16:45 bossandy: 03:25:397 (1,1) - 
16:45 bossandy: also here
16:45 bossandy: end here 03:27:592 - 
16:45 bossandy: probably
16:45 Sun Rainbow: 03:27:592 - end at here
16:45 Sun Rainbow: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10846078
16:45 bossandy: Tap
16:45 bossandy: Yap
16:46 Sun Rainbow: and I added a whistle
16:46 bossandy:  Sure
16:46 bossandy: OK
16:46 bossandy: Looks fine now 
16:46 bossandy: update again xD
16:47 Sun Rainbow: updated
16:48 bossandy: reDL
16:48 bossandy: 02:08:568 (1) - 
16:48 bossandy: D: 
16:48 bossandy: Normal 
16:48 bossandy: Finish
16:49 Sun Rainbow: omg D:
16:49 Sun Rainbow: fixed
16:49 Sun Rainbow: QAQ
16:49 bossandy: OKKKK
16:49 bossandy: last update
16:51 Sun Rainbow: updated
16:51 bossandy: OK
16:51 bossandy: Everything looks fine for me 

• Discussion in game , changed some minor things below

1. Fixed two spinner to have more recovery time between spinner and next object
2. Added and remove some whistle and finish to make them more appropriate

And everything looks fine for me , I don't think these minor things need a rebubble... so...
Qualified

Lanturn wrote:

A map must wait at least 24 hours since the first bubble before it can be qualified. Please call back your BNs and restart the nomination process again.

Amamiya Kanade wrote:

so this rule is too stupid

bossandy wrote:

Amamiya Kanade wrote:

so this rule is too stupid

If this rule needs to be discussed, it will be reviewed.
Before the review is over.
Rules still need to be followed.
My bad , Sorry Sun Rainbow

Lanturn wrote:

Talked with other QATs and reverting this back to its bubbled state. bossandy can qualify this map 24 hours from when p/6604436 was posted which should be shortly.

Sorry for the inconvenience on my end.

Amamiya Kanade wrote:

so this rule is too stupid

Ascendance wrote:

Amamiya Kanade wrote:

so this rule is too stupid

Rules are rules whether you find them stupid or not. The purpose of the rule is for people to be able to potentially find last minute issues before the map hits qualified. If you believe that the rule is truly stupid, feel free to bring it up in the RC subforum with some reasoning and a potential fix!

bossandy wrote:

Sorry for late and my mistake again... I am a bit busy these day , here it is !

RaiFel wrote:

I would like to download music to the player, but I can not find it. Could you drop the link to download this music?

RaiFel wrote:

Thank you.