Please pardon me for replying to you only after a year.
Bubblun wrote:
nm
Posthumous
00:04:421 (1,2,1,2) - The flow of the sliders contradicts how the player would actually play them. I think a pattern like https://puu.sh/wFwJ5/4f3d2002ec.png would work better, except cleaner. 00:04:421 (1) - points towards the following slider so I think it is fine.
00:07:037 (4,1) - These are slightly off. They are not?
00:18:575 (1) - Because of the way this pattern flows the player can't hit this. It's also hidden under the mess of follow circles. You could move the slider head out more so it's visible. I understand that this slider is very hard to hit, but I put it here because of 'suddenness' of the sound.
01:14:421 (1) - This slider is too quick to move the player upwards, so the direction really doesn't matter except it'd play better if the head was under the previous slider. ok I slowed it down
03:26:575 (2,1) - 1 is slightly off center. ok!
Regou's Extra
00:46:113 (1,2,3) - The blanket the triplet forms is slightly off. I will leave it to Regou
Kloyd's Extra
Check aimod for some snapping issues. ok
02:23:344 (3,4,5) - This pattern seems randomly placed as there's no correlation to the previous slider or the next. I had something like https://puu.sh/wFxDt/cf8a8c2bdb.png in mind. I cannot see the hyperlink is dead now after half a year :<
03:12:729 (3,4,1,2,3) - This rhythm seems incorrect. I'd remove 3 and use sv to extend 2 or try I think it is fine
03:18:267 (1,1) - I can't tell what the intent with this was, so I personally think this would look better as a curved slider. I believe the intent is to match the vocal and 03:19:190 (1) -
03:19:959 (4,5,6,2) - You could space these out more, as the overlap seems random. OK
03:35:959 (4,5,6) - lol this looks kinda funny. Doesn't cause any issues but it could look better as a stream or triplet. I personally find it ok
Drop's Extra
00:15:498 (1,1,1) - For these minor fluctuations in rhythm I'd hitsound these. ok
00:17:344 - For the 1/8 stream you don't have to silence the ends, but they do need to get toned down a bit as atm they sound obnoxious. they sound the same as Posthumous and I personally find no problem with the hitsound in the pattern
00:46:267 (5) - Blanket's slightly off. I think Drop does not intend to blanket this slider with (5). (5) is a slider too flowy to manifest the intention of blanketing the next.
yf's Insane
01:38:575 (1) - There's too much background noise to use this idea. I'd shorten it to the 1/4 tick and place a circle. This choice of rhythm is indeed unusual, I however find it fitting as yf has been following the vocal.
Hyper
03:26:882 (1,2,3) - Triangle is off. I don't intend to arrange these circles to form a triangle. Actually it looks better in my opinion to leave it like this
Hard
aimond's showing snapping issues. I am ashamed of myself done
02:06:575 (3) - The automatic stacking mechanic didn't place this right, so you might need to move it. OK
Normal
00:56:729 (3) - Blanket is slightly off. ok
Nothing else to say except why not apply Hard's kiai format on Normal? Out of all the diffs they're the most similar when it comes to ideas.
Easy
00:05:037 (1,2) - These are slightly off from being parallel. they are perfectly parallel: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10558817
04:01:344 (1,1) - ^ OK
gl