forum

Report a Qualified beatmap here!

posted
Total Posts
2,851
show more
Hollow Delta
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/736560/d ... generalAll

Marathon map that drops in difficulty and lacks variety of gameplay mechanics / elements which I feel could make the map more engaging.
pimp
Kuron-kun
^ might also be worth rechecking the lyrics as they might seem to be really inappropriate due to explicit suicide/self-harm and some explicit sexual content (sexual content might be minor, tho).
Gordon123
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/725851

he want add to tags : "Madison alternative Techno Trance"

http://www.dancingastronaut.com/2017/11 ... -spitfire/
Abraxos
p/6526421/

incorrect timing
CXu
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/736560

I posted this over on reddit but I figured I'd post it here too. It's not really a quality issue, and you might've already discussed this before the first dq of the map, but anyway, here's what I posted over there:
I don't really care too much about the pp mapping drama and all that, but it should be named "pp compilation" or something along those lines, and not "songs compilation". If you look at previous compilations https://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmaplist?q=compilation, they all have a theme that makes the songs in the compilation related, be it an anime series, artist or a game mechanic (stream compilation). Except https://osu.ppy.sh/s/343728 lol. Right now the title is non-descriptive and the songs in the compilation don't have any obvious connection other than that they've been popular in osu! due to maps accompanying those songs giving pp.

I guess the question is if people should really be allowed to create arbitrary compilations of songs and just call it "songs compilation", or if compilations should require some kind of theme that connects the songs to each other (which in this case would be pp)

Also, being honest about what it is is better than just calling it some generic "songs compilation", but yeah.
What I'd like is at least some kind of stance on if arbitrary compilations of songs should be allowed, or if it should be required that there is some connection between them?
Imo allowing this map to be titled as it is, just named "Various Artists - Songs Compilation" with seemingly unrelated songs (although in this case it's not exactly a secret what their relation is) would allow i.e. me to just take my graveyard 1 diff maps, put all the songs in a compilation and just rank them like that, circumventing any requirement for spread.

And additionally, the song title really should be related to the audio track, not to the contents of the map, or the lack thereof. The map was disqualified because it took the whole "pp mapping" thing too far, but the title still perfectly describes the songs used in the compilation, and at least I think it should be called that regardless of if the map actually gave pp or not.

As for why I posted it here, I think someone posted it on the map and it was just marked as resolved by sotarks so I dunno what the process would be in that case.

Edit: I'm dumb and didn't look in the ranking criteria subforums.
supersofttomboy
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/655495

weird timing of hitobject on 00:15:995 on [Normal] [1112's Hard]

missing hitsound on 01:12:243 (2) on [1112's Hard]

also requesting for some improvements from creator
VINXIS
Monstrata
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/707380

Kalibe is not in tags even though he's a gd'er.
ktgster
Secre
p/6532281

many problems regarding the CTB difficulty
nextplay
uhh
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/733581
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/729046
Both are qualifed
Both are std
Both are the same Length
TheKingHenry
p/6534762/
Timing issues
Myxo
p/6535321
invisible slider ticks on beginner, not hitsounded section on muya's
MaridiuS
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/736560/d ... al#/144782

Map has room for improvements in terms of song expression other than a few contradictions and inconsistencies.
Mir
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/713347

lack of contrast and hitsounding improvement could be done
Kuron-kun
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/699749
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/699749/d ... al#/144850

A lot of reading issues, overlaps and non-intuitive flow.
Mir
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/673949#osu/1426164

lack of contrast and gd insane has some questionable consistency in those star sliders
Mir
p/6535424#p6535424

rhythm is kinda lacking overall, could use more work in that regard and some emphasis issues as a result of structure on the topdiff
Mir
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/724883

hitsounding seems really inconsistent.. could use looking over

(mao requested i post here btw...)
squirrelpascals
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/715088/d ... al#/145017

uses a circles-only concept that doesn't accurately reflect the music, and feels pretty spontaneous. Makes the rhythm feel lackluster compared to other parts of the map. Also noted some slidertick volume changes that can be improved.
Kin
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/690966/d ... 22/general

intensity problem in Inner Oni

✓ by Raiden
Lasse
p/6530742

bpm should be halved, unfitting rhythm usage on top diff, weird difficulty settings on lower diffs
Kuron-kun
Kuron-kun
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/718016#osu/1570479

short recovery time in Easy and silenced circle in higher diff
-Mo-
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/708478

1/2 slider over a 1/3 rhythm in Easy. Plus some minor quality things.
Chromoxx
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/700384

inappropriate use of slider velocity

✓ by pishifat
Aurele
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/6535920

Mappers willing to change things based off suggestions on their respective difficulties.

✓ by Mao
Mao
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/699588/discussion/1481914/general/pending

stiff movement due to very low sv, wide angles and huge spacing on highest diff
MBomb
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/694107/discussion

Emphasis issues as well as some consistency issues that stand out quite a bit. Also, a few recommendations to get rid of silence in the mp3, to make breaks less tedious.

(Only 1/3rd of the map has been checked, rest can be checked later on, posting now due to how close to ranked the set is).

✓ by Deif
Myxo
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/732994/discussion/-/generalAll#/146547

various smaller things that add up (missing hitsounds in many of the diffs, low hitsound volume, weird 1/1-gaps in insane, out of place pattern in mir's)

✓ by Mao
I Must Decrease
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/736560/discussion/1554502/general#/146254

There are plenty of points made about this maps construction and obvious purpose. An active discussion is underway and I believe it would be appropriate to DQ so that the mapper may be more willing to cooperate rather than blindly refusing all points to avoid DQ. In general the map specifically avoids all "difficult" rhythms of 1/4 even though for a map of this difficulty that seems highly inappropriate. I understand it's subjective but flat out ignoring a large component of the game (streaming) where there are clear points in which the songs not only support it but are built for it seems highly inappropriate. There are a couple specific points I mentioned where the mapper simply uses 1/4th roll over for rhythms that are far more intricate than simple passive rhythm.

Lets make mapping great again! :D

As a side note I would also like to also share this image where Sotarks deliberately tells me that he will not change anything no matter what I say. This seems pretty counter productive considering the purpose of qualified is for maps to be given a chance for community feedback and goes against the code of conduct.

https://puu.sh/zGQQo/80bf9ea84b.jpg




Since I cant post a second time I'll just do it here:

https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/725171/discussion/1541573/general#/146173

The usage of an 85 note combo cannot be left up to a community to discuss. I'm simply asking for clarification on this as I want to make sure that it's not something simply being overlooked and that osu! will allow such a rational in the future for all maps. Please consider at least addressing this formally QAT, thank you.
DeRandom Otaku
Nozhomi
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/737714#osu/1556943
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/737714/discussion/1562274/timeline#/138950

Diffspike, making spread with Hard questionable, in addition with some wrong emphasis on last diff + difficult rhythm on lower diff.
MBomb
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/694025/discussion/1468430/

Quite a few comments on how general emphasis can be improved consistency wise.
Kuron-kun
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/6537046#p6537046

really overmapped rhythm in expert, some inconsistencies with spacing and emphasis issues

✓ by Myxomatosis
Kibbleru
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/680812

00:32:250 - oddly inconsistent rhythm
01:00:107 (2) - 01:16:920 (8) - really poorly done overmapping
Surono
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/728885#osu/1554749

taiko
lack of variation, full of copypasta well saw some small variation tho still feels dull, im okay with this
barlines issues
and 1 inconsistent note on muzu
Kuron-kun
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/740043/discussion/1561320/timeline#/147507

wrongly snapped slider (1/16) and some spacing suggestions
Namki
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/6537854
SB went wrong, missing hitsounds and few quality issues for the top diff
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply