juan tells me he still wants to take the bubble but he has his finals until Monday, so I'll just impart my general thoughts and whatnot for the time being.
Star Rating is completely useless for this kind of thing. You did express a concern about the spread I believe but I don't think the problem is where you think it is. In my opinion, the main problem is the gap between NM and HD; since HD also contains SVs, there's too much of a jump between the two because of how heavy the SVs are.
My suggestion would be to nerf the SVs in HD a fair bit since they appear to be identical to MX right now. Try to make them all normalised here if you can.
I'll be looking forward to checking this, so let me know whenever that first icon comes through, just so things don't get that messy. Pretty sure Garalulu is also interested as well, so there's that. (or just call me back if everything else falls apart)
And stop trying to downplay that this was featured in mwc lol. That's a big thing xd
Star Rating is completely useless for this kind of thing. You did express a concern about the spread I believe but I don't think the problem is where you think it is. In my opinion, the main problem is the gap between NM and HD; since HD also contains SVs, there's too much of a jump between the two because of how heavy the SVs are.
My suggestion would be to nerf the SVs in HD a fair bit since they appear to be identical to MX right now. Try to make them all normalised here if you can.
[General]
Just a couple of reminders:
Could have kiai I reckon. It sounds like there are sections where it would fit.
soft-hitfinish.wav is a little too quiet relatively imo. Might want to increase its volume with audio-editing software.
Tags: Remove everything that appears elsewhere in the metadata (like sakuraburst since that's in the title). When searching for tags it isn't case sensitive, so duplicates can be removed. Not sure about SV in tags but I think you're okay. (just once though lol)
Just a couple of reminders:
- If you don't use a hitsound, there's no need to put it in the folder. (Remove soft-hitwhistle)
- The editor can only set ODHP values to one decimal place. (Editing the .osu for something you can't do in the editor is not allowed.)
- Rankable SV values are between 0.1x and 10x. (Due to how the client interprets SVs outside of these values, i.e. they're not the value they say they are)
Could have kiai I reckon. It sounds like there are sections where it would fit.
soft-hitfinish.wav is a little too quiet relatively imo. Might want to increase its volume with audio-editing software.
Tags: Remove everything that appears elsewhere in the metadata (like sakuraburst since that's in the title). When searching for tags it isn't case sensitive, so duplicates can be removed. Not sure about SV in tags but I think you're okay. (just once though lol)
I'll be looking forward to checking this, so let me know whenever that first icon comes through, just so things don't get that messy. Pretty sure Garalulu is also interested as well, so there's that. (or just call me back if everything else falls apart)
And stop trying to downplay that this was featured in mwc lol. That's a big thing xd