not boasting but im p sure i’m better at timing than many pplelie520 wrote:
Hello,
Thank you for your answer
While what you're saying might be true on some songs, it's almost impossible for a musician to keep a beat to the 1/100 second for 5 minutes. Especially in classical music or any kind of music with "respiration".
The thing is that almost all maps I looked at with the editor were mapped as you say, and the result is pretty terrible. If you play the song in the timing section, with a computer beep every beat, it never matches almost. That's why in a LOT of maps, it's almost impossible to have an UR less than 100/120 in HD (that is when you base your clicks on what you hear), and completely impossible to go lower than 80 for example.
I really mean no disrespect, but looking at your profile, I don't think you're according that much importance to the precision of the ticks. This is fine, everyone focusses on different aspects of the game.
Thanks
Edit: Btw, I'm trying to map a music played by an orchestra, that's why tempo varies a lot, sometimes voluntarily, sometimes not.
You should said earlier youre timing a orchestra! saves a lot of misunderstanding
also, sometimes the timing may not be 100% accurate, but that’s ok. You won’t notice when playing (unless the timing is very bad)
there’s also those offbeat timing lo
5 minute song, only having 50bpm changes? for a classial music perhaps that’s not enough lolelie520 wrote:
Thanks for your answer.
Indeed, you'd still have to count the number of notes, but that's a constant once you have it (and takes one listening with paper to take notes as the song progresses). However, if you change offset to a beat point by 10ms, the bpm before and after both change, and have to recompute both of them. In a 5 minute song, I have about 50 bpm changes, and what takes me the most time is to recompute bpm every 30 seconds to ensure that I set the starting note and the end note right.
You're pretty wrong about the BPM changes, because players play maps a lot when they want to train on it, or just love it. When you heard an interpretation a thousand times, you know the fluctuations, for sure.
Yes, and if the feature I'm asking was implemented, the composer of that said beatmap would have been pleased, I'm sure.
btw I’d fucking love to see a feature that do the timing for you, but variable... thats hard