#modreqs yay
I'm also mapping this song. Can I steal your metadata? It's more accurate than what I have tbh.
Overall it's a good map! Good luck with this.~
I'm also mapping this song. Can I steal your metadata? It's more accurate than what I have tbh.
Niahm
[Niahm]
- 00:40:526 (4) - Do you not wanna emphasize that really noticeable chime? Even just changing the flow of this slider could emphasize that sound well.
- 00:50:254 - There should be a note here if you plan to map this 1/4.
- 01:07:072 (6,7) - Could make this a 1/4 slider to get the guitar and the cymbals I think it is as two seperate sounds. Or rather, two sounds that while the same timing are played differently because they're different sounds. I hope this makes sense.
- 02:03:435 (1) - You don't really need this new combo. Since there's no SV change. If anything you'd want to NC 02:04:163 (5) - instead.
- 02:04:708 - This particular sound, uh.. flute I think? Is consistently being skipped. I don't know why tbh, since there isn't a sound on 02:04:799 - at all. It would make more sense rhythmically if you shortened these sliders to the red tick. This is for all kiais of the same melody.
- 02:07:708 (4) - There is no sound here, so I don't see a reason for this triple.
- 02:12:890 (8,9,10,11) - I really have to listen hard to hear what this is mapped to. You can keep it, but I wouldn't map it, personally.
- 02:21:708 - There should be a note here too if you intend to map this to 1/4.
- 02:38:345 (1) - This played awkwardly for me; personally, I'd map this as two circles. It's up to you though - starting streams after a slider end on a blue tick is usually awkward.
- 02:39:163 (7) - No sound here and it plays awkwardly because of that. I didn't expect a triple, yet I got one. Also starting a triple after a 4 or 5 note burst is also really taxing on finger control, which I don't really think represents the song well. It's a pretty simple song to follow, so I don't think it should be mapped in a complex way. Just personal opinion though.
- 02:39:617 - Now you skip whatever this sound is (hi-hat?). It's not AS bad, but again 3/4 sliders play really weird here.
- 03:16:163 (6) - Maybe two circles to emphasize that high-pitched instrument. (if you haven't noticed by now I have no clue what instruments are which) Same with the other instances such as 03:20:526 (6).
- 03:22:890 (7) - There is super audible sound here that I think is worth mapping. Even more so since you're following the piano thing, which I feel would be better if you mapped it like so: You could shorten 03:22:526 (6) - by one tick and put a 1/2 slider at 03:22:708 - to capture all of the piano thing. In fact, you even did it at 03:31:254 (4,5) - so why not here too?
- 03:40:163 (8,9,10,11) - It's really hard to hear what this is mapped to as well, same as above but I can understand this one a little more because it fits with the hihat thing. I would still recommend removing it.
- 03:42:345 (6) - Two circles to emphasize the flute? Same with other cases like 02:15:072 (6).
- 03:52:890 - 03:53:254 - 03:53:435 - should definitely be clickable in my opinion. These are very noticeable sounds. You weren't against making 03:54:163 (2,3,4) - clickable so I don't see why not here.
- 04:01:254 (3,1) - These are pretty noticeable sounds yet I feel they're underemphasized. Even two 1/2 sliders would emphasize these sounds better.
- 04:19:254 (3,4,1) - This flow is kind of awkward. Moving linear from the slider end to 3 to 4 then a 3.74x 1/1 jump to 04:19:799 (1). It plays weird imo and a little bit overdone too.
- 04:30:435 (6) - This is unneeded, no sound here. Same with 04:39:163 (6) -
- 04:32:072 (5) - Is it just me or should this note be at 04:31:890 - and not where it is now?
- 04:34:890 (6) - There is no noticeable sound here. I suggest making 04:34:708 (5) - a 1/2 slider if you want to fill that gap. Same with 04:37:072 (7) -
- 04:54:163 (4,6) - I don't hear anything for these two notes.
- 04:58:526 (4) - + 1 reverse?
- 05:16:072 (3) - I don't hear anything here. Could remove.
- 05:22:890 (1) - This is a beautiful slider. \o/
Overall it's a good map! Good luck with this.~