Personally, I also like Kurochiie's work, and therefore they will be my vote.
Everyone has submitted some very nice work though, so I've given my opinions on each persons individually. I hope they are useful!XxCrystal
While the colours are nice, they don't really seem to fit well together when compared to the text. Personally, I don't feel as if the font choice fits very well with the theme of the image either... that's probably just me though.
Flanster
While you do maintain a constant theme, I feel as if your choice of image for Flandre could have been improved, for example, as it does look rather strange at the moment. However, that is entirely subjective, and it's not up for me to choose what images you use :p
With the text, while I can see that you've tried to make it so that it flows with the background, it doesn't really seem to have worked, in my honest opinion. As mentioned before, this could be avoided via a use of a different image, which would also help with the colour of the font, which in it's current state, is rather odd...
mina-
I must say, I like this one c:
The colours fit well with one another, the use of layers works well, for example, with the shadow on the render on the left. I like your choice of font and colour, as it fits well with the theme of the image, and the images above it work well too!
[ LemonAdd ]
The use of colour is rather nice, and fits well with the theme you've chosen. The font used is rather nice too, but looks a little strange with the text in the background, in my opinion.
juesus
The image choice is a nice one, but does remove the attention away from the text, especially with the colour you've used for it. It also does seem to clash with the girl a bit, but this could be fixed by moving her slightly to the left(?)
[Kamikazy]
wew.
The colouration is very nice, and the blurring around the edges is a nice touch, as it brings the focus onto the centre. Your choice of font is nice and fits well with the image choice. A very nice piece of work!
JayM3_
While you do maintain a constant theme, it does look rather odd at times, I must admit. For example, the "Yukari" over the image does clash a little. I'm not sure what the pink circle things are meant to be, but they do look a little strange, personally...
Kurochiie
wow.
The colours contrast and fit well with one another, and are really attractive. The highlights on various sections of the image work really well, and the whole image is very well made!
-Haise
Your theme is consistent throughout the image, but a few things could be improved. For example, the text on the left does look a little off, you could potentially blur this to maintain focus on the centre(?)
The girl herself is...uh...brighter than my future pretty bright, you should probably tone down a little on this imo haha
The text on the lower right is rather hard to read, especially towards the far-right, and therefore loses a bit of use there, in my opinion
Reunilu
I like your choice of image and layers. The colouration of them compliments the focus of the image. Overall, it looks nice!
- K a t h -
Again, a very nice use of colour. The font is appealing, and works well with the image. I really like the use of both the notebook effect and the film reel, they are both very aesthetic. The text is nice too, and again, works well with the effects you've used (like little scribbles imo haha).
-[Jess]-
This one is nice too. The shapes are very appealing, especially with how they fade out, such as on the left. The focus is kept on the centre of the image, and the text on the right is very nice as well!
You mentioned a while back about over-editing things, which I feel you do begin to enter here though... It isn't too much of an issue here though.