thx Namki
not gonna pop bubble or i should? since it's just NC issues and three circles at the startNamki wrote:
hello.
From my point of view, map isn't ready yet to go any further due to following reasons:Good luck~! Hope it gets ranked. thanks and good luck on your BN qualification if you are trying!
- According to the first few patterns you must not put whistles here 00:07:834 - and 00:08:285 - here. But you must put it here 00:08:736 - for sure.
And here 00:12:345 - / 00:15:954 - true- 00:19:413 (1,2,3,4,1) - as you picked loud hitsounding, consider doing HS volume a bit lower, ~50-55% for the sake of music audibility, because now I can't hear the music well. it's a preference, i'm ok with how it is now
- 00:30:089 (3) - as there is sound 00:30:240 - I suggest you to do a reverse instead for better music reflection. did same thing as here 00:40:916 (3,4,5) - everywhere, and yes 00:41:668 skipped intentionally
- Can't really get why have you put normal-whistles on these 00:48:056 - / 00:48:835 - / 00:49:606 - etc. piano sound doesn't really mean to have a whistle on it, some normal whistle would fit much better. i'll keep what i have, since it fits in my opinion
By the way, 00:50:394 (3,1,2) - normal-whistle for those is really fine.- Sounds here 00:52:049 - and 00:52:439 - are more intensive than here 00:52:244 - and 00:52:633 - and in that way it's sorta senseless to make triplet at less intense tick. i'm not really mapping this instrument, so i'll keep.
btw if i accept this i should redo whole part from 00:48:056 since i skip it most of the time, i don't know why you mention only those- You're doing acceleration for each of these 00:52:731 (1,2,3,4,1) - but not doing for these 00:53:705 (2,3,4) - but music keeps accelerating. Weird decision, tbh. Consider doing acceleration for each of 8 sliders. tried and didn't like it, i don't want sv here to be more then 1.3 and if i accelerate them by 0.5 its too weak for the music, doesn't fit at all, so i'll keep what i have
- 00:58:965 (1,2) - I'm really nor sure with these emphasized with NC sliders, looks random. its not random, but nc here 00:59:354 (1) - is wrong, removed
- 01:03:835 (1) - but here I'm 100% sure NC is unnecessary. Accroding to this pattern 00:54:289 (1,2) - . true, got fooled by stronger sounds
- 01:30:133 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - as you're emphasizing it by NC, it would be awesome if you change SV for better emphasize. i want sv to be somewhat same through map. i highlighted it with hitsounds, guess it's enough Also NC this 01:31:302 (1) - . true
- 01:33:250 (1,2,1,2,1) - as for it. It's totally meaningless NC smap, if 01:30:133 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - here was clear reason for NC, so here 01:33:250 (1,2,1,2,1) - no any reason, music does not change so far.
- 01:36:367 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - the same with SV change.
- 01:42:795 (6) - mhm, why not NCing this? why should i?
- 02:19:029 (1) - random NC. removed for consistency with other kiais, but it was here for design purposes
- 02:58:283 - badly undermapped stuff. There's a sound! Why skipping, tho. highlighted vocal ending and three sounds farther
- 03:34:808 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - as above.
- 04:38:510 - sound isn't really audible, stack fits better. i'm mapping this three to another instrument
These were the main (but not the all) issues I've noticed while watching the map. Some of these are repeating for the whole map, some not.