Hi, from queue.~
[ General]
[]
[ Farewell]
[ Celsius' Hard]
[ Shogun's Normal]
Lefia's diff is fine.
Good luck.~
[ General]
- Audio file is 128kbps. Don't you have a higher 192kbps version?
- On all diffs you can end the spinner at 01:31:807 (1) - on the white tick before it (still silenced) since it sounds slightly better imo.
[]
[ Farewell]
- 00:00:876 (1,2,3) - Visual spacing looks slightly off here. If you want to fix it move 3 up a bit. Also, the blanket with 1,2 is off: http://i.imgur.com/4foFt0D.png
- 00:05:348 (6) - So your new combos don't really make sense to me. I'd appreciate an explanation (which in itself me asking for an explanation kinda proves the point lol) of what they're following because atm it seems inconsistent. Check them all and maybe make a clearer theme that makes more sense to the player right off the bat.
- 00:12:242 (1,1) - I think stacking these would be better emphasis because the music is really sudden for these notes. That way you can force sudden movement. Also, your current placement could cause unfair misses due to how close 00:11:869 (1,1) - are. Yes, they're NC but it's not enough imo.
- 00:18:205 (1) - This slider ends on SUCH a strong note it hurts. I think you should make it a 1/2 slider + circle or something, but please make 00:18:577 - clickable somehow. Same with 01:28:267 (1).
- 00:39:633 (1,3) - Stack.
- 00:45:596 (1,2,3,4,5) - I kinda get it, but 00:45:969 (3,5) - get no emphasis because everything is stacked. Up to you though if you want to move them.
- 00:58:826 (1,2,3) - There's no triple in the song here, it's unnecessary to emphasize vocals too, just spacing is enough.
- 01:04:230 (3,4) - I don't really see a reason to stack these - nothing in the song to emphasize that stands out, and this just feels weird to play especially considering this whole jump section is flowy.
- 01:16:341 (5,1) - Stack the 5 on the head of 1 at least so this doesn't look so weird. It plays kinda awkward too, the slight movement for this strong note kills emphasis.
- 01:20:254 (2,3,1) - Visual spacing. Stack 01:20:441 (3,1) - or something because this can be misread.
[ Celsius' Hard]
- 00:02:366 (1,2) - If you intend to map the piano I don't really understand why 00:02:925 - is being skipped. You could add a circle here. It at least makes sense at 00:05:907 - because the piano gets drowned out by the rest of the ambiance.
- 00:14:851 (2,3) - You skip the triple here but map it at 00:13:174 (2,3,4) - and pretty much everywhere else in this section.
- 00:30:689 (1,2) - This is a pretty gutsy point, but I think is worth mentioning. I think this is poor rhythm choice. The piano is being skipped on the red at 00:31:248 - and the vocal starts here too. 00:31:435 - Isn't a particularly weak note either. Try this instead maybe?: http://i.imgur.com/7yaCZbX.png
- 00:34:975 - Intentionally skipping this vocal? The rest of this phrase was mapped so I don't see why it's skipped.
- 00:44:851 (3) - Shorten to blue tick? Why is it on a purple?
- 01:21:372 (1,3) - Possible blanket.
- 01:24:354 (1) - If this is following the vocal it should start on 01:24:167. 01:24:354 - Doesn't have a sound on it anyways either. Try http://i.imgur.com/rGSoCXo.png
[ Shogun's Normal]
I'm gonna be suggesting a lot of rhythm changes. You don't have to follow them exactly, but at least try them and see how you like them.
- 00:17:087 (2) - NC here I think, since it's much stronger than 00:16:714 (1). Same for cases like 00:23:049 (2) - but in the end, it's up to you.
- 00:24:726 (1,2) - Skips the vocal on the reds 00:25:658 - 00:26:031 - and since 00:26:217 (3,4,5) - is the same combo and follows vocals better this transition feels weird. I recommend maybe: http://i.imgur.com/gNmv5gu.png
- 00:31:248 - Skipped again? Try a circle here. Same at 00:33:484 - try making 00:33:298 (6) - a slider?
- 00:38:515 (5) - The strong held beat starts on this slider end and 00:39:074 (7) - skips the really noticeable drum. Try this or something similar: http://i.imgur.com/4ManxDo.png but those are some beats that are being poorly represented imo.
- 00:40:565 (3,4,5,6) - This rhythm also is kinda poor imo. You skip the long held note at 00:40:938 (4) - and the drum right in the middle of it. Try this or something similar: http://i.imgur.com/dsKt2go.png
- 00:52:677 (3,4) - Fix blanket?
- 00:57:894 (2,3) - This pause is a bit awkward especially when there's a sound at 00:58:267 - and the held vocal starts on 2's end.
- 01:01:435 (4) - Skips the vocal at 01:01:621 - and the strongest sound is on this slider end. Try this or something similar: http://i.imgur.com/noUwoUd.png Same deal as later in the kiai at 01:13:360 (4) -
- 01:19:509 (4) - Make this a slider maybe to catch that vocal? Still keep it stacked if you want.
Lefia's diff is fine.
Good luck.~