forum

Linkin Park - Guilty All The Same (feat. Rakim)

posted
Total Posts
130
Topic Starter
fieryrage
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on Wednesday, October 04, 2017 at 9:23:35 PM

Artist: Linkin Park
Title: Guilty All The Same (feat. Rakim)
Tags: marathon lp the hunting party nu metal alternative rap project spark
BPM: 200
Filesize: 6913kb
Play Time: 05:53
Difficulties Available:
  1. Shame (7.37 stars, 1495 notes)
Download: Linkin Park - Guilty All The Same (feat. Rakim)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
hello

mp3 and timing (extra ending timing help from pishifat) from 384059043's map of the song -- if you want easier diffs for this song, check it out!

hitsounds from pishifat's 115 map and my own skin

modders
squirrelpascals
direday
amamiya / ayachi nene
idke
pkk
riktoi
hightec
logic agent
davided
morgan
togetic
digitalhypno (kinda)
aeril
deppyforce
rad-
kaifin
vinxis
xilver
dunois
craezy
pishifat
foxygrandpa
p a n
renumi
ultima fox
dab
turquoise2
kroytz
squirrelpascals (second mod, bubble)
mir
hobbes2 (second bubble)
naotoshi
squirrelpascals (third mod, heart)

plus like a million self mods from me

thank you all for supporting and helping this map become what it is today; this is unarguably the one map i've spent the most time on trying to make as perfect as possible. i hope you enjoy it!

first bubble version if anyone really cares about that, it has bigger spacing on almost all jumps
Stoof
first
ConsumerOfBean

Stoof wrote:

first
second
also that ending is gr8 ;)
headphonewearer
Kreygasm
Zel
nice map homie :D
squirrelpascals
mOd 4 mOD

guilty all the sHame
• 00:04:590 - make it clickable? it sounds like you're mapping to the drums here idk

• 00:08:340 - idk why this slider is extended so long. Make this one clickable?

• 00:10:890 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - With the sliders going on to the jumps, it sounds like you're mapping to the guitar and immediatley start mapping to the drums. idk why you chose to do this if so.

• 00:27:840 (1,2,3) - account for this drum roll with a stream/ another slider?

• 00:55:890 (4,1) - more spacing here?

• 01:09:690 - put something here?

• 01:10:440 (1,2,3,4) - no

• 01:20:265 (2) - no beat here?

• 01:45:240 (1,2,3) - why is this spacing so uneven

• 02:22:440 (1) - why did you choose to make the reverse arrow like this?

• 02:27:465 - same, don't hear a beat here again :p

• 04:27:090 (1,2,3) - large jump after this is fine but i still dont understand what this particular spacing pattern is.

• 05:01:740 (1) - remove this nc? i'd save these patterns for the guitar at 05:02:040 -

• 05:05:340 (4,2) - slightly triggered by watching this in the editor

• 05:27:840 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - I don't hear notes under a lot of these triples or repeats. Same for 05:30:840 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) -

• 05:37:440 (1) - dont think thie repeats are necessary here

• 05:45:687 (7,8,1) - please move 1 to the left. At this speed this flow isprobably going to screw up a lot of ppl

• 05:51:805 - From here, same thing about the triples and repeats. I hear the guitar notes yes but it doesn't sound much at all like a 1/4 rhythm

Creative map. gl!
direday
Topic Starter
fieryrage
ya im trying 2 figure out how to fix it, worse comes to worse i'll have to resubmit

for now i'll just put the osz with the fully updated versions in description
Topic Starter
fieryrage

squirrelpascals wrote:

mOd 4 mOD Yea

guilty all the sHame
• 00:04:590 - make it clickable? it sounds like you're mapping to the drums here idk i was messing around with this beforehand, as the pattern stands rn it's pretty hard to make that last snare clickable so i didn't; will probably relook at pattern later

• 00:08:340 - idk why this slider is extended so long. Make this one clickable? agree

• 00:10:890 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - With the sliders going on to the jumps, it sounds like you're mapping to the guitar and immediatley start mapping to the drums. idk why you chose to do this if so. having sliders in the beginning was to introduce the new rhythm (ie faster than slower) rather than just immediately going to jumps, there were sliders here before but it felt out of place considering the drums were louder here (the guitar riff seems to be louder in the beginning but i might just be stupid)

• 00:27:840 (1,2,3) - account for this drum roll with a stream/ another slider? i actually didn't even know this was a five burst lol

• 00:55:890 (4,1) - more spacing here? made this flow into the next pattern a bit better, spacing increased slightly

• 01:09:690 - put something here? nothing in the rhythm to really warrant it here, guitar takes a break and so does drums

• 01:10:440 (1,2,3,4) - no ur mad

• 01:20:265 (2) - no beat here? yea, removed, will probably have to readjust pattern later

• 01:45:240 (1,2,3) - why is this spacing so uneven 01:45:690 (2) - snare drum which is more potent than 01:45:840 (3) - bass drum here, at least in my view

• 02:22:440 (1) - why did you choose to make the reverse arrow like this? because i'm pishi and i dont know how to make good slider

• 02:27:465 - same, don't hear a beat here again :p this one is an easier fix luckily

• 04:27:090 (1,2,3) - large jump after this is fine but i still dont understand what this particular spacing pattern is. these should be stacked actually

• 05:01:740 (1) - remove this nc? i'd save these patterns for the guitar at 05:02:040 - agree

• 05:05:340 (4,2) - slightly triggered by watching this in the editor Ur Mad

• 05:27:840 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - I don't hear notes under a lot of these triples or repeats. Same for 05:30:840 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - there's definitely 1/4 notes here, the guitar has a 1/4 pattern to it despite it being pretty quiet here

• 05:37:440 (1) - dont think thie repeats are necessary here guitar distortion

• 05:45:687 (7,8,1) - please move 1 to the left. At this speed this flow isprobably going to screw up a lot of ppl had some ppl testplay and from my recollection most people didn't break here, it was 05:46:726 (4,5,6,7,1) - the stream into a more spaced one here; i think this should be ok since it doesn't require much cursor movement as is rn

• 05:51:805 - From here, same thing about the triples and repeats. I hear the guitar notes yes but it doesn't sound much at all like a 1/4 rhythm it's the best rhythm you can find for this, honestly, else it'd be a cluster of 1/4 and 1/6 most likely

Creative map. gl! tyty
direday
Hello! Modding cause I like the song.

General

  • Nope, not working for me at least.
    Try this in order to fix the map:
  1. rename all the files manualy. Or at least .osu ones. My bet is that paranthesis "(feat. Rakim)" messes it up since "()" are used for uploaders' name.
  2. create new diff, delete the old one.
    Also Mod Assistant shows your diff's name like this. Sends an error when trying to open but opens anyway. So definetly smthing is up with the name of .osu file.
    If you end up resubmiting I'll throw some kudosu in your face since the map is worth it.

    Dunno if this is trustworthy 'cos errors but:
    Unused hitsounds:
    drum-slidertick.wav
    normal-slidertick.wav

SHAME on this PP mapping

  • JK. Map's lit af

    Ok, I can play it only with relax, but it's completely readable for me which is good sign.
  1. 00:04:440 (4) - place it a bit lower for followpoint to cross 00:03:690 (1) 's end right in the middle? I'd also rotate it to look like this
  2. 00:18:840 (1) - is not in line with stream but by such a small amount that it bugs me. Place it higher or in line?
  3. 00:33:690 (2,3) - this and all that you ctrl+c ctrl+v'ed are not in perfect line. You can check it by ctrl+g'ing the slider and looking at the followpoint
  4. 00:43:590 (3,4) - ^
  5. 00:54:690 (2) - this should be higher in order to follow 00:54:240 (1) 's curve. It will also space 00:54:690 (2) and 00:55:740 (3) - better
  6. 01:12:840 (1,2) - now this IS perfect line :3
  7. 01:20:940 (1) - place it lower to be in the middle of 01:20:340 (2) 's straight line?
  8. 01:21:690 (2,5) - not quite at the same place
  9. 01:37:740 (5) - yeaaah geometry nazi: end should be lower a bit. Use folowpoint as a guideline.
  10. 01:44:640 (3,4,5,6,7) - were those supposed to look at 01:45:240 (1) - end?
  11. 02:10:140 (6) - ctrl+j it and place at the same place? would look better imo
  12. 02:13:740 (2,1) - blanket's off
  13. 03:18:840 (1) - quaver flashbacks but this time it actually fits the song
  14. 04:06:690 (1) - place it to be the "cap" of 04:06:240 (3) - ? Like this
  15. 04:21:840 (4) - make it "look" at 04:21:540 (2,3) - ?
  16. 05:05:940 (2) - reduce SV by 0.03~ to place its end directly on top of 05:05:340 (4) - ?
  17. 05:17:490 (1) - its end is a bit off for perfect overlap
  18. Not a big fan of wacky sliders so consider making them more clean, like this one 05:38:340 (1). Just a suggestion.

    That's all I've found. Rythmically its good and I can't judge the DS.

Hope that helped.
Topic Starter
fieryrage
responding once home, but i will say in response to general:

i did end up renaming the bg and .osu file and updating it after, which apparently didn't fix the issue; the issue started once i tried resubmitting this after a name change, so it's probably something related to that
Ayachi Nene_old

GUILTY ALL THE SAME

  1. 00:39:765 (3) - I don't hear a triple.
  1. 04:24:240 (1,2,3) - Same as 04:23:040 (1) - so I don't know why you don't want to continue doing sliders to emphasize this.
idke
ok im gonna mod this when i get home

im gonna literally point out every donut slider there is while im at it so i dont get bored

prediction:37 donuts
Topic Starter
fieryrage
god dammti idke fucking posted his mod after i finsihed Dires
idke
00:03:690 (1,2,3,4) - rhythm gets fuked here badly im confused like
00:07:890 (1,2,3) - over here is fine

00:12:690 (1,2,3,4) - y does this jump get like 1.5x bigger when there is no difference in music good mapping

00:18:840 (1) - didnt i say something about this before
make repeat clickable cus ur completely skipping out on it

00:34:590 (1,2,1,2,1) - godtier copy paste

00:39:690 (2,3) - lower hitsounds maybe??? i didnt even think there were drums in the bg until i deleted notes

00:55:890 (4,1,2,3,4) - rhythm hear is at its climax but the pattern is actually smaller than the other jumps prior ????

01:01:740 (1,1) - this is weird since the slider is going in totally opposite directions fucking antijumps smh especially on slider??

01:11:040 (1,2,3,4) - wow square hahahahaah

01:23:640 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - only star maps like this please dont like this is an overusage of 1-2 like
maybe remove these 1-2s 01:24:840 (1,2,1,2,1,2) -

01:28:440 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - no reason for 1-2 to be here because it isnt accented like the kiais

02:07:740 (1) - are you going with lyrics or rhythm here because its like alternating between both so its really weird having sudden stops

02:09:090 (1) - remove full red tick slider please NEVER AGAIN

02:11:040 (3,4,5,6,1) - another example of confused beat/lyric transition because its the only time in which it doesnt use a repeat slider while everything else does

either make it consistent or like make it consistent, your choice, kiddo.

02:23:340 (1,1) - lower hitsounds on blue ticks a bit more

02:26:040 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - no reason for giant jumps or 1-2s here because it sounds completely normal not accented on every 1

02:34:440 (1) - remove nc and put 02:35:040 (3) - nc here because you had a break in between middle of combos like gj and because u did it everywhere else too like here 02:44:640 (1,2,3,4,5) -

02:47:040 (1,2,3) - im not too sure about kicksliders right here but yknow idfk get more ppl to complain here
and here 02:49:440 (1,2,3,4) -

maybe remove 03:04:440 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - 1-2s here to accent the bigger jump part because its way too consistent and feels very bland probably because of the jumps
because 03:09:240 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - right here i feel like its 100% fine even though its the same beat
so basically make the second half or first half of the 1-2s change patterns since its like the same thing

03:12:990 (2) - remove kickslider theres nothing on blue tick and its emphasizing nothing no excuses here or idk lmao

03:14:040 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - ok you're actually the worst fucking person
second half of all 1-2s are smaller even though they're supposed to be more accented so nerf first half of the patterns or buff the second half idk
fucking kys for using like 5 stacks in 1 whole rhythm

03:44:640 (1) - these donuts in the slow section are the only ones that makes sense in the entire song like lmao
also imo i think sv should be buffed a little but we'll see what other ppl say ya ok thanks

04:39:240 (1,2,1,2,1,2,3) - most accented part gets lower for no reason??/

04:44:640 (1,2,1,2) - this is the only time where i would ever say
wow a square fits here pretty nicely

04:52:440 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - is this copy pasted from the beginning wtf
if not its similar as hell like wtf

04:56:640 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - should accent the first 1-2 pattern and lower the second 1-2 pattern and so on
because it feels like its just jump practice as its not really accented
but the other 8 1-2s are pretty fine just stop using fucking polygon circles like GODDAMn

05:00:990 (2) - doesnt line up with 1

05:02:040 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - fuck your polygon circles and same emphasis problem as 3:14

05:29:640 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - uh

05:35:640 (1) - de
05:36:090 (2) - le
05:36:540 (1) - te
05:37:440 (1) - th
05:37:890 (3,1) - is

05:45:762 (8,1) - awful transition

total donut count: 36

i was pretty close actually but i may have miscounted

Thanks For The Mod1!!! :) :) :) :) :) :D :D ;)
Topic Starter
fieryrage
idke

[Toy]s our boy wrote:

00:03:690 (1,2,3,4) - rhythm gets fuked here badly im confused like ok fucks sake i aded a note on the red tick
00:07:890 (1,2,3) - over here is fine

00:12:690 (1,2,3,4) - y does this jump get like 1.5x bigger when there is no difference in music good mapping cuz u fucking told me to make thes not sliders retar reduced spacing

00:18:840 (1) - didnt i say something about this before
make repeat clickable cus ur completely skipping out on it will consider but this isnt really meant to be clickable, the beginning of the slider is supposed to follow the piano which is what the rest of the sliders in this section are doing so ya

00:34:590 (1,2,1,2,1) - godtier copy paste im embracing pishi mapping at its fullest

00:39:690 (2,3) - lower hitsounds maybe??? i didnt even think there were drums in the bg until i deleted notes amamiya pointed this out as well but idk i think the triple stands out pretty clearly regardless of hitsounding

00:55:890 (4,1,2,3,4) - rhythm hear is at its climax but the pattern is actually smaller than the other jumps prior ???? spaced out more

01:01:740 (1,1) - this is weird since the slider is going in totally opposite directions fucking antijumps smh especially on slider?? this isnt even that weird compared to the stupid shit i do later r u high

01:11:040 (1,2,3,4) - wow square hahahahaah Blue Dragon

01:23:640 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - only star maps like this please dont like this is an overusage of 1-2 like
maybe remove these 1-2s 01:24:840 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - removing the ncs here make the follow points look ugly as hell

01:28:440 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - no reason for 1-2 to be here because it isnt accented like the kiais yea

02:07:740 (1) - are you going with lyrics or rhythm here because its like alternating between both so its really weird having sudden stops stops are here to introduce rhythm at first, it maps to both later on

02:09:090 (1) - remove full red tick slider please NEVER AGAIN agree

02:11:040 (3,4,5,6,1) - another example of confused beat/lyric transition because its the only time in which it doesnt use a repeat slider while everything else does i think i just made this even worse

either make it consistent or like make it consistent, your choice, kiddo.

02:23:340 (1,1) - lower hitsounds on blue ticks a bit more 5% is the lowest they can go lolz

02:26:040 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - no reason for giant jumps or 1-2s here because it sounds completely normal not accented on every 1 yea

02:34:440 (1) - remove nc and put 02:35:040 (3) - nc here because you had a break in between middle of combos like gj and because u did it everywhere else too like here 02:44:640 (1,2,3,4,5) -

02:47:040 (1,2,3) - im not too sure about kicksliders right here but yknow idfk get more ppl to complain here
and here 02:49:440 (1,2,3,4) - ok will do

maybe remove 03:04:440 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - 1-2s here to accent the bigger jump part because its way too consistent and feels very bland probably because of the jumps
because 03:09:240 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - right here i feel like its 100% fine even though its the same beat
so basically make the second half or first half of the 1-2s change patterns since its like the same thing was considering remapping this as it is, if another person complains ill remove and remap

03:12:990 (2) - remove kickslider theres nothing on blue tick and its emphasizing nothing no excuses here or idk lmao when u try mapping triples to spice up ur map and u get shit on for it but the ranked one has a shitload of triples landing on nothing

03:14:040 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - ok you're actually the worst fucking person
second half of all 1-2s are smaller even though they're supposed to be more accented so nerf first half of the patterns or buff the second half idk
fucking kys for using like 5 stacks in 1 whole rhythm honestly its hard to make a jump pattern without having symmetry like this cuz the first jump pattern was like the only one without symmetry and its aids

03:44:640 (1) - these donuts in the slow section are the only ones that makes sense in the entire song like lmao
also imo i think sv should be buffed a little but we'll see what other ppl say ya ok thanks it used to be higher but then i realized it played like shit so i didnt

04:39:240 (1,2,1,2,1,2,3) - most accented part gets lower for no reason??/ the only part it gets lower at is the triangle and thats hard as shit to hit considering the spacing of it as it is (also i cant increase it more)

04:44:640 (1,2,1,2) - this is the only time where i would ever say wow a square fits here pretty nicely Nice

04:52:440 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - is this copy pasted from the beginning wtf it actually isnt lmao
if not its similar as hell like wtf

04:56:640 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - should accent the first 1-2 pattern and lower the second 1-2 pattern and so on agreed on lowering second pattern, don't know why i spaced it out that much
because it feels like its just jump practice as its not really accented
but the other 8 1-2s are pretty fine just stop using fucking polygon circles like GODDAMn Its Stylistic My Man

05:00:990 (2) - doesnt line up with 1 darnit

05:02:040 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - fuck your polygon circles and same emphasis problem as 3:14 will chang if more ppl complain but most ppl dont care so idk

05:29:640 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - uh ya thats the guitar rhythm here wots ur point

05:35:640 (1) - de
05:36:090 (2) - le
05:36:540 (1) - te
05:37:440 (1) - th
05:37:890 (3,1) - is i think ur mad and u know what happens to mad gamers

05:45:762 (8,1) - awful transition fucks sake

total donut count: 36

i was pretty close actually but i may have miscounted

Thanks For The Mod1!!! :) :) :) :) :) :D :D ;) eee

everyone else
@amamiya triple is there, there's a lot more emphasis on the blue tick as well so i mean
emphasis on certain sliders because there's a distinct whistling sound after the ones that are emphasized

@direday

direday wrote:

Hello! Modding cause I like the song.


Nope, not working for me at least.
Try this in order to fix the map:
rename all the files manualy. Or at least .osu ones. My bet is that paranthesis "(feat. Rakim)" messes it up since "()" are used for uploaders' name.
create new diff, delete the old one. probably will have to end up doing this
Also Mod Assistant shows your diff's name like this. Sends an error when trying to open but opens anyway. So definetly smthing is up with the name of .osu file.
If you end up resubmiting I'll throw some kudosu in your face since the map is worth it.

Dunno if this is trustworthy 'cos errors but:
Unused hitsounds:
drum-slidertick.wav
normal-slidertick.wav normal is used constantly lul idk about drum slidertick though so ill double check that

00:04:440 (4) - place it a bit lower for followpoint to cross 00:03:690 (1) 's end right in the middle? I'd also rotate it to look like this basically anything i do is going to ruin the overlap 00:04:440 (4,1) - here, i would do the first thing you mentioned but it'd be a pain to resort this pattern tbh
00:18:840 (1) - is not in line with stream but by such a small amount that it bugs me. Place it higher or in line? this is given more emphasis to show player the difference in rhythm indirectly
00:33:690 (2,3) - this and all that you ctrl+c ctrl+v'ed are not in perfect line. You can check it by ctrl+g'ing the slider and looking at the followpoint
00:43:590 (3,4) - ^ i double checked these and i'm pretty sure they're linear as can be so
00:54:690 (2) - this should be higher in order to follow 00:54:240 (1) 's curve. It will also space 00:54:690 (2) and 00:55:740 (3) - better sure
01:12:840 (1,2) - now this IS perfect line :3
01:20:940 (1) - place it lower to be in the middle of 01:20:340 (2) 's straight line? kinda useless if you ask me but i moved it up a tiny bit regardless
01:21:690 (2,5) - not quite at the same place they are now
01:37:740 (5) - yeaaah geometry nazi: end should be lower a bit. Use folowpoint as a guideline. slight adjustment to 4th slider
01:44:640 (3,4,5,6,7) - were those supposed to look at 01:45:240 (1) - end? nop
02:10:140 (6) - ctrl+j it and place at the same place? would look better imo i use this sort of aesthetic throughout the map so i'd rather keep it
02:13:740 (2,1) - blanket's off time to die
03:18:840 (1) - quaver flashbacks but this time it actually fits the song screamo
04:06:690 (1) - place it to be the "cap" of 04:06:240 (3) - ? Like this adjusted a bit to make it better??i think
04:21:840 (4) - make it "look" at 04:21:540 (2,3) - ? not sure what you mean here
05:05:940 (2) - reduce SV by 0.03~ to place its end directly on top of 05:05:340 (4) - ? nah not going for aesthetic overlap here
05:17:490 (1) - its end is a bit off for perfect overlap it's on it for me lolz
Not a big fan of wacky sliders so consider making them more clean, like this one 05:38:340 (1). Just a suggestion. guitar is distorted here so sliders represent that

ty for mods!
Ascendance
first
Topic Starter
fieryrage
ctb
rc fox
rank
pkk
m4m

krispy kreme more like krispy meme haha lol XDDDD : gun:
  1. imo the clicky soft-hitnormal sound kinda detracts from the playing experience/song
    like im trying to enjoy some sick hot jazz by linkin park with their sick t r ad iti onal instruments and then suddenly b AM wot r these electronic clicky sounds doing in my 1980s emo rock ?? ? he lO

    anyways I feel that you should probably just remove them or use some different sound. Get some more opinions on it imo ! you could replace it with some ride/hihat sound/insert drum terminology here/etc and it might sound good. I think the drum hitwhistle is fine since you use it sparingly

    You can give this soft-hitnormal a try and see how it sounds
  2. 00:50:340 (1) - maybe ctrl g here because at 00:47:340 (1,2,1) - and 00:48:240 (3,4,1) - and 00:54:840 (3,4,1) - etc there r angled jumps that go into the long slider but here 00:50:040 (3,4,1) - its just back and forth w OAH man
  3. 00:57:240 (1) - ctrl g cud be nice here for the more circular flow into the next slidre + i feel that it plays better going clockwise from the previous straigh tslider
  4. 01:22:440 (1,2,3) - I think I get why you did this (stacking the hting + placing 1 there cuz otherwise it wu dbe 2 close to slider 5 before it) but I feel that the spacing difference between the other instances in this section where you do slider-circle-slider is too large. You could try redoing the pattern
  5. 01:27:390 (2,3,4) - this part of the music repeats 4 times and you have 3 other instances where u map the triple (01:17:640 (1,2,3) - , 01:22:440 (1,2,3) - 01:32:040 (1,2,3) - ) differently with a slider-circle-slider. im O if you don't have a strong reason to deviate from your rhythm choice then I would say it's best to just keep it the same for all of them, unless you wanna do something like every other one is a triple or something lo lz.
  6. 01:51:240 (1,2,3) - I think this rhythm variation (different from 01:36:840 (1,2) - , 01:41:640 (1,2) - , 01:46:440 (1,2) - in the section) would make more sense than what I mentioned previously because it happens in the last repetition of this part of the music (i forgot all my music terminology xd) and it works to serve as a transition into the next section, similar to how you have a stream at 01:51:840 (1,2,3,4,5) - instead of the kicksliders like at 01:47:040 (3,4) - ). However, I don't hear any distinct changes/differences between 01:51:240 - and 01:36:840 (1,2) - , 01:41:640 (1,2) - , 01:46:440 (1,2) so you could just use a circle and slider and that would work too. mayb keep in mind for this section too 02:33:240 - with the kicksliders/streams
  7. 02:22:440 (1) - I think a cool effect you could do here is to not have the clicky sound on the tail (set the sampleset to S instead of S:C1) and possibly remove the whistle on the tail to really emphasize the vocal/absence of instruments.

    Same for 02:23:340 (1,1) - , I suggest using the default soft sampleset and maybe the soft hitwhistle because that sounds nice ! same with 03:00:840 (1,2,3,4) -
    And 04:48:390 (1,2,1,2,1,2) -
  8. 02:24:840 (1,2,3) - 03:03:240 (1,2,3) - I would space these out just a liiiitle bit more, maybe it will look ni cer : ok_hand:. u have overlap at 02:15:840 (4,5,6) - but i thought that one was more ok cuz it was slow part so low spacing
  9. 02:35:040 (3) - 02:39:840 (1) - 02:56:640 (3) - are these supposed to be nc'd or not cuz sometimes u have nc and sometimes u dont just like how sometimes i think im a furry but im not really lol !!!
  10. 03:23:040 (1) - i think the default drum-hitnormal would sound great here (remove those whistles while you're at it) and raise the green line volume to 70/80% if u do change it
  11. 03:28:740 (1,2) - u brave soul
    i respect that
  12. 03:29:340 (3,1) - this could use more emphasis by changing the angle of the jump (compare to 03:24:540 (3,1) - , 03:25:740 (3,1) - , 03:30:540 (3,1) - in the same section). Might need to redo the pattern here instead of just moving the circle to get the desired fl ow
  13. 03:48:690 (1,2,3,1) - smooth! very cool
  14. 03:54:690 - this rhythm might sound better if you switch the slider and circle around so that the vocal syllable at 03:54:990 - is mapped by the circle instead of a sliderend
  15. 04:59:340 (1,2,1) - 05:04:140 (1,2,1) - if you compare the emphasis, the second one doesn't feel as strong because of the angle. Try moving 05:04:440 (1) - up more (~x27 y62) and see if that feels better
  16. 05:30:540 (4) - I kinda expected two kick sliders here because of the two claps. I feel that it would also maintain momentum if you made it into two sliders instead of one that ends on a clap
  17. 05:53:391 - 5% volume here pls ! u dont want people who dont use ur custom hitsounds to hear a loud BWAP on the slider tail when there is q uioet in the musiccc : )))

clean aes, emphasis is pretty good for the most part imo

hav fun mapping lmoa
Topic Starter
fieryrage
remindr 2 respond and m4m uta

+ relook at jump sections with polygons and 1/8 slider sv (or reduce by one 1/8 tick) and hitsounds @ idke
Aerolustly
hi please make it harder furry rage
Topic Starter
fieryrage
pk

pkk wrote:

m4m

krispy kreme more like krispy meme haha lol XDDDD : gun:
  1. imo the clicky soft-hitnormal sound kinda detracts from the playing experience/song
    like im trying to enjoy some sick hot jazz by linkin park with their sick t r ad iti onal instruments and then suddenly b AM wot r these electronic clicky sounds doing in my 1980s emo rock ?? ? he lO Yea lol i removed them i just used my skin hitsounds

    anyways I feel that you should probably just remove them or use some different sound. Get some more opinions on it imo ! you could replace it with some ride/hihat sound/insert drum terminology here/etc and it might sound good. I think the drum hitwhistle is fine since you use it sparingly

    You can give this soft-hitnormal a try and see how it sounds
  2. 00:50:340 (1) - maybe ctrl g here because at 00:47:340 (1,2,1) - and 00:48:240 (3,4,1) - and 00:54:840 (3,4,1) - etc there r angled jumps that go into the long slider but here 00:50:040 (3,4,1) - its just back and forth w OAH man the flow right here i think is good as is and its high ar so whatever lo
  3. 00:57:240 (1) - ctrl g cud be nice here for the more circular flow into the next slidre + i feel that it plays better going clockwise from the previous straigh tslider i might just be autistic but i play this so much better when this isnt ctrl+gd
  4. 01:22:440 (1,2,3) - I think I get why you did this (stacking the hting + placing 1 there cuz otherwise it wu dbe 2 close to slider 5 before it) but I feel that the spacing difference between the other instances in this section where you do slider-circle-slider is too large. You could try redoing the pattern
    fixd differently
  5. 01:27:390 (2,3,4) - this part of the music repeats 4 times and you have 3 other instances where u map the triple (01:17:640 (1,2,3) - , 01:22:440 (1,2,3) - 01:32:040 (1,2,3) - ) differently with a slider-circle-slider. im O if you don't have a strong reason to deviate from your rhythm choice then I would say it's best to just keep it the same for all of them, unless you wanna do something like every other one is a triple or something lo lz. way it is rn is fine imo since the triples b4 the finishes are a lot more noticeable and some ppl wanted me to remove them for playability SO WHATEVER
  6. 01:51:240 (1,2,3) - I think this rhythm variation (different from 01:36:840 (1,2) - , 01:41:640 (1,2) - , 01:46:440 (1,2) - in the section) would make more sense than what I mentioned previously because it happens in the last repetition of this part of the music (i forgot all my music terminology xd) and it works to serve as a transition into the next section, similar to how you have a stream at 01:51:840 (1,2,3,4,5) - instead of the kicksliders like at 01:47:040 (3,4) - ). However, I don't hear any distinct changes/differences between 01:51:240 - and 01:36:840 (1,2) - , 01:41:640 (1,2) - , 01:46:440 (1,2) so you could just use a circle and slider and that would work too. mayb keep in mind for this section too 02:33:240 - with the kicksliders/streams gotta have rhythm differentiation here else its boring as fuck (even though its already boring as fuck) so i'd rather keep this the way it is
  7. 02:22:440 (1) - I think a cool effect you could do here is to not have the clicky sound on the tail (set the sampleset to S instead of S:C1) and possibly remove the whistle on the tail to really emphasize the vocal/absence of instruments. not removing whistle but this is basically fixd cuz of the removal of soft hitsample so d

    Same for 02:23:340 (1,1) - , I suggest using the default soft sampleset and maybe the soft hitwhistle because that sounds nice ! same with 03:00:840 (1,2,3,4) -
    And 04:48:390 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - all thes fixed already Wew
  8. 02:24:840 (1,2,3) - 03:03:240 (1,2,3) - I would space these out just a liiiitle bit more, maybe it will look ni cer : ok_hand:. u have overlap at 02:15:840 (4,5,6) - but i thought that one was more ok cuz it was slow part so low spacing ur mom lol
  9. 02:35:040 (3) - 02:39:840 (1) - 02:56:640 (3) - are these supposed to be nc'd or not cuz sometimes u have nc and sometimes u dont just like how sometimes i think im a furry but im not really lol !!! fuck rhythm and i cant fix because my autistic is autism
  10. 03:23:040 (1) - i think the default drum-hitnormal would sound great here (remove those whistles while you're at it) and raise the green line volume to 70/80% if u do change it ok fixd it kind of i think
  11. 03:28:740 (1,2) - u brave soul
    i respect that wot the fuck is wrong wiht hese sliders tho
  12. 03:29:340 (3,1) - this could use more emphasis by changing the angle of the jump (compare to 03:24:540 (3,1) - , 03:25:740 (3,1) - , 03:30:540 (3,1) - in the same section). Might need to redo the pattern here instead of just moving the circle to get the desired fl ow still has a lot of emphasis, just not straightforward like the others tho
  13. 03:48:690 (1,2,3,1) - smooth! very cool Clean Split
  14. 03:54:690 - this rhythm might sound better if you switch the slider and circle around so that the vocal syllable at 03:54:990 - is mapped by the circle instead of a sliderend sure
  15. 04:59:340 (1,2,1) - 05:04:140 (1,2,1) - if you compare the emphasis, the second one doesn't feel as strong because of the angle. Try moving 05:04:440 (1) - up more (~x27 y62) and see if that feels better readjusted (ie rotated xd) pattern i think it still flows well??
  16. 05:30:540 (4) - I kinda expected two kick sliders here because of the two claps. I feel that it would also maintain momentum if you made it into two sliders instead of one that ends on a clap i tried experimenting with this and i came to the conclusion its like near impossible to make this play well when doing this
  17. 05:53:391 - 5% volume here pls ! u dont want people who dont use ur custom hitsounds to hear a loud BWAP on the slider tail when there is q uioet in the musiccc : ))) niga theres a guitar squeak here but i made it 15%

clean aes, emphasis is pretty good for the most part imo

hav fun mapping lmoa Lol!

also adjusted 1/8 tick and hitsounds as per idkes request, still looking at some polygon jumps to see how to improve

@jared this was 7.8 stars but then the ending was cancer so i remapped lolz
Dashyy-
guilt all same

i'll mod this l8ter cause ur hot
riktoi
00:18:840 (1) - looks nicer if you line it up with the rest of the stream

00:41:640 (1,2,3,4) - I think unless you're going for a specific kind of movement here you could try transitions with sharper angles i guess lo (it's the kind of movement alumetorz uses a lot)
ex
current
"new"

00:49:140 (3) - sharper angle for this will be nicer (closer to the slider)

00:50:340 (1) - since this slider doesn't work as a stopper like 00:49:440 (1) - does, having the flow from 00:50:040 (3,4) - be more circular makes sense; currently it requires you to do a very weird reverse L shape with your cursor

00:53:190 (4) - might want to manually stack this as it's nigh on the shadow of the last slider (feel free to ignore these stacking suggestions, you are way better at reading than I am anyway [and it's a 7.7* map anyway])

01:10:440 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - this is really neat

01:13:440 (1,2,1,2) - buff the spacing a bit, even though it's a very awkward pattern I feel like it needs just a bit more spacing

01:19:890 (4) - manually stack this one too

01:21:090 (2) - just a little bit lower

01:21:990 (4) - if you decide to manually stack whatever i pointed out before or after this might as well manually stack these too (even though they are fine from a reading aspect)
01:23:490 (2) - ^ I guess
01:27:690 (5) - ^ lol
01:30:240 (1) - ^ a
01:30:540 (3) - ^

01:35:040 (1,2) - ctrl + g (feel it's misleading compared to the jumps before)

02:02:940 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - really hard but feels good

02:59:940 (1) - nc this as it follows the same pattern as 02:59:640 (1,2) -

03:00:090 (2,1,2,3) - if people struggle hitting this it's most likely because of the really wide curve

03:27:240 - headbanged so hard to these it hurt my neck fukc (no it's fine)

04:39:840 (1,2,3,1) - ouch, try ctrl + h so you get rid of the mean angle here 04:39:690 (2,1,2) -

05:39:240 (1,2,1,2) - spooky

05:43:140 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - you could follow the riff here (dunno the guitar is way too random to follow)

Thank
Topic Starter
fieryrage
responding 2day Lol
Topic Starter
fieryrage
god dammit i still forgot
riktoi
lmao
Topic Starter
fieryrage
rik

riktoi wrote:

00:18:840 (1) - looks nicer if you line it up with the rest of the stream trying to emphasize the piano starting here since its a new instrument/slowdown section which would otherwise look normal if it were just lined up

00:41:640 (1,2,3,4) - I think unless you're going for a specific kind of movement here you could try transitions with sharper angles i guess lo (it's the kind of movement alumetorz uses a lot) ya im going for movement here

00:49:140 (3) - sharper angle for this will be nicer (closer to the slider) this works fine tho wot

00:50:340 (1) - since this slider doesn't work as a stopper like 00:49:440 (1) - does, having the flow from 00:50:040 (3,4) - be more circular makes sense; currently it requires you to do a very weird reverse L shape with your cursor actually will consider remapping this though as of right now no one else really complained about it in playtests so idk if its worth remapping atm

00:53:190 (4) - might want to manually stack this as it's nigh on the shadow of the last slider (feel free to ignore these stacking suggestions, you are way better at reading than I am anyway [and it's a 7.7* map anyway]) ya this is kind of expected in terms of jump pattern placement prior so its more than readable rn

01:10:440 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - this is really neat

01:13:440 (1,2,1,2) - buff the spacing a bit, even though it's a very awkward pattern I feel like it needs just a bit more spacing revamped the pattern a bit cuz its gay anyway but increasing spacing would reduce the metric fuckton of overlaps later on

01:19:890 (4) - manually stack this one too e

01:21:090 (2) - just a little bit lower ok

01:21:990 (4) - if you decide to manually stack whatever i pointed out before or after this might as well manually stack these too (even though they are fine from a reading aspect)
01:23:490 (2) - ^ I guess
01:27:690 (5) - ^ lol
01:30:240 (1) - ^ a
01:30:540 (3) - ^ ya this is basically just aesthetics lul

01:35:040 (1,2) - ctrl + g (feel it's misleading compared to the jumps before) it goes in a circular pattern near the end and reduces in spacing so this is fine

02:02:940 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - really hard but feels good Hey Thanks

02:59:940 (1) - nc this as it follows the same pattern as 02:59:640 (1,2) - dont really see a need for nc here and it helps readability kind of since the times i use 1-2 is either during a pause or during spacing changes

03:00:090 (2,1,2,3) - if people struggle hitting this it's most likely because of the really wide curve everyone ive seen play fced this so ya

03:27:240 - headbanged so hard to these it hurt my neck fukc (no it's fine) thanks

04:39:840 (1,2,3,1) - ouch, try ctrl + h so you get rid of the mean angle here 04:39:690 (2,1,2) - u increased the star rating by 0.02 somehow good job

05:39:240 (1,2,1,2) - spooky xd

05:43:140 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - you could follow the riff here (dunno the guitar is way too random to follow) nah rn should be good since its a continuous pattern

Thank eeeeeeeeeeee

fd
Vivyanne
00:10:290 (1) - considering that the music is going rly down u should consider to decrease the spacing instead of increasing it to emphasise the drums stopping at this note ya
00:46:440 (1) - feeling like this note could be spaced more since theres a strong drumbeat on here so spacing it out more would make more sense emphasiswise d
00:55:590 (2,3) - nah fam dis spacing be way too low to what u had before this buff rn or i will eat ur dog
01:38:040 (1,2,3) - weird flow tbh, (2,3) go the opposite direction of (1) without any strong feeback from the song which makes this rly suprising and misleading. u shud follow the curve of (1) ya
04:01:140 (2,3,5) - pls make the visual distance equal cus rn it isnt ):


since i didnt find anything wrong with the map since everything's done in a consistent manner lemme just point out all stacks that are off in the map.
00:01:290 (1,3) -
00:13:140 (4,2) -
00:32:190 (2,3) -
00:32:490 (4,2,2) -
00:33:990 (3,1) -
00:42:390 (2,1) - tbh this should just kinda stack as u didnt ever use this kind of overlap before ya
01:13:590 (2,1) -
01:18:540 (1,1) -
01:38:490 (2,2) -
01:40:290 (6,2) -
01:41:790 (2,4) -
01:56:940 (5,2) -
02:06:690 (3,2) -
02:14:490 (2,1,3) -
02:23:340 (1,1) -
02:32:640 (1,1) -
04:15:540 (2,1) -
04:24:390 (2,1) -
04:26:490 (3,1) -
04:34:290 (1,3) -
05:04:890 (2,4) -
05:15:840 (1,1) -
05:17:490 (1,2,1) -

gl :3/
Topic Starter
fieryrage
i cant wait for the stack realignments weeeeeEEEE
Topic Starter
fieryrage
hiugh

HighTec wrote:

00:10:290 (1) - considering that the music is going rly down u should consider to decrease the spacing instead of increasing it to emphasise the drums stopping at this note ya they stop after this and if it were stacked it'd flow really weird so
00:46:440 (1) - feeling like this note could be spaced more since theres a strong drumbeat on here so spacing it out more would make more sense emphasiswise d pattern would be d if it had more spacing
00:55:590 (2,3) - nah fam dis spacing be way too low to what u had before this buff rn or i will eat ur dog ok thanks
01:38:040 (1,2,3) - weird flow tbh, (2,3) go the opposite direction of (1) without any strong feeback from the song which makes this rly suprising and misleading. u shud follow the curve of (1) ya as it is rn i think the flow is fine since i do this like 100 times later on in the song in similar ways, so no huge issue
04:01:140 (2,3,5) - pls make the visual distance equal cus rn it isnt ): eeeeeee


since i didnt find anything wrong with the map since everything's done in a consistent manner lemme just point out all stacks that are off in the map.
00:01:290 (1,3) - this ones fine
00:13:140 (4,2) -
00:32:190 (2,3) - this 1 is also fine
00:32:490 (4,2,2) - ^
00:33:990 (3,1) - ok all these slider stacks are actually the best they can be idk what the fuck ur talking about actualy
00:42:390 (2,1) - tbh this should just kinda stack as u didnt ever use this kind of overlap before ya i do this later on as well tho
01:13:590 (2,1) -
01:18:540 (1,1) -
01:38:490 (2,2) -
01:40:290 (6,2) -
01:41:790 (2,4) -
01:56:940 (5,2) -
02:06:690 (3,2) -
02:14:490 (2,1,3) -
02:23:340 (1,1) -
02:32:640 (1,1) -
04:15:540 (2,1) -
04:24:390 (2,1) -
04:26:490 (3,1) -
04:34:290 (1,3) -
05:04:890 (2,4) -
05:15:840 (1,1) -
05:17:490 (1,2,1) -

gl :3/

i didnt look at half the stacks (from 02:14:490 (2,1,3) - onwards) cuz like halfway thru there was no change in stacking them so ya if i get bugged about more ill fix them
Logic Agent
[General]
  1. resize bg like what year is this
[Shame]
  1. 00:22:740 - skipping this noise on purpose or
  2. 01:18:540 (1,1) - stack?
  3. 01:20:340 (2) - the fuck
  4. 01:21:840 (3,4) - ds here is pretty small compared to the rest of the section
  5. 01:23:340 (1,2) - these jumps being so big takes away from the impact when the actual 1-2 spam starts, i'd nerf this.
  6. 01:32:940 (1,2) - yeah
  7. 01:34:140 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - fieryrage
  8. 01:37:440 - for some reason i think it'd be cute if you silenced these slider ends. just the first one, not 01:37:665 - it's not that serious though
  9. 02:13:740 (2,3,1) - the visual distance here is triggering if you dont want me to be triggered make it look like this
  10. 02:15:840 (4,5,6) - do these really gotta overlap i mean this is a 7 star map i think they can handle a lil jump here
  11. 02:30:540 (1,2) - again i think the lead in to the 1-2 spam could be stronger by nerfing this combo. not gonna mention it again just know this change goes for everywhere applicable in the map if you choose to add it
  12. 03:28:740 (1) - STOP
  13. 03:59:040 - I think it's kinda strange how you represented this drum sound with different sv's throughout this section, personally I think a consistent sv and interesting shape (aka this slider shape is fine) would work better.
  14. 04:03:090 (1) - ctrl + g this and the next one? or fix this 04:11:490 (1,1) - because this ones different so ya just make them consistent
  15. 04:39:240 (1,2,1,2,1,2,3) - FIERYRAGE
  16. 04:51:240 (1,2,3) - same thing as earlier with the overlaps
  17. 05:09:840 (1,2,1,2,1) - ok you're reported
    05:35:640 (1,2,1,3,1,1,2,1,2,1,2,3,4) - stop, stop winny upload
  18. 05:43:590 (1,2) - don't rly like this would prefer it being more flowy after the stream section (so at the end of the slider tail somewhere)
  19. 05:44:940 (1,2,3,4) - I think a more accurate representation of the music would be for this to be a smaller portion of the stream before the actual stream stuff starts. The guitar doesn't really "erupt" until this combo of 4 is over, but after these 4 notes the stream gets smaller in ds so it's not really fitting. Something like this always looks nice but you'd probably have to change the jumps before it do something like this.
  20. in general im not like 100% sure about the rhythms in the stream near the end because that stupid ass constant guitar in the background is confusing me so yeah


can't be a pp map if nobody can fc it
Topic Starter
fieryrage
logic

Logic Agent wrote:

[General]
  1. resize bg like what year is this find me a better one cuz i sure as hell cant Lol
[Shame]
  1. 00:22:740 - skipping this noise on purpose or ya, i follow the piano notes that are most intense during this slow part
  2. 01:18:540 (1,1) - stack? when the hell (changed this pattern a bit because ppl said 300 on slider repeat was unrankable so d)
  3. 01:20:340 (2) - the fuck mad
  4. 01:21:840 (3,4) - ds here is pretty small compared to the rest of the section there was a section just before this that was similar so i think this should be fine
  5. 01:23:340 (1,2) - these jumps being so big takes away from the impact when the actual 1-2 spam starts, i'd nerf this. put this jump here to introduce the flow more than anything, reducing it kinda makes this pattern hard as hell to play
  6. 01:32:940 (1,2) - yeah this one i agree with though, adjusted pattern
  7. 01:34:140 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - fieryrage mad
  8. 01:37:440 - for some reason i think it'd be cute if you silenced these slider ends. just the first one, not 01:37:665 - it's not that serious though theres a clap on that slider end >:(
  9. 02:13:740 (2,3,1) - the visual distance here is triggering if you dont want me to be triggered make it look like this cymbal emphasis also ur mad
  10. 02:15:840 (4,5,6) - do these really gotta overlap i mean this is a 7 star map i think they can handle a lil jump here how th e fuck am i gonna make a jump of this
  11. 02:30:540 (1,2) - again i think the lead in to the 1-2 spam could be stronger by nerfing this combo. not gonna mention it again just know this change goes for everywhere applicable in the map if you choose to add it yeah, basically all of these are intended so i don't really plan on changing any more of these, the jumps feel/flow fine as they are rn to the music so i'm kinda hesitant on changing any of them
  12. 03:28:740 (1) - STOP mad
  13. 03:59:040 - I think it's kinda strange how you represented this drum sound with different sv's throughout this section, personally I think a consistent sv and interesting shape (aka this slider shape is fine) would work better. u linked the wrong thing first of all and those have a lot more emphasis so i feel a slightly higher sv makes them emphasized properly
  14. 04:03:090 (1) - ctrl + g this and the next one? or fix this 04:11:490 (1,1) - because this ones different so ya just make them consistent how long was this like this lmao
  15. 04:39:240 (1,2,1,2,1,2,3) - FIERYRAGE mad
  16. 04:51:240 (1,2,3) - same thing as earlier with the overlaps i dont rly see an issue here with overlaps? im confused what ur point is
  17. 05:09:840 (1,2,1,2,1) - ok you're reported mad
    05:35:640 (1,2,1,3,1,1,2,1,2,1,2,3,4) - stop, stop winny upload mad
  18. 05:43:590 (1,2) - don't rly like this would prefer it being more flowy after the stream section (so at the end of the slider tail somewhere) i mean it's kinda flow-based right now anyways, it's continuing the stream pattern giving emphasis to the guitar squeak at the end, think of it as a sliderstream near the end if that helps
  19. 05:44:940 (1,2,3,4) - I think a more accurate representation of the music would be for this to be a smaller portion of the stream before the actual stream stuff starts. The guitar doesn't really "erupt" until this combo of 4 is over, but after these 4 notes the stream gets smaller in ds so it's not really fitting. Something like this always looks nice but you'd probably have to change the jumps before it do something like this. definitely will consider this since i feel like the combo is more spaced out anyway than it should be (this was the only part from previous solo that wasn't changed), will probably have to think of some fancy kick slider patterns probably
  20. in general im not like 100% sure about the rhythms in the stream near the end because that stupid ass constant guitar in the background is confusing me so yeah linkin park guitarist on drugs


can't be a pp map if nobody can fc it mad
Logic Agent

fieryrage wrote:

stuff
Dilectus
Combo colors is hard to differentiate. I mean, the target audience probably can read without it anyways buuuut... idk actually. Perhaps you could make the brighter color a bit brighter and the darker one a bit more darker.

00:22:740 - Missing beat
00:23:340 - ^
The sudden rhythm change doesn't make sense as you seem to only follow the piano at this part . Also seems undermapped to me.

00:48:540 (1) - Just for more comfortable movement, make it the same shape as 00:47:640 (1) -
00:56:940 (1) - Could also use a bit more comfortable movement just for better flow. So you can bend it?
02:20:640 (4,5,6,7,1) - Rotate 3 degrees anti-clockwise to fix the straight line with 02:21:090 (2) -

----

Can't find anything more. Everything looks consistent to me. Nice that you did some slider art for Brad's little Tom Morello solo there.

Good luck!
Topic Starter
fieryrage
david

DavidEd wrote:

Combo colors is hard to differentiate. I mean, the target audience probably can read without it anyways buuuut... idk actually. Perhaps you could make the brighter color a bit brighter and the darker one a bit more darker. yea sure why not

00:22:740 - Missing beat
00:23:340 - ^
The sudden rhythm change doesn't make sense as you seem to only follow the piano at this part . Also seems undermapped to me. supposed to be undermapped, the two missing beats would feel out of place if i did map them

00:48:540 (1) - Just for more comfortable movement, make it the same shape as 00:47:640 (1) - this should be comfortable enough as is honestly
00:56:940 (1) - Could also use a bit more comfortable movement just for better flow. So you can bend it? same as above, don't really see a need to change jump patterns here since it's high sr and all of them flow fine to me and others so
02:20:640 (4,5,6,7,1) - Rotate 3 degrees anti-clockwise to fix the straight line with 02:21:090 (2) - done and fixed overlaps

----

Can't find anything more. Everything looks consistent to me. Nice that you did some slider art for Brad's little Tom Morello solo there.

Good luck! ty!
Topic Starter
fieryrage
modded in discord with morgano but he restrictedo so no kudosuo

basically 00:01:740 (2,3) - changed rhythm here, 04:39:240 (1,2) - reduced spacing here, 05:34:140 (6,7) - brought 7 a bit closer for better playability and that's it
Togetic
comin in HOT with that mod

shame
shame on these overdone jumps i'm not funny

if i ever mention something that may "flow awkwardly" it's because in my opinion this song doesn't warrant any abnormal or special type of movement that could be reflected in mapping but hey it's a matter of subjectivity i guess.

00:08:340 (2,3) - yes i know this map is like 7.7* or w/e but here it feels like the spacing between these jumps are kinda unwarranted for the intensity of the music. the other jumps a the beginning make more sense (spacing wise ofc) but this seems a bit excessive.
00:14:340 (6,1) - theres a strange change in flow here due to the angle of the jump being fairly wider than the previous jumps. playing this felt unnecessarily awkward and theres nothing in the music that really warrants this sort of change in flow so i would recommend changing the placement.
00:32:790 (2) - i do hear in the music how this rhythm choice could be justified (although its still kinda subtle) but this specific choice is kinda confusing. the part of the song that i hear that justifies the rhythm starts at 00:32:640 (1), so i feel it is kind of strange how you did not decide to use another kick slider in place of that circle. in general i think if you made both 00:32:640 (1,2) circles or kick sliders it would make more sense rhythmically.
01:16:140 (1,2) - if this were ctrl+g then i think it would flow a bit less awkwardly.
03:12:990 (2) - i cannot hear anything in the music that really justifies the use of a kick rather than just a circle but maybe i'm deaf idk.
03:26:940 (3,4,1) - these two circles flow awkwardly into the slider.
04:31:740 (5) - i don't hear any rhythm that justifies the use of a kick slider over a circle here.

i hope this helped in some way! this map is really fun and although the jumps are kinda ridiculous to me, thats just my opinion and i know it'd be silly to tell you to change that lol. good luck with ranking! :]
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply