Woo here we goooo :v
SPOILER
[Ascension to Heaven]
btw fix this
00:12:157 (3) - Missing whistle
00:12:510 (6) - ^ slider head
00:14:275 (1,2,3) - ^ on all the white ticks. I'd also say remove the clap from 00:14:981 (3) - the red tick cuz the normal-hitnormal can be used for that kick sound and the clap is more suited to just following sounds like 00:15:334 - (slider tail)
00:14:275 - Also here I don't really like the volume changes they're pretty strong although there isn't an instrument that's notably getting quieter. On stark contrast 00:07:216 - 00:10:040 - there is a small buildup but that wasn't taken into account. So for example I could see the volume of 00:10:040 - being at 20% then building up by like 3% each starting 00:07:216 - and leaving it at 45% at 00:10:040 - meanwhile getting rid of the volume changes at 00:14:275 - 00:14:628 - 00:14:981 - unless you wanna emphasize the volume in crease in which case you can make it increase still by 3% starting at 00:12:863 -
So this is the part where it's gonna get a bit tricky and there's gonna be a lot of suggestions all in the sake of consistency and I really hope you go through with all of them unless I mention it's optional.
I guess some people might view this differently but hitsounds are about complimenting the song whether that's to mimic the song's instruments or to add certain rhythms to make them stand out among the music as an extra instrument. In this case we're gonna mimic the song because that seems to be more towards what you're aiming for. Okay here we go
00:15:687 (1) - Change the slider head to Normal sampleset Soft addition and remove the clap and normal addition from the slider end.
00:16:040 (2) - Change to auto addition and sample.
00:16:393 (4) - Change to auto addition, remove clap and add whistle and finish instead
00:16:746 (5) - Change to auto addition
00:16:922 (6) - Change to auto addition
00:17:099 (1) - Add whistle to slider head and get rid of the clap on the slider end
00:17:452 (2) - Change to clap
00:17:805 (4) - Add whistle and finish to slider head
00:18:157 (5) - replace finish with clap
00:18:334 (6) - Not really a hitsound suggestion but it could be a 1/8 kick slider per the sound that it makes here :v something like this
00:18:510 (1) - Add finish and whistle to slider head
00:18:863 (2) - Change to clap
00:19:216 (4) - Add whistle and finish to slider head
00:19:569 (5) - Change to whistle and clap. So what we're doing to clarify here is using the finishes to follow that big 2/1 tuba like sound and the whistles to sorta follow miku.
00:19:922 (1) - Finish and whistle on slider head
00:20:275 (2) - remove finish and change to clap and whistle
00:20:452 (1) - Remove whistle from the slider head. Add finish and whistle to slider end.
00:20:805 (2) - Remove whislte from slider head. Remove finish and add clap on slider end
00:21:334 (1) - Change to normal sampleset soft addition. Remove clap and change to finish and whistle on slider head
00:21:687 (2) - Change to clap not finish.
00:22:040 (4) - Add finish and whistle to slider head. Remove clap from slider end and also change to normal sample here.
00:22:393 (5) - Change to clap not finish.
00:22:746 (1) - Add finish and whistle to slider head
00:23:099 (2) - Change to clap not finish.
00:23:363 (4) - Change to normal sampleset. 00:23:452 (5) - Also change this to normal sampleset and soft addition, remove the clap and add Whistle and finish
00:23:805 (6) - Change to clap not finish.
00:24:157 (1) - Change to normal sampleset and soft addition, remove clap and add whistle and finish on slider head
00:24:510 (2) - Change to clap not finish.
00:24:863 (4) - Add whistle and finish to slider head
00:25:216 (5) - Change to clap not finish.
00:25:393 (6) - Add finish and whistle to slider end
00:25:922 (2) - Change to clap not finish.
00:26:275 (4) - Add whistle
00:26:628 (6) - Change to clap. You can leave the finish on this one if you prefer or not for consistency.
00:26:981 (1) - Add a finish. Arguably you don't have to but cuz you got the volume lowered which is nice it's works better.
00:35:452 (1) - Also another small suggestion but this could be a nice low SV slider that ends at either 00:36:510 - 00:36:687 - or 00:36:775 - and near the start of 00:36:863 (1) - maybe something like this. Oh also add a finish to that note/slider head.
00:38:275 - Add a volume timing here and raise it to 60%. This part's pretty awesome to just make it be so quiet. Also customs would be pretty cool for this section but since they're not here we'll improvise
00:38:275 (1) - Add a normal whistle. We're gonna use this sound to get that low kick sound. Alternatively you can use drum hitnormal but that's more complicated so let's keep it simple :v
00:38:981 (2) - Well you seem to enjoy using finishes for the clap sounds so we can do that for this section. Add a finish.
00:40:393 (2) - Add normal sampleset and soft addition.
00:41:099 (1) - Add normal addition and whistle
00:42:510 (1) - ^
00:43:922 (1) - Add finish, whistle and use normal addition instead of normal sample.
00:48:863 (1) - OOOOOOO man here I REALLY wish this was a slow sv slider that ended at 00:49:481 - something like this. (Using .75x in that screenshot)
00:49:569 (1) - Add whistle and finish to slider head as well as normal addition
00:50:275 (1) - Change to normal sample soft addition in the slider head.
00:50:981 (5) - Add whistle and change to normal sample
00:53:040 (2,3) - Again make sure to resnap these. I guess you're using 1/6 so resnap the ends only.
00:53:805 (1) - Whistle and normal addition
00:55:216 (1) - Whistle and normal addition
00:56:628 (1) - Whistle and normal addition
00:57:334 (1) - Could get rid of the whistle here if you want
01:00:863 (1) - Whistle and normal addition
01:02:275 (4) - ^
01:03:687 (1) - ^
01:04:393 (1) - Finish
01:05:099 (1) - Whistle normal addition
01:06:510 (1) - ^
01:07:922 (5) - ^
01:09:334 (1) - HERE you can do a soft whistle instead cuz of the change in the music intensity.
01:10:746 (1) - This one could use a whistle as well if you want
01:11:442 (1) - Finish on slider end
Well I guess you really like finishes instead of claps uhhhhh.....tbh I think you should definitely consider changing those to claps because for one a finish at least to me is more like what the name implies a "finisher" sort of thing so when you have them instead of claps it kinda loses its impact idk how to explain it. Ssecondly a lot of custom skins actually kinda mute or use a less subtle finish mostly because a lot of mappers tend to use the finish samples for certain custom sounds and if you were to have your skin custom hitsounds enabled you'd likely hear a bunch of finish spam so most skins tend to kinda mute or use a softer sound for that reason. Of course it seems that you are conscious of wanting finishes for your claps so I don't know how willing you would be to change that. I would urge you to PM me so we can continue with this hitsound mod in regards to the claps but for now I'll point out any other inconsistencies.
TL;DR - Let me know if you don't mind changing all your finishes to claps from this point forward and I'll help you with the hitsounding in that regard from there.
01:12:139 - Also another note you seem to use 80% volume during the uninherited timing point bpm changes but the rest uses 50% volume so might wanna keep that consistent. I would suggest keeping this entire section at about 60% volume overall. This applies to the later red points as well.
01:12:844 (3) - Could use a whistle to get that violin sound. If you agree feel free to apply them here as well: 01:13:550 (1) - 01:14:256 (4) - 01:14:962 (1) - 01:15:663 (4) - 01:16:365 (1) - 01:16:876 (1) - (slider end), 01:17:728 (1) - 01:18:390 (4) - 01:19:053 (1) - 01:19:691 (5) - (slider head)01:20:329 (1) - 01:20:950 (4) - 01:21:417 (1) - (slider end) 01:22:175 (1) - (slider head) Just make sure they're soft whistles
01:16:365 (1) - Change this to soft sampleset btw
01:16:876 (1) - Remove finish from slider end
01:19:212 (2) - Add finish to slider end
01:19:531 (3) - PLEASE remove this finish
01:19:691 (5) - And this one in the slider end thanks
01:20:010 (6) - And add the finish here using soft addition
01:20:329 - See here you go back to 50% volume when the rest was at 80 and it's very noticeable yet nothing in the music indicates softer volume. Going from the previous volume suggestion just stick to 60% and you're good.
01:22:778 (1) - Use soft addition and add a finish possibly.
01:29:498 - Nice :v
01:31:680 (1) - So for this section I'd just basically suggest adding normal whistles on notes like 01:31:680 (1) - 01:32:771 (1) - 01:33:862 (1) - etc. like I did in the other section. You can do that here as well.
01:37:680 (2) - This would be pretty cool as a slider that ends at 01:38:157 -
01:39:862 (1,2) - Also nice :v
02:33:139 - Use 60 or 70% volume for this section. It should be more intense than the previous section. And I mean this apples to every green point from 02:33:139 - to 03:07:021 -
02:35:963 (1) - Remove finish since you're using them as claps ;^)
02:38:080 (6) - And here add finish since you're using them as claps :^V
02:39:492 (2) - ^
02:40:727 (1) - Add normal sampleset to the slider end
02:40:904 (2) - Add finish :^)
02:54:316 (1) - 02:55:021 (1) - Small suggestion but you could add soft whistles to these two
02:55:727 (1) - See the problem with using finishes for claps is when you get to the section changes. Oftentimes in music you'll have a finish to indicate the transition as a FINISHER (oooooooooooo) to the previous section so when it comes time to show that we can't cuz it will blend in with 02:56:433 (1) - etc. Just pointing that out don't add a finish on (1) :v
03:03:315 (1) - Normal sample on slider head
03:03:492 (2) - Finish :^)
03:05:963 (4) - 03:06:315 (1) - Like the other small suggestion consider soft whistles here
03:23:444 (5) - This would have that nice 1/3 swing effect if it was a 1/3 slider with a reverse arrow and then if 03:23:717 (1) - was a 1/1 slider like at 03:19:353 (1) - it'd give it a nice effect. Something like this maybe (note 03:24:172 (2) - was rotated by 120 degrees clockwise as shown in the screenshot)
03:27:058 - Also another small suggestion but you could have a note here so it doesn't feel so empty and has a similar effect to 03:26:512 (1) -
03:55:435 (2) - Change to drum sample and soft addition like 03:56:620 (2) - and 03:57:851 (2) -
05:03:504 (3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Nice :v
05:09:231 (3) - Finish on slider head
05:22:791 (3) - Change slider end to normal sample. Remove whistle as well
05:23:276 (1) - Change to normal sample.
05:37:305 (2) - Remove finish from slider end and change to normal sample soft addition. You COULD also remove the whistle to add to that pause effect but that ones up to you.
05:40:217 (1) - Remove finish. Change to normal sample.
Hoyl lol the maps actually pretty cool. Crazy and weird like the song itself so I'd say it's very suitable. Not sure about some of the snaps though. Might've missed a few hitsound things cuz I started this at 4 a.m. (couldn't sleep lol) And yeah if you plan to change the finishes to claps hit me up I'll help you out and stuffz. TBH the easiest solution would be to copy the default soft-hitfinish and paste it as a soft-hitclap in the song folder so you keep that sound but move it over to a clap so it's more suitable. Then copy over the normal-hitfinish and paste it over the soft hitfinish ANYWAY....
btw fix this
00:12:157 (3) - Missing whistle
00:12:510 (6) - ^ slider head
00:14:275 (1,2,3) - ^ on all the white ticks. I'd also say remove the clap from 00:14:981 (3) - the red tick cuz the normal-hitnormal can be used for that kick sound and the clap is more suited to just following sounds like 00:15:334 - (slider tail)
00:14:275 - Also here I don't really like the volume changes they're pretty strong although there isn't an instrument that's notably getting quieter. On stark contrast 00:07:216 - 00:10:040 - there is a small buildup but that wasn't taken into account. So for example I could see the volume of 00:10:040 - being at 20% then building up by like 3% each starting 00:07:216 - and leaving it at 45% at 00:10:040 - meanwhile getting rid of the volume changes at 00:14:275 - 00:14:628 - 00:14:981 - unless you wanna emphasize the volume in crease in which case you can make it increase still by 3% starting at 00:12:863 -
So this is the part where it's gonna get a bit tricky and there's gonna be a lot of suggestions all in the sake of consistency and I really hope you go through with all of them unless I mention it's optional.
I guess some people might view this differently but hitsounds are about complimenting the song whether that's to mimic the song's instruments or to add certain rhythms to make them stand out among the music as an extra instrument. In this case we're gonna mimic the song because that seems to be more towards what you're aiming for. Okay here we go
00:15:687 (1) - Change the slider head to Normal sampleset Soft addition and remove the clap and normal addition from the slider end.
00:16:040 (2) - Change to auto addition and sample.
00:16:393 (4) - Change to auto addition, remove clap and add whistle and finish instead
00:16:746 (5) - Change to auto addition
00:16:922 (6) - Change to auto addition
00:17:099 (1) - Add whistle to slider head and get rid of the clap on the slider end
00:17:452 (2) - Change to clap
00:17:805 (4) - Add whistle and finish to slider head
00:18:157 (5) - replace finish with clap
00:18:334 (6) - Not really a hitsound suggestion but it could be a 1/8 kick slider per the sound that it makes here :v something like this
00:18:510 (1) - Add finish and whistle to slider head
00:18:863 (2) - Change to clap
00:19:216 (4) - Add whistle and finish to slider head
00:19:569 (5) - Change to whistle and clap. So what we're doing to clarify here is using the finishes to follow that big 2/1 tuba like sound and the whistles to sorta follow miku.
00:19:922 (1) - Finish and whistle on slider head
00:20:275 (2) - remove finish and change to clap and whistle
00:20:452 (1) - Remove whistle from the slider head. Add finish and whistle to slider end.
00:20:805 (2) - Remove whislte from slider head. Remove finish and add clap on slider end
00:21:334 (1) - Change to normal sampleset soft addition. Remove clap and change to finish and whistle on slider head
00:21:687 (2) - Change to clap not finish.
00:22:040 (4) - Add finish and whistle to slider head. Remove clap from slider end and also change to normal sample here.
00:22:393 (5) - Change to clap not finish.
00:22:746 (1) - Add finish and whistle to slider head
00:23:099 (2) - Change to clap not finish.
00:23:363 (4) - Change to normal sampleset. 00:23:452 (5) - Also change this to normal sampleset and soft addition, remove the clap and add Whistle and finish
00:23:805 (6) - Change to clap not finish.
00:24:157 (1) - Change to normal sampleset and soft addition, remove clap and add whistle and finish on slider head
00:24:510 (2) - Change to clap not finish.
00:24:863 (4) - Add whistle and finish to slider head
00:25:216 (5) - Change to clap not finish.
00:25:393 (6) - Add finish and whistle to slider end
00:25:922 (2) - Change to clap not finish.
00:26:275 (4) - Add whistle
00:26:628 (6) - Change to clap. You can leave the finish on this one if you prefer or not for consistency.
00:26:981 (1) - Add a finish. Arguably you don't have to but cuz you got the volume lowered which is nice it's works better.
00:35:452 (1) - Also another small suggestion but this could be a nice low SV slider that ends at either 00:36:510 - 00:36:687 - or 00:36:775 - and near the start of 00:36:863 (1) - maybe something like this. Oh also add a finish to that note/slider head.
00:38:275 - Add a volume timing here and raise it to 60%. This part's pretty awesome to just make it be so quiet. Also customs would be pretty cool for this section but since they're not here we'll improvise
00:38:275 (1) - Add a normal whistle. We're gonna use this sound to get that low kick sound. Alternatively you can use drum hitnormal but that's more complicated so let's keep it simple :v
00:38:981 (2) - Well you seem to enjoy using finishes for the clap sounds so we can do that for this section. Add a finish.
00:40:393 (2) - Add normal sampleset and soft addition.
00:41:099 (1) - Add normal addition and whistle
00:42:510 (1) - ^
00:43:922 (1) - Add finish, whistle and use normal addition instead of normal sample.
00:48:863 (1) - OOOOOOO man here I REALLY wish this was a slow sv slider that ended at 00:49:481 - something like this. (Using .75x in that screenshot)
00:49:569 (1) - Add whistle and finish to slider head as well as normal addition
00:50:275 (1) - Change to normal sample soft addition in the slider head.
00:50:981 (5) - Add whistle and change to normal sample
00:53:040 (2,3) - Again make sure to resnap these. I guess you're using 1/6 so resnap the ends only.
00:53:805 (1) - Whistle and normal addition
00:55:216 (1) - Whistle and normal addition
00:56:628 (1) - Whistle and normal addition
00:57:334 (1) - Could get rid of the whistle here if you want
01:00:863 (1) - Whistle and normal addition
01:02:275 (4) - ^
01:03:687 (1) - ^
01:04:393 (1) - Finish
01:05:099 (1) - Whistle normal addition
01:06:510 (1) - ^
01:07:922 (5) - ^
01:09:334 (1) - HERE you can do a soft whistle instead cuz of the change in the music intensity.
01:10:746 (1) - This one could use a whistle as well if you want
01:11:442 (1) - Finish on slider end
Well I guess you really like finishes instead of claps uhhhhh.....tbh I think you should definitely consider changing those to claps because for one a finish at least to me is more like what the name implies a "finisher" sort of thing so when you have them instead of claps it kinda loses its impact idk how to explain it. Ssecondly a lot of custom skins actually kinda mute or use a less subtle finish mostly because a lot of mappers tend to use the finish samples for certain custom sounds and if you were to have your skin custom hitsounds enabled you'd likely hear a bunch of finish spam so most skins tend to kinda mute or use a softer sound for that reason. Of course it seems that you are conscious of wanting finishes for your claps so I don't know how willing you would be to change that. I would urge you to PM me so we can continue with this hitsound mod in regards to the claps but for now I'll point out any other inconsistencies.
TL;DR - Let me know if you don't mind changing all your finishes to claps from this point forward and I'll help you with the hitsounding in that regard from there.
01:12:139 - Also another note you seem to use 80% volume during the uninherited timing point bpm changes but the rest uses 50% volume so might wanna keep that consistent. I would suggest keeping this entire section at about 60% volume overall. This applies to the later red points as well.
01:12:844 (3) - Could use a whistle to get that violin sound. If you agree feel free to apply them here as well: 01:13:550 (1) - 01:14:256 (4) - 01:14:962 (1) - 01:15:663 (4) - 01:16:365 (1) - 01:16:876 (1) - (slider end), 01:17:728 (1) - 01:18:390 (4) - 01:19:053 (1) - 01:19:691 (5) - (slider head)01:20:329 (1) - 01:20:950 (4) - 01:21:417 (1) - (slider end) 01:22:175 (1) - (slider head) Just make sure they're soft whistles
01:16:365 (1) - Change this to soft sampleset btw
01:16:876 (1) - Remove finish from slider end
01:19:212 (2) - Add finish to slider end
01:19:531 (3) - PLEASE remove this finish
01:19:691 (5) - And this one in the slider end thanks
01:20:010 (6) - And add the finish here using soft addition
01:20:329 - See here you go back to 50% volume when the rest was at 80 and it's very noticeable yet nothing in the music indicates softer volume. Going from the previous volume suggestion just stick to 60% and you're good.
01:22:778 (1) - Use soft addition and add a finish possibly.
01:29:498 - Nice :v
01:31:680 (1) - So for this section I'd just basically suggest adding normal whistles on notes like 01:31:680 (1) - 01:32:771 (1) - 01:33:862 (1) - etc. like I did in the other section. You can do that here as well.
01:37:680 (2) - This would be pretty cool as a slider that ends at 01:38:157 -
01:39:862 (1,2) - Also nice :v
02:33:139 - Use 60 or 70% volume for this section. It should be more intense than the previous section. And I mean this apples to every green point from 02:33:139 - to 03:07:021 -
02:35:963 (1) - Remove finish since you're using them as claps ;^)
02:38:080 (6) - And here add finish since you're using them as claps :^V
02:39:492 (2) - ^
02:40:727 (1) - Add normal sampleset to the slider end
02:40:904 (2) - Add finish :^)
02:54:316 (1) - 02:55:021 (1) - Small suggestion but you could add soft whistles to these two
02:55:727 (1) - See the problem with using finishes for claps is when you get to the section changes. Oftentimes in music you'll have a finish to indicate the transition as a FINISHER (oooooooooooo) to the previous section so when it comes time to show that we can't cuz it will blend in with 02:56:433 (1) - etc. Just pointing that out don't add a finish on (1) :v
03:03:315 (1) - Normal sample on slider head
03:03:492 (2) - Finish :^)
03:05:963 (4) - 03:06:315 (1) - Like the other small suggestion consider soft whistles here
03:23:444 (5) - This would have that nice 1/3 swing effect if it was a 1/3 slider with a reverse arrow and then if 03:23:717 (1) - was a 1/1 slider like at 03:19:353 (1) - it'd give it a nice effect. Something like this maybe (note 03:24:172 (2) - was rotated by 120 degrees clockwise as shown in the screenshot)
03:27:058 - Also another small suggestion but you could have a note here so it doesn't feel so empty and has a similar effect to 03:26:512 (1) -
03:55:435 (2) - Change to drum sample and soft addition like 03:56:620 (2) - and 03:57:851 (2) -
05:03:504 (3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Nice :v
05:09:231 (3) - Finish on slider head
05:22:791 (3) - Change slider end to normal sample. Remove whistle as well
05:23:276 (1) - Change to normal sample.
05:37:305 (2) - Remove finish from slider end and change to normal sample soft addition. You COULD also remove the whistle to add to that pause effect but that ones up to you.
05:40:217 (1) - Remove finish. Change to normal sample.
Hoyl lol the maps actually pretty cool. Crazy and weird like the song itself so I'd say it's very suitable. Not sure about some of the snaps though. Might've missed a few hitsound things cuz I started this at 4 a.m. (couldn't sleep lol) And yeah if you plan to change the finishes to claps hit me up I'll help you out and stuffz. TBH the easiest solution would be to copy the default soft-hitfinish and paste it as a soft-hitclap in the song folder so you keep that sound but move it over to a clap so it's more suitable. Then copy over the normal-hitfinish and paste it over the soft hitfinish ANYWAY....
Anyway hope this helps. Good luck!