Everlasting Snow00:08:550 (4) - Even though it's the beginning of the map and it might not seen a really big trouble, rotating it a bit to the right would improve the flow a lot. You created a nice transition on the last pattern and you could do the same here. Maybe rotating 25° clockwise would be nice!
I see what you meant there and I'd gladly do it, but in that case I should do the same for the other one before this. Basically 00:07:138 (4) - and 00:08:550 (4) - have those directions based on pitch of the note there. If I rotate by 25 degrees as you suggested I would end up with a fairly straight movement for 00:08:020 (1,2,3,4) - which imo doesn't give a great emphasis as it does right now. It is a small thing, I know, but it makes a difference for me.00:28:138 (3) - I don't feel that this kick slider fits here as perfectly as the others. You were using them either to emphasize the vocal or a specific part of the song that has a really strong beat or 1/4 rhythms, but I can't feel there's any of these parts here. In my opinion, adding a circle here would be much better, but I don't know, it might be just me.
while I can't agree on making this a circle I noticed that it is actually inconsistent with another pattern which is the same rhythm. Fixed in my own way00:39:697 - You missed a beat here, and it would be pretty bad, since you are perfectly following the consistency of the song. What do you think about adding a kick slider instead of just one circle? It definitely wouldn't break the flow, since there's a lot of sliders like these in this section, and would keep the rhythm more consistent.
same as above, and this shows how this thing was actually consistent lol00:42:432 (2) - Might consider adding another repeat for the same reason I've mentioned above.
uh... let's say you're right (because you are) but if I want to keep that beat I inevitably have to change how that whole part works, with quite big side effects on the rest of the entire first minute of mapping. Since it is not clickable it's not a big deal in the end here01:44:550 (4,5,1) - Aren't these too close to each other? If you compare with the rest, they are. You might consider increasing the DS between them for flow / consistency improvements.
managed something01:53:202 - This is more like a suggestion than anything else, since you were mostly following the vocal; don't you think that adding a circle here wouldn't be better than left it empty? It's just because it's not really nice to leave an empty sound when you have the chance to fill it. But, as I said, just my opinion! Same would apply here 03:23:373 - and here 04:53:726 -
you're again right, but in this case it is an ending vocal. By considering this and the rhythm by the the synth sound I thought of leaving it blank to let players listen to that instrument in particular and also to give a little rest01:53:903 (1) - I'm almost sure you forgot to add a Finish here, and if you didn't, you should since you added in other sections like 03:24:256 (1) - and here 00:46:138 (1) - .
I'm also sure :p04:29:550 (3,4,5) - The transition you did between (3) and (4) was kinda weird, specially considering the jump before (3), which was totally pointing that the next pattern would be to the right, but you did it the opposite way. It even confused me while playing. Don't you think that
this would be much better? I also have moved (6), so they wouldn't be so close to each other.
I must admit I did this on purpose ahahaha. I know this is not the best reason ever, but I realized I end up unconsciously making this sort of flows where I make a stop in a regular circular flow and then go back to it. For example, take in consideration 04:29:550 (3,6) - . While they are not perfectly flowy they still keep the same circular flow, right? Well, that's something I tend to do a lot and if I'd have to define it, I'd call it style since other than "I like it like that" I have no solid reasons. Imo it flows nicely enough and most testplayers didn't have problems with it. I know this is not professional, but I can't really give up on that pattern