IRC Mod on Sandwich diff, sorry if this seemed harsh, but even if you accept half of these changes you will see a massive increase in quality, if you need more help PM me personally and i'll go through it in more detail
Ok you wanted me to go through the easier diffs to so here you go
WARNING - HARSH COMMENTS INSIDE
04:38 Nierth: hey buddy
04:39 Log Off Now: hi
04:39 Nierth: will you mod one of my diffs
04:39 Log Off Now: might do later, 4:40am atm lol
04:39 Nierth: lol alright
04:39 Nierth: whenever you're free
04:39 Nierth: irc mod
04:40 Nierth: for one of my GDs
04:40 Log Off Now: kk
04:40 Nierth: i want you to roast this person
04:40 Log Off Now: why lol
04:40 Nierth: cuz its fun
04:40 Nierth: ._.
04:40 Log Off Now: lmao
04:41 *Nierth is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/927349 Aoi Eir - Cynthia No Hikari [Sandwich-kun]]
04:41 Log Off Now: oo i like this song
04:41 Nierth: i know you do
04:41 Log Off Now: want me to mod this diff?
04:41 Log Off Now: the first 4 notes are triggering already
04:41 Nierth: LOL
04:41 Nierth: you want to mod it now?
04:42 Log Off Now: why did you accept this
04:42 Log Off Now: lmfao
04:42 Log Off Now: remap kds pls
04:42 Nierth: its my friend's
04:42 Nierth: kds for you
04:42 Log Off Now: 00:16:623 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - DansGame
04:43 Nierth: wat
04:43 Nierth: pls roast my friend
04:43 Log Off Now: lmao
04:43 Nierth: never been roasted
04:43 Log Off Now: eh i may as well do a short mod now
04:44 Log Off Now: first off audio preview time conflicts with lost difficulty
04:44 Nierth: preview conflicts with all of dem
04:44 Nierth: focusing on the mapping part atm
04:44 Log Off Now: gg
04:44 Log Off Now: 00:03:431 (1,2,3,4) - this just looks ugly
04:45 Log Off Now: just use same length slider or something
04:45 Log Off Now: 00:04:696 (4) - this can be extended since it's a held note
04:45 Log Off Now: 00:05:238 - probably to here
04:46 Log Off Now: 00:06:322 (6,7) -
04:46 Log Off Now: these don't match the vocals
04:46 Log Off Now: 6 should be repeated and 7 moved to the red tick
04:46 Log Off Now: although make sure to change 7's position
04:47 Log Off Now: 00:12:828 (3) - please don't use slider shapes like this, or at least make them overlap properly so they don't look as bad as this
04:47 Log Off Now: 00:13:370 (4,5,6) - these should probably blanket
04:47 Nierth: squished sliders are the best
04:47 Log Off Now: squished sliders are the worst q.q
04:48 Log Off Now: 00:14:997 (1,2,3) - even distance spacing pls
04:48 Log Off Now: 00:16:262 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - this is fine although try to not have the circles overlap
04:48 Log Off Now: use same slider shape 00:17:888 (1,2) -
04:49 Log Off Now: 00:18:611 (1) - remove new combo
04:49 Log Off Now: 00:25:659 - missing circle, i assume following vocal and theres a vocal here thats missed
04:49 Log Off Now: ]00:26:563 (1,2,1) - even distance spacing again
04:50 Log Off Now: 00:28:009 (3,4) - because of how the rest of this map is mapped this spacing is incredibly misleading
04:50 Log Off Now: 00:28:732 (4) - also this could probably be turned into a repeating slider because of vocals and drum fill
04:50 Log Off Now: 00:30:539 (1,2) - again misleading distance spacing because of the buildup here 00:29:455 (1,2,3,4,5,6) -
04:51 Log Off Now: 00:32:346 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - again this is fine but space a little more so they dont overlap, although you might be able to get away with this one since its all even
04:51 Log Off Now: 00:33:611 (8,9,10,11) - see why can you evenly space these but not the others q.q
04:52 Log Off Now: also at this point this map is mapped in aa pretty old looking style, very linear which not many people are fans of
04:52 Nierth: this is hurting me more than it hurts you
04:52 Log Off Now: i would suggest looking at other hard difficulties (i think thats what this is?) and try to look at some of the other flows and patterns they use
04:52 Log Off Now: 00:38:129 (4,5) - make these blanket?
04:52 Log Off Now: trust me this hurts me a lot, rip fingers kek
04:53 Log Off Now: 00:38:129 (4,5,6,7) - woah i didnt even notice there were two sliders here, if you're going to do this don't perfectly stack them so they're readabke
04:53 Log Off Now: readable*
04:53 Log Off Now: 00:39:575 (1,2,3) - fix blankets
04:53 Log Off Now: 00:42:467 (5) - emphasis here isn't that great
04:53 Log Off Now: 5 ends on a really strong beat that should be clickable
04:54 Log Off Now: not gonna go through the spacing much anymore because i would basically be saying remap then lmao
04:55 Log Off Now: 00:45:720 (2,3,4) - make 2/3 overlap perfectly into the slider of 4, looks much better
04:55 Log Off Now: 00:46:443 (4) - downbeat should be clickable imo
04:56 Log Off Now: 00:54:033 (8) - instead of just one long repeating slider why not split it up into even parts?
04:56 Log Off Now: much more enjoyable to play
04:56 Log Off Now: 00:55:298 - also missing circle here
04:56 Log Off Now: makes playing 00:55:479 (1,2,3) - feel weird
04:56 Log Off Now: 00:56:563 - same here
04:57 Log Off Now: 00:58:370 (1,2,3) - not a fan of these sliders, its fine but i would suggest that you dont make them so 'tight'
04:57 Log Off Now: a more open circle shape would look way better
04:57 Log Off Now: 01:00:358 (6,7,8,9,10) - see another perfect star here with no overlaps, why didnt you do this near the start of the diff? q.q
04:58 Log Off Now: 01:06:684 (3) - change this into repeating slider? i would argue the drum fill here is more important than the vocal line, and since the vocal ends at the fill anyway it would be fine imo
04:58 Log Off Now: 01:07:406 (4,5,6,7,8) - jumps here instead? maybe another star pattern like before?
04:59 Log Off Now: 01:14:093 (9) - same comment as previous long repeating slider
04:59 Log Off Now: although imo that slider should just be a normal one
04:59 Log Off Now: 01:16:081 (3,5) - ugly overlap
04:59 Log Off Now: 01:21:503 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - maybe gradual spacing increase? also again don't perfectly stack these since they can be hard to read for people playing these diffs
05:00 Log Off Now: 01:22:407 (3,1,2,3) - although instead these should be repeating sliders
05:00 Log Off Now: 01:26:382 (1) - instead of this
05:00 Log Off Now: https://i.gyazo.com/ebcf0e8134e0f79e030 ... a51559.png try this
05:01 Log Off Now: 01:29:274 (4) - same comment as previous long repeating sliders
05:01 Log Off Now: 01:30:177 (1) - add a green inherit point sometime after the spinner and change volume to 5%
05:01 Log Off Now: so the spinner ends a lot quieter
05:01 Log Off Now: ok thats me done lol
05:01 Log Off Now: sorry if i put you off mapping forever
05:02 Nierth: short mod my ass lol
05:02 Nierth: this isnt my map
05:02 Log Off Now: when he reads the log tho
05:02 Nierth: she*
05:02 Nierth: you're gonna make her cry
05:02 Nierth: kudosu for you?
05:02 Log Off Now: yes pls
05:02 Log Off Now: let me post log
05:02 Log Off Now: can you link thread?
04:39 Log Off Now: hi
04:39 Nierth: will you mod one of my diffs
04:39 Log Off Now: might do later, 4:40am atm lol
04:39 Nierth: lol alright
04:39 Nierth: whenever you're free
04:39 Nierth: irc mod
04:40 Nierth: for one of my GDs
04:40 Log Off Now: kk
04:40 Nierth: i want you to roast this person
04:40 Log Off Now: why lol
04:40 Nierth: cuz its fun
04:40 Nierth: ._.
04:40 Log Off Now: lmao
04:41 *Nierth is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/927349 Aoi Eir - Cynthia No Hikari [Sandwich-kun]]
04:41 Log Off Now: oo i like this song
04:41 Nierth: i know you do
04:41 Log Off Now: want me to mod this diff?
04:41 Log Off Now: the first 4 notes are triggering already
04:41 Nierth: LOL
04:41 Nierth: you want to mod it now?
04:42 Log Off Now: why did you accept this
04:42 Log Off Now: lmfao
04:42 Log Off Now: remap kds pls
04:42 Nierth: its my friend's
04:42 Nierth: kds for you
04:42 Log Off Now: 00:16:623 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - DansGame
04:43 Nierth: wat
04:43 Nierth: pls roast my friend
04:43 Log Off Now: lmao
04:43 Nierth: never been roasted
04:43 Log Off Now: eh i may as well do a short mod now
04:44 Log Off Now: first off audio preview time conflicts with lost difficulty
04:44 Nierth: preview conflicts with all of dem
04:44 Nierth: focusing on the mapping part atm
04:44 Log Off Now: gg
04:44 Log Off Now: 00:03:431 (1,2,3,4) - this just looks ugly
04:45 Log Off Now: just use same length slider or something
04:45 Log Off Now: 00:04:696 (4) - this can be extended since it's a held note
04:45 Log Off Now: 00:05:238 - probably to here
04:46 Log Off Now: 00:06:322 (6,7) -
04:46 Log Off Now: these don't match the vocals
04:46 Log Off Now: 6 should be repeated and 7 moved to the red tick
04:46 Log Off Now: although make sure to change 7's position
04:47 Log Off Now: 00:12:828 (3) - please don't use slider shapes like this, or at least make them overlap properly so they don't look as bad as this
04:47 Log Off Now: 00:13:370 (4,5,6) - these should probably blanket
04:47 Nierth: squished sliders are the best
04:47 Log Off Now: squished sliders are the worst q.q
04:48 Log Off Now: 00:14:997 (1,2,3) - even distance spacing pls
04:48 Log Off Now: 00:16:262 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - this is fine although try to not have the circles overlap
04:48 Log Off Now: use same slider shape 00:17:888 (1,2) -
04:49 Log Off Now: 00:18:611 (1) - remove new combo
04:49 Log Off Now: 00:25:659 - missing circle, i assume following vocal and theres a vocal here thats missed
04:49 Log Off Now: ]00:26:563 (1,2,1) - even distance spacing again
04:50 Log Off Now: 00:28:009 (3,4) - because of how the rest of this map is mapped this spacing is incredibly misleading
04:50 Log Off Now: 00:28:732 (4) - also this could probably be turned into a repeating slider because of vocals and drum fill
04:50 Log Off Now: 00:30:539 (1,2) - again misleading distance spacing because of the buildup here 00:29:455 (1,2,3,4,5,6) -
04:51 Log Off Now: 00:32:346 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - again this is fine but space a little more so they dont overlap, although you might be able to get away with this one since its all even
04:51 Log Off Now: 00:33:611 (8,9,10,11) - see why can you evenly space these but not the others q.q
04:52 Log Off Now: also at this point this map is mapped in aa pretty old looking style, very linear which not many people are fans of
04:52 Nierth: this is hurting me more than it hurts you
04:52 Log Off Now: i would suggest looking at other hard difficulties (i think thats what this is?) and try to look at some of the other flows and patterns they use
04:52 Log Off Now: 00:38:129 (4,5) - make these blanket?
04:52 Log Off Now: trust me this hurts me a lot, rip fingers kek
04:53 Log Off Now: 00:38:129 (4,5,6,7) - woah i didnt even notice there were two sliders here, if you're going to do this don't perfectly stack them so they're readabke
04:53 Log Off Now: readable*
04:53 Log Off Now: 00:39:575 (1,2,3) - fix blankets
04:53 Log Off Now: 00:42:467 (5) - emphasis here isn't that great
04:53 Log Off Now: 5 ends on a really strong beat that should be clickable
04:54 Log Off Now: not gonna go through the spacing much anymore because i would basically be saying remap then lmao
04:55 Log Off Now: 00:45:720 (2,3,4) - make 2/3 overlap perfectly into the slider of 4, looks much better
04:55 Log Off Now: 00:46:443 (4) - downbeat should be clickable imo
04:56 Log Off Now: 00:54:033 (8) - instead of just one long repeating slider why not split it up into even parts?
04:56 Log Off Now: much more enjoyable to play
04:56 Log Off Now: 00:55:298 - also missing circle here
04:56 Log Off Now: makes playing 00:55:479 (1,2,3) - feel weird
04:56 Log Off Now: 00:56:563 - same here
04:57 Log Off Now: 00:58:370 (1,2,3) - not a fan of these sliders, its fine but i would suggest that you dont make them so 'tight'
04:57 Log Off Now: a more open circle shape would look way better
04:57 Log Off Now: 01:00:358 (6,7,8,9,10) - see another perfect star here with no overlaps, why didnt you do this near the start of the diff? q.q
04:58 Log Off Now: 01:06:684 (3) - change this into repeating slider? i would argue the drum fill here is more important than the vocal line, and since the vocal ends at the fill anyway it would be fine imo
04:58 Log Off Now: 01:07:406 (4,5,6,7,8) - jumps here instead? maybe another star pattern like before?
04:59 Log Off Now: 01:14:093 (9) - same comment as previous long repeating slider
04:59 Log Off Now: although imo that slider should just be a normal one
04:59 Log Off Now: 01:16:081 (3,5) - ugly overlap
04:59 Log Off Now: 01:21:503 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - maybe gradual spacing increase? also again don't perfectly stack these since they can be hard to read for people playing these diffs
05:00 Log Off Now: 01:22:407 (3,1,2,3) - although instead these should be repeating sliders
05:00 Log Off Now: 01:26:382 (1) - instead of this
05:00 Log Off Now: https://i.gyazo.com/ebcf0e8134e0f79e030 ... a51559.png try this
05:01 Log Off Now: 01:29:274 (4) - same comment as previous long repeating sliders
05:01 Log Off Now: 01:30:177 (1) - add a green inherit point sometime after the spinner and change volume to 5%
05:01 Log Off Now: so the spinner ends a lot quieter
05:01 Log Off Now: ok thats me done lol
05:01 Log Off Now: sorry if i put you off mapping forever
05:02 Nierth: short mod my ass lol
05:02 Nierth: this isnt my map
05:02 Log Off Now: when he reads the log tho
05:02 Nierth: she*
05:02 Nierth: you're gonna make her cry
05:02 Nierth: kudosu for you?
05:02 Log Off Now: yes pls
05:02 Log Off Now: let me post log
05:02 Log Off Now: can you link thread?
Ok you wanted me to go through the easier diffs to so here you go
LESS HARSH BUT STILL SORT OF HARSH COMMENTS INSIDE
05:12 Nierth: CHECK MY EASY/NORMAL
05:12 Log Off Now: https://www.twitch.tv/
05:12 Log Off Now: 0.91 easy wtf
05:12 Nierth: thanks buddy
05:12 Log Off Now: wow this slider speeeed
05:13 Nierth: its for people who've never touched osu before
05:13 Nierth: this map will bring us more new osu players
05:13 Log Off Now: ok if thats the case
05:13 Log Off Now: nice meme kek
05:13 Log Off Now: 00:09:214 (1) - recovery time after this spinner is too little
05:13 Nierth: no pls actualy help me
05:13 Nierth: lol
05:13 Log Off Now: even though its technically rankable since you're going for the uber noobs
05:14 Log Off Now: its still probably not enough time
05:14 Log Off Now: i would just end on the downbeat
05:14 Log Off Now: 00:12:105 (1,2) - pls make these blanket
05:14 Log Off Now: 00:21:503 (4,5) - try to not make these overlap
05:15 Log Off Now: 00:25:117 (2,3) - same comment as above
05:15 Log Off Now: oh
05:15 Log Off Now: https://i.gyazo.com/7180824486e930468f3 ... 382c3c.png fix these too
05:15 Log Off Now: they're definitely unrankable
05:16 Log Off Now: 00:39:575 (2,3) - overlap again
05:16 Log Off Now: tiny but noticeable
05:16 Log Off Now: 00:27:286 (1) - remove new combo
05:16 Log Off Now: 00:28:009 (2) - start new combo here
05:16 Log Off Now: 00:29:455 (1) - remove new combo
05:17 Log Off Now: 00:41:021 (4) - new combo
05:17 Log Off Now: 00:46:804 (1,2) - blanket can be improved, its uneven on both sides atm
05:17 Log Off Now: move the middle slider point on 2 inwards a little more
05:17 Log Off Now: 00:49:696 (3,4) - fix blanket and overlap
05:18 Log Off Now: 00:55:479 (1) - same comment as first spinner
05:18 Log Off Now: 01:04:153 (4,5) - overlaps like these in easies are unrankable, and this also is a bit of a flow break considering the direction of the repeat slider
05:18 Log Off Now: i would move the 5 to the right of the slider and continue the combo that way
05:19 Log Off Now: 01:14:997 (3,4) - consider making 4 blanket 3?
05:19 Log Off Now: 01:21:503 (3) - consider making the top half of this slider blanket 2? do this by using a mixture of grey and red slider points
05:19 Log Off Now: 01:30:449 (1) - move spinner to downbeat
05:20 Log Off Now: kk thats the easy diff
05:20 Log Off Now: although i would reccommend look at your combo structure since i dont really see one tbh XD
05:21 Log Off Now: for normal 00:13:190 (3,4) - distance snap needs fixing, the rest of the diff is fine ds wise
05:21 Log Off Now: again same comment about new combos
05:22 Nierth: is this what you do for a living
05:22 Nierth: make people cry
05:22 Log Off Now: im so sorry
05:22 Log Off Now: but you asked for it XD
05:22 Log Off Now: + everything is to help you improve
05:22 Log Off Now: 00:29:455 (1,2,3) - pretty big flow breaks even for a normal diff although without remapping the shape of this idk what to change, might be fine as it is but idk
05:23 Log Off Now: 00:33:069 (3) - rotate this 33 degrees and move it back to original spot for better shape + flow
05:23 Log Off Now: ctrl + shift + r if you didnt know how to rotate
05:23 Log Off Now: 00:34:876 (6,1) - consider making 1 blanket 6?
05:23 Log Off Now: also you know some 1/2 is allowed in normals diffs? XD
05:24 Log Off Now: this is entirely 1/1
05:24 Log Off Now: 00:47:527 (6) - delete this and just copy 00:46:804 (5) - and rotate 90 degrees for better look/shape
05:25 Log Off Now: 00:55:479 - why no note here? tbh i think you should map where the break is although i can understand why you've put it here
05:25 Log Off Now: up to you really
05:25 Log Off Now: 01:11:382 (3,4,5,6) - don't make these stack perfectly, hard to read for noobs
05:26 Log Off Now: ok thats it for normal
05:12 Log Off Now: https://www.twitch.tv/
05:12 Log Off Now: 0.91 easy wtf
05:12 Nierth: thanks buddy
05:12 Log Off Now: wow this slider speeeed
05:13 Nierth: its for people who've never touched osu before
05:13 Nierth: this map will bring us more new osu players
05:13 Log Off Now: ok if thats the case
05:13 Log Off Now: nice meme kek
05:13 Log Off Now: 00:09:214 (1) - recovery time after this spinner is too little
05:13 Nierth: no pls actualy help me
05:13 Nierth: lol
05:13 Log Off Now: even though its technically rankable since you're going for the uber noobs
05:14 Log Off Now: its still probably not enough time
05:14 Log Off Now: i would just end on the downbeat
05:14 Log Off Now: 00:12:105 (1,2) - pls make these blanket
05:14 Log Off Now: 00:21:503 (4,5) - try to not make these overlap
05:15 Log Off Now: 00:25:117 (2,3) - same comment as above
05:15 Log Off Now: oh
05:15 Log Off Now: https://i.gyazo.com/7180824486e930468f3 ... 382c3c.png fix these too
05:15 Log Off Now: they're definitely unrankable
05:16 Log Off Now: 00:39:575 (2,3) - overlap again
05:16 Log Off Now: tiny but noticeable
05:16 Log Off Now: 00:27:286 (1) - remove new combo
05:16 Log Off Now: 00:28:009 (2) - start new combo here
05:16 Log Off Now: 00:29:455 (1) - remove new combo
05:17 Log Off Now: 00:41:021 (4) - new combo
05:17 Log Off Now: 00:46:804 (1,2) - blanket can be improved, its uneven on both sides atm
05:17 Log Off Now: move the middle slider point on 2 inwards a little more
05:17 Log Off Now: 00:49:696 (3,4) - fix blanket and overlap
05:18 Log Off Now: 00:55:479 (1) - same comment as first spinner
05:18 Log Off Now: 01:04:153 (4,5) - overlaps like these in easies are unrankable, and this also is a bit of a flow break considering the direction of the repeat slider
05:18 Log Off Now: i would move the 5 to the right of the slider and continue the combo that way
05:19 Log Off Now: 01:14:997 (3,4) - consider making 4 blanket 3?
05:19 Log Off Now: 01:21:503 (3) - consider making the top half of this slider blanket 2? do this by using a mixture of grey and red slider points
05:19 Log Off Now: 01:30:449 (1) - move spinner to downbeat
05:20 Log Off Now: kk thats the easy diff
05:20 Log Off Now: although i would reccommend look at your combo structure since i dont really see one tbh XD
05:21 Log Off Now: for normal 00:13:190 (3,4) - distance snap needs fixing, the rest of the diff is fine ds wise
05:21 Log Off Now: again same comment about new combos
05:22 Nierth: is this what you do for a living
05:22 Nierth: make people cry
05:22 Log Off Now: im so sorry
05:22 Log Off Now: but you asked for it XD
05:22 Log Off Now: + everything is to help you improve
05:22 Log Off Now: 00:29:455 (1,2,3) - pretty big flow breaks even for a normal diff although without remapping the shape of this idk what to change, might be fine as it is but idk
05:23 Log Off Now: 00:33:069 (3) - rotate this 33 degrees and move it back to original spot for better shape + flow
05:23 Log Off Now: ctrl + shift + r if you didnt know how to rotate
05:23 Log Off Now: 00:34:876 (6,1) - consider making 1 blanket 6?
05:23 Log Off Now: also you know some 1/2 is allowed in normals diffs? XD
05:24 Log Off Now: this is entirely 1/1
05:24 Log Off Now: 00:47:527 (6) - delete this and just copy 00:46:804 (5) - and rotate 90 degrees for better look/shape
05:25 Log Off Now: 00:55:479 - why no note here? tbh i think you should map where the break is although i can understand why you've put it here
05:25 Log Off Now: up to you really
05:25 Log Off Now: 01:11:382 (3,4,5,6) - don't make these stack perfectly, hard to read for noobs
05:26 Log Off Now: ok thats it for normal