- I'm going to soon upload a temporary keysounded version of Skyloft, made by mithew. (I can't upload it right now because the audio files are too large sadly). I'd like to possibly hear feedback from what you have to say about the keysounding and if the feedback is mostly positive, I will consider adding it to the set. Thank you!
Will edit this post with response to mods in a bit.
pishifat
fixed all the non-smoother ones (hopefully). should have cleaner flow now. thank you!
pishifat
fixed all the non-smoother ones (hopefully). should have cleaner flow now. thank you!
Kuuma
Skyloft
00:20:506 (1,1,1) - im going to say the same thing here that i said for hard. The fact that you did it twice and smoothie even did leads me to believe you have a reasoning for doing this that i just cant seem to figure out. So even if you leave this, please take into account the strong note at 00:21:158. It needs to be clickable, otherwise it just doesnt feel right. You're right, but the problem with this part is that to most people, it feels like 1/3 despite it being normal 1/4 in the song, so I made the repeat sliders go over the strong part to not mess up players.
00:29:310 (2,3,4) - not sure why these notes are getting closer together.. Seems random I like this effect, i feel like it represents the piano better. This whole "moving forward but stopping short" thingy to me adds to the melancholy feeling the piano seems to have in this section.
00:31:919 (2,3,4) - same for these.. Why is the 4 so close to the 3.. You obviiously intended to do it, i just dont understand why/dont agree, its your map though. If you do decide to change this, make sure to change the ones after it too ^
00:40:723 (1,2) - i think the movement would better the capture the song if you ctrl + g this, and then also why not just line it up with 00:39:419 (1,2) ?? if you notice at 00:28:984 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - how i overlapped both of them but with different scaling, i did the same thing for 00:40:723 (1,2) - but i reduced the spacing instead of increasing it to indicate how the song is getting smaller in intensity before getting strong at 00:41:375 (1,2,3,4,1) -
you mapped the kiai beautifully that's always a nice thing to hear. thank you!!
01:31:593 (1) - move to x:188 y:244? ooh, i like that blanket idea. moved.
Hard
00:20:506 (1,1,1) - The instrument starts on the first circle. Just delete 00:20:506 (1), and then move the the two reverse sliders so the first one is at 00:20:506. Also: DEFINITELY put a clickable object at 00:21:158. That is a very powerful note same reason as Skyloft diff, also if you look at ktgster's mod i feel like this mroe accurately represents the rhythm here.
00:31:593 (1,2,3,4) - i dont like the lowered spacing here… and also the spacing for 00:34:202 (1,2,3,4) isnt consistent with 00:31:593 (1,2,3,4) I lowered it because the song seemed to lower in intensity at this part, but I feel like i lowered it too much so i increased it a bit.
00:47:245 (1,2) - these sliders are too close together moved a bit
Kiai - I love the way you mapped this part, good job c:
01:52:462 (1,2) - flip one of these sliders vertically good idea, moved
Advanced
00:02:245 (2,2) - I dont think you should stack these. Different piano note then the one before it and so it feels better to have to move your pen to play it. Like what you did 00:12:680 (2,2) and in the outro true, changed
00:38:767 - youre missing a circle here. Make it consistent with 00:33:549 (1,1) woops, these notes shouldn't have been there, fixed
00:59:636 (4,1) - you should blanket this like how you blanketed 00:57:028 (4,1)
01:02:897 (1) - A few things about this circle. 1) I think you should move it to x:168 y:160 in order to make the movement flow better.. Having such an abrupt pen movement like how you have it for this very smooth piano part just doesnt feel right. Even something like x:144 y:64 would be better. 2) This note is so powerful, i think a slider would do it way more justice. moved to what you specified, but i kept it a circle because to me it seems more powerful than a slider :p
01:07:788 (1) - this doesnt have to be a nc. Make it consistent like 01:13:006 (4) fixed (and now to colorhax again aaaaaaaaaa)
Kuuma
Skyloft
00:20:506 (1,1,1) - im going to say the same thing here that i said for hard. The fact that you did it twice and smoothie even did leads me to believe you have a reasoning for doing this that i just cant seem to figure out. So even if you leave this, please take into account the strong note at 00:21:158. It needs to be clickable, otherwise it just doesnt feel right. You're right, but the problem with this part is that to most people, it feels like 1/3 despite it being normal 1/4 in the song, so I made the repeat sliders go over the strong part to not mess up players.
00:29:310 (2,3,4) - not sure why these notes are getting closer together.. Seems random I like this effect, i feel like it represents the piano better. This whole "moving forward but stopping short" thingy to me adds to the melancholy feeling the piano seems to have in this section.
00:31:919 (2,3,4) - same for these.. Why is the 4 so close to the 3.. You obviiously intended to do it, i just dont understand why/dont agree, its your map though. If you do decide to change this, make sure to change the ones after it too ^
00:40:723 (1,2) - i think the movement would better the capture the song if you ctrl + g this, and then also why not just line it up with 00:39:419 (1,2) ?? if you notice at 00:28:984 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - how i overlapped both of them but with different scaling, i did the same thing for 00:40:723 (1,2) - but i reduced the spacing instead of increasing it to indicate how the song is getting smaller in intensity before getting strong at 00:41:375 (1,2,3,4,1) -
you mapped the kiai beautifully that's always a nice thing to hear. thank you!!
01:31:593 (1) - move to x:188 y:244? ooh, i like that blanket idea. moved.
Hard
00:20:506 (1,1,1) - The instrument starts on the first circle. Just delete 00:20:506 (1), and then move the the two reverse sliders so the first one is at 00:20:506. Also: DEFINITELY put a clickable object at 00:21:158. That is a very powerful note same reason as Skyloft diff, also if you look at ktgster's mod i feel like this mroe accurately represents the rhythm here.
00:31:593 (1,2,3,4) - i dont like the lowered spacing here… and also the spacing for 00:34:202 (1,2,3,4) isnt consistent with 00:31:593 (1,2,3,4) I lowered it because the song seemed to lower in intensity at this part, but I feel like i lowered it too much so i increased it a bit.
00:47:245 (1,2) - these sliders are too close together moved a bit
Kiai - I love the way you mapped this part, good job c:
01:52:462 (1,2) - flip one of these sliders vertically good idea, moved
Advanced
00:02:245 (2,2) - I dont think you should stack these. Different piano note then the one before it and so it feels better to have to move your pen to play it. Like what you did 00:12:680 (2,2) and in the outro true, changed
00:38:767 - youre missing a circle here. Make it consistent with 00:33:549 (1,1) woops, these notes shouldn't have been there, fixed
00:59:636 (4,1) - you should blanket this like how you blanketed 00:57:028 (4,1)
01:02:897 (1) - A few things about this circle. 1) I think you should move it to x:168 y:160 in order to make the movement flow better.. Having such an abrupt pen movement like how you have it for this very smooth piano part just doesnt feel right. Even something like x:144 y:64 would be better. 2) This note is so powerful, i think a slider would do it way more justice. moved to what you specified, but i kept it a circle because to me it seems more powerful than a slider :p
01:07:788 (1) - this doesnt have to be a nc. Make it consistent like 01:13:006 (4) fixed (and now to colorhax again aaaaaaaaaa)
missa1912
00:20:669 (1,1) - in here what about make this like: http://puu.sh/pY5lD/d3e8661006.jpg to make 00:21:158 - clickeable(? same reason as kuuma's mod
00:50:832 (4) - stack this slider with 00:51:810 (1) - to evoid that overlap true, fixed
01:17:571 (3,5) - move a bit to the left so (5) can make a blank with 01:18:386 (7) - and (3) will flow better imo moved a bit
Advanced
00:03:875 (2,1,2,3) - make these a triangle and stack 00:03:875 (2,1) - changed to something else from kuuma's mod and i think it works pretty well
01:02:571 (5,6,1,2) - this can be confusing, sugesstion: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5586929 that's actually what kuuma suggested, fixed c:
01:41:375 (4,5,1,2,3) - this part can be more symetrical, to evoid some overlaps, like: 01:40:723 (3,1) - 01:41:375 (4,3) - true, fixed
01:49:528 (3,1) - blanket(? done
missa1912
00:20:669 (1,1) - in here what about make this like: http://puu.sh/pY5lD/d3e8661006.jpg to make 00:21:158 - clickeable(? same reason as kuuma's mod
00:50:832 (4) - stack this slider with 00:51:810 (1) - to evoid that overlap true, fixed
01:17:571 (3,5) - move a bit to the left so (5) can make a blank with 01:18:386 (7) - and (3) will flow better imo moved a bit
Advanced
00:03:875 (2,1,2,3) - make these a triangle and stack 00:03:875 (2,1) - changed to something else from kuuma's mod and i think it works pretty well
01:02:571 (5,6,1,2) - this can be confusing, sugesstion: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5586929 that's actually what kuuma suggested, fixed c:
01:41:375 (4,5,1,2,3) - this part can be more symetrical, to evoid some overlaps, like: 01:40:723 (3,1) - 01:41:375 (4,3) - true, fixed
01:49:528 (3,1) - blanket(? done
_DT3
[Hard]
00:05:506 (1,2) - Can be adjusted to stack (2) with (5) i think it's fine
00:06:810 (3,4,1) - Blanket looks nice, but the overlap troubles me a bit... made it less ugly i think
00:31:593 (1,2,3,4) - Why not the same spacing as here: 00:30:288 (1,2,3,4) - etc.? same reason as kuuma's mod
01:51:158 (3) - You use skystar wave sliders? Ok then ^^ (Just a comment) yeeeeeeee
[Advanced]
00:01:593 (1) - I feel like this NC is unnecessary but it might be intentional (Same with 00:04:201 (1) - ) fits Skyloft more because it had it there aswell
00:05:506 (1) - Why not stacked perfectly? they're not? i changed it a bit from previous mods hopefully it's perfect by then
00:05:506 (1,2,1,2) - What about something like this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5586483 i kinda like it better when it's side to side like that
00:18:223 (5,1,2,3) - Same as in Normal, the overlap is barely visible while playing but doesn't look good imo tried to make it as pretty as i could
00:22:462 - I feel like this beat is strong. This should be mapped imo with a HC even if that was intentional it was mapped to the piano/flute synth for this part, did the same thing for Skyloft/hard
00:25:071 - ^
00:27:680 - ^
00:30:288 - Same here but a slider is better because the beat here is kinda connected with the beat here 00:30:615
00:40:071 (3,4,1,2) - Kinda don't like the look of this constellation did a blanket, hopefully it looks nicer
01:02:734 (6) - I think it's best if stacked with (5) nah
01:12:517 (2,3,4,5,1) - Plays weird imo i think it's fine, flow is nice
01:49:528 (3,1) - Why is there no blanket here? Would fit made one from previous mod
01:53:767 (3,4,5,6) - Could look better fixed
00:05:506 (1,2) - Can be adjusted to stack (2) with (5) i think it's fine
00:06:810 (3,4,1) - Blanket looks nice, but the overlap troubles me a bit... made it less ugly i think
00:31:593 (1,2,3,4) - Why not the same spacing as here: 00:30:288 (1,2,3,4) - etc.? same reason as kuuma's mod
01:51:158 (3) - You use skystar wave sliders? Ok then ^^ (Just a comment) yeeeeeeee
[Advanced]
00:01:593 (1) - I feel like this NC is unnecessary but it might be intentional (Same with 00:04:201 (1) - ) fits Skyloft more because it had it there aswell
00:05:506 (1) - Why not stacked perfectly? they're not? i changed it a bit from previous mods hopefully it's perfect by then
00:05:506 (1,2,1,2) - What about something like this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5586483 i kinda like it better when it's side to side like that
00:18:223 (5,1,2,3) - Same as in Normal, the overlap is barely visible while playing but doesn't look good imo tried to make it as pretty as i could
00:22:462 - I feel like this beat is strong. This should be mapped imo with a HC even if that was intentional it was mapped to the piano/flute synth for this part, did the same thing for Skyloft/hard
00:25:071 - ^
00:27:680 - ^
00:30:288 - Same here but a slider is better because the beat here is kinda connected with the beat here 00:30:615
00:40:071 (3,4,1,2) - Kinda don't like the look of this constellation did a blanket, hopefully it looks nicer
01:02:734 (6) - I think it's best if stacked with (5) nah
01:12:517 (2,3,4,5,1) - Plays weird imo i think it's fine, flow is nice
01:49:528 (3,1) - Why is there no blanket here? Would fit made one from previous mod
01:53:767 (3,4,5,6) - Could look better fixed
Updated deetz' and Smoothie World's diffs aswell from previous mods. Currently waiting on a hitsound mod from Naitoshi and a BN check from nathan c:
Thank you everyone! Expect a mod back in the next couple of days.