forum

Sigma Ft Paloma Faith - Changing [Osu|Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
201
show more
Topic Starter
Hula
It's fine. Thanks though :)

I can place a circle there and have more of it circle outside the grid, so it can't be out of playfoeld
Monstrata
Dropping my two cents, since Hula told me to mae a post...

GN's Medium is quite inconsistent about spacing and NC choice.

  1. 00:42:601 (1) - 1.00 > 1.20 for no real reason of emphasis. It just makes the structure look unpolished.
  2. 00:43:478 (3,4) - Compare the spacing there to here, and you see it goes from 1.20 to 0.83. The spacing's are just so widely different in such a short timeframe.
  3. 00:46:811 (4,1,2) - To a lesser extent, you can see it here too.
  4. 00:47:337 (1,2) - Shouldn't the NC be swapped here? You've been NC'ing to every 2nd measure up until here.
  5. 00:49:267 (1) - And this shouldn't be NC"ed. It should instead be on 00:50:671 (4) - ., And consequently 00:52:074 (1) - should have its NC removed.
  6. 00:54:180 (2,1,2) - Spacing here is also noticeably uneven.
  7. 01:06:636 - Also, the blue combo color really blends into the BG here. You might want to use a different combo color here
  8. 01:56:636 (1) - You NC here but not 02:02:074 (3) - . It seems inconsistent and I like the 2-measure approach better.
  9. 02:05:934 (1,2) - Same as earlier, the NC's should be swapped, and you should NC on the 2nd downbeat because right now, you're swapping between one-measure patterns, and two-measure patterns, and it's resulting in places like 02:09:267 - which should be NC'ed (start of a new stanza) being left as part of a previous combo.
Let me know if you have questions.
Topic Starter
Hula
I didn't tell you to make a post.

You threatened me with a DQ mod and I said, go ahead, wahtever.

Gonna tell GN he got a mod to look at to see if it's valid :)


p.s. i like that you're worried about such small DS changes despite the spacing in your current maps ;)



Looks like we got another Wafu on our hands!
Akali
Every map deserves a little bit of drama
Voli
really? an attempt to revenge DQ?

it's obviously fine to mod qualified maps with how the system currently works but trying to target a map out of personal antagonism because of your own map is low.
Topic Starter
Hula
In case -GN doesn't reply quickly or something.

@Monstrata

Your issues with the DS stuff. I remember GN saying something along the lines of that he was heavily pattern-orientated when making this map. It's not meant to be a totally standard diff, and I like that for the level of difficulty his diff is aimed at. It's different, it's variety in its least extreme forms for new/low skilled osu! players. When you look at the map from a pattern perspective, it looks really nice. Thanks for your concern though :)


About the colour thing. It's fine, it's turquoise against dark blue, on the SB. Otherwise, turn off the SB, no problems.
Voli
Looking at the past mods, the DS things with GN's diff were thoroughly revised many times already (since it used to be the easiest difficulty), and that is why Hula decided to add an easier difficulty. I see no reason to further discuss these points.
Arphimigon

Voli wrote:

Looking at the past mods, the DS things with GN's diff were thoroughly revised many times already (since it used to be the easiest difficulty), and that is why Hula decided to add an easier difficulty. I see no reason to further discuss these points.
Can agree, normals or above easies can break DS minorly without it really being a problem.
Source: Myself for reference because I actually remember what it was like to suck
Battle
lol
Toy

Hula wrote:

It's fine. Thanks though :)

I can place a circle there and have more of it circle outside the grid, so it can't be out of playfoeld

okay cool, i was just asking because it's offscreen if you don't use a widescreen resolution http://puu.sh/pQQIn/c585dcaea0.jpg
Sonnyc
Offscreen normally gets analyzed 4:3, and it is fine here. :3 http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5541719
Topic Starter
Hula
8)
Raiden
Hm, why is the Oni SV1.6?
Zare
trash
Nwolf
Kurosanyan is anti-meta and it just was his choice


also he's non-existant now so hard to ask him
Topic Starter
Hula

Raiden wrote:

Hm, why is the Oni SV1.6?

I asked you to mod the taikos about 5 billion times on this set fyi, could've asked me the many months it was pending :p, and cos it's kurosanyan, a pro taiko mapper o/
Raiden
I knew you'd bring that up lmao

It's not a real problem when it comes to overall play but our guidelines specify 1.4 for a reason (best readability by consensus).
Topic Starter
Hula
:p

But, this won't affect how much people like the map too much, right? D: And to be quite honest I didn't know there was a suggested SV guideline thing for taiko, but the SV never got brought up before this.
Raiden
As I said, it's totally fine but it was worth mentioning. Just so it doesn't get out of hand lol

In 99% of the cases SV1.4 is better, though. (2.1 for 1/3 snapped low BPM songs, 2.8 for really low BPM songs, 0.7 for really high BPM, etc.)
Topic Starter
Hula
Cool. And thanks for finally looking at the map!
Gero
You did it, congratulations.
Arphimigon
YEAH
Topic Starter
Hula
we did it bois!
-GN
congrats on ranking! thanks based hula

i never heard about monstrata's mod and the more i look at that map again the more i suspect it was replaced with an earlier version before the time i respaced every object in the map. it's too late to do something about it now though. i see the NCs as a subjective thing and think they work just fine
Topic Starter
Hula
Lol probably, but oh well! I remmeber you saying things about it being pattern based and the map does look pretty imo
-GN
well i doubt anyone cares at this point. as you said, i've worked too damn hard for a normal diff lol
Topic Starter
Hula
Yep, when more effort and shit has been done than for the peak difficulty, you know you've done your fair share.

Thanks again! :D
Arphimigon
Yep, when more effort and shit has been done than for the peak difficulty, you know you've done your fair share.
Fookin -GN is the real MVP in this mapset
Yuii-
Completely agree. GN carried us so hard.
Monstrata
You guys should really be more accepting of criticism, especially since you like to go out of your way to mod people's maps post-qualified xD. I'm not trying to revenge dq, that's like, some high school drama thing lmao. I coulda mentioned the stuff Zare posted in #modhelp and expanded on the mod, but I didn't want to spend more than 5 minutes on this lol. Anyways, I'm responding to the comments now that the map is ranked so I won't cause any heated drama.

So much for telling -GN about my mod though :P. I hope this Medium is the final version -GN had wanted to submit, because what good is all the effort put in if it's not even seen? As well, "a lot of effort/work has already been done" is not a good excuse to deny any mod, sadly. I hope the disqualification system can be more transparent going forward so we can know why a QAT has decided to either disqualify a map, or chosen not to take any action.
Voli

Monstrata wrote:

I didn't want to spend more than 5 minutes on this lol.
why did you care to post anything at all anyways then?

also, you did try to revenge DQ, as you literally said ''oh, i bet i can point out so many things aswell on your map, i can mod it at any time ;)'' in #modhelp after your map was DQ'd earlier.
diraimur
gz hula and every gd owner, nice set!
JBHyperion
Let's keep the thread clean and not attack one another, please.
Topic Starter
Hula
Lol okay.

Monstrata. Gj for being a hypocrit
Arphimigon
I'm just glad the set is ranked at this stage, let's all sit and enjoy some nice music.
felys
next time try to care more for the timing please, this is at least 20ms off
Topic Starter
Hula
Would you care to say which direction it is off? Cos this has been this offset for the past bloody 7 months and is fine to me.
felys
-20, maybe a little less, -16/18
Arphimigon
Everything is changing, even the offset.
Topic Starter
Hula

Arphimigon wrote:

Everything is changing, even the offset.
In a bit, I'm really short on time to play games for a couple of months though 8).
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply