Rendyindo wrote:

From My modding queue!
Here are some of my opinion
Advanced
00:21:396 (1) - move to x:272 y:152 breaks DS
00:21:864 (2) - Edit the middle dot (or anything that name) to x:440 y:210 (CTRL + Right button) nah
00:44:989 - Add a circle at x:184 y:128 i want to keep plenty of breaks so its a smoother transition from normal
00:47:177 - Add a circle at x:288 y:80 ^^
01:34:521 (2) - I prefer CTRL + G this changed, but got rid of blanket for DS purposes

1. 00:05:771 (4) - see this hitsound whatever or however you got it there it should be on 00:05:458 (3) - as well, it sounds way nicer imo
2. 00:08:271 (5) - same here put that hitsound on 00:07:958 (3) - and so on for the similar beats
3. 02:17:646 (3,4,5,6) - idk why but this feels weird and out of tune, but that may be just me
4. 02:40:927 (4) - if im not mistaken this touches the progress bar which will disqualify from what i seen

1. 01:27:021 (3) - the progress bar thingy
2. 02:23:896 (1) - this part should be quiter tbh it should be like 20% volume, since all you can hear is clicks atm which is eeeeh
3. 02:43:896 (6) - again ^

C00L wrote:

ello

[General]
Inconsistency in combo colours every diff has more colours except the last one Ookami to Akazukin yeah im gonna change that after I catch all the major problems with that diff since colorhaxing is a pain in the butt if im gonna have to redo the combo changes everytime
Inconsistency in Preview time again the last diff has a different offset fixed

[Timing]
checked

[Ai-Mod]
Normal Diff has DS issues fixed but ill probably end up remapping that diff anyways since its kinda ugly imo

[Ookami to akazukin]

1. 00:05:771 (4) - see this hitsound whatever or however you got it there it should be on 00:05:458 (3) - as well, it sounds way nicer imo I think I will add the soft hitclap to the normal soundset.
2. 00:08:271 (5) - same here put that hitsound on 00:07:958 (3) - and so on for the similar beats yeah ok
3. 02:17:646 (3,4,5,6) - idk why but this feels weird and out of tune, but that may be just me probably because weird rhythm and weird drums, but i cant change that
4. 02:40:927 (4) - if im not mistaken this touches the progress bar which will disqualify from what i seen should be fixed

looks aight

[Insane]

1. 01:27:021 (3) - the progress bar thingy should be fixed
2. 02:23:896 (1) - this part should be quiter tbh it should be like 20% volume, since all you can hear is clicks atm which is eeeeh fixed
3. 02:43:896 (6) - again ^ i can barely hear the hitsounds already so nah

Can't find much tbh since it's pretty nicely mapped imo

Hueon wrote:

[Insane]

NC

I'm not sure
worst mod ever

00:15:927 (7) - NC here
00:18:427 (6) - NC
00:20:927 (7) - NC
00:25:771 (6) - NC
01:15:771 (3) - NC
01:18:427 (3) - NC
01:25:771 (6) - NC
01:38:271 (3) - NC
02:15:927 (6) - NC
02:43:583 (5) - NC changed

In itself, it is very hard to be an Insane. Very abrupt and rude. rude? also hard prob because general DS
But still good the mapset, GJ

Grim Rapper wrote:

my God over 1 month, I'm so sorry... dont worry, Im still in the process of editing!

Easy

This is too hard for an Easy (not EZ mod) player, so here are my suggestion cant change DS or SV any more cuz itll be too cluttered and look bad
00:08:896 (1,2,3,4,5) - Replace the 3 note into slider-reversed fixed
00:15:662 (1,2,3,4,5) - Change the 4th and 5th note into a slider fixed
00:17:958 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ fixed
00:20:667 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ fixed
00:25:458 (1,2,3,4,5) - Change the 4th and 5th note into a 2x slider-reversed what?
00:28:114 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ ^
01:25:302 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ ^
01:28:123 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ ^
00:31:558 - add a note? there's a beat here no 1/2 beat for this diff
00:45:458 (1,2,3,4) - change the 4th note into a slider i dont have a 4th note here
00:49:521 (1,2,3,4) - Stack one note on 2nd note and 4th note there is no 4th note, also Easy shouldn't have close stacks
01:00:458 (1,2) - Change the 2nd note into a slider that would mean itd have to use 1/2 beat, too fast for easy
01:13:427 (1,2,3,4) - Stack the 1st note on 2nd note cant stack on easy
01:20:458 (1,2,3,4) - Remove the 4th note why? that leaves uneccessary space
01:29:208 (1,2,3,4) - It's awkward to hit between 2nd and 3rd note,dunno how to fix it use your imagination XD seems fine to me
01:45:771 (1,2,3,4) - The 4th note isn't sync with the 3rd one [I'd even use 25% and didn't see it sync] i dont understand what youre saying
02:13:739 (1,2,3,4,5) - I personally agree with the 3 notes pattern, but replace it to a slider-reversed because the beat that follows are so weak fixed

Normal

It's actually mapped pretty good, but it doesn't suit for "Normal" difficulty what do you mean by that
00:31:396 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Stack another note on the "2" slider what note? and where on the timeline would I put it?
00:36:023 (5,1,2) - Remove the 5th note (I didn't hear any beat that follow the note) i dont know where you are but the drum is quite clear to me
00:51:802 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - There's a beat between 3rd and 4th note, maybe you can add something? again, use your imagination XD ok, but the design will be pretty cluttered.
01:00:146 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Change the stack of the 2nd note to the 3rd note instead at the 1st slider-end nah cuz 1. 3 is too far away and gotta do proper DS and 2. if I move 3 closer then there'll be a double overlap/stack with slider 1 and I dont want that. I ended up getting rid of the stack.
01:31:239 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Add a note at the 2nd slider-head what note/where timeline
FACK, I DIDN'T KNOW YOU'LL REMAP THIS DIFF lol sorry, its mostly just design remapping. rhythm is good to go for modding

Advanced

E>N>A>H>I>X? ,was it E>N>H>A>I>X? well normally I see Advanced difficulties around 2.5-2.9ish stars or something, and Hard difficulties usually sit around 3. Anyway, if there's an error I'll just let BNs catch it and it'll be a quick fix.
I'm lazy, will update n different post

Hard

I'm lazy, will update in different post

Insane

I'm lazy, will update in different post

Ookami no Akazukin

I'm lazy, will update in different post

1. Widescreen Support is not disabled in Advanced ~ Hard ~ Ookami to Akazukin diffs

1. 00:26:239 (9) - start nc from here
2. 02:17:646 - use 1/3 snap divisor here ~ for all these 02:17:646 (3,4,5,6,7) -

1. 00:44:833 (4) - move it 1 grid down
2. 00:46:239 (5) - start nc from here?
3. 00:51:083 - why is there no note?
4. 01:14:521 (4) - move it 3 grids to right
5. 01:38:427 (4) - move to 252,185
6. 01:51:083 - add circle .w.
7. 02:46:083 (4) - move to 122,300
8. 02:52:333 - again circle ;w;
9. 03:17:646 - maybe add ncs like
   

DeRandom Otaku wrote:

Hi ~ queue and stuff~

General :

1. Widescreen Support is not disabled in Advanced ~ Hard ~ Ookami to Akazukin diffs fixed

Ookami to Akazukin :

1. 00:26:239 (9) - start nc from here the next note is more important tho
2. 02:17:646 - use 1/3 snap divisor here ~ for all these 02:17:646 (3,4,5,6,7) - this works way better, thanks dude!

Insane :

1. 00:44:833 (4) - move it 1 grid down why? this is stacked
2. 00:46:239 (5) - start nc from here? nope, next phrase starts on the next note
3. 00:51:083 - why is there no note? for emphasis on the crash cymbals, but i will consider adding
4. 01:14:521 (4) - move it 3 grids to right this is a blanket
5. 01:38:427 (4) - move to 252,185 DS too small
6. 01:51:083 - add circle .w. same
7. 02:46:083 (4) - move to 122,300 fixed blanket
8. 02:52:333 - again circle ;w; same
9. 03:17:646 - maybe add ncs like that style of NC misses the finish emphasis
   

Thats all ~

Good Luck!~

100bit wrote:

Hey from my queue, my name is Max 100bit, and this is my mod!
Well, opinion of modder is opinion of modder.
Do not judge strictly, I could be wrong.
And yep, I am just learning. My english is bad, so sorry for googletranslate.
P.S. What about searching of BNs?:D I'll do that as soon as im 99% happy with my mapset

Song and beatmaps

None here...
Nice skin:D Thanks!

Easy

00:23:896 (1,3) - identical nah
00:31:864 (5) - maybe nc here? fixed
00:58:896 (1) - make sliderpoints away from each other (and copy 00:58:896 (1,1) because it's identical) i dont think i understand
01:00:146 (1) - i don't see any reason to nc here fixed
01:33:896 (1) - Ctrl+G here? nah
01:39:521 (2) - make sliderpoint closer to the top (like in %image%) sure
01:47:646 (3) - slider break this map, i think. Can you make two sliders instead one? yup
02:48:896 (3) - ^ yup
03:22:646 (1,1,1) - change to slider?:D sure

Normal

00:27:489 (6) - nc messed up NC pattern somewhere else, fixed that instead
01:34:989 (4) - strange slider, i think... lol yeah but i like it so ill keep it for now XD
02:24:208 (5) - nc? NC on the previous note instead
02:32:646 (3,4) - identical sure
02:48:896 (3) - same as in Easy fixed
02:53:583 (3) - ^ fixed

Advanced

You have some problems (%image%) with Distance Spacing: Ctrl+Shift+A -> Check distance snap shhhhh...it makes nice stacks also this is Advanced, so weird DS is still rankable
00:28:896 (1) - make sliderpoints away from each other nah
00:31:864 (3,4) - identical? nah
01:00:927 (1) - remove nc fixed
01:03:896 (6) - nc fixed
01:30:614 (5) - make sliderpoint closer to the top nah
01:52:646 (1,2) - remove finish-hitsound why?
02:03:896 (6) - nc fixed
02:34:052 (2) - make sliderpoints away from each other nah
03:05:146 (1) - maybe start in 03:04:989 ? will consider, but strongest note starts where it is right now

Hard

similar to Hyper, i think:D
00:18:427 (3,4,5) - make another jump- or singletapping-pattern ok
00:32:958 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^ because doubles is boring ok
00:38:271 (2,3,4) - it's suddenly, but good cool!
01:38:271 (2,3,4) - ^ ^
01:03:271 (1,2,3,4) - doubles is boring fixed
01:13:583 (1,2) - make like in 00:06:864 (2,3) fixed
01:22:489 (4) - omg this slider:D yeah, Len has some pretty amazing vibrato goin on (well not really but whatever)
01:58:427 (2,3,4) - make another singletapping-pattern fixed
02:00:146 (1,2) - this flow, fix eh
02:00:614 (2,3,4,5,1) - strange jumps, it's confused fixed
02:51:864 (2,3,4,5,1) - ^ fixed
02:21:396 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - ...you know i think this is fine
02:28:896 (2) - jumps or make 2 sliders instead 1 nah

Get kudosustar! Get kudosu!
Good luck!
{end of mod}

N0thingSpecial wrote:

RIP mod 2k16, IRC instead

06:07 N0thingSpecial: so
06:07 *N0thingSpecial is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/834951 Hitoshizuku x Yama - Ookami wa Akazukin ni Koi wo Shita [Ookami to Akazukin]]
06:07 N0thingSpecial: ready?
06:07 Yahuri: yup
06:07 N0thingSpecial: so
06:08 N0thingSpecial: 00:04:364 (2) - personal preference, long straight sliders are best when complimented
06:08 N0thingSpecial: right now it's just looks bland
06:08 N0thingSpecial: it
06:09 Yahuri: what do you mean by complimented?
06:09 N0thingSpecial: btw right now I'm just repeating what I remember I had in the mod
06:09 N0thingSpecial: like have several other straight sliders to compliment it
06:09 N0thingSpecial: like here 00:04:364 (2,3,4,5) -
06:09 Yahuri: ah
06:09 Yahuri: gotcha
06:09 N0thingSpecial: 00:05:458 (3,4,5) -
06:09 N0thingSpecial: and then speaking of 00:05:458 (3,4,5) -
06:10 N0thingSpecial: while I was playing this it felt clustered to me
06:10 Yahuri: what do you mean
06:10 N0thingSpecial: too close together
06:11 Yahuri: eh
06:11 Yahuri: so further apart for whistle emphasis?
06:11 Yahuri: like the slider heads
06:11 N0thingSpecial: yea
06:12 N0thingSpecial: I remember I had something similar to this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5225658
06:12 N0thingSpecial: for suggestion
06:12 Yahuri: ah
06:12 Yahuri: yeah that looks nice
06:13 N0thingSpecial: yea just remember to triangulate 00:05:771 (4,5,1) - when doing it
06:13 N0thingSpecial: next one
06:13 N0thingSpecial: 00:11:708 (1) -
06:13 Yahuri: well ill see how it looks then see if triangulation is necessary
06:14 N0thingSpecial: this could be moved down a little to match the spacing of 00:11:396 (7,2,2) -
06:14 N0thingSpecial: looks tidier that way imo
06:15 Yahuri: fixed
06:15 N0thingSpecial: moving on
06:15 N0thingSpecial: 00:21:864 (2,3) -
06:15 N0thingSpecial: just a suggestion
06:16 N0thingSpecial: slightly curve them upwards
06:16 N0thingSpecial: something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5225671
06:16 Yahuri: flow might be a lil wonky leading into the next slider tho
06:16 Yahuri: ohh thats what you mean
06:16 Yahuri: ok
06:17 N0thingSpecial: yea in terms of aethetics it flows better
06:17 N0thingSpecial: with how everything is curved
06:17 Yahuri: yeah
06:19 N0thingSpecial: 00:26:396 (1,2) - not sure if this is your style but I find it rather inconsistent to suddenly have perfectly lined up straight sliders
06:20 N0thingSpecial: angle it
06:20 N0thingSpecial: curve it
06:20 Yahuri: people tell me i have really straight flow
06:20 Yahuri: XD
06:20 N0thingSpecial: ^ this is what I'm about to bring up
06:21 N0thingSpecial: 00:29:989 (1) - this could use a ctrl+g
06:21 Yahuri: i dont think that will work well with the next circle
06:22 Yahuri: also the head would start right under the previous slider
06:22 N0thingSpecial: it seem like it would
06:22 N0thingSpecial: but it actually plays quite well imo
06:22 Yahuri: ill test it
06:23 N0thingSpecial: it breaks up the linear/oval flow you constantly have
06:23 Yahuri: ye
06:24 N0thingSpecial: which I was going to lead into how linear/oval flow work best with varible spacing and structure in my mod, which I'm still very salty about
06:25 N0thingSpecial: and 00:32:489 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - is what I was going to talk about
06:26 N0thingSpecial: you put clap on 00:32:958 (2,4) -
06:26 N0thingSpecial: which I think should be emphasize by actual spacing, rather than just linear flow
06:26 N0thingSpecial: like larger spacing
06:26 N0thingSpecial: same goes for this 00:33:583 (6) -
06:27 Yahuri: so i should move 4, 2, 5 down?
06:27 N0thingSpecial: I think i had this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5225691
06:27 N0thingSpecial: which 00:33:271 (4,5,6,7,1) -
06:28 N0thingSpecial: forms a pentagon
06:30 N0thingSpecial: ok moving on
06:30 N0thingSpecial: 00:41:396 (1) - this I suggest moving it down
06:30 N0thingSpecial: so it looks like it forms a circle with 00:41:083 (3) -
06:30 N0thingSpecial: just a suggestion
06:31 Yahuri: gotcha
06:31 N0thingSpecial: 00:44:677 (4,5,6,1) - this
06:32 N0thingSpecial: hmmm
06:33 N0thingSpecial: same with the last one
06:33 N0thingSpecial: where you had clap/finish on notes but you don't have ways to emphasize it
06:34 Yahuri: DS?
06:34 N0thingSpecial: thats one way
06:34 Yahuri: DS is already changed tho
06:35 N0thingSpecial: the thing is I'm rarely work with linear flow and
06:35 N0thingSpecial: what ever i suggest here would probably not be your style
06:36 Yahuri: welp i was considering remapping the first part of kiai so go for it
06:36 N0thingSpecial: ignore if you will
06:38 N0thingSpecial: 00:55:146 (1) - I suggest if you're going to use relatively similar DS
06:38 N0thingSpecial: anti flow would be your best bet in making stronger emphasis
06:40 Yahuri: wait
06:40 N0thingSpecial: which I think I had [https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5225711 this] for suggestion
06:40 Yahuri: anitflow in the slider angle or wat
06:40 Yahuri: ah
06:41 Yahuri: ill see how that works out
06:41 N0thingSpecial: like what you did here 00:55:927 (4,1) -
06:41 Yahuri: ok
06:41 N0thingSpecial: moving on to 01:00:614 (2) -
06:42 N0thingSpecial: the way you curved 01:00:146 (1) -
06:42 N0thingSpecial: wait
06:43 N0thingSpecial: still morning lol wait
06:43 Yahuri: ok XD
06:44 N0thingSpecial: ok right the combination of 01:00:146 (1,2) - which makes a really awkward momentum change
06:44 N0thingSpecial: like I don't here anything significant that would suggest players to go fast then stop suddenly
06:45 N0thingSpecial: my suggest was to just 01:00:614 (2) - space this out
06:45 Yahuri: space out how
06:46 N0thingSpecial: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5225727
06:46 N0thingSpecial: like this
06:46 N0thingSpecial: cause players would just ignore the curve at the button and go striaght down
06:47 N0thingSpecial: along with the speed they gain from following the high SV slider
06:48 N0thingSpecial: got it?
06:48 Yahuri: aite
06:48 Yahuri: yup
06:49 N0thingSpecial: 01:17:177 (4) - this I would just suggest moving it like [https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5225737 this]
06:50 N0thingSpecial: to break up the flow
06:50 N0thingSpecial: at least a little bit
06:50 Yahuri: prefer not to overlap
06:50 N0thingSpecial: ok
06:51 N0thingSpecial: 01:37:958 (2,3,4,5,6,7) -
06:51 N0thingSpecial: I don't think linear flow is the best way to emphasize the vocals
06:52 Yahuri: doing drums
06:52 N0thingSpecial: also your jumps here need a bit more structure than just constant DS
06:52 N0thingSpecial: structured
06:53 Yahuri: should i make DS gradually bigger?
06:53 N0thingSpecial: I could not really tell why this part would be seperated into two patterns when vocals last all six notes
06:53 N0thingSpecial: so i was suggesting that you find a stucture that would fit 6 notes in and lead into 01:38:896 (1) - nicely
06:55 Yahuri: ok
06:58 N0thingSpecial: ok so
06:58 N0thingSpecial: 01:40:458 (1,2,3) -
06:58 N0thingSpecial: personally I find this untidy
06:58 N0thingSpecial: and I couldn't really figure out how did you come up with this pattern
07:00 N0thingSpecial: I did [https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5225771 this] but I still don't think it's good
07:00 N0thingSpecial: maybe you could come up with something better
07:00 Yahuri: probably yeah
07:01 N0thingSpecial: ok so 01:41:708 (2) - this litterally just moveit down a few pixels so 01:41:396 (1,3) - looks like it is spaced equally
07:02 Yahuri: its not supposed to be spaced equally
07:02 N0thingSpecial: ohh
07:03 N0thingSpecial: um then 01:42:646 (5,6) - this I suggest you space 01:42:958 (6) - out a bit further
07:03 N0thingSpecial: cause with how you placed it
07:04 N0thingSpecial: it is just stalling, cause there's no need to go through the entirety of der
07:04 N0thingSpecial: 01:42:646 (5) -
07:04 N0thingSpecial: so players would just be stopping in the middle of the slider for no reason and click on 01:42:958 (6) -
07:05 Yahuri: ok
07:06 N0thingSpecial: nazing 01:46:708 (2) -
07:06 N0thingSpecial: point it between 01:47:021 (3,4) -
07:06 N0thingSpecial: rather than directly at 01:47:021 (3) -
07:06 Yahuri: ok
07:07 N0thingSpecial: just personal opinion
07:07 N0thingSpecial: 01:47:646 (1,2,3,4,5) - just want to point out this is very good
07:07 N0thingSpecial: in terms of flow
07:08 Yahuri: cool
07:10 N0thingSpecial: 02:16:396 (1) - nazi
07:11 N0thingSpecial: I suggested [https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5225810 this]
07:11 N0thingSpecial: looks less clustered
07:12 Yahuri: ok
07:13 N0thingSpecial: 02:17:646 (3,4,5,6) -
07:13 N0thingSpecial: ok this
07:13 N0thingSpecial: currently it is ok
07:14 N0thingSpecial: but personally I would just add a reverse arrow on02:17:750 (4) -
07:15 N0thingSpecial: 02:23:114 (2,3,4,5,6,1) - nazi
07:15 N0thingSpecial: pentagon plz
07:16 Yahuri: i dont think polygon DS goes that high
07:16 N0thingSpecial: well
07:16 N0thingSpecial: umm
07:16 N0thingSpecial: use maths
07:16 Yahuri: i cant math
07:16 N0thingSpecial: ok fine
07:16 N0thingSpecial: um
07:17 N0thingSpecial: copy 2 and 5
07:17 N0thingSpecial: rotate by 36 degree
07:17 N0thingSpecial: repeat process and you get pentagon
07:18 Yahuri: actually i think the reason i changed that pattern from insane was cuz i couldnt play it lol
07:18 N0thingSpecial: lol
07:18 Yahuri: too many notes in the same flow screw me up
07:19 N0thingSpecial: there are flow base mappers like moph you should probably check out his maps
07:19 Yahuri: i believe i have a few
07:19 N0thingSpecial: namely fairtale
07:19 *N0thingSpecial is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/815219 Nekomata Master feat. Misawa Aki - chrono diver -fragment-]
07:19 N0thingSpecial: and
07:19 *N0thingSpecial is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/759192 cillia - Fairytale,]
07:20 N0thingSpecial: his maps I find it quite similar to this one you have
07:20 Yahuri: aite
07:21 N0thingSpecial: well thats kinda it for this diff
07:22 Yahuri: ok cool
07:22 N0thingSpecial: and thats where my mod died
07:22 Yahuri: rip
07:23 Yahuri: well thanks a lot dude
07:23 N0thingSpecial: tbh I like your insane diff more than the one I just mod
07:23 Yahuri: lol i spent ages on that one
07:23 Yahuri: XD
07:23 N0thingSpecial: cause everything is more evenly spaced
07:23 Yahuri: probably because i remapped most of it
07:24 Yahuri: recently
07:24 N0thingSpecial: when I say evenly spaced, I'm refering to spaical spacing rather than DS
07:24 Yahuri: yea
07:25 Yahuri: i try to do that in my more recent maps
07:25 N0thingSpecial: try to put some more variable spacing in your hardest diff
07:25 N0thingSpecial: like how you did it in insane
07:25 Yahuri: ok
07:25 N0thingSpecial: then you're golden
07:25 Yahuri: so basically more DS on the claps n finishes n stuff right
07:26 N0thingSpecial: don't always have to be the case
07:26 N0thingSpecial: but I I usaully eaither
07:26 N0thingSpecial: either
07:26 N0thingSpecial: put more DS
07:26 N0thingSpecial: or use snappier flow
07:26 Yahuri: gotcha
07:26 N0thingSpecial: like back and forth and stuff
07:27 Yahuri: that stuff hard
07:27 Yahuri: XD
07:27 N0thingSpecial: or if it applies use stacks
07:27 N0thingSpecial: but a lot of people don't like it lol

-NanoRIPE- wrote:

Hi ~ M4M request ~

[General]
looks fine

[Easy]
01:29:989 (3) - fix DS lol oops
01:38:896 (1) - ctrl j? nah, slider will have to go offscreen for that to happen
01:56:708 (5) - NC? fixed
02:33:896 (3) - fix DS changed rhythm, fixed
02:25:146 (1,2,3) - stacked? not sure if this counts as a stack since the notes are so far apart, but ill see if anyone else mentions it as well
02:45:146 (1,2) - blanket? nah

[Normal]
01:48:896 (1) - ctrl j and move to x:378 y:350 that makes no sense.
02:18:896 (1) - sliding down slightly *i think pattern with same position previous note not good,especially u use staright slider ~ not sure what youre looking for, but i made the flow more straight.
02:33:896 (4,1) - blanket? sure
03:23:114 (1,1) - remove NC nope

[Adcvanced]
00:03:903 (1) - move to x:410 y:66 for better flow changed, but not with the coordinates you said
00:26:396 (1) - ctrl j nah
00:34:989 (3,4) - blanket improve fixed
02:53:271 (3) - remove finish pretty sure there is very clear sound for this
03:04:833 (1) - remove NC nah

[Hard]
00:31:708 (1,2) - blanket? will mess up DS, but ill see if i can do something for this section later
01:01:864 (2,3) - try this pattern http://prntscr.com/bf2so1 sure
01:39:364 (1,2) - blanket? nope

[Insane]
00:08:271 (5,6) - blanket? or like this http://prntscr.com/bf2xd0 dont want blanket here
02:24:833 (4,1) - blanket? ^
03:15:614 (2) - move to x:458 y:15 and use straight slider ~ like this http://prntscr.com/bf2zbb changed sorta like that, but moved the following circle as well for less straight flow/DS consistency

[Ookami]
Nice Diff ~ thanks!

GL ~ and nice beatmap ~ you deserve my kudosu star ~ :DD
sorry for short mod is k~

1. use easy hp2 and normal hp3 if u want, thought od is like 345678, same might apply to hp lol

1. 00:28:271 (4) - ds is a bit off here
2. 01:35:927 (3) - tho there's a relatively strong drum now, thought new players don't actually read with ds so imo following drum here is not the best choice, having this started at the previous white tick may work better
3. 02:45:771 (2) - 02:51:396 (3) - this is touching with the key overlay (under my 4:3 resolution), worth fixing a bit
4. 02:23:896 - 03:24:833 - unused inherited points

1. 00:43:896 (1) - moving this to 256,349 can also be a nice symmetry pattern, and it flows better from 6 to 2 imo
2. 01:58:896 (1,2) - does not flow well visually, what about leaving the slider 1 straight?
3. 03:24:833 - unused inherited points

1. 02:38:739 (4,5) - doesn't flow well, this might work
2. 02:43:896 (2,1) - is reading trap really necessary in an advanced diff lol
3. 03:24:364 - slider should end here, same applied to other higher diffs

1. 00:12:177 - add two notes like u do in the Advanced diff, why is hard diff even easier here
2. 00:38:427 (3) - maybe keep the same distance
3. 01:03:271 (1,2,3,4,1) - pretty hard tbh, if u wanna emphasize those drums, i'd suggest replace 3,4 with a slider and jump somewhere else, that's much more player friendly
4. 01:22:489 (4) - the slider path might not be safe imo, u can consult other ppl for their opinions
5. 02:18:896 (1) - inapproriate spacing for me, either space it out somewhere else or have it stacked with 5 works better
6. 02:54:052 (1,2,3) - drums are all strong here, i don't see a specific reason why u wanna space 3 out. If u wanna stack 02:53:583 (4,4) - , u can keep the same large distance like this something

1. 00:49:833 (5,1) - this might flow better
2. 00:59:677 (4,1) - this is a bit too much, having the sliderend of 1 stacked with 3 and adjust the curve a little can be a neat solution
3. 01:03:271 (1,2,3,4) - the snake flow here doesn't agree with ur hard diff lol, u might want sth likethis
4. 01:55:146 (1,2) - 01:54:989 (5,1) - both don't flow visually well, to protect the 5,2 blanket, maybe u can try having 1 blanketed with sliderhead of 01:54:364 (3) -
5. 02:01:239 (3,1) - this is almost a cross screen jump, can move 1 up a bit

1. 00:41:396 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - 01:41:396 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - 02:38:896 (1,2,3) - 03:02:646 (1,3) - silence those sliderends with 5%volume , soft hitsounds here are abrupt for me
2. 02:18:062 - there is a 1/3 sound here as well, u can add a note and make this a relatively big ds stream, it's not that hard to play and is fun. btw 02:18:271 (6) - tho there's no actual sound, imo this should snapped to 1/3 as well, that plays more fluently
3. 02:21:396 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - can try gradually larger spacing cuz pitch is getting higher here, and it won't feel forced while doing these jumps 02:22:958 (1,2,3,4,5,6) -
4. 02:29:521 (3,1) - can be a confusing spacing, what about stacking 1 with sliderhead of 02:28:896 (1) - instead?
5. 02:55:146 (2) - nc, also i think it's the most highlighting section of the song, u can map full potential difficulty of this part to make it an x icon, it's ur own choice but plz at least don't simply use similar spacing like previous parts
6. 03:04:833 (1,2,3,4,5) - this might flow better while playing
   

ProEzreal wrote:

Hello~ M4M from my queue

There is no need to have an Advanced and a Hard diff. Consider having one difficulty removed. not removing any because of difficulty jump, i only added Advanced just to lighten the gap

Easy

1. 03:05:146 (1) - just as I expected, you should put a full measure of break after a spinner on an easy diff. where would i logically end it tho

Normal

1. Normal with a rating of 2.25. seems legit. You can make this a bit easier if i can then good but if i cant oh well but im not remapping it again
2. 02:41:396 (4) - NC here for consistency

fixed

I would remove the Advanced diff if I were you. nope

Hard

1. 00:08:896 (4) - NC
2. 00:09:677 (1) - disable nc
3. 00:10:458 (1) - NC
4. 00:11:396 (1) - disable nc redid NCs for Hard
5. 00:11:708 (1,2) - consider having this closer to the last note ok
6. 00:23:114 (3,4) - triple could fit here no triples for Hard
7. 00:26:396 (4) - this should be nc not this 00:26:708 (1) -
8. 00:28:739 (3,4) - what's with the distance here? is it to emphasize the drums? yes
9. 01:03:271 (1,2,3,4,1) - I would make this into a even spacing if possible nah but i still changed the pattern a bit anyways
10. 01:22:489 (4) - slider doesn't look good, doesn't match the song and skips a triplet that could be mapped i knew someone was going to complain about that slider eventually lol, ill remap that but still no triplets for Hard
11. 01:27:021 (3,4) - spacing remapped section
12. 01:38:896 (1,2) - blanket the blanket here is the curve under the wave slider + the head of the next slider (preserve DS for 2,3)
13. 02:54:208 (2,3) - spacing remapped section

Insane

1. 00:07:177 (3,1) - bad flow, you should keep the circular flow going. I would ctrl-g this 00:07:333 (1) - anti flow for emphasis but ill test this anyways
2. 00:08:583 (6) - this breaks the flow you had going on. try putting it somewhere else nah
3. 00:11:083 (7) - ^ this is the same motion
4. 00:33:583 (1) - I wouldn't nc here. Goes for every other stream you nced like this fixed
5. 00:45:927 (4,5) - instead of awkward pauses here, I think you could put a slider somewhere between these two Again, goes for every awkward pause you have pretty sure someone suggested i add those pauses in but ill experiment more with it
6. 01:03:896 (1) - pull this down for a pentagon shape emphasis
7. 01:42:958 (2,3) - I would have these spaced a little, its like literally closer than 01:42:646 (1,2) - these two which are only 1/2 far fixed
8. 01:47:958 (2,3) - flow flow flow. ctrl-g ctrl g for 3
9. 03:04:833 (1) - this can be easily mistaken to be a 1/4 that repeats once. put 03:05:146 (2) - on the bottom of this slider maybe

Ookami to Akazukin

1. 00:18:739 (8,1) - flow isnt good here, 00:18:427 (6,7,8) - this flows in a circular motion, clockwise. then the slider points counter clockwise. wot never liked the shape of that slider so ill see if i can cushion the landing better
2. 00:32:958 (2,3,4,5) - this has a circular flow, but then it breaks on 00:33:583 (6,7) - I would say that the flow needs to be continued but it actually cannot because of 00:33:896 (1) - which is pointing the total opposite direction. 00:32:958 (2,3,4,5) - instead of creating a circular flow here, try making something that would actually connect to 00:33:896 (1) - without breaking the flow that much will check
3. 00:55:146 (1,2,3,4) - 3 and 4 breaks the flow change of direction sure but i dont see how its wrong
4. 01:00:146 (1,2) - there's nothing to emphasize here, yet you change the sv to 1.5 :/ k
5. 01:25:927 (5,6) - this is the last difficulty, try mapping these better what is mapping "better" i did this the last time too
6. 01:43:583 (8,9) - these can be spaced a bit fixed
7. 02:00:146 (1,2) - same thing as I said before. k
8. 03:13:896 (1,2,3,4,1) - seems waaaaay too spaced. eh

Most of the problems are the flow of the whole map which was mostly random and consistency with new combos. To be really honest, I would say that you should practice making good flows and learn when to NC then try working on this again. not intending on dropping work on this map until its ranked so i dont have a mountain of other sets i need to remap. will recheck NCs again.

Well good luck with this, I'll be waiting for your mod.

ProEzreal wrote:

Looking at how hard the normal diff is, removing advanced wouldn't really hurt you imo.
What's the point of having 2 (potentially 3) hard difficulties anyways?

roshan117 wrote:

From my modding queue

Easy

02:19:521 (2,3) - At slider 3, instead of having the clap sound effect at the end of the slider, put it at the beginning of the slider, as when it is at the end it sounds out of place and is offbeat. When it is at the top, it does not sound out of place anymore, and goes with the song. offbeat has nothing to do with where a hitsound should be placed. the timeline at the beginning of the slider has no indication of having the clap sound.

Normal

01:33:271 (4,5) - Set the drumming audio sampleset to start at slider 4 here instead of slider 5, it feels out of place only starting at slider 5. i use the drum sampleset almost nowhere but the kiai. this section emphasizes claps, not drums.
03:03:896 (1,2,3) - stack hitcircles 1, 2, and 3. They feel out of place when they are seperated like this, especially with a spinner right afterward. spinners have nothing to do with stacks, and they should be fine as they are

Overall

I feel these beatmaps were VERY SOLID. It was hard to find things that could be fixed! I hope this post helped you, and I hope this gets ranked! (i love the song btw) thank you, but sorry, the mod didnt help :/

Garden wrote:

[General]

1. use easy hp2 and normal hp3 if u want, thought od is like 345678, same might apply to hp lol

[Easy]

1. 00:28:271 (4) - ds is a bit off here fixed
2. 01:35:927 (3) - tho there's a relatively strong drum now, thought new players don't actually read with ds so imo following drum here is not the best choice, having this started at the previous white tick may work better yeah but this pattern has been present in many other places so i think itll be fine
3. 02:45:771 (2) - 02:51:396 (3) - this is touching with the key overlay (under my 4:3 resolution), worth fixing a bit i dont get what youre saying
4. 02:23:896 - 03:24:833 - unused inherited points true but ima leave em in in case i need to map that part again

[Normal]

1. 00:43:896 (1) - moving this to 256,349 can also be a nice symmetry pattern, and it flows better from 6 to 2 imo sure
2. 01:58:896 (1,2) - does not flow well visually, what about leaving the slider 1 straight? sure
3. 03:24:833 - unused inherited points same as last time

[Advanced]

1. 02:38:739 (4,5) - doesn't flow well, this might work sure
2. 02:43:896 (2,1) - is reading trap really necessary in an advanced diff lol not necessary but did it anyways to represent missing instrumentals, changed anyways
3. 03:24:364 - slider should end here, same applied to other higher diffs theres actually a note where i end the sliders so nah

[Hard]

1. 00:12:177 - add two notes like u do in the Advanced diff, why is hard diff even easier here fixed
2. 00:38:427 (3) - maybe keep the same distance eh
3. 01:03:271 (1,2,3,4,1) - pretty hard tbh, if u wanna emphasize those drums, i'd suggest replace 3,4 with a slider and jump somewhere else, that's much more player friendly fixed
4. 01:22:489 (4) - the slider path might not be safe imo, u can consult other ppl for their opinions fixed
5. 02:18:896 (1) - inapproriate spacing for me, either space it out somewhere else or have it stacked with 5 works better 5 would work worse because slider overlap
6. 02:54:052 (1,2,3) - drums are all strong here, i don't see a specific reason why u wanna space 3 out. If u wanna stack 02:53:583 (4,4) - , u can keep the same large distance like this something did a different pattern but might change later

[Insane]

1. 00:49:833 (5,1) - this might flow better nope but did what you said + ctrl j for flow into 2
2. 00:59:677 (4,1) - this is a bit too much, having the sliderend of 1 stacked with 3 and adjust the curve a little can be a neat solution ok
3. 01:03:271 (1,2,3,4) - the snake flow here doesn't agree with ur hard diff lol, u might want sth likethis did something like that
4. 01:55:146 (1,2) - 01:54:989 (5,1) - both don't flow visually well, to protect the 5,2 blanket, maybe u can try having 1 blanketed with sliderhead of 01:54:364 (3) - intention was to blanket 2 from the previous combo, but i might end up remapping this part again
5. 02:01:239 (3,1) - this is almost a cross screen jump, can move 1 up a bit fixed

[Ookami to Akazukin]

1. 00:41:396 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - 01:41:396 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - 02:38:896 (1,2,3) - 03:02:646 (1,3) - silence those sliderends with 5%volume , soft hitsounds here are abrupt for me fixed
2. 02:18:062 - there is a 1/3 sound here as well, u can add a note and make this a relatively big ds stream, it's not that hard to play and is fun. its a pretty soft note tho btw 02:18:271 (6) - tho there's no actual sound, imo this should snapped to 1/3 as well, that plays more fluently if this happens on a white tick then its already snapped to 1/3
3. 02:21:396 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - can try gradually larger spacing cuz pitch is getting higher here, and it won't feel forced while doing these jumps 02:22:958 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - will check
4. 02:29:521 (3,1) - can be a confusing spacing, what about stacking 1 with sliderhead of 02:28:896 (1) - instead? fixed
5. 02:55:146 (2) - nc, fixed also i think it's the most highlighting section of the song, u can map full potential difficulty of this part to make it an x icon, it's ur own choice but plz at least don't simply use similar spacing like previous parts will check
6. 03:04:833 (1,2,3,4,5) - this might flow better while playing lining up stream with spinner border
   

For me the lower diffs are solid overall, i suggest u get some ppl irc mod ur higher diffs specifically.
I see ur great efforts in this set, good luck getting it ranked!

Lasse wrote:

d

[x]
00:10:927 (4) - suddenly stacking such a strong sound here makes no sense, give it some spacing as soon as i find a pttern that doesnt look like crap
00:18:427 (6) - why suddenly such low spacing comapred to similar sounds like 00:15:927 (6) - remap
00:23:427 (6,7) - using a more acute angle or evening out spacing will look and play better, for example making 00:22:958 (2,3,4,5,6) - a triangle and then moving 7, which also gets more spacing (emphasis) on 00:23:896 (1) - like http://i.imgur.com/O4cl9qc.jpg or even sth like http://i.imgur.com/cj0egk3.jpg
there are lots of options better than current thats more obtuse, not acute. will fix
no idea why you suddenly switch from 2 measure to 1 measure nc patterns, it seems kinda random at most spots will recheck NCs for this diff
00:33:271 (4,5,6,7,8) - will be played like http://i.imgur.com/uGrs864.jpg => obtuse angles speedup which is pretty uncomfortable to snap and uncalled for by the music here this is the phrase right before a section change so uhhhh will recheck again anyways
00:50:927 - ending on strong cymbal + vocal k im surprised nobody caught that before lmao def will fix
01:00:927 (1) - sudden stop for ^ ?? you could ctrlg 01:00:927 (1,2) - to fit the music better and it plays nice too this is a stop because the instrumentals stop here but ill remap if possible i guess
01:14:833 (5,1) - sliderbodies indicating movement that doesnt actually happen is sth you normally dont want, poor usage of sliderbodies basically http://i.imgur.com/pUIcbFa.jpg i dont get the diagram at all and how am i supposed to show the vocals without a slider
01:18:896 (1) - nearly straight line + slowdown for epmhasized sounds => no emphasis + awkward movement, which is not what you want here, when you could have sth like http://i.imgur.com/0nyLXbh.jpg or whatever i hope you dont think i should map like the image because the image is basically also weird DS with better angles but anyways ill remap that too
02:59:052 (2) - only stack for the whole chorus and it doesnt fit the music cause 2 is still strong probably gonna remap this section of kiai

poor movement can be okay it it fits the music and is intetionall done, but not here lol uhh im pretty sure poor movement means it doesnt fit the music
there are lots of other spots where momentum is poorly handled so take a look with this in mind as pointing them all out would be pointless (heh)
but 01:43:583 (8,9,1) - is another great example of weird linear speedup 8 and 9 match the DS of 6 and 7, also all of the instrumentals except for some small guitar drop out so i dont see why the DS should be similar to the general DS. also the angle isnt that straight
// 02:47:333 (5,1,2) - and so on, i think you should get it, if not then gg remap

[i]
00:07:958 (4) - there is no reason to stack this, if anything it should be spaced more than the others with how strong it is remap

pretty much same issues as extra



generally placement feels a bit unstructured. it's like you put notes on spots where (you think) they "flow well" (but often they dont even do that) and the "spacing fits" (which also at some points isn't the case) while there is so much more to note placement, like getting nice equal visual spacing, good looking patterns, even angles etc. After all it's your choice whether to care about aesthetics or not but it's one of those things to make maps much neater
i think our ideas of equal visual spacing are different 00:18:427 (6) except for that cuz it was always kinda dumb
and i know for a fact that our ideas of visual aesthetics are very different lol

going to stop here as that already seems like too much effort for what I got lol sorry :O
hope this could help even if it might sound pretty harsh at some spots, gl sugarcoating is for the weak

Nao Tomori wrote:

d (cuz i secretly aspire to be lasse but i know i never will be so im on xanax)

[i]
intro not mapped =(
really seems like it should be, it's super duper loud and supports rhythm and all that jazz going by video, the vid doesnt open up til where i start mapping

00:04:833 (1) - seems like a really good place for a 1/1 slider to highlight the really really loud chord that happens that lasts for a measure
in fact tall through the intro, replacing the 1/2 slider + circle circle with 1/1 slider + circle seems to fit better, it accents the chords in the guitar more imo.
00:09:833 (1) - like here where you do it hmmm ill think about it. i put this 1/2 pattern thing in Hard too, 00:09:833 (1) was a mistake XD

for the next part, i thought the placement of stacks was rather random. not in the sense that the rhythm was random (as in they were always in the same place) but rather because there isnt a real reason for them to be stacks in the first place. 00:24:364 (2,3) - has two different piano notes, 00:26:864 (2,3) - as well. it seems like it would be better to replace them with sliders since neither beat is particularly strong, but you make them seem that way by stacking and making the player snap there. i put normal stacks only for places that have two consecutive kick drums. idea is kinda weird so ill probably rework it

00:30:302 (2) - just slide this down and left a bit to be even with 3 imo. dont really see the need for that, also DS

00:43:427 - the ignored beat here is irritating as a player because it feels like the 1/2 jump would be to your slider at 00:43:583 - but instead its just a float over, even though the song is still going. it doesnt help that the sound that that slider follows begins at 00:43:271 - but doesnt have the highlight it needs with a slider. added 3/4 slider

00:48:583 (5) - wew this is the biggest jump in the map so far and it's on this? better off stacking 5 under 2's slider end imo. jump so big cuz it has clap+unique whistle thing, but yea the jump is huge. i still want this jump to bigger than 5-6 tho

00:50:614 (2) - the effect created at 01:00:614 - by the 1/1 break is really nice, consider doing something like that here? ill try that

00:55:458 (2) - this thing just plays weirdly it's like a wide angle that gets slightly sharper then super sharp all of a sudden. better to just make it a normal jump pattern instead of switching from pentagon to star in the middle. fixed

01:01:396 - cute cute =^.^=

01:18:583 (4,5) - makes sense to ctrl g this imo, puts more force on the loud clap notes with sharp angles and makes the angle into the slider more comfortable. 00:17:958 (2,3,4,5) - this is the same pattern. it WAS like you suggested, but i felt that the angle was too sharp from 2-3-4 and then i moved the slider too.

also it makes sense to map where the break is and break where the map is up to 01:23:896 - from 01:13:583 - wait what

01:29:989 (1) - easy symmetry with 01:29:677 (4) - ? no symmetry, but i made slider shapes the same

01:48:583 (5) - same thing, huge jump, not huge emphasis in song at all. better to move this somewhere like 1's tail then adjust the resulting massive wide angle jump to 01:48:896 (1) - fixed

01:50:614 (2) - same thing as up there with the 1/1 pause fixed

02:02:021 (3) - unnecessarily large jump, better to ctrl g this since the song is calming down here imo. rip symmetry ill try find something so i wont get a jump here 02:02:021 (3,4) too

02:18:479 (3) - angle this like 3 degrees clockwise and you'll have it be a straight line from 2, which looks nice. rotated 10 degrees

02:56:396 - ppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp jumps plz thx not for this diff

03:04:833 (4,5,6,7,8) - this is horrifically irritating to play, you make the cursor do the weirdest movement ever. please improve this by curving the stream and the triple that it corresponds to, or something, because it is so hard to hit fixed

03:09:989 (4) - this seems a bit big as well, maybe bring 3 down to head of 03:09:208 (5) - fixed

03:18:252 - rip guitar solo triples going for other instruments rather than guitar, but maybe ill follow more guitar in Cursed Love

03:23:114 (1,2) - this will throw everyone off cuz other times they were normal back and forths and this time you decided to use HW's amazing antijump style that makes it annoying as hell, just ctrl g this please (*triggered*) i use 1/1 manual stacking pretty often but ok

yheaja.