1. FOUR DIMENSIONS (6.21 stars, 1478 notes)

Kibbleru wrote:

uh i hope im modding the right map (u have 4 in pending soo idk)
00:06:578 (5) - personally, i don't like putting anchor points with calmer sections of the song :X i only do it with the 1/3
00:26:354 (1) - nice o3o
00:42:374 (3) - personally i feel like this slider fits better without the straight edges to fit the smooth music here something like this changed!

SPOILER

dont use my example tho cuz it sux xd. but just a general idea
00:53:055 (6,7,8) - uhmm make the circle spacing a bit bigger closer to slider spacing. i think it plays better in general that way. changed
00:58:081 (4,5,6) - ^etc. yes
01:18:484 (1,2,3,4) - for this jump pattern, u should try to make 01:18:641 (2,3) - a significantly larger jump than the other parts since i assume that is the part you would want to be highlighting q: moved (2) further
01:37:961 (6,7) - needs some more spacing, due to the nature of how dropoff flow works, the gap here feels smaller than what it is, making the pause rather weird to play. agreed and changed
01:51:390 (4,7,10) - maybe nc these to emphasize the 3/4 beat piano playing that u are trying to map here. ok
01:54:610 (11) - nc would help make 01:54:767 (12) - more readable ok
01:55:395 - skipping the piano here is kinda awkward, why have the 1/1 gap when u built up all the momentum agree and changed pattern
02:02:778 (4,5,6,7,8) - asthetic wise maybe u can blanket the end of 02:02:463 (3) - this slider with the stream? agree
02:08:432 (8) - instead of putting a circle u can probably map out 02:08:510 - 02:08:589 - 02:08:668 - with 1/4 sliders or something to emphasize the end of the section more (02:08:746 (1) - ) not sure about this because I don't think the music justifies it
02:10:003 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - im not sure if im missing it or something but i hear the music here in groups of 2 or 4, not 3 >< the pitches of the notes are in 3,3,3,4, I'm pretty sure >w<
02:12:516 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - ^ ^
03:54:295 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - ^ etc ^
so.. u know what to do if u want to fix this.
02:18:798 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - with how the music is here, u can probably ctrl g these rhythms 02:18:798 (1,2,3) - this way the higher emphasis slider heads would be on the white tick. and how triplets usually work is that their emphasis is focused on the last note of the triplet. so u want that to land on the white tick instead. remapped
03:12:516 (13) - some more asthetic tricks. u could try to make it so that the slider end is blanketed by 03:12:123 (8,9,10,11,12) - yes

SPOILER

04:59:321 (1) - ^ yes
03:35:368 (3) - uh.. this could be an issue? since the head of the slider is like litterally covering the repeat and from RC one of the rules was 'if a hitburst covers a slider repeat, its unrankable'. idk if this is exactly considered that, but i would increase sv for this slider. moved the hitcircle stack instead; the arrows are visible now in testing
03:48:955 (14) - i would seperate this to 2 sliders, putting the drums on a repeat is kinda anticlimatic agree and changed
04:45:028 (4) - could nc here if u'd like i'm going to rework the whole nc thing lmao


that end up being longer than i thought lol

Anxient wrote:

hurry up and apply kibby's mod

4D
General: use ar 9.5. a four dimensions diff with ar 9? this aint FD4D man. also suits the velocity of the song i've been getting a lot of opinions about suitable ar. I orginally had it as 9.5 but was recommended 9. So I'm going to try out 9.3 for now ahahah


00:42:374 (3) - come on man you can do better than that! changed with kibble's mod
00:47:086 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - and similar parts. as from what youve seen from my hard diffs, i always keep the distance large enough for a follow line to be visible so they dont look so clustered/cluttered. try doing the same. ok, i like it
00:55:882 (5,6,7,8) - try doing this. it helps with emphasis http://puu.sh/n7hLS/7ead2c7156.jpg done
01:08:904 (2,3) - overmap why did i even
01:14:558 (10,11,12) - try doing this http://puu.sh/n7hRI/181b1e723f.jpg coz you got that back and forth motion with the last two sliders. making a stack triple kinda kills the fun. interesting, i'm a little bit iffy on the flow but I think it's better given the previous patterning as you said
01:13:301 (6) - you forgot to NC i bet i need to figure out the nc stuff
01:14:715 (1) - also here if you didnt know
01:14:715 (12) - and here
01:19:270 (6,7,8,9,10,11) - pls make the same DS :c i dont see a reason as to why this isnt consistent they look consistent to me; they were all snapped with 0.8x. There's like a variation of 0.04x here and there lol
01:21:940 (8,9,10,11,1) - this stream feels too slow if you listen to the song. space em out! http://puu.sh/n7i3V/e8b4215f2e.jpg i did that. using the same ds as I did throughout the first kiai, 0.8x
also 01:21:469 (6,1) - theres an overlap you couldve avoided so fix that as well. yes
01:34:820 (9) - NC coz downbeat don't agree here because (9) is part of both the piano riff and the pattern
01:36:076 (6) - NC coz new music part agree
01:39:374 (5) - at the speed of where your cursor is moving, i suggest to space this out more http://puu.sh/n7i8W/c863d3b964.jpg moved
01:44:872 (9) - NC as above
01:46:442 (4,7,10) - NC for that sweet emphasis coz oh my god
01:50:526 (2,3,4,5) - try mapping to the piano instead. theyre more powerful changed
01:51:154 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - try dividing these streams into sets of 4, like this http://puu.sh/n7iij/6623e471e0.jpg. fix any spacing issues that may arise. for that entire part, this is how i remade it http://puu.sh/n7im7/188fb1d67a.jpg mm, I'm stressing the 3/4 accented pitches in the piano line
01:54:767 (12) - this note seems kinda hard to read coz its covered by that last stream. the attention of the player wouldnt be on the stream but rather somewhere else such as forward. supporting my idea for this, try moving this here http://puu.sh/n7iqf/d79c8c52a2.jpg flows alot better as well! kibble mentioned this and i took your suggestion
02:06:233 (1) - you did a 1/1 gap for 02:04:976 (1) - coz there was no beat to represent, so using a repeat slider would kinda be overmap lol. just put a hitcircle since thats the only thing that makes sense anyway. there is a beat on the repeat, it's in the drum line.
02:09:060 (2) - 1/8 slider pls yeah, and manually stacked because of kibble's concern
02:10:003 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - these are in beats of 4 as in kibble's mod, i don't agree
02:12:516 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - ^ ^
02:15:343 (2,3,4,1,2) - lmao these are random. why not do the same things as you did on the last part? remember; beats of 4. i want to give the player a small break, but will definitely get more opinions
02:21:626 (2,3,4,5) - lol whats with you and groups of 3 o-o use this rhythm http://puu.sh/n7iNV/d755128570.jpg it's in the music man! ;w;
02:22:804 (3) - make this into a kickslider so that the next note has emphasis http://puu.sh/n7k7e/f5034b4681.jpg and http://puu.sh/n7k7E/85a7969b63.jpg <-- shit examples yes, remapped
02:25:709 (1) - NC disagree, but NC on (10)
02:28:380 (8) - use a faster slider lol your streams are moving at sanic speed and then this slider is snail uehue
==there are alot of NC problems in this map so ill point them out in another notice box==
02:36:233 (1) - ctrl g'iing this is literally 200% better than what you have currently. ayy lmao
02:43:144 (7) - ctrl g this and place it here 183:288 coz this note has emphasis. agree but stacked on (1)
02:46:914 - totally mappable beat you couldnt mapped idek how i missed all of these
02:57:594 (1) - this position is super uncomfortable to play lol.. try placing it here http://puu.sh/n7ja4/be8d38dd11.jpg stack it with 02:56:338 (1) - ok
02:59:008 (1) - consider ctrl g'ing this ya
02:59:479 (2) - ^ apply this mod if you apply the above one, coz these work hand in hand for flow. butt
03:14:086 (1) - i would expect aLOT more spacing than this coz of the loudness of this part. try doing this http://puu.sh/n7jkL/d72b868735.jpg spaced further away but didn't use the new slider
03:20:054 (1) - AIRMAN AIRMAN kek
03:33:876 (3,4,5,6) - consider using a repeat slider for this coz the sound supporting this stream isnt that strong. (not strong enough for a full stream at least) disagree here... personal preference and I've had this before
03:35:368 (3) - place in here 03:35:447 - also arrange the notes so they look like this. apparently your positioning rn is illegal. http://puu.sh/n7krU/31ac62ede9.jpg disagree with the timeline move but I did this with kibble's mod LOL
03:35:761 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,1) - and similar parts: it might be just me but this stream seems too fast for this part of the song lol. i mean the song is super quiet and calm and suddenly speed stream. i think it's fine, but we'll see how this changes with more mods
03:53:352 (2) - 1/16 slider pls i cant even deal with u
03:54:295 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,1,2,1,2,1) - remember. these are 4 hit patters, not 3. u LIE
04:40:630 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - NC them in groups of 3, not 2. http://puu.sh/n7jAw/9b1ee353bd.jpg oooo
04:59:949 (1) - idk why but placing this note in 512:193 feels so much better but symmetry ;w;

its not over yet. NC

NC

01:10:788 (4) - NC
01:13:301 (6) - NC
01:14:558 (1) - continue combo
01:14:715 (3) - NC
01:20:840 (4) - NC
01:23:353 (4) - NC
01:25:867 (6) - im gonna stop typing NC coz it should be pretty obvious at this point here are the rules. if i highlight a NC'd note, it means continue combo, vice versa.
01:26:809 (1) -
01:28:851 (5) -
01:29:479 (5) -
01:30:893 (5) -
01:33:406 (6) -
01:34:191 (1) -
01:36:076 (6) -
01:36:390 (10) -
01:40:945 (5) -
01:43:458 (5) -
01:52:411 (5) -
01:54:296 (7) -
02:07:490 (8) -
02:07:804 (1) -
02:10:003 - 02:14:401 - should be pretty obvious
im gonna stop here. by this point you should know where to NC lol

i'm still a little iffy with the NC things, i'll have to do this more in depth. :S

good luck!