SPOILER

Reclaimation
00:13:185 to 00:14:095 sounds weird. either delete 1 slider of leave decrease slider length
01:49:125 to 01:50:398 beats could be louder
01:50:579 to 01:51:852 ^same
02:06:579 to 02:07:852 too confusing
02:38:579 sounds weird
03:16:398 to 03:21:489 could be a bit faster
03:45:489 to 03:46:761 too confusing. Spread them out more
04:46:579 to 04:50:761 ^same
05:00:822 i think you can add a note here
05:17:125 to 05:18:398 looks messy. consider putting them closer together or spreading them into a star again
05:30:943 to 05:34:398 way too confusing
05:39:610 to 05:39:731 these notes could be softer

gameuse wrote:

Nice song!
Just a heads up, there are a lot of confusing patterns in your map, consider changing them because when numbers fly all over the place, its hard for the player to hit them. Also, you have a lot of single hit notes, consider adding more sliders to the mix.

SPOILER

Reclaimation
00:13:185 to 00:14:095 sounds weird. either delete 1 slider of leave decrease slider length This is fine, the noise (idk what you would call it ) that 00:13:670 (2,3) is mapped to calls for 2 sliders since the noise resets.
01:49:125 to 01:50:398 beats could be louder True, made them a bit louder because of the vocals
01:50:579 to 01:51:852 ^same ^
02:06:579 to 02:07:852 too confusing This is fine, it's a triangle pattern that builds to the music (Though I may move the notes around a bit so i doens t look like a big blob in editor)
02:38:579 sounds weird This is fine, it follows the rythm
03:16:398 to 03:21:489 could be a bit faster This is a 1/3 stream it's supposed to be 'slow'
03:45:489 to 03:46:761 too confusing. Spread them out more Spreading them out more would cause for unneeded difficulty (this actually used to be really spread out but it was way too difficult for what the song offers)
04:46:579 to 04:50:761 ^same This is fine, the notes follow the volume of the sound and build up to the loud beats
05:00:822 i think you can add a note hereThere's nothing to map to! Except the vocals but it isn't necessary to map to the vocals there, since it go from somewhat calm vocals to very jumpy beats.
05:17:125 to 05:18:398 looks messy. consider putting them closer together or spreading them into a star again You're right, wired looking pattern, changed it around a bit
05:30:943 to 05:34:398 way too confusing Not as much confusing as it is a long jumping section, Added some sliders for ease
05:39:610 to 05:39:731 these notes could be softer True, adjusted the volume to 80%

well, you need to work on making the map not so confusing as well as beat snap pattering, as some of them are off (especially at the single note phrases "which are the confusing areas"). Fix your beat snap pattering as well as making the beatmap not so confusing then it should be good to go for ranked.

Good luck

Isozaki wrote:

Hitsounding is perfect now, I can actually say honey to the ears, good job following my pointers, really like that man

1. Please add "Bakemonogatari" to tags
2. You should remove one .OSB file "dj - Jo - Kimi No Shiranai Monogatari feat. Hatsune Miku [ dj-Jo Remix ] (Reclaimer)"

1. normal-hitwhistle10.wav
2. soft-sliderslide3.wav
3. soft-sliderslide10.wav
4. normal-hitfinish4.wav
5. normal-hitclap4.wav
6. soft-hitwhistle.wav
7. normal-hitwhistle4.wav
8. normal-hitfinish3.wav
9. soft-sliderslide5.wav
10. normal-hitfinish10.wav
11. normal-hitclap10.wav
12. soft-sliderslide4.wav
13. normal-hitclap.wav

1. 00:14:215 (4) - As you made this part 00:13:670 (2,3) - , you try to make same sound at this part. That sound has 1/4 rhythm like this
   
2. 00:21:670 - I feel empty at here. Because you took the same sound on here 00:20:943 -
3. 00:35:670 (5) - It's better to add a new combo for playing to here since you changed spacing on circle.
4. 01:43:307 (1) - add a finish
5. 01:54:216 (4) - I prefer you don't take this sound. It would be better in my opinion.
6. 02:17:852 (2,3,4) - hmm, try to use more spacing at this part. I feel this spacing is too short for playing.
7. 02:44:398 - Please use over 20% volume. i can't hear it when i am playing.
8. 02:43:670 - missing a clap
9. 03:07:670 (1) - add a finish
10. 03:17:125 (4) - Please add a new combo for 1/3 rhythm.
11. 04:29:126 (1,3,4,5) - no hitsounds :O try to add a finish to head of the sliders!

alacat wrote:

M4M

[General]

1. Please add "Bakemonogatari" to tags
2. You should remove one .OSB file "dj - Jo - Kimi No Shiranai Monogatari feat. Hatsune Miku [ dj-Jo Remix ] (Reclaimer)"

The following hitsounds are unused:

1. normal-hitwhistle10.wav
2. soft-sliderslide3.wav
3. soft-sliderslide10.wav
4. normal-hitfinish4.wav
5. normal-hitclap4.wav
6. soft-hitwhistle.wav This one is actually used here 04:22:943 (5,6,7,8,9)
7. normal-hitwhistle4.wav
8. normal-hitfinish3.wav
9. soft-sliderslide5.wav
10. normal-hitfinish10.wav
11. normal-hitclap10.wav
12. soft-sliderslide4.wav
13. normal-hitclap.wav

All fixed ty

[Ienakatta]

1. 00:14:215 (4) - As you made this part 00:13:670 (2,3) - , you try to make same sound at this part. That sound has 1/4 rhythm like this Not sure I understand, 00:14:215 (4) is mapped to the piano and could only be mapped to the piano, there's no other sound to mapped to
   
2. 00:21:670 - I feel empty at here. Because you took the same sound on here 00:20:943 Good catch! Fixed
3. 00:35:670 (5) - It's better to add a new combo for playing to here since you changed spacing on circle. Fair enough, fixed
4. 01:43:307 (1) - add a finish Fixed
5. 01:54:216 (4) - I prefer you don't take this sound. It would be better in my opinion. I think it's fine, there's constant strumming in the background and the slider follow the claps
6. 02:17:852 (2,3,4) - hmm, try to use more spacing at this part. I feel this spacing is too short for playing. Alright, the sounds are loud so it make sense, fixed
7. 02:44:398 - Please use over 20% volume. i can't hear it when i am playing. Fixed
8. 02:43:670 - missing a clap oops, fixed
9. 03:07:670 (1) - add a finish Fixed
10. 03:17:125 (4) - Please add a new combo for 1/3 rhythm. Not sure why I'd need a NC here, I think this is fine
11. 04:29:126 (1,3,4,5) - no hitsounds :O try to add a finish to head of the sliders! Didn't add finishes but a soft-clap instead to fit the bass

It leaves something to be desired, you should consider adding more finish sounds to kiai parts ! Good luck ~

1. 00:06:434 (4,5) - This spacing is going to be really confusing to read.
2. 00:07:161 (5,1,2,1,2) - Actually all of this xP.
3. 00:11:161 (2,4,2,4) - These are overmapped xP
4. 00:14:979 (5,6) - You miss quite a few of the background intruments with this rhythm choice xP
5. 00:17:524 (1,2,3,4) - ^ There are some cool drums you could have followed.
6. 00:23:888 (3,4) - These two notes should be emphasized xP I used 1/2 sliders for the jumps instead of leaving a 1/1 gap.
7. 00:26:070 (4) - You want to start an object on the downbeat here xP The slider end is noticeably stronger than the head.
8. 00:45:161 (9,1) - Why the jump here xP. You should put the jump on the downbeat (large white tick) so it makes sense with the music.
9. 01:02:615 (1,2,3,1) - I really dont get this rhythm here xP. 01:03:343 - 01:04:070 - are the strong beats but you neglect them.
10. 01:18:434 (5) - You're completely skipping a downbeat with that repeat
11. 01:20:070 - ^ Please start an object on a downbeat unless you have a specific rhythmic reason not to xP
12. 01:28:434 (5) - ^
13. 01:28:070 (4) - Could make this a 1/2 slider instead so there isn't an awkward spacing gap between 4 and 5
14. 01:29:525 (4,5) - ^^
15. 01:41:706 - You could put a circle here and start the spinner 1/2 a beat later
16. 01:47:706 (5,1) - Why the jumpx P
17. 01:48:979 (7,1) - ^This is what you should be doing honestly.
18. 02:03:706 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - Oh, nice <3
19. 02:29:525 (7) - STart on a downbeat please so the stream isnt so awkward to play
20. 02:30:161 (3) - People don't expect hold sliders on a blue tick.. Also they don't expect 3 repeats. its always 2 repeats xP. 02:30:979 (5) - Like this. THe fact you have 3 just means your rhythm choice is poor because you dont start on a downbeat.
21. 02:31:706 (5) - Remove one of the repeats, a circle on 02:32:070 - is nice.
22. 02:52:979 (4) - Downbeat please
23. 02:52:979 (4,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - What you have here is a 1/2 jump rhythm, but the rhythm here is 3/2. one two three one two three. you arrange it like "one two one two one two" with the back and forth jumps which imo is incorrect
24. 03:01:646 - It's 1/6 here too. Begins here.
25. 03:39:343 (7) - Downbeat
26. 04:05:888 - Ehh not going to map this?
27. 04:08:797 (1) - I would end the spinner 1/2 earlier so i can map another circle on 04:10:979 - . plays really well imo.
28. 05:39:645 (1,2,3) - I would just use a repeat slider... people aren't going to expect 1/6 triples here especially when they dont even begin on a white/red tick.
29. 05:45:525 - I feel like ending the spinner on a white tick is always better

monstrata wrote:

[Ienakatta]

1. 00:06:434 (4,5) - This spacing is going to be really confusing to read. I can see why, i changed the note around so they don't overlap so much, fixed
2. 00:07:161 (5,1,2,1,2) - Actually all of this xP. ^
3. 00:11:161 (2,4,2,4) - These are overmapped xP Fixed
4. 00:14:979 (5,6) - You miss quite a few of the background intruments with this rhythm choice xP This is fine, these sounds are the loudest and most emphasized, the other choice would be the piano which isn't as important since it is much quieter and more of a secondary sound
5. 00:17:524 (1,2,3,4) - ^ There are some cool drums you could have followed. Hmm true, for now I'll leave it as is until I figure out what I should do
6. 00:23:888 (3,4) - These two notes should be emphasized xP I used 1/2 sliders for the jumps instead of leaving a 1/1 gap. Ahh they do drag, fixed
7. 00:26:070 (4) - You want to start an object on the downbeat here xP The slider end is noticeably stronger than the head. True, fixed
8. 00:45:161 (9,1) - Why the jump here xP. You should put the jump on the downbeat (large white tick) so it makes sense with the music. Remapped a bit and fixed
9. 01:02:615 (1,2,3,1) - I really dont get this rhythm here xP. 01:03:343 - 01:04:070 - are the strong beats but you neglect them. Hmm I'll see what I can do, not sure exactly how to make it better tho lol
10. 01:18:434 (5) - You're completely skipping a downbeat with that repeat Yeah I caught this not too long ago, haven't bothered to fix it tho lol, I'll rework the stream so a NC starts on the down beats
11. 01:20:070 - ^ Please start an object on a downbeat unless you have a specific rhythmic reason not to xP I realize that but I did this in order to follow the sound that the slider started on
12. 01:28:434 (5) - ^ This slider follows the piano and I put a clap on the slider end to emphasize the strong beat so I think this is fine
13. 01:28:070 (4) - Could make this a 1/2 slider instead so there isn't an awkward spacing gap between 4 and 5 Fixed
14. 01:29:525 (4,5) - ^^ ^
15. 01:41:706 - You could put a circle here and start the spinner 1/2 a beat later Fixed
16. 01:47:706 (5,1) - Why the jumpx P The sound changes, I wanted to emphasize that
17. 01:48:979 (7,1) - ^This is what you should be doing honestly. ??
18. 02:03:706 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - Oh, nice <3 :D
19. 02:29:525 (7) - STart on a downbeat please so the stream isnt so awkward to play o shit, you're right, the stream didn't play right, fixed
20. 02:30:161 (3) - People don't expect hold sliders on a blue tick.. Also they don't expect 3 repeats. its always 2 repeats xP. 02:30:979 (5) - Like this. THe fact you have 3 just means your rhythm choice is poor because you dont start on a downbeat.Hm then i'll have to have 02:29:525 (7) end on the white tick other wise the stream will be even causing players to hit 02:30:252 (4) with their off finger
21. 02:31:706 (5) - Remove one of the repeats, a circle on 02:32:070 - is nice. Fixed
22. 02:52:979 (4) - Downbeat please If I where to put a circle on the down beat that would create for awkward play, I don't want to remove the return slider because it's a beat I can't skip, this is fine
23. 02:52:979 (4,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - What you have here is a 1/2 jump rhythm, but the rhythm here is 3/2. one two three one two three. you arrange it like "one two one two one two" with the back and forth jumps which imo is incorrect Ah I see exactly what you mean, fixed
24. 03:01:646 - It's 1/6 here too. Begins here. It's actually 1/3, fixed it though
25. 03:39:343 (7) - Downbeat This is fine, it follows a specific sound and there's a clap on the slider end to emphasize the down beat
26. 04:05:888 - Ehh not going to map this? No reason to really
27. 04:08:797 (1) - I would end the spinner 1/2 earlier so i can map another circle on 04:10:979 - . plays really well imo. Fixed
28. 05:39:645 (1,2,3) - I would just use a repeat slider... people aren't going to expect 1/6 triples here especially when they dont even begin on a white/red tick. True, fixed
29. 05:45:525 - I feel like ending the spinner on a white tick is always better It's fine how it is, the sound begins immediately after the triple, or return slider now

Ah well good luck. A lot of what I said applies elsewhere too.

Thank you so much for the mod!

1. 00:02:615 (3,4,1) - try this rhythm instead? http://puu.sh/kSKSo/ddd961d5c3.jpg . The repeat slider doesn't really fit imo because the strong downbeat is not clickable or at the repeat end
2. 00:07:161 (5) - move this to 00:06:979 (5) - because there's a strong piano note there?
3. 00:07:343 (1,1,3) - about these sliders, try copying the first slider and rotate by 120deg for the next similar slider, and the one after that. I get that you're trying to blanket but atm, it looks quite forced
4. 00:11:705 (1,2,3,4) - switch the positions of circle 1 and 2, and move circle 4 to somewhere like x:249 y:220. I reckon this would flow/jump better
5. 00:30:615 (7,1) - switch NC around, vocals start on thet large white downbeat tick
6. 00:30:797 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - This is very boring... Try adding in 1/2 sliders to emphasise when the vocaloid holds notes and not bunch circles up like this.
7. 00:40:252 (6,7,8) - can probably add a jump or at least increase spacing here (because vocals vary greatly here)
8. 01:06:434 (4,5) - dunno if intentional or not but the spacing here is smaller than the spacing at 01:05:888 (2,3) -
9. 01:17:979 - there's no note in the music at this time, I don't think a slider end is appropriate here
10. 01:40:979 (3,4,5) - try this rhythm here http://puu.sh/kSMi0/46f8c101d4.jpg
11. 01:41:888 (1) - end at 01:42:979 because this is where the drums sound is
12. 01:46:252 (1) - confusing as this is the only slider with so many repeats so far (i think)
13. 01:47:343 (3,4) - I really don't like bunched notes mapping like this... at this part, you can increase spacing because of vocal variation
14. 02:01:343 (4,5) - you can clearly hear the drum beat here but the circles at this point provide no emphasis for it...
15. 02:18:252 (4) - NC
16. 02:51:888 (7,8) - any reason why this is more spaced out than the other 3?
17. 02:53:706 (3,6) - these notes should be emphasised because the instrument thingy in the background go from lowering in pitch(?) to the top
18. 03:01:646 (1) - NC

[ Rizen ] wrote:

Hello o/

I'm no good at modding diffs more difficult than hard but i'll try my best!

[Ienekatta]

1. 00:02:615 (3,4,1) - try this rhythm instead? http://puu.sh/kSKSo/ddd961d5c3.jpg . The repeat slider doesn't really fit imo because the strong downbeat is not clickable or at the repeat end Here I was going with the vocals, she utters some words very quickly so i thought it was fitting for a return slider to do the vocals justice
2. 00:07:161 (5) - move this to 00:06:979 (5) - because there's a strong piano note there? I kept 00:07:161 (5) as is but added a note to 00:06:979
3. 00:07:343 (1,1,3) - about these sliders, try copying the first slider and rotate by 120deg for the next similar slider, and the one after that. I get that you're trying to blanket but atm, it looks quite forced I think it's fine, the blanket gives these notes a good flow that doesn't feel forced
4. 00:11:705 (1,2,3,4) - switch the positions of circle 1 and 2, and move circle 4 to somewhere like x:249 y:220. I reckon this would flow/jump better I swapped (1) and (2) but I'm keeping (4) where it is because i like the back and forth jump there, I think it fits nicely
5. 00:30:615 (7,1) - switch NC around, vocals start on thet large white downbeat tick Oh right, I forgot about that little bit, nice catch, fixed
6. 00:30:797 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - This is very boring... Try adding in 1/2 sliders to emphasise when the vocaloid holds notes and not bunch circles up like this. For now it will remain until I know what I wanna do with it, but I'll add in some 1/2 sliders, I agree
7. 00:40:252 (6,7,8) - can probably add a jump or at least increase spacing here (because vocals vary greatly here) This is fine, the vocals do change yes but I emphasized it with the difference in spacing of that whole string of notes, it's consistent and I think it's fine
8. 01:06:434 (4,5) - dunno if intentional or not but the spacing here is smaller than the spacing at 01:05:888 (2,3) This was intentional
9. 01:17:979 - there's no note in the music at this time, I don't think a slider end is appropriate here Hmm you're right, good catch, this stream is due for a rework bc of some down beat issues but I'll definitely take note of that
10. 01:40:979 (3,4,5) - try this rhythm here http://puu.sh/kSMi0/46f8c101d4.jpg It's fine how it is, having 4 as a slider allows for a clickable object on the beat, having 3 be a return slider, the beat on the red tick wouldn't be clickable
11. 01:41:888 (1) - end at 01:42:979 because this is where the drums sound is I get what you're saying but the slider is there to emphasiz the drawn out sound, and this sound continues until 01:43:343 (1)
    so i think the slider should last as long as possible fro that sound
12. 01:46:252 (1) - confusing as this is the only slider with so many repeats so far (i think) Here I was just trying to avoid the constant tapping and add something to escape that for a bit
13. 01:47:343 (3,4) - I really don't like bunched notes mapping like this... at this part, you can increase spacing because of vocal variation At some point I plan to rework these constant tapping section to be more fun, and I understand what you mean about vocals so I'll keep that in mind
14. 02:01:343 (4,5) - you can clearly hear the drum beat here but the circles at this point provide no emphasis for it... It's emphasized with hit sounds, here I don't think there's a need to emphasizing them with spacing because I'm going for a consistent pattern
15. 02:18:252 (4) - NC Fixed
16. 02:51:888 (7,8) - any reason why this is more spaced out than the other 3? Nope, not at all, just some silly mapping mistake by me , fixed
17. 02:53:706 (3,6) - these notes should be emphasised because the instrument thingy in the background go from lowering in pitch(?) to the top True, I swapped the notes around a bit
18. 03:01:646 (1) - NC 03:02:070 (1) changed that to a new combo instead

I'm actually very busy with exams so this is all I can do... I glazed through everything past 3 mins and it's looks alright (nothing terribly out of place)

Good luck!

1. You have a lot of areas where nothing is going on, I know that it's for a more dramatic effect but it'll probably fuck over people playing with HR by just straight draining them out unless they have full hp 02:56:070 (8,1) - Like in this area
2. Second thought on hp and drain stuff, For breaks you can have them end on different ticks by dragging them, like the one here 03:21:525 (3) - you should have instead of just starting, since miku is still singing, have it end on the downbeat at 3:22:252
3. Your hitsounding is very loud in parts that I don't think it should be loud on. Try turning down your volumes when the song gets quiet.
4. A lot of your angles for jumps can be really harsh, make sure you actually mean for it to be that way
5. During your streams sometimes you put in back and forths that don't really make sense to me, but it's your map so if they make sense to you keep them, but I feel like most of the streams should just be long streams with *maybe* increased Distance Snap on the parts where the music gets a bit more intense.
6. For the final spinner, the spinnerspin sound is super loud, especially since it appears you wanted the spinner to be a sort of "fade out" kind of deal, I would just add in changing volumes as you spin

-Lemons wrote:

Just a few thoughts of mine after playing this again

1. You have a lot of areas where nothing is going on, I know that it's for a more dramatic effect but it'll probably fuck over people playing with HR by just straight draining them out unless they have full hp 02:56:070 (8,1) - Like in this area HP is fine, it drains to about half (?) or a little less than half should be fine
2. Second thought on hp and drain stuff, For breaks you can have them end on different ticks by dragging them, like the one here 03:21:525 (3) - you should have instead of just starting, since miku is still singing, have it end on the downbeat at 3:22:252 Fixed
3. Your hitsounding is very loud in parts that I don't think it should be loud on. Try turning down your volumes when the song gets quiet. I think most of my volumes are fine some hit sounds are much quieter than others, so the volume they're at is a good volume for all hitsounds, including the default
4. A lot of your angles for jumps can be really harsh, make sure you actually mean for it to be that way At some point I'll take a real good look at the jumps but most of them are intended to have harsh angling for emphasis on the sharp sounds
5. During your streams sometimes you put in back and forths that don't really make sense to me, but it's your map so if they make sense to you keep them, but I feel like most of the streams should just be long streams with *maybe* increased Distance Snap on the parts where the music gets a bit more intense. I like back and forths because personally I don't like long drawn out streams, the back and forths add for a reset to the player and give the streams ease, If i wanted to map for difficulty I'd have acceleration streams out the ass but the difficulty should remain consistent
6. For the final spinner, the spinnerspin sound is super loud, especially since it appears you wanted the spinner to be a sort of "fade out" kind of deal, I would just add in changing volumes as you spin I'm not even sure how to adjust the spinner volume, I assume if i just put timing points in the spinner the volume will change but I don't think it really matters that much tbh

That's all, just some things to consider as you move forward, I would give you a full mod but this song bores me to tears so I wouldn't be able to give you anything of value. Goodluck

1. 02:33:525(2) I think the note here could be maybe be moved a little. Something like this.
   
   
   SPOILER

   
   
   If you change the snap distance to 0.5 and move it you can get it like this. So instead of completely stopping the cursor to wait for a note, it'll flow into the next note.
2. 03:42:615(1) I noticed how you lowered the volume here with the song. There's a hitsound, or rather a silent sound(?) lol, that you can add there to make the notes completely slilent. It should be last on the list here t/15407 . You might even be able to use it elsewhere.

1. 00:34:979 to 00:35:343 You can add a reverse slider here
2. 00:35:706 to 00:36:070 ^
3. 00:49:525 to 00:50:797(1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) In this section you can add sliders to replace every 2 notes. For example you can add a slider in the place of 1 and 2, and for 3 and 4, and so on.
4. 01:46:252 to 01:47:525(1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) Here you can replace these will sliders as well to lead up to your singles. Here's what I did.
   
   SPOILER

   
   
   If you stack the notes the right way, the 4th slider will lead start directly on top of the note at 01:47:706
5. 01:49:888(5) You change this note and make it a reverse that ends at 01:50:252 like this
   
   SPOILER

   
6. 01:51:343 ^ same concept here
7. 04:50:252 to 04:51:161 You can do the same thing here like at 00:49:525 to 00:50:797. You can angle them like you have your singles to lead downwards to your other notes.

Doj wrote:

Looks like people have already modded the hell out of this map, so I'll try my best

lenakatta

1. 02:33:525(2) I think the note here could be maybe be moved a little. Something like this. I think it's fine how it is, if I were to move it like you suggested it would ruin my flow consistency with the notes stopping with the music
   
   
   SPOILER

   
   
   If you change the snap distance to 0.5 and move it you can get it like this. So instead of completely stopping the cursor to wait for a note, it'll flow into the next note.
2. 03:42:615(1) I noticed how you lowered the volume here with the song. There's a hitsound, or rather a silent sound(?) lol, that you can add there to make the notes completely slilent. It should be last on the list here t/15407 . You might even be able to use it elsewhere. I appreciate your suggestion but I don't want the sounds to be completely silent because the bass is pretty heavy so it's best to have a quieter bassy hitsound to compliment the bass that the song provides
   
   At this point I've scratched my head a million times thinking about what else to say. I've noticed you have a lot of singles so from this point it's gonna be suggestions to where you can add sliders.
   
3. 00:34:979 to 00:35:343 You can add a reverse slider here I'm gonna keep this ass is simply because there are a good amount of sliders after that part and I like the emphasis these singles put on the sound changing
4. 00:35:706 to 00:36:070 ^ ^
5. 00:49:525 to 00:50:797(1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) In this section you can add sliders to replace every 2 notes. For example you can add a slider in the place of 1 and 2, and for 3 and 4, and so on. I see what you mean, there's too many singles and I agree but instead I put a slider at every 7th note in each combo like so
6. 01:46:252 to 01:47:525(1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) Here you can replace these will sliders as well to lead up to your singles. Here's what I did. Fixed
   
   SPOILER

   
   
   If you stack the notes the right way, the 4th slider will lead start directly on top of the note at 01:47:706
7. 01:49:888(5) You change this note and make it a reverse that ends at 01:50:252 like this I like these singles as is, the helpe emphasize the vocals
   
   SPOILER

   
8. 01:51:343 ^ same concept here ^
9. 04:50:252 to 04:51:161 You can do the same thing here like at 00:49:525 to 00:50:797. You can angle them like you have your singles to lead downwards to your other notes. Keeping this as is But you helped me realize a mistake so thanks lol

I'm actually legitimately tired from trying to mod this map. I'm going take a nap. Good luck

Kalibe wrote:

Ok, here we go

general:

you have two weird .osb files. I advise to delete it :

Supercell - Kimi No Shiranai Monogatari feat. Hatsune Miku [ dj-Jo Remix ] (Reclaimer)
dj - Jo - Kimi No Shiranai Monogatari feat. Hatsune Miku [ dj-Jo Remix ] (Reclaimer) Done, thanks.

add custom colours? Idk if it's necessary lol

[Ienakatta]

00:08:070 (1) - delete NC. Really unnessesary and NC this if you want 00:08:797 (3) omg how did that happen lmao thanks for pointing that out
00:16:342 (1,2) - this spacing is specially? At least stack this Fixed
00:33:525 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - this part is confusing man and boring. You could add idk little jumps, sliders? but not like this ;w; . This is fine how it is, the 'confusing' part isn't really confusing at all it looks like that purely for aesthetic, and it plays fine, it's better than it being a curve or a straight line and 00:34:978 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) is also fine, it emphasizes the change in sound. This is a boring part of the song, I did as much as I could to make it not so and this section is totally fine
00:42:979 (3,5) - don't fully overlap 5 with 3? They aren't overlapped?
00:46:252 (7) - omg fix this . prefer to stack on 4 Isn't supposed to stack
00:48:069 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - please reapiting rhythm is good, but pattern is really bad . be more creative :p This is fine, the fact that the triangle pattern is bigger in each pattern makes it fine. it expands with the volume of the music and I like to keep consistency, after a few triangle patterns players would expect an other because it they would understand that this is how the section is mapped. If I were to break the pattern for something else then it wouldn't make sense. After seeing the previous similar patterns.
01:01:524 (3) - weird looking slider Ahh right, forgot about that one, fixed
01:04:252 (1,2) - prefer to swaps NC, but your choice It's fine
01:08:433 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - ?
01:26:979 (1) - remove NC lol oops
01:31:888 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4) - this jumps are nice to play :D
01:50:615 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - again... very confusing. Prefer to remove this and add sliders? circles with spacing? Not really that confusing 01:50:615 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) these go according to vocals, and change when the vocals do. And 01:52:070 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) this also goes with the vocals, she holds her note so the notes remain consistent

ok, enough to enter this pattern again, but consider remove it and do smth new :3

03:01:646 (2) - mhh... 1/3 is good here, but try add 1/6 here and listen it. Consider it Staying as 1/3 because its a 1/3 rhythm lol
03:09:161 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - i know you can better to make this pattern This pattern is fine tbh

Ok, i'll stop here. GL with that . ~~

Rifdi wrote:

General

- AR9.3 on 165 bpm? This map better suit AR9. Yes, there are many slow bpm with AR higher than 9 but its because the mapstyle itself requires high AR in order to be readable and playable, the ones with crazy sliders and stuff. This one with no crazy slider like some other crazy map is okay with AR9 imo. 9.3 is fine, mainly because the jumps hold the weight of being able to be 9.3, I'm keeping it at 9.3 unless I really have to change it

Mods

- 00:08:070 (3) Just a little snag, this slider doesn't follow the curve shape of circle no.4 nicely. You might wanna check it out Made a tiny adjustment

- 00:13:706 - 00:14:252 This part is kinda hard to play. In my opinion, slider no. 3 should start where slider no. 2 ends. I noticed that "chiptune"ish rhythm extends this long. Dividing this part for kick sliders might be a good idea : ehh I think it's fine how it is, it isn't that hard to play honestly

https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3894947

Maybe some people would think its overmapping to do this, but this follows the rhythm anyway imo.

- 00:14:252 (5) this part has a strong "chiptune" (i dont know if it is chiptune or not :v) sound, maybe you want to make it a triple that ends with a slider? just my opinion : Nah I think it's fine

https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3894976

- 00:19:525 (2,3) this part is 1/8, my ears told me. You're right but it would play horribly as 1/8 imo

- 01:54:979 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) since its a repeating pattern, why not make it symmetrical? just to make it tidy. Fixed

- 02:02:615 (3,4,5) I noticed these notes has much bigger DS. Maybe you can throw in a bit of a triangle jump? Just a suggestion. If you want to keep this pattern you might want to make the DS the same for the rest of the notes after these three, for flow imo. The DS is bigger to epmhasize the drum

- 03:04:979 (2) move this note a little bit to the left for better visual? its a bit blocked by previous slider no. 4 Fixed


- 03:41:706 (4,5,6,7,8) I noticed that you are following that fading sound. You should make the distance between notes slowly decreasing by the same amount, just to make it structured and more bootiful. Well, for this pattern to succeed, you might want to remove that "boom" from the hitsound of note no.5, since the sound was fading away. made them decrease by .10 at a time. and the boom' is there no matter what, if i remove the hit sound you'll hear the sound in the song so it'll be fine if it stays

- 05:10:070 (2) Little snaggy, this circle overlaps circle no.3 more than circle no. 1. make it equal? oo fixed

- 05:17:343 (2) This note is being blocked by previous slider no. 4. Though you have some other blocked notes prior to this, this one is a bit odd and kinda hard to read. o thats silly, moved the slider

- 05:22:979 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4) I do love back and forth jump, but this gets repetitive, make different variations? I think this is fine ;-;

So many people have mod this. God its hard finding the flaws xD
Good luck!

1. 00:03:525 (3) - place at x208 y288 or something so its smoother to play, kinda awkward angle.
2. 00:06:979 (5) - you can probably delete this so its same rhythm as 00:03:525 (3,4) - which has the same vocal patterns,
3. 00:13:706 (2,3) - try this rhythm. http://puu.sh/l4weE.jpg your current rhythm isnt pressuring the right spots of the scratching noise, 00:13:706 - 00:13:888 - 00:14:070 - . and also moving 00:14:252 (4) - down 1/2 beat places it at the bass line.
4. 00:16:342 (1,2) - you can make this a slider because the rhythm is kinda weird, the current slow sv fits reaallyyy well musical pattern.
5. 00:19:525 (2,3,4) - same as above, but with small adjustment to accomodate the next rhythm. http://puu.sh/l4wB1.jpg
6. 01:33:888 (5,6,7,8) - think its kinda odd how they break the pattern, I really think they should keep going wtih the outwards growing tri thing because the rotation reverse really throws you off.
7. 03:01:646 (2) - you should remove the repeat and make a circle at 03:01:646 (2) - , because its a really strong downbeat and should be clicked.
8. 04:29:161 (1,2,3,4,5) - you should either shorten each slider so they end on a white/red tick, it makes for a good filler anyways. OR silence each sliderend, as long as there isnt that doublet sound which doesnt fit at all.
9. 04:33:525 - place circle here and move down the spinner
10. 04:34:615 - missed beat here

dqs01733 wrote:

m4m

[General]
Really shouldnt be ar 9.3, slow bpm, and there arent any patterns that are difficult to read. If only it wasnt for the kind large spacing on some patterns, this could even be ar8 lol Fine I guess I'll change it ;-;

[Ienakatta]

1. 00:03:525 (3) - place at x208 y288 or something so its smoother to play, kinda awkward angle. Fixed
2. 00:06:979 (5) - you can probably delete this so its same rhythm as 00:03:525 (3,4) - which has the same vocal patterns, yeah, fixed
3. 00:13:706 (2,3) - try this rhythm. http://puu.sh/l4weE.jpg your current rhythm isnt pressuring the right spots of the scratching noise, 00:13:706 - 00:13:888 - 00:14:070 - . and also moving 00:14:252 (4) - down 1/2 beat places it at the bass line. hmm alright, makes sense, fixed
4. 00:16:342 (1,2) - you can make this a slider because the rhythm is kinda weird, the current slow sv fits reaallyyy well musical pattern. This is fine, it's better to have those drum sounds as cliackable objects, it make more sense that way
5. 00:19:525 (2,3,4) - same as above, but with small adjustment to accomodate the next rhythm. http://puu.sh/l4wB1.jpg Fixed
6. 01:33:888 (5,6,7,8) - think its kinda odd how they break the pattern, I really think they should keep going wtih the outwards growing tri thing because the rotation reverse really throws you off. I thought it played fine for me but I guess you're right, fixed
7. 03:01:646 (2) - you should remove the repeat and make a circle at 03:01:646 (2) - , because its a really strong downbeat and should be clicked. It's a slider because it's a 1/3 rhythm and no one would expect a 1/3 right there
8. 04:29:161 (1,2,3,4,5) - you should either shorten each slider so they end on a white/red tick, it makes for a good filler anyways. OR silence each sliderend, as long as there isnt that doublet sound which doesnt fit at all. Fixed
9. 04:33:525 - place circle here and move down the spinner Fixed
10. 04:34:615 - missed beat here Used spinner end

cool map, good luck !!

1. 00:14:070 (4) - anyone playing is gonna predict 4 has the same amount of repeats as 00:13:706 (2,3) - leading to misreads of when 5 should be clicked. taking off the last repeat and adding a circle like 00:19:525 (2,3,4,5) - is more appropriate
2. 00:15:706 (7,1,2) - so the irregular 3/4 rhythm isn't easy to interpret either, but it's especially gross when you've got the start of the 3/4 rhythm beginnign from a sliderend. clicking on the white tick at the end of 7 zzzzzz makes it easier to interpret
3. 00:22:797 (5) - would be nice to have a new combo since spacing isn't doing anything to indicate the difference between 1/1 and 1/2 here
4. 01:03:706 (3) - so the song is emphasizing beats like this here, yet 3's ending on a strong beat and 1 is starting on a weak one. p much using some rhythm concentrating on those beats in the ss works alright
5. 01:04:434 - similar to ^ having this loud af sound unclickable is kinda ew especially when you choose to clearly map it with 01:04:797 (2) -
6. 01:17:161 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - looks pretty messy when streams aren't consistently spaced. in the first two groups, both 5s are different from 1234 and the last one is like major fukd
7. 01:19:343 (6) - i see monstrata mentioned this above and your reason was "to follow the sound the slider started on." you can easily get the same effect by like removing the repeat. having a gap can emphasize things in a way that having a constant chain of objects can't really reproduce.
8. 01:26:979 (6) - and another way to emphasize a held out sound would be extended sliders, which would work pretty well in this sort of case with a lower volume sliderend. both these are just ideas though, i'm trying to say that there are ways to bring out what you're trying to make powerful (where the slider starts) and what would conventionally be powerful (strong sounds)
9. 01:53:525 (1,5) - tbh sounds way better to have sliders starting on the unique redtick soudns rather than having them as the only tails
10. 01:34:434 (8) - yeah i'm pointing out these kinds of things too much, but they really are important lol. removing a repeat and clicking on the loud af thing = sense, especially when you've got the same sound mapped as super important with 01:35:161 (2,4) - . i'll stop mentioning now, but just know that there are definitely more that are triggering me hardcore
11. 02:06:615 (1) - so sound on this is super loud and hitsound volume is super quiet. i get that it's for the buildup thing, but it needs to still be audible (which 20% right now is not)
12. 02:29:525 (7,1) - when playing, people instinctively assume new combos during streams are on white ticks since that's just how players have been trained to interpret them. when you've got one starting on a blue tick, it's more confusing to interpret when the stream starts than it looks.
13. 02:29:979 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - yea um im still not understanding the spacing variation within sterams
14. 02:43:525 (3,4) - ye same thing i said at 22seconds. 4 with a new combo = easier to understand the timeline gap not indicated through spacing
15. 03:41:888 (5,6,7,8) - starting the antijump thing on 5 sounds way better
16. 04:33:615 (1,1) - major pain to understand that the first object being clicked here is on a 1/3 tick. like unless you know the song already, you're gonna click assuming it's 1/2 since that's what the song usually is
17. 05:12:615 (8) - nice finish spam dood song doesnt support it at all

pishifat wrote:

6:35 PM - ringating: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/643 ... r/chin.jpg
6:35 PM - ringating: can inlcude that with your mod
^bg quality is a big deal Fixed

custom combo colors. any skin's defaults could easily look like garbage paired with the bg's color scheme. combocolor choices relating to the pink/purple/blueness are prob fine Will add soon

od8 would make sense. lower tier insanes are usually the difficulties to use sub8 so an extra using sub8 is what Fixed

one sorta big picture thing i'm disliking is movement into sliderbodies. stuff like 05:03:343 (5,6) - is good since motion between these lead into 6's sliderbody, whereas stuff like 05:01:888 (5,6) - isn't as nice since movement doesn't really lead into the sliderbody. while it doesn't affect much on repeat sliders since you're p much just holding them, they coudl still easily be better with slight rotation like bleh or even bleh. i get especially triggered by nonrepeat ones like 00:26:979 (4) - which would work better with the same rotation idea. don't know how else to explain this so gl interpreting I totally understand what you're saying, I'll go through and fix all of the ones that apply

1. 00:14:070 (4) - anyone playing is gonna predict 4 has the same amount of repeats as 00:13:706 (2,3) - leading to misreads of when 5 should be clicked. taking off the last repeat and adding a circle like 00:19:525 (2,3,4,5) - is more appropriate Fixed
2. 00:15:706 (7,1,2) - so the irregular 3/4 rhythm isn't easy to interpret either, but it's especially gross when you've got the start of the 3/4 rhythm beginnign from a sliderend. clicking on the white tick at the end of 7 zzzzzz makes it easier to interpret Fixed
3. 00:22:797 (5) - would be nice to have a new combo since spacing isn't doing anything to indicate the difference between 1/1 and 1/2 here Fixed
4. 01:03:706 (3) - so the song is emphasizing beats like this here, yet 3's ending on a strong beat and 1 is starting on a weak one. p much using some rhythm concentrating on those beats in the ss works alright hnn fixed
5. 01:04:434 - similar to ^ having this loud af sound unclickable is kinda ew especially when you choose to clearly map it with 01:04:797 (2) - ^
6. 01:17:161 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - looks pretty messy when streams aren't consistently spaced. in the first two groups, both 5s are different from 1234 and the last one is like major fukd Fixed
7. 01:19:343 (6) - i see monstrata mentioned this above and your reason was "to follow the sound the slider started on." you can easily get the same effect by like removing the repeat. having a gap can emphasize things in a way that having a constant chain of objects can't really reproduce. I see what you mean, fixed
8. 01:26:979 (6) - and another way to emphasize a held out sound would be extended sliders, which would work pretty well in this sort of case with a lower volume sliderend. both these are just ideas though, i'm trying to say that there are ways to bring out what you're trying to make powerful (where the slider starts) and what would conventionally be powerful (strong sounds) I get what you're saying, I did what you suggested with extending the slider ends. I just didn't think it would flow well or play well but I guess I was wrong
9. 01:53:525 (1,5) - tbh sounds way better to have sliders starting on the unique redtick soudns rather than having them as the only tails True, fixed
10. 01:34:434 (8) - yeah i'm pointing out these kinds of things too much, but they really are important lol. removing a repeat and clicking on the loud af thing = sense, especially when you've got the same sound mapped as super important with 01:35:161 (2,4) - . i'll stop mentioning now, but just know that there are definitely more that are triggering me hardcore I'm glad you pointed these out, I'll go through and fix them all
11. 02:06:615 (1) - so sound on this is super loud and hitsound volume is super quiet. i get that it's for the buildup thing, but it needs to still be audible (which 20% right now is not) Upped the volume to 35%
12. 02:29:525 (7,1) - when playing, people instinctively assume new combos during streams are on white ticks since that's just how players have been trained to interpret them. when you've got one starting on a blue tick, it's more confusing to interpret when the stream starts than it looks. Fixed, reduced 02:29:525 (7) by 1 tick, also fixed the stream spacing
13. 02:29:979 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - yea um im still not understanding the spacing variation within sterams ^
14. 02:43:525 (3,4) - ye same thing i said at 22seconds. 4 with a new combo = easier to understand the timeline gap not indicated through spacing Fixed
15. 03:41:888 (5,6,7,8) - starting the antijump thing on 5 sounds way better Fixed
16. 04:33:615 (1,1) - major pain to understand that the first object being clicked here is on a 1/3 tick. like unless you know the song already, you're gonna click assuming it's 1/2 since that's what the song usually is I put a slider there instead of circles, hopefully that fixes that
17. 05:12:615 (8) - nice finish spam dood song doesnt support it at all lmao oops, must have miss clicked

happy halloween!!

1. pishifat wrote:

   one sorta big picture thing i'm disliking is movement into sliderbodies.

   I have to agree with this. There's still quite a few spots where the flow feels unintentionally awkward. I'll mention some of the ones I found below, but it might be worth your time to go through your map again and try to fix these
2. 00:03:525 (3) - bad flow. http://puu.sh/mSJcf/adc85cf710.jpg suggestion: http://puu.sh/mSJxE/eed4781327.jpg
3. 00:05:161 (5) - same thing. the sliderbodies govern the flow (err, pishi did a much better job describing this, so go read his explanation again lol) rotate 00:04:434 (1,2,3,4) - 20 degrees for better flow. I would also make (5) flatter to avoid some overlaps
4. other places this happens: 00:06:434 (5) - 00:12:434 (5) -
5. 00:07:343 (1,2,3,4) - ^ can be fixed by making 00:07:343 (1,3) - flatter http://puu.sh/mSKaJ/5cbda52a66.jpg
6. 00:16:070 (1,2,3) - confusing spacing, especially since 00:16:979 (5,6,7,8,9) - has a similar spacing but is 1/4. I would use a NC on each note to make the rhythm more clear
7. 00:20:071 (5,1) - so this 1/1 rhythm and spacing looks like 00:14:252 (5,6) - except there it's 1/2. please make the spacing more clear if you're going to be using different rhythms in similar sounding sections.
8. 00:25:525 (3) - blanket 00:26:252 (1) - instead to fix flow
9. 00:26:434 (2) - ^ bend slider other way to fix flow http://puu.sh/mSKLS/8f828ebaca.jpg
10. 00:27:343 (5) - same thing. not sure how to fix, but you could try this http://puu.sh/mSKVC/3691a32184.jpg (bad flow + small spacing to give similar emphasis)
11. 00:30:615 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - are all these overlaps necessary? at least reduce the up-and-down motion a lil so that (1,3,5) and (2,4,6) don't look like they're kissing each other
12. 00:58:797 (1) - why NC? the beat doesn't feel particular strong or different here
13. 01:26:979 (6,1) - aesthetics can be improved by either overlapping a lot or not overlapping at all
14. 01:33:161 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I'd prefer if the spacings don't just keep growing with every note. Try to place more emphasis on 01:32:434 (5,1,5) - these are the strong beats, so the spacings right before these notes should be larger than the spacing to the following note imo. you can still build up the spacings, just don't do it for every single note
15. 01:47:706 (1,2) - not a fan of these multi-repeat 1/2 sliders, since they generally don't play very well. I think removing one repeat on each and adding a note instead would be better.
16. 01:51:888 (4) - could maybe make this a jump to emphasize the vocal
17. 01:53:525 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - the most powerful sound here is the drums, so you should make the spacing before (2,3,5,6) bigger than the rest.
18. 02:00:434 (6) - make this slider perfectly vertical for better flow
19. 02:01:343 (4,5) - these are emphasized quite strongly by the drums, so the spacing and approach angles to these notes should be different than the surrounding notes to reflect this
20. 02:08:979 (4) - fix flow here. you could make this completely horizontal for instance
21. 02:13:888 (1,2,3,4,5) - this is just me being anal, but could you move/modify this pattern so (5) lands exactly in the center of the map for symmetry with the spinner?
22. 02:18:615 (2,3,4,5,6) - maybe readjust this so that 02:18:252 (1,2) - looks similar to 02:18:797 (3,4,5,6) - to reflect the similarities in the music http://puu.sh/mSMiP/71b53a62a7.jpg
23. 02:21:161 (1,2,3,4,5) - for this section, instead of NC every downbeat, consider NC after every 1/1 gap to help with readability.
24. 02:59:161 (3) - move to [332, 268] for perfect triangle
25. 03:02:797 (5) - rotate by 30 degrees for better flow
26. 03:04:252 (4) - 25 degrees this time
27. 03:10:615 (1) - ~20 degrees
28. 03:12:070 (1,2,3) - move this to [296, 22] for constant spacing. don't use too many spacing inconsistencies, otherwise it loses its effect
29. 03:17:161 (4) - you're missing a s:c2 drum clap here, and the rhythm really falls apart without it
30. 03:18:615 (2) - i see why you used a normal clap, but this still needs a s:c2 drum clap to match music
31. 03:18:979 - ^
32. 03:35:343 - strong beat here, make this a clickable object plz
33. 03:41:888 (5,6,7,8) - spacing change here is way too drastic. make this more gradual to match song
34. 03:45:525 (1) - was expecting this to be at [168, 16] x.x
35. 03:45:525 (1) - missing clap?
36. 04:05:525 (5) - for a cool effect, you could NC this, make this a 1/1 slider instead and set SV to like 0.5-0.7 so it slides right into the clap/vocal
37. 04:17:525 (1,2,3,4) - maybe start off with a smaller DS so spacing growth is more drastic/apparent
38. 04:23:434 (1) - just an idea, but you could end this spinner at 04:26:070 - and put a note in the center at 04:26:252 - so the strong beat is clickable
39. 04:51:525 (4) - the shallow approach angle to this slider felt weird to play. i think moving this to the right and keeping the back-and-forth motion would be better.
40. 05:23:706 (5) - is clearly a much stronger beat than 05:23:343 (3,7) - so this should be reflected in your mapping pattern
41. 05:33:888 (5) - ^
42. 05:39:615 (1) - leaving aside why you chose to make an R, the pause in the music would be much better accentuated if 05:39:615 (1) - was stacked with 05:38:797 (8) -
43. 05:42:615 (1) - spinner feels unnecessary, there's like no sound left

MokouSmoke wrote:

m4m from your queue

[Vocaloidogatari]

1. pishifat wrote:

   one sorta big picture thing i'm disliking is movement into sliderbodies.

   I have to agree with this. There's still quite a few spots where the flow feels unintentionally awkward. I'll mention some of the ones I found below, but it might be worth your time to go through your map again and try to fix these
2. 00:03:525 (3) - bad flow. http://puu.sh/mSJcf/adc85cf710.jpg suggestion: http://puu.sh/mSJxE/eed4781327.jpg
3. 00:05:161 (5) - same thing. the sliderbodies govern the flow (err, pishi did a much better job describing this, so go read his explanation again lol) rotate 00:04:434 (1,2,3,4) - 20 degrees for better flow. I would also make (5) flatter to avoid some overlaps
4. other places this happens: 00:06:434 (5) - 00:12:434 (5) -
5. 00:07:343 (1,2,3,4) - ^ can be fixed by making 00:07:343 (1,3) - flatter http://puu.sh/mSKaJ/5cbda52a66.jpg Fixed all of the above issues regarding slider bodies
6. 00:16:070 (1,2,3) - confusing spacing, especially since 00:16:979 (5,6,7,8,9) - has a similar spacing but is 1/4. I would use a NC on each note to make the rhythm more clear fixed, made spacing a bit farther and made the notes nc
7. 00:20:071 (5,1) - so this 1/1 rhythm and spacing looks like 00:14:252 (5,6) - except there it's 1/2. please make the spacing more clear if you're going to be using different rhythms in similar sounding sections. fixed
8. 00:25:525 (3) - blanket 00:26:252 (1) - instead to fix flow fixed
9. 00:26:434 (2) - ^ bend slider other way to fix flow http://puu.sh/mSKLS/8f828ebaca.jpg fixed
10. 00:27:343 (5) - same thing. not sure how to fix, but you could try this http://puu.sh/mSKVC/3691a32184.jpg (bad flow + small spacing to give similar emphasis) I like this note where it is because it follows 00:26:252 (1,3) well since all 3 of those notes are on the same piano sound
11. 00:30:615 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - are all these overlaps necessary? at least reduce the up-and-down motion a lil so that (1,3,5) and (2,4,6) don't look like they're kissing each other Changed it up
12. 00:58:797 (1) - why NC? the beat doesn't feel particular strong or different here o wasnt supposed to be nc lol
13. 01:26:979 (6,1) - aesthetics can be improved by either overlapping a lot or not overlapping at all right
14. 01:33:161 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I'd prefer if the spacings don't just keep growing with every note. Try to place more emphasis on 01:32:434 (5,1,5) - these are the strong beats, so the spacings right before these notes should be larger than the spacing to the following note imo. you can still build up the spacings, just don't do it for every single note I'm keeping it how it is, the volume in the music continually escalates so the gap growing bigger each note makes sense, and it also wouldn't go according to hit sounds if spacing stayed the same as the hitsounds go with the music
15. 01:47:706 (1,2) - not a fan of these multi-repeat 1/2 sliders, since they generally don't play very well. I think removing one repeat on each and adding a note instead would be better. Changed
16. 01:51:888 (4) - could maybe make this a jump to emphasize the vocal The lump fits better on 01:52:070 (1) - since th 'laaa' is much more intense
17. 01:53:525 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - the most powerful sound here is the drums, so you should make the spacing before (2,3,5,6) bigger than the rest. Changed it around
18. 02:00:434 (6) - make this slider perfectly vertical for better flow ye
19. 02:01:343 (4,5) - these are emphasized quite strongly by the drums, so the spacing and approach angles to these notes should be different than the surrounding notes to reflect this certainly
20. 02:08:979 (4) - fix flow here. you could make this completely horizontal for instance fixed
21. 02:13:888 (1,2,3,4,5) - this is just me being anal, but could you move/modify this pattern so (5) lands exactly in the center of the map for symmetry with the spinner? ehh I don't think it really matters lol i'll keep it how it is
22. 02:18:615 (2,3,4,5,6) - maybe readjust this so that 02:18:252 (1,2) - looks similar to 02:18:797 (3,4,5,6) - to reflect the similarities in the music http://puu.sh/mSMiP/71b53a62a7.jpg good idea
23. 02:21:161 (1,2,3,4,5) - for this section, instead of NC every downbeat, consider NC after every 1/1 gap to help with readability. Hm yeah that makes a lot of sense
24. 02:59:161 (3) - move to [332, 268] for perfect triangle But I made theis with ctrl + shift + d so it cant be wrong lol
25. 03:02:797 (5) - rotate by 30 degrees for better flow
26. 03:04:252 (4) - 25 degrees this time
27. 03:10:615 (1) - ~20 degrees
28. 03:12:070 (1,2,3) - move this to [296, 22] for constant spacing. don't use too many spacing inconsistencies, otherwise it loses its effect wat, those cords are off lol, and I changed it a bit
29. 03:17:161 (4) - you're missing a s:c2 drum clap here, and the rhythm really falls apart without it ye
30. 03:18:615 (2) - i see why you used a normal clap, but this still needs a s:c2 drum clap to match music I like the normal clap, I think it follows the music fine
31. 03:18:979 - ^ ^
32. 03:35:343 - strong beat here, make this a clickable object plz yeee
33. 03:41:888 (5,6,7,8) - spacing change here is way too drastic. make this more gradual to match song uh I think its fine, its pretty gradual as is lol
34. 03:45:525 (1) - was expecting this to be at [168, 16] x.x fixed
35. 03:45:525 (1) - missing clap? wat, there is a clap there
36. 04:05:525 (5) - for a cool effect, you could NC this, make this a 1/1 slider instead and set SV to like 0.5-0.7 so it slides right into the clap/vocal hm i like it
37. 04:17:525 (1,2,3,4) - maybe start off with a smaller DS so spacing growth is more drastic/apparent sure
38. 04:23:434 (1) - just an idea, but you could end this spinner at 04:26:070 - and put a note in the center at 04:26:252 - so the strong beat is clickable makes sense
39. 04:51:525 (4) - the shallow approach angle to this slider felt weird to play. i think moving this to the right and keeping the back-and-forth motion would be better. fixed
40. 05:23:706 (5) - is clearly a much stronger beat than 05:23:343 (3,7) - so this should be reflected in your mapping pattern fixed
41. 05:33:888 (5) - ^ ^
42. 05:39:615 (1) - leaving aside why you chose to make an R, the pause in the music would be much better accentuated if 05:39:615 (1) - was stacked with 05:38:797 (8) - fixed
43. 05:42:615 (1) - spinner feels unnecessary, there's like no sound left this was changed during your mod

Good luck!

Left wrote:

My M4M mod~

[Miku Kawaii]
00:20:433 (1,2) - I think you shouldn't pass the beat between these two notes. o, didnt even notice that beat, good catch!
00:56:615 (2,3,4) - three beats are really strong, so emphasizing by using more distance would be more fit. Increased the spacing a bit
00:57:161 (5) - You can improve slider shape. now it's a bit... I like it :<
02:26:615 (3) - blanket It's fine?
02:32:070 (6,1) - too close considering 02:32:252 (1) - 's strong clap. Increased spacing slightly but I don't want it to be too big bc trying to land that jump right after a stream is hard, and increasing the spacing too much would render it unforgiving
02:56:070 (8) - NC sure
03:12:070 (1,2) - too close...I think it's unnatural. I think it's fine, the music cuts out after those notes so I like the small cursor movements as it compliments the song well
03:15:342 (2) - unsnapped
03:16:069 (4) - ~ fixed both
03:42:434 (8,1,2) - It's very uncomfortable angle to play i think...perfect linear would be better. I think it's fine how it is
03:42:615 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - In 03:41:888 (5,6,7,8) - , you used distance to represent sound volume, so you can do same thing here to represent rising volume. 03:42:615 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - The beats these notes are mapped to are of the same volume. 03:45:525 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6) - This is what represents the volume escalation
04:00:070 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - DS different from 04:02:979 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,1) - , is there any reason? Nope, was a mistake
04:22:979 (5,6,7,8,9) - make DS more similarly. fixed
04:23:343 (9) - how about NC? Sure
04:32:070 (4) - NC I like all those long sliders being the same combo
04:48:797 (5) - strong clap in here, but there's no emphasis Fixing that would cause issues with flow but I'll keep it in mind
04:55:343 (1,2,3,4,5) - vocal sound is really high, so you can use more distance in here. Adjusted the spacing
05:42:615 - two timing points??? oops

05:39:797 (2) - lol Nice R slider it is Thanks

Good Luck with your map!

• 00:05:161 (5,1) - This would obviously look better as a perfect blank
  00:07:343 (1,2) - ^
  00:16:070 (1,1,1) - This should be a slider. I guess noone expects the next Circle to be on a blue tick if theire playing the map for the first time
  00:18:070 - Are you sure about ignoring the beat here for some soft melodics?
  00:24:252 (4,1) - An edged slider starting at the same place as a straight one looks weird
  00:28:070 (2,3) - Yeah, Ii looks kinda weird how close (3) to (2) is. It makes the whole pattern look weird and randomly placed
  00:30:615 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - This might be confusing aswell. Many players will expect a stream there since the part before seems more like a build-up. Maybe you should increase the distance a bit, so it wont look like a stream
  00:35:706 (1) - Why the NC here? It isnt necessary since you havent placed NCs there before.
  00:39:343 (1,2) - The repeatslider should definetley start on the white tick where (1) starts. Otherwise it wont quite fit with the song, try it out.
  00:40:070 (3,4) - ^
  00:40:797 (1,2,3,4,5) - How about the same ds as here 00:34:979 (1,2,3,4) - for consistency?
  00:42:252 (1,2,3,4,1) - Did you run out of idead here? This is really boring to play. Maybe you could make the last (1) curvy or place it somewhere else so it wont look so boring
  00:50:979 (1,2,3,4) - Multiple repeatsliders are boring to play in an Insane or Extra. Just place a few 1/2 sliders instead, they will bring some movement into the map.
  01:02:615 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Okay, the sliders here should definetely all start on a white tick. Letting sliders start on a redtick where theres no drum or so and letting it end on a white tick when there are drums is just wrong, and playing the sliders will be akward.
  01:05:525 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - For Example, here it fits since the sliders are all starting in pretty strong beats
  01:10:070 (2,4) - shouldnt they be hitsounded the same way as 01:08:615 (2,4) - ?
  01:12:070 (5,6) - How about ctrl+g those? I think the jumps would get a cool movement then.
  01:15:706 (1,2,3,4) - I think this pattern would look better if (4) would be the same way as (3), otherwise it looks somehow randomly placed
  01:22:979 (1,2,3,4) - ^
  01:24:434 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - This pattern would be really cool to play if (6) would be just circle aswell placed the same way as (1,2,3,4,5). That would be a really cool jump pattern
  01:25:888 (2,3) - Maybe you should ctrl+g those. I think the jump will play more smoothly then, and one little thing aswell. Move the slidertail of 01:26:615 (5) - too 344/68. It will fit more with the movement of the jjumps then.
  01:28:797 (1,2,3,4) - I dont like those jumps, they are kinda boring. Ive tried many different things, but i dont really know what to do there hmmm.
  01:30:979 (5) - This one should be curvy so it will fit more with 01:31:343 (6) -
  01:31:706 (1,2,3,4) - I like the idea but a bit more distance would be great here, it looks so cramped
  01:34:797 (2,4) - Those sliders are starting on nothing and end on beats. That really shouldnt be the case here. It would be alot better to play if the sliders would just start on beats instead.